Managing the Organisation: Theories of Leadership and Motivation
Trait, behavioural, contingency and transformational leadership; Maslow, Herzberg, McGregor, McClelland, Vroom and Adams on motivation for UGC NET.
- 17 min
On this page · 11 sections
Prerequisites
- Theories of Organisation — Taylor’s economic man and Mayo’s social man, the two views of human nature that motivation theory develops.
- Learner Characteristics (Paper 1) — needs and motivation in the classroom, a familiar entry point to Maslow.
- Democracy and Power — Weber’s charismatic authority, the root of charismatic and transformational leadership.
The Hook: Same Office, Two Bosses
How UGC NET asks it: Maslow’s hierarchy in sequence; Herzberg’s hygiene factors vs motivators; McGregor’s Theory X and Y; Blake and Mouton’s grid positions; Fiedler’s three situational variables; Hersey–Blanchard styles; Burns’s transactional vs transforming leadership; Vroom’s expectancy equation; content vs process theories as classification.
Part A: Leadership
Meaning
Leadership is the process of influencing the behaviour of others towards the achievement of goals. It differs from headship (formal position) and from management (planning, organising, controlling). A manager has authority by position; a leader has influence, which may or may not come from position.
The evolution of leadership theories
graph LR
A["Trait theories
(to the 1940s)
Who is a leader?"] --> B["Behavioural theories
(1940s-60s)
What do leaders do?"]
B --> C["Contingency / situational
(1960s-70s)
Which style, when?"]
C --> D["Transactional and
transformational
(1978 onwards)"]1. Trait theories
- The “great man” view: leaders are born, with traits such as intelligence, self-confidence, initiative, energy, integrity and sociability.
- Ralph Stogdill’s review of trait studies (1948) found that no consistent set of traits distinguished leaders from non-leaders across situations; traits matter only in relation to the situation.
- Criticism: lists differ from study to study; ignores followers and situation; cannot be taught.
2. Behavioural theories
(a) Iowa studies: Kurt Lewin, Ronald Lippitt and Ralph White (1939)
| Style | Feature | Finding (in substance) |
|---|---|---|
| Autocratic (authoritarian) | Leader decides alone | High output under supervision, but hostility and dependence |
| Democratic (participative) | Group decides with the leader | Higher satisfaction, more originality |
| Laissez-faire (free-rein) | Leader leaves the group alone | Lowest quality and satisfaction |
(b) Ohio State studies (late 1940s) found two independent dimensions:
- Initiating structure — task orientation: defining roles, setting standards and schedules.
- Consideration — people orientation: trust, respect, concern for subordinates’ feelings.
A leader can be high or low on each, giving four quadrants.
(c) University of Michigan studies (Rensis Likert and colleagues) found two styles: job-centred (production-oriented) and employee-centred. Employee-centred supervisors tended to have more productive groups.
(d) Rensis Likert’s four systems of management (New Patterns of Management, 1961; The Human Organization, 1967):
| System | Name | Nature |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Exploitative authoritative | Fear, threats, top-down decisions |
| 2 | Benevolent authoritative | Paternalistic; rewards, some upward communication |
| 3 | Consultative | Subordinates consulted; top still decides |
| 4 | Participative group | Full participation; Likert’s preferred system |
Likert also gave the linking pin concept: each manager is a member of two groups, the one he leads and the one above, and links them.
(e) Blake and Mouton’s Managerial Grid (1964) plots concern for production (horizontal, 1–9) against concern for people (vertical, 1–9):
| Grid position | Name | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| 1,1 | Impoverished | Minimum effort for both |
| 9,1 | Authority–compliance (task management) | Production high, people low |
| 1,9 | Country club | People high, production low |
| 5,5 | Middle-of-the-road | Balance and compromise |
| 9,9 | Team management | Both high; the ideal |
(f) Tannenbaum and Schmidt’s continuum (“How to Choose a Leadership Pattern”, Harvard Business Review, 1958): leadership is a range from boss-centred (the manager decides and announces) to subordinate-centred (the manager lets the group decide within limits). The right point depends on forces in the manager, the subordinates and the situation.
3. Contingency (situational) theories
(a) Fred Fiedler’s contingency model (A Theory of Leadership Effectiveness, 1967)
- The leader’s style is measured by the LPC (least preferred co-worker) scale: a high-LPC leader is relationship-oriented, a low-LPC leader is task-oriented. Style is treated as fixed.
- Situational favourableness depends on three variables:
- Leader–member relations (good or poor)
- Task structure (high or low)
- Position power (strong or weak)
- Finding: task-oriented leaders do best when the situation is very favourable or very unfavourable; relationship-oriented leaders do best in moderately favourable situations.
- Implication: since style is fixed, change the situation or the leader (“engineer the job to fit the manager”).
(b) Hersey and Blanchard’s situational leadership (“life cycle theory of leadership”, 1969)
Style depends on the maturity (readiness) of followers: their ability and willingness.
| Follower readiness | Style | Task / relationship behaviour |
|---|---|---|
| R1: unable and unwilling | S1 Telling | High task, low relationship |
| R2: unable but willing | S2 Selling | High task, high relationship |
| R3: able but unwilling | S3 Participating | Low task, high relationship |
| R4: able and willing | S4 Delegating | Low task, low relationship |
(c) Robert House’s path–goal theory (1971): the leader’s job is to clarify the path to the subordinate’s goals and remove obstacles. Four leader behaviours (as set out in House and Mitchell’s 1974 version): directive, supportive, participative, achievement-oriented. It draws on expectancy theory of motivation.
(d) Vroom–Yetton model (1973): a decision tree for choosing how far to involve subordinates in a decision (from autocratic to consultative to group), depending on decision quality and acceptance needs.
4. Transactional and transformational leadership
James MacGregor Burns, Leadership (1978), distinguished:
| Transactional leadership | Transforming (transformational) leadership |
|---|---|
| An exchange: rewards for performance, punishment for failure | Leader and followers raise one another to higher levels of motivation and morality |
| Works within the existing system | Changes the system, values and aspirations |
| Contingent reward, management by exception | Vision, inspiration, moral purpose |
Bernard Bass, Leadership and Performance Beyond Expectations (1985), developed Burns’s idea into a measurable model; in its later form (with Bruce Avolio) it is taught as the “four Is” of transformational leadership:
- Idealised influence (charisma, role model)
- Inspirational motivation
- Intellectual stimulation
- Individualised consideration
Other approaches you may meet: charismatic leadership (from Weber’s charismatic authority), servant leadership (Robert Greenleaf), and Mary Parker Follett’s view that leadership belongs to whoever knows the situation best (the “law of the situation”, see Communication, Conflict and MBO).
Part B: Motivation
Meaning and classification
Motivation is the set of forces that initiate, direct and sustain behaviour towards a goal. Theories are classified as:
| Content theories (what motivates?) | Process theories (how does motivation work?) |
|---|---|
| Maslow, Herzberg, McGregor, Alderfer, McClelland, Argyris | Vroom, Porter and Lawler, Adams, Locke, Skinner (reinforcement) |
Content theories
(a) Abraham Maslow: hierarchy of needs (“A Theory of Human Motivation”, Psychological Review, 1943; Motivation and Personality, 1954)
graph TD
E["5. Self-actualisation
(realising one's potential)"]
D["4. Esteem
(self-respect, recognition, status)"]
C["3. Social / love and belonging
(affiliation, acceptance)"]
B["2. Safety / security
(protection, job security)"]
A["1. Physiological
(food, water, shelter)"]
A --> B --> C --> D --> E- Needs are arranged from lower to higher; a lower need must be largely satisfied before the next becomes dominant.
- A satisfied need is no longer a motivator.
- The lower four (physiological, safety, social, esteem) are deficiency needs; self-actualisation is a growth need.
- Criticism: order varies across cultures and individuals; several needs operate at once; weak empirical support.
(b) Frederick Herzberg: two-factor (motivation–hygiene) theory (The Motivation to Work, with Mausner and Snyderman, 1959). Based on interviews with about 200 engineers and accountants in Pittsburgh using the critical incident method.
| Hygiene (maintenance) factors — prevent dissatisfaction | Motivators — create satisfaction |
|---|---|
| Company policy and administration | Achievement |
| Supervision | Recognition |
| Interpersonal relations | Work itself |
| Working conditions | Responsibility |
| Salary | Advancement |
| Status, job security | Growth |
- The opposite of satisfaction is no satisfaction, not dissatisfaction; the opposite of dissatisfaction is no dissatisfaction.
- Hygiene factors are extrinsic (job context); motivators are intrinsic (job content).
- Practical result: job enrichment (adding responsibility and challenge), not just better pay.
(c) Douglas McGregor: Theory X and Theory Y (The Human Side of Enterprise, 1960)
| Theory X (traditional) | Theory Y (integrative) |
|---|---|
| People dislike work and avoid it | Work is as natural as play or rest |
| Must be coerced, controlled, threatened | Exercise self-direction and self-control towards objectives they are committed to |
| Prefer to be directed; avoid responsibility | Accept and seek responsibility |
| Little ambition; want security above all | Creativity and ingenuity are widely distributed |
| Fits Taylor’s “economic man” | Fits Maslow’s higher needs |
William Ouchi’s Theory Z (1981) described Japanese-style management: lifetime employment, collective decision-making, slow promotion and holistic concern for employees.
(d) Clayton Alderfer: ERG theory (1969) condensed Maslow into three needs: Existence, Relatedness, Growth. Unlike Maslow, more than one need can operate at once, and the frustration–regression principle holds: if a higher need is frustrated, a person regresses to a lower one.
(e) David McClelland: acquired needs theory (The Achieving Society, 1961): three learned needs:
- Need for achievement (nAch) — to excel, take moderate risks, get feedback
- Need for affiliation (nAff) — warm relationships
- Need for power (nPow) — to influence others
High nAch is linked to entrepreneurship and economic growth; effective senior managers tend to have high (institutional) nPow.
(f) Chris Argyris: immaturity–maturity continuum (Personality and Organization, 1957): as people mature they move from passivity to activity, dependence to independence, short to long time perspectives; formal organisations, by keeping people dependent and passive, conflict with the mature personality.
Process theories
(a) Victor Vroom: expectancy theory (Work and Motivation, 1964)
$$\text{Motivation} = \text{Expectancy} \times \text{Instrumentality} \times \text{Valence}$$| Term | Question the worker asks | Range |
|---|---|---|
| Expectancy | If I try, will I perform? (effort → performance) | 0 to 1 |
| Instrumentality | If I perform, will I be rewarded? (performance → reward) | 0 to 1 |
| Valence | Do I value the reward? | Negative to positive |
Because the terms are multiplied, if any one is zero, motivation is zero.
(b) Porter and Lawler model (Managerial Attitudes and Performance, 1968): extends Vroom: effort → performance (also depending on ability and role perception) → rewards (intrinsic and extrinsic) → satisfaction, if rewards are perceived as equitable. Key insight: performance leads to satisfaction, not the reverse as the human relations school assumed.
(c) J. Stacy Adams: equity theory (1963): people compare the ratio of their outcomes to inputs with that of a referent other:
$$\frac{\text{Outcomes}_{\text{self}}}{\text{Inputs}_{\text{self}}} \quad \text{vs} \quad \frac{\text{Outcomes}_{\text{other}}}{\text{Inputs}_{\text{other}}}$$Perceived under-reward leads people to reduce effort, demand more, distort perceptions, change the referent or leave. Relevant to pay commissions and promotion policy.
(d) Edwin Locke: goal-setting theory (1968): specific and difficult goals, accepted by the worker and accompanied by feedback, lead to higher performance than vague “do your best” goals. This is the psychological basis of MBO.
(e) B.F. Skinner: reinforcement theory: behaviour followed by positive consequences is repeated (operant conditioning). Applied as positive reinforcement, negative reinforcement, punishment and extinction.
Motivation in public administration
- Pay and job security in government are high on hygiene but often low on motivators (recognition, achievement), which helps explain apathy in routine posts.
- Public service motivation — commitment to public interest and compassion — is a motive that public choice theory neglects.
- Indian tools: Annual Performance Appraisal Reports, awards such as the Prime Minister’s Awards for Excellence in Public Administration, performance-linked incentives; their success depends on the instrumentality link (does performance really lead to reward?).
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Maslow — five needs, strict hierarchy | vs | Alderfer — three needs (ERG), frustration–regression |
| Herzberg’s hygiene — prevent dissatisfaction | vs | Herzberg’s motivators — create satisfaction |
| McGregor’s Theory X/Y (1960) | vs | Ouchi’s Theory Z (1981) |
| Ohio State — initiating structure and consideration | vs | Michigan — job-centred and employee-centred |
| Grid 9,1 — authority–compliance | vs | Grid 1,9 — country club |
| Fiedler — style fixed; change the situation | vs | Hersey–Blanchard — style flexible; adapt to follower readiness |
| Burns (1978) — transforming leadership | vs | Bass (1985) — four Is of transformational leadership |
| Content theories — what motivates | vs | Process theories — how motivation works |
| Vroom — expectancy × instrumentality × valence | vs | Adams — equity of outcome/input ratios |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Who wrote The Human Side of Enterprise (1960)?
- What are the three situational variables in Fiedler’s contingency model?
- In Blake and Mouton’s grid, what is the 9,9 style called?
Answers
- Douglas McGregor.
- Leader–member relations, task structure and position power.
- Team management.
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) Under Vroom’s expectancy theory, an employee has an expectancy of 0.6, an instrumentality of 0.5 and a valence of 8 for a reward. A second employee has an expectancy of 0.9, an instrumentality of 0.8 and a valence of 3. Which statement is correct?
- (a) The first employee’s motivation score is 2.4 and is higher than the second’s
- (b) The second employee’s motivation score is 2.16 and is higher than the first’s
- (c) Both scores are equal
- (d) The first employee’s score is 9.1
Answer and explanation
(a). First: \( 0.6 \times 0.5 \times 8 = 2.4 \). Second: \( 0.9 \times 0.8 \times 3 = 2.16 \). The three terms are multiplied, not added: option (d) is the trap of adding them (\( 0.6 + 0.5 + 8 = 9.1 \)).
Q2. (Practice) Which of the following is a hygiene factor in Herzberg’s two-factor theory?
- (a) Recognition
- (b) Responsibility
- (c) Working conditions
- (d) Advancement
Answer and explanation
(c) Working conditions. The other three are motivators (job content).
Q3. (Practice) Consider the following statements:
- Alderfer’s ERG theory allows more than one need to operate at the same time.
- McClelland identified the needs for achievement, affiliation and power.
- Maslow placed esteem needs above self-actualisation.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 2 and 3 only
- (c) 1 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(a) 1 and 2 only. Self-actualisation is at the top of Maslow’s hierarchy, above esteem.
Q4. (Practice) In Hersey and Blanchard’s model, the appropriate style for followers who are able but unwilling is:
- (a) Telling
- (b) Selling
- (c) Participating
- (d) Delegating
Answer and explanation
(c) Participating (low task, high relationship): they have the skill, so the leader works on commitment.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Herzberg argued that improving salary and working conditions alone will not make employees highly motivated. Reason (R): In Herzberg’s theory, hygiene factors can remove dissatisfaction but do not create positive satisfaction.
Answer and explanation
(a). R is precisely the reason Herzberg gives for A.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): Fiedler recommends changing the situation rather than the leader’s style. Reason (R): Fiedler treats a leader’s style, measured by the LPC scale, as relatively fixed.
Answer and explanation
(a). Because style is fixed, the practical option is to match the leader to the situation or to engineer the situation.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (Thinker) with List II (Concept).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Rensis Likert | I. Managerial grid |
| B. Blake and Mouton | II. Linking pin |
| C. J. Stacy Adams | III. Transforming leadership |
| D. James MacGregor Burns | IV. Equity theory |
- (a) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
- (b) A-I, B-II, C-IV, D-III
- (c) A-II, B-I, C-III, D-IV
- (d) A-II, B-IV, C-I, D-III
Answer and explanation
(a) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange Maslow’s needs from the lowest to the highest:
- Esteem
- Safety
- Self-actualisation
- Social
- Physiological
- (a) 5, 2, 4, 1, 3
- (b) 5, 4, 2, 1, 3
- (c) 2, 5, 4, 1, 3
- (d) 5, 2, 1, 4, 3
Answer and explanation
(a) 5, 2, 4, 1, 3. Physiological → safety → social → esteem → self-actualisation.
Q5. (Practice) Arrange the following works in chronological order:
- Herzberg, The Motivation to Work
- McGregor, The Human Side of Enterprise
- Maslow, “A Theory of Human Motivation”
- Vroom, Work and Motivation
- (a) 3, 1, 2, 4
- (b) 3, 2, 1, 4
- (c) 1, 3, 2, 4
- (d) 3, 1, 4, 2
Answer and explanation
(a) 3, 1, 2, 4. 1943 → 1959 → 1960 → 1964.
Quick Revision Table
| Thinker | Work / model | Year | Key idea |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lewin, Lippitt and White | Iowa studies | 1939 | Autocratic, democratic, laissez-faire |
| Stogdill | Review of trait studies | 1948 | No universal leadership traits |
| Tannenbaum and Schmidt | Leadership continuum | 1958 | Boss-centred to subordinate-centred |
| Likert | New Patterns of Management / The Human Organization | 1961 / 1967 | Linking pin; Systems 1–4 |
| Blake and Mouton | Managerial Grid | 1964 | 1,1; 9,1; 1,9; 5,5; 9,9 |
| Fiedler | Contingency model | 1967 | LPC; leader–member relations, task structure, position power |
| Hersey and Blanchard | Life cycle / situational | 1969 | Telling, selling, participating, delegating |
| House | Path–goal theory | 1971 | Directive, supportive, participative, achievement-oriented |
| Vroom and Yetton | Decision model | 1973 | How much participation |
| Burns | Leadership | 1978 | Transactional vs transforming |
| Bass | Leadership and Performance Beyond Expectations | 1985 | Four Is |
| Maslow | “A Theory of Human Motivation” | 1943 | Five-level hierarchy |
| Argyris | Personality and Organization | 1957 | Immaturity–maturity |
| Herzberg | The Motivation to Work | 1959 | Hygiene vs motivators |
| McGregor | The Human Side of Enterprise | 1960 | Theory X, Theory Y |
| McClelland | The Achieving Society | 1961 | nAch, nAff, nPow |
| Adams | Equity theory | 1963 | Outcome/input comparison |
| Vroom | Work and Motivation | 1964 | \( M = E \times I \times V \) |
| Porter and Lawler | Managerial Attitudes and Performance | 1968 | Performance → satisfaction |
| Locke | Goal-setting theory | 1968 | Specific, difficult goals |
| Alderfer | ERG theory | 1969 | Existence, relatedness, growth |
| Ouchi | Theory Z | 1981 | Japanese management |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Communication, Conflict and MBO — Barnard, Follett and Drucker, the last three official lines of the unit
- Theories of Organisation — revisit Mayo and the Hawthorne studies, where motivation theory began
- Factors and Methods of Teaching (Paper 1) — the same ideas of motivation and participation in the classroom
- Public Administration — Quick Revision