Communication, Conflict and MBO: Barnard, Follett and Drucker
Organisational communication and Chester Barnard's principles, information management, Mary Parker Follett on conflict, and Peter Drucker's MBO for UGC NET.
- 19 min
On this page · 14 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Three Practitioners Who Changed Management Thought
- Part A: Organisational Communication
- Part B: Chester Barnard
- Part C: Information Management in the Organisation
- Part D: Managing Conflict: Mary Parker Follett
- Part E: Management by Objectives: Peter Drucker
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Theories of Organisation — formal and informal organisation, hierarchy and the human relations school.
- Leadership and Motivation — Locke’s goal-setting theory, the psychology behind MBO.
- Communication: Meaning, Types and Characteristics and Barriers to Effective Communication (Paper 1) — the communication models (Shannon–Weaver, Lasswell) this page applies to organisations.
The Hook: Three Practitioners Who Changed Management Thought
How UGC NET asks it: Barnard’s three elements of organisation, the acceptance theory of authority, the four conditions of acceptance, the zone of indifference and his principles of communication; types and networks of communication; Follett’s three methods of dealing with conflict, the law of the situation and her four principles of co-ordination; Drucker’s MBO and its steps; books matched to authors and years.
Part A: Organisational Communication
1. Meaning and importance
Communication is the transfer of information and understanding from one person to another. In an organisation it is the nervous system: it links goals to action, superiors to subordinates and the organisation to its environment. Barnard went further: “the first executive function is to develop and maintain a system of communication.”
2. Theories (models) of communication applied to organisations
| Model | Author (year) | Elements |
|---|---|---|
| Lasswell’s formula | Harold Lasswell (1948) | Who says what in which channel to whom with what effect |
| Mathematical (information) model | Claude Shannon and Warren Weaver, The Mathematical Theory of Communication (1949) | Information source → transmitter → channel (with noise) → receiver → destination |
| Two-way / interactive models | Later models (e.g. Schramm) | Add feedback and shared field of experience |
In organisations the sender is often a superior, the message an order or report, the channel the formal line of command, and noise includes distance, status, jargon and overload.
3. Types of organisational communication
| Basis | Types |
|---|---|
| Direction | Downward (orders, policies, instructions); upward (reports, suggestions, grievances); horizontal / lateral (between peers, for co-ordination); diagonal (across levels and departments) |
| Formality | Formal (through official channels) and informal (the grapevine) |
| Mode | Oral, written, non-verbal, electronic |
The grapevine. Informal communication spreads fast, is often largely accurate, and cannot be abolished. Keith Davis identified four grapevine chains: single strand, gossip, probability and cluster; the cluster chain (each person tells a few selected others) is the most common.
4. Communication networks
Small-group experiments by Alex Bavelas and Harold Leavitt (around 1950) compared networks:
| Network | Shape | Speed and accuracy (simple tasks) | Member satisfaction | Leader emergence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wheel (star) | All through one central person | Fast, accurate | Low (except the centre) | High (the centre) |
| Chain | Linear, like a hierarchy | Moderate | Low | Moderate |
| Y | Chain with a fork | Moderate | Low–moderate | Moderate |
| Circle | Each talks to two neighbours | Slow | Moderate–high | Low |
| All-channel | Everyone to everyone | Slow for simple tasks, good for complex ones | Highest | None |
Centralised networks suit simple, routine tasks; decentralised networks suit complex problems.
5. Principles of effective communication
Commonly listed principles: clarity (of thought and language), adequacy and completeness, consistency with organisational policy, timeliness, integrity (respect for the chain of command), attention (the receiver must attend), feedback, and use of the informal organisation to support the formal.
6. Barriers to communication
| Type | Examples |
|---|---|
| Semantic | Jargon, ambiguous words, translation problems |
| Physical | Distance, noise, faulty equipment |
| Organisational | Too many levels (filtering and distortion), rigid rules, status differences, specialisation |
| Psychological | Selective perception, emotions, distrust, premature evaluation |
| Information overload | More messages than can be processed; Herbert Simon warned that a wealth of information creates a poverty of attention |
Part B: Chester Barnard
The Functions of the Executive (1938)
Chester Irving Barnard (1886–1961) is a bridge between the classical and behavioural schools. Herbert Simon built directly on his ideas.
Organisation as a co-operative system. A formal organisation is a system of consciously co-ordinated activities or forces of two or more persons. It comes into being when:
- there are persons able to communicate with one another,
- who are willing to contribute action (willingness to serve or co-operate),
- to accomplish a common purpose.
Acceptance theory of authority
For Barnard, authority is the character of a communication (order) by which it is accepted by a member of the organisation as governing his action. Authority lies with the receiver, not the issuer: this is the “bottom-up” or acceptance theory of authority.
Four conditions under which a person will accept a communication as authoritative (all four must be met at the same time):
- He can and does understand the communication.
- At the time of decision, he believes it is not inconsistent with the purpose of the organisation.
- At the time of decision, he believes it is compatible with his personal interest as a whole.
- He is able, mentally and physically, to comply with it.
Zone of indifference. Within each person there is a range of orders that he will accept without consciously questioning their authority. Orders falling in this zone are obeyed almost automatically; the zone is wider when the inducements the organisation offers exceed the burdens it imposes. (Simon later called it the zone of acceptance.)
Barnard’s principles of communication
Barnard set out the controlling factors in the character of a communication system (the “principles of communication” of the syllabus). Objective authority is maintained only if:
- The channels of communication should be definitely known to all members.
- There should be a definite formal channel of communication to every member of the organisation (everyone must report to, and be subordinate to, someone).
- The line of communication must be as direct and short as possible.
- The complete line of communication should normally be used (no skipping of levels, to avoid conflicting communications and misunderstanding).
- The competence of the persons serving as communication centres (officers, supervisors) must be adequate.
- The line of communication should not be interrupted while the organisation is functioning (offices must be filled; arrangements for absence and substitution).
- Every communication should be authenticated: it must be clear that the person communicating actually occupies the position and that the communication is within the authority of that office.
Other ideas of Barnard
| Idea | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Economy of incentives (inducements–contributions balance) | People contribute only if the inducements they receive (material and non-material) equal or exceed the contributions asked of them |
| Informal organisation | Necessary to the formal: it aids communication, cohesion and the feeling of personal integrity |
| Effectiveness vs efficiency | Effectiveness = accomplishing the co-operative purpose; efficiency = satisfying the individual motives of members (Barnard’s special usage) |
| Executive functions | (1) maintain the system of communication; (2) secure essential services from individuals; (3) formulate and define purpose |
| Moral leadership | The executive must create and sustain a moral code that binds members to purpose |
Part C: Information Management in the Organisation
Meaning
Information management is the planned collection, storage, processing, retrieval, sharing and protection of information so that decision-makers get the right information, in the right form, at the right time. Since Simon made decision-making the heart of administration, information is its raw material.
| Concept | What it does |
|---|---|
| Data → information → knowledge | Raw facts become information when processed for a purpose; knowledge when interpreted with experience |
| Management Information System (MIS) | Organised system that supplies managers with regular reports for planning and control |
| Decision Support System (DSS) | Interactive tools for semi-structured decisions |
| Knowledge management | Capturing and sharing the know-how of employees (tacit and explicit knowledge) |
| Records management | Creation, classification, retention and disposal of files |
| E-governance | Using ICT to deliver services and information (G2C, G2B, G2G) |
Characteristics of good information
Accurate, relevant, timely, complete (but concise), reliable, accessible, and secure.
Information management in Indian administration
| Year | Measure |
|---|---|
| 2000 | Information Technology Act |
| 2005 | Right to Information Act: citizens’ right to information held by public authorities; duty of proactive disclosure (Section 4) |
| 2006 | National e-Governance Plan |
| 2015 | Digital India programme |
| 2023 | Digital Personal Data Protection Act |
Tools such as e-Office (paperless files), public grievance portals and dashboards for scheme monitoring apply MIS and MBO ideas to government. The challenges are the digital divide, data security and privacy, information overload and resistance to transparency.
Part D: Managing Conflict: Mary Parker Follett
Who she was
Mary Parker Follett (1868–1933), an American political scientist and social worker, wrote The New State (1918) and Creative Experience (1924). Her lectures to business audiences were published after her death as Dynamic Administration (1940, edited by Henry C. Metcalf and Lyndall Urwick). Her paper “Constructive Conflict” (1925) is the source of the syllabus line. She is often grouped with the human relations school, though her main ideas were in print before the Hawthorne studies were reported.
Conflict as difference
Follett asked us to think of conflict not as warfare but as the appearance of difference: differences of opinion and interest. Conflict, she said, is neither good nor bad in itself; we should use it, as an engineer uses friction, to make it constructive.
Three ways of dealing with conflict
| Method | What happens | Follett’s verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Domination | One side wins over the other | Easiest, but least satisfactory in the long run: the defeated side waits for its chance |
| Compromise | Each side gives up part of what it wants | Common, but nobody gets what they want; the conflict will reappear in another form |
| Integration | A solution is found in which both sides’ desires find a place, and neither has to sacrifice anything | Follett’s preferred method: it creates something new |
The library window. Follett’s own example: in a library reading room, one person wanted the window open, the other wanted it shut. They opened a window in the next room, where no one was sitting. One wanted fresh air, the other did not want a draught on him: both wishes were met. That is integration.
How to achieve integration
- Bring the differences into the open — face the conflict; put cards on the table.
- Break up the whole — examine the demands of both sides and break them into their constituent parts (what each side really wants beneath its stated demand).
- Revalue the demands — each side re-evaluates its desires in the light of the other’s.
- Follett also stressed the circular response: each side’s behaviour responds to the relation between itself and the other, so both change through interaction.
Obstacles to integration: it needs high intelligence and inventiveness; habits of domination; the pleasure of fighting and winning; theorising instead of examining concrete proposals; language that sharpens antagonism; and the influence of leaders who gain from conflict.
Other ideas of Follett (often in options)
| Idea | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Law of the situation | Orders should be depersonalised: both superior and subordinate take their orders from the situation, not from each other |
| Power-with vs power-over | Co-active power (developed jointly) rather than coercive power over others |
| Authority | Comes from function, not position; there is no “final” authority at the top |
| Responsibility | Cumulative responsibility shared across the organisation |
| Leadership | The leader is the one who best understands the whole situation and can organise the experience of the group |
Four principles of co-ordination:
- Co-ordination by direct contact of the responsible people concerned
- Co-ordination in the early stages (of policy-making, not after decisions are fixed)
- Co-ordination as the reciprocal relating of all the factors in a situation
- Co-ordination as a continuing process
Modern views of conflict (for comparison)
| View | Position |
|---|---|
| Traditional | All conflict is harmful and must be avoided (classical theorists) |
| Human relations | Conflict is natural and inevitable; accept it |
| Interactionist | Some conflict is functional; too little leads to stagnation |
| Follett | Conflict as difference; integrate it constructively |
The Thomas–Kilmann modes of conflict handling (competing, collaborating, compromising, avoiding, accommodating) map onto Follett: domination ≈ competing, compromise ≈ compromising, integration ≈ collaborating.
Part E: Management by Objectives: Peter Drucker
Origin
Peter F. Drucker (1909–2005), the Austrian-born American management thinker, introduced “management by objectives and self-control” in The Practice of Management (1954). George Odiorne’s Management by Objectives (1965) systematised it as a technique. Drucker also coined the term “knowledge worker” (The Landmarks of Tomorrow, 1959).
Meaning
MBO is a process in which superior and subordinate jointly identify common goals, define each individual’s major areas of responsibility in terms of expected results, and use these measures to guide the unit and to assess each member’s contribution. The key word is self-control: people who know their objectives and see their results can control their own work, instead of being controlled from above.
The MBO cycle
graph TD
A["1. Set organisational goals
(top management)"] --> B["2. Set unit and individual objectives
jointly (superior + subordinate)"]
B --> C["3. Action planning
(resources, timelines)"]
C --> D["4. Self-control in execution
(feedback on progress)"]
D --> E["5. Periodic review
(adjust objectives)"]
E --> F["6. Performance appraisal
(results vs objectives)"]
F --> AFeatures of good objectives
Objectives should be specific, measurable, time-bound, realistic and agreed. George T. Doran’s SMART acronym (1981) became the standard checklist (Specific, Measurable, Assignable, Realistic, Time-related; later versions vary the words).
Features of MBO
- Participative goal-setting (joint, not imposed)
- Results orientation (outputs, not activities)
- Self-control and self-appraisal
- Feedback and periodic review
- Linking individual objectives to organisational goals (a cascade from top to bottom)
Advantages and limitations
| Advantages | Limitations |
|---|---|
| Clarity of goals and roles | Hard to set measurable objectives for many public functions (policing, diplomacy, welfare) |
| Better planning and co-ordination | Emphasises short-term, quantifiable goals over long-term, qualitative ones |
| Motivation through participation (Locke’s goal-setting) | Time-consuming; paperwork |
| Objective basis for appraisal | Can become top-down imposition in practice |
| Develops managers; supports delegation | Rigid in a changing environment; may encourage gaming of targets |
W. Edwards Deming, the quality-management pioneer, was a strong critic: one of his fourteen points calls for eliminating management by objective and management by numbers, because fixed numerical targets distract from improving the system.
MBO in public administration
- Fits the results orientation of later reforms: performance budgeting, outcome budgeting (India introduced an Outcome Budget in 2005), and the “results-oriented” principle of Osborne and Gaebler.
- India’s Results-Framework Documents (RFDs), introduced as part of a Performance Monitoring and Evaluation System around 2009, applied MBO-style agreements to ministries.
- Problems in government: multiple and conflicting objectives, political priorities, difficulty of measurement, and rigid rules that limit self-control.
Other Drucker ideas worth knowing
| Work | Year | Idea |
|---|---|---|
| Concept of the Corporation | 1946 | Study of General Motors; the corporation as a social institution |
| The Practice of Management | 1954 | MBO; “the purpose of a business is to create a customer” |
| The Landmarks of Tomorrow | 1959 | “Knowledge worker” |
| The Effective Executive | 1967 | Effectiveness can be learned |
| The Age of Discontinuity | 1969 | Knowledge society; argued for “reprivatisation” of many government activities |
| Management: Tasks, Responsibilities, Practices | 1973 | Comprehensive statement |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Barnard — zone of indifference (1938) | vs | Simon — zone of acceptance (1947) |
| Barnard’s effectiveness — achieving the purpose | vs | Barnard’s efficiency — satisfying individual motives |
| Acceptance theory (Barnard) — authority from below | vs | Formal / classical theory — authority from above (position) |
| Follett’s compromise — each side gives up something | vs | Follett’s integration — both sides’ desires find a place |
| Law of the situation (Follett) | vs | Unity of command (Fayol) |
| Drucker (1954) — introduced MBO | vs | Odiorne (1965) — systematised MBO |
| MBO — joint, results-based objectives | vs | Management by exception — managers attend only to significant deviations |
| Wheel network — centralised, fast for simple tasks | vs | All-channel network — decentralised, high satisfaction |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Name Barnard’s three elements of a formal organisation.
- Which method of dealing with conflict did Mary Parker Follett prefer?
- In which book did Peter Drucker introduce management by objectives?
Answers
- Communication, willingness to serve (co-operate) and common purpose.
- Integration.
- The Practice of Management (1954).
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) Which of the following is not one of Barnard’s conditions for a person to accept a communication as authoritative?
- (a) He can and does understand it
- (b) He believes it is not inconsistent with the purpose of the organisation
- (c) It has been issued by the head of the organisation personally
- (d) He is able mentally and physically to comply with it
Answer and explanation
(c). Barnard’s third condition is that the order is compatible with the person’s personal interest as a whole; the issuer’s identity is not a condition. Authority depends on acceptance, not on the issuer’s rank.
Q2. (Practice) “Both superior and subordinate should take their orders from the situation.” This idea is associated with:
- (a) Henri Fayol
- (b) Chester Barnard
- (c) Mary Parker Follett
- (d) Peter Drucker
Answer and explanation
(c) Mary Parker Follett: the law of the situation, which depersonalises orders.
Q3. (Practice) Consider the following statements about management by objectives:
- Objectives are set jointly by the superior and the subordinate.
- It emphasises self-control rather than control from above.
- It was first described in Odiorne’s Management by Objectives (1965).
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 2 and 3 only
- (c) 1 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(a) 1 and 2 only. Drucker described MBO first in The Practice of Management (1954); Odiorne systematised it later.
Q4. (Practice) In small-group communication experiments, which network is generally fastest and most accurate for simple tasks but gives low satisfaction to peripheral members?
- (a) Circle
- (b) All-channel
- (c) Wheel
- (d) Chain
Answer and explanation
(c) Wheel. All messages go through one central person, who emerges as leader; others are dissatisfied. All-channel and circle are slower for simple tasks but more satisfying.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Follett regarded compromise as an unsatisfactory way of settling conflict. Reason (R): In a compromise each side gives up part of what it wants, so the conflict tends to reappear in another form.
Answer and explanation
(a). R gives Follett’s own reason for A.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): Barnard held that authority depends on its acceptance by the person to whom an order is addressed. Reason (R): Barnard defined the efficiency of an organisation as the accomplishment of its common purpose.
Answer and explanation
(c). A is true. R is false: for Barnard, accomplishing the purpose is effectiveness; efficiency is the satisfaction of individual motives. (Even if it were true, it would not explain A.)
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (Thinker) with List II (Idea).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Chester Barnard | I. Law of the situation |
| B. Mary Parker Follett | II. Zone of indifference |
| C. Peter Drucker | III. Fourteen points, including elimination of management by objective |
| D. W. Edwards Deming | IV. Management by objectives and self-control |
- (a) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
- (b) A-I, B-II, C-IV, D-III
- (c) A-II, B-I, C-III, D-IV
- (d) A-IV, B-I, C-II, D-III
Answer and explanation
(a) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following in chronological order:
- Drucker, The Practice of Management
- Follett, The New State
- Barnard, The Functions of the Executive
- Follett, Dynamic Administration (posthumous)
- (a) 2, 3, 4, 1
- (b) 2, 4, 3, 1
- (c) 3, 2, 4, 1
- (d) 2, 3, 1, 4
Answer and explanation
(a) 2, 3, 4, 1. 1918 → 1938 → 1940 → 1954.
Q5. (Practice) Arrange the steps of the MBO cycle in the correct order:
- Performance appraisal against objectives
- Joint setting of individual objectives
- Setting of organisational goals
- Periodic review of progress
- (a) 3, 2, 4, 1
- (b) 2, 3, 4, 1
- (c) 3, 4, 2, 1
- (d) 3, 2, 1, 4
Answer and explanation
(a) 3, 2, 4, 1. Organisational goals → individual objectives → review → appraisal (which feeds the next cycle).
Quick Revision Table
| Thinker / item | Work | Year | Key idea |
|---|---|---|---|
| Follett | The New State | 1918 | Group process, democracy |
| Follett | Creative Experience | 1924 | Circular response |
| Follett | “Constructive Conflict” | 1925 | Domination, compromise, integration; library window |
| Barnard | The Functions of the Executive | 1938 | Co-operative system; acceptance theory; zone of indifference; 7 principles of communication |
| Follett (posthumous) | Dynamic Administration (eds Metcalf and Urwick) | 1940 | Law of the situation; four principles of co-ordination |
| Lasswell | Communication formula | 1948 | Who, what, channel, whom, effect |
| Shannon and Weaver | The Mathematical Theory of Communication | 1949 | Source, transmitter, channel, noise, receiver |
| Drucker | The Practice of Management | 1954 | MBO and self-control |
| Drucker | The Landmarks of Tomorrow | 1959 | Knowledge worker |
| Odiorne | Management by Objectives | 1965 | MBO systematised |
| Doran | SMART objectives | 1981 | Specific, Measurable, Assignable, Realistic, Time-related |
| India | RTI Act | 2005 | Access to information; proactive disclosure |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Public Administration — Quick Revision — the whole unit on one page
- Rational Choice, NPA, Development Administration and NPM — how MBO’s results orientation reappears in NPM
- Meaning, Evolution and Approaches — Simon’s decision-making approach, which built on Barnard
- Barriers to Effective Communication (Paper 1) — the same barriers from the teaching side