Skip to content

Locke and Rousseau

Locke's Two Treatises (natural rights, property, trust, resistance) and Rousseau's Discourses and Social Contract (general will, sovereignty) for UGC NET.

  • 21 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 12 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: Two Answers to Leviathan
  3. 1. John Locke (1632–1704)
  4. 2. Jean-Jacques Rousseau (1712–1778)
  5. Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau Compared
  6. Memory Tricks
  7. Don’t Confuse
  8. Common Mistakes
  9. Practice
  10. Quick Revision Table
  11. Key Takeaways
  12. What’s Next

Prerequisites

The Hook: Two Answers to Leviathan

How UGC NET asks it: Locke’s three inconveniences, his labour theory of property and its provisos, legislative–executive–federative powers, tacit consent; Rousseau’s opening line, general will vs will of all, “forced to be free”, his attack on representation; and three-way comparisons with Hobbes, which are among the most common match-the-following items in this unit.


1. John Locke (1632–1704)

Life and context

  • Studied and taught at Oxford; trained in medicine.
  • From 1667 he was physician, secretary and adviser to Anthony Ashley Cooper, first Earl of Shaftesbury, leader of the Whig opposition to Charles II and the campaign to exclude the Catholic James from the throne (the Exclusion Crisis, 1679–81).
  • Lived in exile in the Netherlands (1683–89) and returned to England after the Glorious Revolution of 1688.

Works

WorkYearNote
Two Treatises of GovernmentPublished anonymously 1689 (title page dated 1690)First Treatise refutes Sir Robert Filmer’s Patriarcha; Second Treatise gives Locke’s own theory
A Letter Concerning Toleration1689Written in Latin; toleration and separation of church and state
An Essay Concerning Human Understanding1689 (dated 1690)Empiricism: the mind as a blank slate (tabula rasa); no innate ideas
Some Thoughts Concerning Education1693Education of a gentleman

The First Treatise: against patriarchalism

Filmer’s Patriarcha (published 1680) derived the absolute power of kings from the power God gave Adam over his children and the world. Locke replies that political power is different in kind from a father’s power over children, a husband’s over a wife and a master’s over a servant, and that no one today can show descent from Adam’s heir.

The state of nature (Second Treatise, ch. 2)

  • A state of perfect freedom and a state of equality, “within the bounds of the law of nature”.
  • It is “a state of liberty, yet it is not a state of licence”: the law of nature, which is reason, teaches that no one ought to harm another in his life, health, liberty or possessions.
  • Every person holds the executive power of the law of nature: each may punish offenders and seek reparation.
  • The state of war (ch. 3) is distinct from the state of nature. Locke separates the two concepts that Hobbes had merged.

Why leave the state of nature: three inconveniences (ch. 9)

The state of nature is peaceful but inconvenient, because it lacks:

  1. an established, settled, known law, received by common consent as the standard of right and wrong;
  2. a known and indifferent judge with authority to settle disputes;
  3. a power to back and support the sentence when right, and to execute it.

These map onto the legislative, judicial and executive functions of government. People join in society for the “mutual preservation of their lives, liberties and estates, which I call by the general name, property”.

Property and labour (ch. 5)

  • God gave the world to mankind in common. Yet “every man has a property in his own person”, and so in the labour of his body and the work of his hands.
  • Whatever a person removes from the state of nature and mixes his labour with becomes his property, without the consent of others.
  • Labour creates most of the value of things: Locke says it accounts for the greater part of the value of cultivated land.
  • Two limits (often called provisos) on natural appropriation:
    • Sufficiency: there must be “enough, and as good, left in common for others”;
    • Spoilage: no one may take more than he can use before it spoils.
  • The invention of money, by tacit consent, removes the spoilage limit: money does not spoil, so people can accumulate unequal possessions legitimately.

C.B. Macpherson (The Political Theory of Possessive Individualism: Hobbes to Locke, 1962) read this chapter as a justification of unlimited capitalist appropriation. Locke is therefore claimed both as the father of liberalism and as the philosopher of possessive individualism.

  • People are by nature free, equal and independent; no one can be subjected to the political power of another without his own consent.
  • By the contract people form one body politic, which acts by the will of the majority.
  • Express consent makes one a full member. Tacit consent is given by anyone who enjoys the possessions or protection of a government: owning land, lodging for a week, even “travelling freely on the highway”.
  • Textbooks often describe two steps: a social contract that creates civil society, and a relation of trust by which society entrusts power to government. The government is a trustee, not a party with rights against the people.

Limited government

FeatureLocke’s position
Supreme powerThe legislative (ch. 11), but it is a fiduciary power held on trust
Limits on the legislativeMust rule by promulgated, standing laws; cannot be arbitrary; cannot take property without consent; cannot transfer law-making power to others
Three powersLegislative (makes law), executive (enforces it at home), federative (war, peace, alliances, foreign relations)
SeparationLegislative and executive should be in different hands; executive and federative usually in the same hands
Prerogative (ch. 14)Executive discretion to act for the public good where law is silent, or even against it
Ultimate powerRemains with the people, who may remove or alter a legislative that acts contrary to its trust

Dissolution and the right of resistance (ch. 19)

  • Locke distinguishes dissolution of society (rare, mainly by foreign conquest) from dissolution of government.
  • Government is dissolved when the legislative is altered without the people’s consent, when the executive neglects its duty, or when legislative or executive acts contrary to its trust by invading the people’s property.
  • Then the people may resist and set up a new legislative. Where there is no judge on earth, the remedy is the “appeal to heaven”.
  • Locke’s answer to the charge that this invites anarchy: people are slow to rebel, and do so only after “a long train of abuses”. The American Declaration of Independence (1776) uses a similar phrase and the triad “life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness”.

Toleration

The Letter Concerning Toleration separates the business of civil government (civil interests: life, liberty, health, possessions) from that of religion (the salvation of souls), which force cannot achieve. But toleration had limits: Locke excluded atheists (whose oaths could not be trusted) and those who owed allegiance to a foreign prince, which in context meant Roman Catholics.


2. Jean-Jacques Rousseau (1712–1778)

Life

  • Born in Geneva in 1712; signed himself “Citizen of Geneva”. His mother died soon after his birth; he left Geneva as a teenager.
  • In Paris he knew Diderot and wrote for the Encyclopédie, then broke with the philosophes.
  • After Emile and The Social Contract (both 1762) were condemned in Paris and Geneva, he lived as a fugitive for several years.
  • His Confessions were published after his death.

Works

WorkYearNote
Discourse on the Sciences and Arts (First Discourse)1750Prize essay, Academy of Dijon: progress in the arts and sciences has corrupted morals
Discourse on the Origin of Inequality (Second Discourse)1755Natural man, the origin of property and of inequality
Discourse on Political Economy1755Article for the Encyclopédie; an early statement of the general will
Julie, or the New Heloise1761Novel
The Social Contract (Du contrat social)1762Subtitle: Principles of Political Right
Emile, or On Education1762Natural (negative) education; Book V on the education of Sophie
Considerations on the Government of PolandWritten 1771–72Practical constitutional advice
ConfessionsPosthumousAutobiography

The Second Discourse: how inequality arose

  • Natural man is solitary, healthy, independent and peaceful, moved by two pre-rational principles: amour de soi (self-love, the concern for one’s own preservation) and pitié (compassion, a natural repugnance at seeing another suffer). What distinguishes him from animals is free agency and perfectibilité (perfectibility).
  • Hobbes’s mistake, says Rousseau, was to give natural man passions such as pride and fear of others that only society produces.
  • With settled life, comparison and the desire to be esteemed, amour-propre (vanity, self-love dependent on the opinion of others) appears.
  • Property is the turning point: “The first man who, having enclosed a piece of ground, bethought himself of saying ‘This is mine’, and found people simple enough to believe him, was the real founder of civil society.”
  • The rich then propose a fraudulent contract, presented as protecting everyone, which in fact turns usurpation into right and fixes inequality in law.
  • Two kinds of inequality: natural or physical (age, health, strength) and moral or political (established by convention and consent; privileges some enjoy at others’ expense).

The Social Contract (1762)

The problem. The book opens: “Man is born free, and everywhere he is in chains.” Rousseau does not ask how this happened (the Second Discourse did) but what can make it legitimate. Force does not make right, and no one can alienate his freedom by a contract of slavery.

The formula (Book I, ch. 6). “To find a form of association which will defend and protect with the whole common force the person and goods of each associate, and in which each, while uniting himself with all, may still obey himself alone, and remain as free as before.”

The solution. Each associate makes a total alienation of himself and all his rights to the whole community. Since each gives himself to all, he gives himself to no one in particular, and the conditions are equal for all. The act produces a moral and collective body, called the sovereign when active, the state when passive, and people collectively; its members are citizens as sharers in sovereignty and subjects as bound by its laws.

Three liberties. In the transition from nature to civil society a person loses natural liberty (an unlimited right to everything he can get, limited only by his strength) and gains civil liberty (limited by the general will) and moral liberty, which alone makes him master of himself: “the mere impulse of appetite is slavery, while obedience to a law which we prescribe to ourselves is liberty.”

The general will

General will (volonté générale)Will of all (volonté de tous)
Aims atThe common interestPrivate interests
NatureWhat each citizen wills as a citizenThe sum of particular wills
Rousseau’s claim“Always right” and tends to the public advantageCan be mistaken; the people can be deceived
  • The general will is found by taking away from the particular wills “the pluses and minuses that cancel one another”; the sum of the differences is the general will. It is best expressed when citizens deliberate without communicating with one another and without partial associations (factions) that put group interests in place of the common one.
  • “Whoever refuses to obey the general will shall be compelled to do so by the whole body. This means nothing less than that he will be forced to be free.” (Book I, ch. 7)
  • The general will must be general in its object and in its source: it makes laws about the community as a whole, never decrees about particular individuals.

Sovereignty

Rousseau’s sovereignty belongs to the people and is:

  • Inalienable: the will cannot be transferred; power can be.
  • Indivisible: those who divide it into legislative, executive, taxing powers and so on “make the sovereign a fantastic being”.
  • Unrepresentable: “the English people thinks it is free; it is greatly mistaken; it is free only during the election of members of parliament. As soon as they are elected, slavery overtakes it.” Deputies can only be the people’s agents (commissaires); any law the people have not ratified in person is null.
  • Infallible in the sense that the general will is always right, though the people’s deliberations are not always correct.

Government, the legislator and civil religion

  • Government (Book III) is an intermediate body between sovereign and subjects that executes the laws. It is not created by a contract but by a law and a nomination. Rousseau classifies governments as democracy, aristocracy (natural, elective and hereditary; elective is the best) and monarchy. True democracy suits only “a people of gods”.
  • No one form suits every country: the right government depends on size, climate and population. Large states tend to monarchy, small ones to democracy.
  • Government tends to usurp sovereignty; hence periodic assemblies of the people should ask whether to keep the form of government and the present office-holders.
  • The Legislator (Book II, ch. 7) is an extraordinary figure (Lycurgus, Calvin) who drafts the laws but holds no power; the people must still approve them.
  • Civil religion (Book IV, ch. 8): a few simple dogmas (existence of God, the life to come, the happiness of the just and punishment of the wicked, the sanctity of the social contract and the laws) and one negative dogma, intolerance, which is excluded.

Rousseau’s legacy and critics

  • Inspired the radical phase of the French Revolution (the Jacobins invoked him) and popular sovereignty generally.
  • Influenced Kant’s idea of autonomy and Hegel’s rational will.
  • J.L. Talmon, The Origins of Totalitarian Democracy (1952), and Isaiah Berlin treated the general will and “forced to be free” as roots of modern authoritarianism. Defenders reply that Rousseau insists on law, equality and the people’s own assembly.
  • Emile’s Book V, which educates Sophie to please and serve Emile, was attacked by Mary Wollstonecraft in 1792 (next page).

Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau Compared

This three-column table is the single most useful revision table in Western political thought.

FeatureHobbesLockeRousseau
Key workLeviathan (1651)Two Treatises (1689)The Social Contract (1762)
Human natureSelfish, fearful, power-seekingRational, sociable enough to keep the law of natureNaturally good; corrupted by society
State of natureWar of all against allPeace, liberty and equality, but inconvenientSolitary, innocent, peaceful (Second Discourse)
Natural lawRules of prudence for survivalReason; rights to life, liberty, estatePre-rational sentiments: self-love and pity
ContractEach with each, to authorise a sovereignTo form society; government holds power on trustEach gives himself totally to the community
SovereignOne man or assembly, absoluteLimited; supreme legislative under trustThe people, through the general will
Rights retainedSelf-preservation onlyLife, liberty, estateExchanged for civil and moral liberty
ResistanceNo (except to save one’s life)Yes, when trust is brokenSovereign people can change government at will
Ideological heirAbsolutism, legal positivismLiberalism, constitutionalismPopular sovereignty, radical democracy
graph LR
    H["Hobbes 1651
fear → absolute sovereign"] --> L["Locke 1689
rights → limited trust"] L --> R["Rousseau 1762
freedom → general will"] R --> K["Kant, Hegel
autonomy, rational will"]

Memory Tricks

Don’t Confuse

ThisvsThat
Locke’s state of nature: peace, but inconvenientvsLocke’s state of war: a separate condition of force without right
Express consent: full membershipvsTacit consent: enjoying property or using the highway
Federative power: foreign relations (Locke)vsFederal: division of power between centre and units
General will: common interest, always rightvsWill of all: sum of private wills
Amour de soi: natural self-preservationvsAmour-propre: vanity born of comparison in society
Natural liberty: limited by strengthvsCivil liberty: limited by the general will; moral liberty: self-legislation
Sovereign (Rousseau): the people legislatingvsGovernment (Rousseau): executive agent of the sovereign
Filmer’s Patriarcha: divine right through AdamvsLocke’s First Treatise: its refutation

Common Mistakes


Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. Whose patriarchal theory does Locke’s First Treatise refute?
  2. What two limits does Locke place on natural appropriation of property?
  3. Complete Rousseau’s line: “Man is born free, and …”
Answers
  1. Sir Robert Filmer (Patriarcha).
  2. Sufficiency (“enough, and as good” left for others) and spoilage (no waste).
  3. “… everywhere he is in chains.” (The Social Contract, Book I, ch. 1)

Level 2: Exam-style MCQs

Q1. (Practice) According to Locke, which of the following is not one of the wants of the state of nature that lead people to form civil society?

  • (a) An established, settled, known law
  • (b) A known and indifferent judge
  • (c) A power to back and execute the sentence
  • (d) A sovereign who is not a party to the contract
Answer and explanation

(d). (a)–(c) are Locke’s three inconveniences. A sovereign who stands outside the contract is Hobbes’s idea.

Q2. (Practice) Consider the following statements about Rousseau:

  1. He held that sovereignty can be represented by elected deputies.
  2. He distinguished the general will from the will of all.
  3. He argued that partial associations obstruct the expression of the general will.

Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  • (a) 1 and 2 only
  • (b) 2 and 3 only
  • (c) 1 and 3 only
  • (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation

(b) 2 and 3 only. Statement 1 is false: for Rousseau sovereignty “cannot be represented”; deputies are only agents.

Q3. (Practice) In Locke’s theory, a person who merely travels on the highway within a country has given:

  • (a) express consent
  • (b) tacit consent
  • (c) no consent at all
  • (d) consent only to the federative power
Answer and explanation

(b) tacit consent (Second Treatise, ch. 8). Tacit consent binds a person to obey while he enjoys the government’s protection, but only express consent makes him a full member.

Q4. (Practice) Which thinker described the transition to civil society as the gain of “moral liberty, which alone makes man truly master of himself”?

  • (a) Hobbes
  • (b) Locke
  • (c) Rousseau
  • (d) Montesquieu
Answer and explanation

(c) Rousseau (The Social Contract, Book I, ch. 8): obedience to a self-prescribed law is liberty.

Q5. (Practice) Who argued that Locke’s theory of property provided a justification for unlimited capitalist appropriation?

  • (a) Peter Laslett
  • (b) C.B. Macpherson
  • (c) J.L. Talmon
  • (d) Leo Strauss
Answer and explanation

(b) C.B. Macpherson, The Political Theory of Possessive Individualism (1962). Laslett edited the Two Treatises (1960); Talmon wrote on Rousseau and “totalitarian democracy”.

Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence

For assertion–reason questions, use these options:

  • (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
  • (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
  • (c) A is true, but R is false
  • (d) A is false, but R is true

Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Locke held that the invention of money made large inequalities of possession legitimate. Reason (R): Money does not spoil, so accumulating it does not break the spoilage limit, and people agreed to its use by tacit consent.

Answer and explanation

(a). Both true, and R is exactly Locke’s explanation in chapter 5.

Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): Rousseau held that the general will is always right. Reason (R): Rousseau held that the deliberations of the people always reach the correct decision.

Answer and explanation

(c). A is true. R is false: Rousseau explicitly says the people can be deceived, so their deliberations do not always have the same rectitude as the general will.

Q3. (Practice) Match List I (Thinker) with List II (Idea).

List IList II
A. HobbesI. Federative power
B. LockeII. Separation of judicial power
C. RousseauIII. War of every man against every man
D. MontesquieuIV. Sovereignty cannot be represented
  • (a) A-III, B-I, C-IV, D-II
  • (b) A-III, B-II, C-IV, D-I
  • (c) A-I, B-III, C-II, D-IV
  • (d) A-III, B-IV, C-I, D-II
Answer and explanation

(a) A-III, B-I, C-IV, D-II.

Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following works in chronological order of publication:

  1. Discourse on the Origin of Inequality
  2. Two Treatises of Government
  3. Leviathan
  4. The Social Contract
  • (a) 3, 2, 4, 1
  • (b) 2, 3, 1, 4
  • (c) 3, 2, 1, 4
  • (d) 3, 1, 2, 4
Answer and explanation

(c) 3, 2, 1, 4. Leviathan 1651 → Two Treatises 1689 → Second Discourse 1755 → The Social Contract 1762.

Q5. (Practice) Consider Rousseau’s three forms of liberty: (1) moral liberty, (2) natural liberty, (3) civil liberty. Which statement correctly describes what happens when a person moves from the state of nature into a legitimate civil order?

  • (a) 2 is lost; 3 and 1 are gained
  • (b) 1 is lost; 2 and 3 are gained
  • (c) 3 is lost; 1 and 2 are gained
  • (d) All three are kept
Answer and explanation

(a). Natural liberty is given up; civil liberty and moral liberty are gained (The Social Contract, Book I, ch. 8).


Quick Revision Table

ThinkerWork (year)Key ideas
Locke (1632–1704)Two Treatises (1689)State of nature = liberty not licence; three inconveniences; property = life, liberty, estate; labour theory; sufficiency and spoilage; money by tacit consent; express and tacit consent; majority; legislative supreme under trust; legislative, executive, federative; prerogative; right of resistance, “appeal to heaven”
LockeLetter Concerning Toleration (1689)Church and state separate; no toleration for atheists, foreign allegiance
LockeEssay Concerning Human Understanding (1689)Tabula rasa, empiricism
FilmerPatriarcha (1680)Divine right through Adam; refuted in First Treatise
Rousseau (1712–1778)First Discourse (1750)Arts and sciences corrupt morals
RousseauSecond Discourse (1755)Amour de soi, pity, perfectibility, amour-propre; “This is mine”; natural vs moral inequality
RousseauThe Social Contract (1762)“Born free … in chains”; total alienation; general will vs will of all; forced to be free; sovereignty inalienable, indivisible, unrepresentable; legislator; civil religion
RousseauEmile (1762)Negative education; Sophie (Book V)
TalmonOrigins of Totalitarian Democracy (1952)Rousseau as source of totalitarian democracy
LaslettEdition of Two Treatises (1960)Written around the Exclusion Crisis
MacphersonPossessive Individualism (1962)Locke and unlimited appropriation

Key Takeaways

What’s Next

Advertisement
Advertisement