Hegel, Wollstonecraft and Mill
Hegel's dialectic, civil society and state; Wollstonecraft's Vindication of the Rights of Woman; J.S. Mill on liberty, representation and women, for UGC NET.
- 21 min
On this page · 13 sections
Prerequisites
- Locke and Rousseau: Hegel builds on Rousseau’s idea of a rational will; Wollstonecraft answers Rousseau’s Emile; Mill inherits Locke’s liberal individualism.
- Liberty and Equality in Unit 1 already states Mill’s harm principle and Berlin’s two concepts of liberty. This page places Mill’s whole system around it.
- Feminism, Ecologism, Multiculturalism and Postmodernism places Wollstonecraft and Mill at the start of liberal feminism.
The Hook: Three Answers to the French Revolution
How UGC NET asks it: Hegel’s family–civil society–state triad and the stages of world history; Wollstonecraft’s works, her dedicatee and her critique of Rousseau; Mill’s harm principle, his four arguments for free speech, higher and lower pleasures, plural voting and proportional representation, and The Subjection of Women. Sequencing questions on Mill’s works are common.
1. G.W.F. Hegel (1770–1831)
Life and works
- Born in Stuttgart in 1770. Studied at the Tübingen seminary, where he shared rooms with Schelling and the poet Hölderlin.
- Taught at Jena, edited a newspaper at Bamberg, was a school rector at Nuremberg, then professor at Heidelberg (1816) and Berlin (from 1818) until his death in 1831.
| Work | Year | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Phenomenology of Spirit | 1807 | Journey of consciousness to absolute knowing; lord and bondsman (master–slave) dialectic |
| Science of Logic | 1812–1816 | The dialectical logic |
| Encyclopaedia of the Philosophical Sciences | 1817 | Logic, nature, spirit: the whole system |
| Elements of the Philosophy of Right | 1820 (title page dated 1821) | His political philosophy: right, morality, ethical life, state |
| Lectures on the Philosophy of History | Published after his death | World history as the progress of freedom |
Key concepts
- Geist (Spirit, Mind): reality is the self-development of spirit, which comes to know itself through nature, human history, institutions, art, religion and philosophy.
- Dialectic: every limited idea or form of life contains a contradiction that drives it beyond itself to a richer form. The movement is captured by Aufhebung (sublation), which means at once to cancel, to preserve and to lift up.
- “What is rational is actual, and what is actual is rational.” (Preface, Philosophy of Right)
- “The owl of Minerva spreads its wings only with the falling of the dusk.” (same Preface): philosophy understands an age only when it has matured, too late to tell it how it ought to be.
- Lord and bondsman (Phenomenology): two self-consciousnesses struggle for recognition; the loser becomes the bondsman. But the bondsman, by labour on the world, achieves a truer self-consciousness than the idle lord. Marx and later Kojève read this passage closely.
World history as the progress of freedom
“The history of the world is none other than the progress of the consciousness of freedom.” Hegel divides it into stages:
| Stage | Who is known to be free |
|---|---|
| Oriental world | One is free (the despot) |
| Greek and Roman world | Some are free (citizens, not slaves) |
| Germanic (Christian-European) world | All are free, as human beings |
World-historical individuals (Caesar, Alexander, Napoleon) pursue their own passions but serve ends larger than they know: the “cunning of reason” uses individual passions to realise the purposes of spirit.
The Philosophy of Right: the structure
graph TD
A["Abstract Right
property, contract, wrong"] --> B["Morality (Moralität)
intention, conscience, the good"]
B --> C["Ethical Life (Sittlichkeit)"]
C --> D["Family
unity through love"]
D --> E["Civil Society
system of needs, administration
of justice, police and corporation"]
E --> F["State
actuality of the ethical Idea"]- Abstract right: the person as owner; property is the first embodiment of freedom; contract; wrong and punishment.
- Morality (Moralität): the inward, subjective will; intention and conscience. Hegel criticises Kant’s morality as empty formalism: duty for duty’s sake gives no content.
- Ethical life (Sittlichkeit): freedom embodied in institutions and customs.
- Family: immediate unity based on love; dissolves when children grow up.
- Civil society (bürgerliche Gesellschaft): the sphere of particular interests and the market, “the battlefield where everyone’s individual private interest meets everyone else’s”. It contains the system of needs, the administration of justice, and the police (public authority) and corporation (occupational associations). Hegel notices that civil society produces a rabble (Pöbel) of the poor that it cannot absorb.
- State: the unity of the universal and the particular. “The state is the actuality of the ethical Idea.” In it individuals find their freedom, not as a limitation but as fulfilment.
The rational state
- A constitutional monarchy with three powers: the crown (the monarch’s role is to give the final “I will”), the executive, staffed by a professional civil service, the universal class, and the legislature of the estates.
- Hegel’s three classes: the agricultural (substantial) class, the business (reflecting) class and the universal class of civil servants, who have the interest of the whole as their business.
- War has an ethical function: it preserves the ethical health of nations, as the movement of the winds preserves the sea from stagnation. There is no judge above sovereign states.
- A remark in the lecture notes printed with the Philosophy of Right is often translated “the march of God in the world, that is what the state is”. The translation is disputed (another rendering is “it is the way of God in the world that there should be a state”).
Reception
| Reader | Reading of Hegel |
|---|---|
| Young (Left) Hegelians: Feuerbach, Bruno Bauer, the young Marx | Used the dialectic to criticise religion and the existing state |
| Old (Right) Hegelians | Read him as a defender of the Prussian state and Christianity |
| Marx | Critique of Hegel’s Philosophy of Right (1843); the dialectic is “standing on its head” and must be “turned right side up” (afterword to Capital, 1873) |
| British idealists: T.H. Green, F.H. Bradley, Bernard Bosanquet | The state as the realisation of the common good |
| Karl Popper, The Open Society and Its Enemies (1945) | Hegel (with Plato and Marx) as an enemy of the open society and a forerunner of totalitarianism |
| Francis Fukuyama, “The End of History?” (1989) | Liberal democracy as the end point of the Hegelian struggle for recognition, by way of Kojève’s reading |
2. Mary Wollstonecraft (1759–1797)
Life
- Born in London in 1759; largely self-educated. Ran a school at Newington Green with her sister and a friend, worked as a governess in Ireland, then as a writer and reviewer for the radical publisher Joseph Johnson.
- Lived in revolutionary France from late 1792; later married the anarchist philosopher William Godwin (Political Justice, 1793) in 1797.
- Died in 1797, days after giving birth to her daughter Mary, later Mary Shelley, author of Frankenstein.
Works
| Work | Year | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Thoughts on the Education of Daughters | 1787 | Early conduct book |
| A Vindication of the Rights of Men | 1790 | Reply to Burke’s Reflections on the Revolution in France, published within weeks of it |
| A Vindication of the Rights of Woman | 1792 | Dedicated to Talleyrand, urging him to include girls in his plan for French national education |
| An Historical and Moral View of the French Revolution | 1794 | History |
| Letters Written … in Sweden, Norway, and Denmark | 1796 | Travel letters |
| Maria, or the Wrongs of Woman | Posthumous (unfinished novel) | Women’s legal and economic oppression |
A Vindication of the Rights of Woman (1792): the argument
- Reason is the basis of rights. God gave reason to human beings as such; virtue is the exercise of reason. Women are rational creatures, so the same virtue and the same rights apply to them.
- Women’s “weakness” is manufactured. Women appear vain, frivolous and cunning because they are educated only to please men, confined to sensibility and appearance, and denied the exercise of reason. Their condition is a product of education and circumstance, not nature.
- Against Rousseau. Book V of Emile educates Sophie to be pleasing, obedient and dependent on Emile. Wollstonecraft’s sharpest pages are a point-by-point critique of this; she also attacks conduct-book writers such as Dr James Fordyce and Dr John Gregory.
- Independence, not domination. “I do not wish them to have power over men; but over themselves.” She wants women to be independent persons, better wives and mothers because they are rational citizens.
- National education. Chapter 12 proposes free, state-supported co-educational day schools in which girls and boys of all ranks study together in early years.
- Against arbitrary power everywhere. She compares the power of husbands to that of kings: “the divine right of husbands, like the divine right of kings, may, it is to be hoped, in this enlightened age, be contested without danger”. She also attacks hereditary aristocracy, the army and the clergy as institutions that make people dependent.
- Political voice. She suggests that women ought to have representatives instead of being governed without any direct share in the deliberations of government, though she presents this cautiously.
3. John Stuart Mill (1806–1873)
Life
- Son of the utilitarian James Mill, who gave him a famously rigorous home education (Greek at three, by his own account in the Autobiography), under the influence of Jeremy Bentham.
- Worked for the East India Company in London from 1823 until the Company was wound up in 1858.
- A mental crisis in 1826 led him to Wordsworth’s poetry, Coleridge and the Romantics, and to a broader idea of human happiness.
- Close intellectual partnership with Harriet Taylor, whom he married in 1851; On Liberty is dedicated to her memory.
- MP for Westminster (1865–1868). In 1867 he moved an amendment to the Reform Bill to replace “man” with “person”, the first proposal for women’s suffrage in the House of Commons. It was defeated.
Works
| Work | Year | Note |
|---|---|---|
| A System of Logic | 1843 | Methods of induction; logic of the moral sciences |
| Principles of Political Economy | 1848 | Laws of production are fixed, laws of distribution are human institutions; stationary state |
| On Liberty | 1859 | Harm principle; freedom of thought; individuality |
| Considerations on Representative Government | 1861 | Best form of government; PR; plural voting |
| Utilitarianism | 1861 (magazine), 1863 (book) | Higher and lower pleasures |
| The Subjection of Women | 1869 | Legal subordination of women as wrong in itself |
| Autobiography | 1873 | Published after his death |
| Chapters on Socialism | Published posthumously | Sympathetic but cautious view of socialism |
Utilitarianism revised
- Mill accepts the greatest happiness principle: actions are right as they tend to promote happiness.
- But against Bentham’s purely quantitative calculus (often summed up as “push-pin is as good as poetry”), Mill introduces qualitative differences between pleasures. Higher pleasures of the intellect, feelings, imagination and moral sentiments are more valuable than lower bodily pleasures; competent judges who have experienced both prefer the higher.
- “It is better to be a human being dissatisfied than a pig satisfied; better to be Socrates dissatisfied than a fool satisfied.”
On Liberty (1859)
The danger. In democratic societies the threat to liberty comes less from rulers than from the tyranny of the majority (a phrase he takes from Tocqueville) and from the “social tyranny” of prevailing opinion and custom, which “enslaves the soul itself”.
The harm principle. “The only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilised community, against his will, is to prevent harm to others. His own good, either physical or moral, is not a sufficient warrant.” And: “Over himself, over his own body and mind, the individual is sovereign.”
- Self-regarding actions (affecting only oneself) are free from interference; other-regarding actions that harm others may be regulated by law or opinion.
- Mill grounds liberty in utility “in the largest sense, grounded on the permanent interests of man as a progressive being”, not in abstract natural rights.
- Limits: the principle applies only to adults “in the maturity of their faculties”; not to children, and not to “backward states of society”. “Despotism is a legitimate mode of government in dealing with barbarians, provided the end be their improvement.” This passage is central to postcolonial critiques of Mill, who spent his career in the East India Company.
Chapter 2: liberty of thought and discussion. “If all mankind minus one were of one opinion, … mankind would be no more justified in silencing that one person, than he, if he had the power, would be justified in silencing mankind.” Four grounds:
- The silenced opinion may be true: to deny this is to assume our own infallibility.
- Even if false, it may contain a portion of truth, and the prevailing opinion is rarely the whole truth.
- Even if the received opinion is wholly true, unless it is vigorously contested it will be held as a dead dogma or prejudice.
- Its very meaning will be lost or enfeebled, and it will cease to influence character and conduct.
Chapter 3: individuality. Individuality is one of the elements of well-being. Mill praises “experiments of living”, eccentricity and originality, and fears the “despotism of custom” that leaves people like trees clipped into shapes.
Chapters 4–5: limits and applications. Society may require each person not to injure others’ interests and to bear a fair share of common burdens. Mill applies the principle to trade, sale of poisons, drunkenness, contracts selling oneself into slavery (forbidden: one cannot be “free not to be free”) and state education (the state should require education, not necessarily provide it).
Considerations on Representative Government (1861)
- The ideally best form of government is representative government: it protects people’s interests and educates and improves them through participation.
- The proper office of the representative assembly is “to watch and control the government” and to be a “Congress of Opinions”; drafting laws should be left to a skilled legislative commission.
- Dangers: low intelligence in the assembly, and class legislation by a numerical majority.
- Remedies:
- Proportional representation on Thomas Hare’s scheme, so minorities are represented.
- Plural voting: extra votes for those with higher education or more responsible occupations (not for property).
- Open (public) voting rather than the secret ballot, because the vote is a public trust.
- Exclusion of those who cannot read, write and do simple arithmetic, and of those living on parish relief.
- Women’s suffrage on equal terms with men.
- Representative government requires a people willing and able to sustain it; nationality matters (“free institutions are next to impossible in a country made up of different nationalities”).
The Subjection of Women (1869)
- “The legal subordination of one sex to the other is wrong in itself, and now one of the chief hindrances to human improvement; … it ought to be replaced by a principle of perfect equality.”
- What is now called the nature of women is “an eminently artificial thing”, the result of forced repression and unnatural stimulation.
- Marriage law of the time made the wife’s legal position comparable to slavery; Mill calls for equality in marriage, property rights, education and access to all occupations, and the vote.
- Mill credits Harriet Taylor with many of these ideas; her essay “The Enfranchisement of Women” (1851) is often read alongside the book.
Mill’s place
- A bridge between classical liberalism and the “new” or social liberalism of T.H. Green and Hobhouse: he keeps individual liberty but accepts state education, regulation of labour and (later) sympathy for co-operative socialism.
- A reluctant democrat: he supports universal suffrage, including women, but fears mass mediocrity, hence plural voting and open ballots.
The Three Compared
| Hegel | Wollstonecraft | Mill | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Key work | Philosophy of Right (1820) | Vindication of the Rights of Woman (1792) | On Liberty (1859) |
| Freedom is | Realised in rational institutions, above all the state | Exercise of reason and independence | Absence of interference in self-regarding conduct; self-development |
| The individual | Finds fulfilment in ethical life | Rational being whatever the sex | Sovereign over self |
| On women | Women belong to the family sphere | Equal reason, equal education | Perfect legal equality |
| Method | Dialectical, historical | Enlightenment rationalism | Utilitarian, empirical |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Vindication of the Rights of Men (1790): reply to Burke | vs | Vindication of the Rights of Woman (1792): dedicated to Talleyrand |
| Paine’s Rights of Man (1791–92) | vs | Wollstonecraft’s Rights of Men (1790): both replied to Burke |
| Hegel’s civil society: market sphere between family and state | vs | Locke’s civil society: political society as opposed to the state of nature |
| Moralität: subjective, individual morality | vs | Sittlichkeit: ethical life in institutions |
| Bentham: quantity of pleasure | vs | Mill: quality of pleasure too |
| Mill’s plural voting: for education | vs | Property qualification: Mill rejected it as the basis |
| The Subjection of Women (1869), J.S. Mill | vs | “The Enfranchisement of Women” (1851), Harriet Taylor |
| Popper (1945): Hegel as enemy of the open society | vs | Fukuyama (1989): Hegel via Kojève, the end of history |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Name the three moments of Hegel’s “ethical life”.
- To whom did Wollstonecraft dedicate A Vindication of the Rights of Woman?
- Whose scheme of proportional representation did Mill support?
Answers
- Family, civil society and state.
- Talleyrand, author of a plan for French national education.
- Thomas Hare’s.
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) “The owl of Minerva spreads its wings only with the falling of the dusk.” This line appears in:
- (a) Phenomenology of Spirit
- (b) the Preface to Elements of the Philosophy of Right
- (c) The Subjection of Women
- (d) Science of Logic
Answer and explanation
(b). In the same Preface Hegel writes that the rational is actual and the actual is rational. The owl image means philosophy understands an age only after it has matured.
Q2. (Practice) Consider the following statements about J.S. Mill:
- He argued that despotism is a legitimate mode of government in dealing with “barbarians”, provided the end is their improvement.
- He favoured the secret ballot to protect voters.
- He proposed extra votes for the more educated.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 1 and 3 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 1 and 3 only. Mill favoured open voting, treating the vote as a public trust.
Q3. (Practice) Which work attacked the education of Sophie in Rousseau’s Emile?
- (a) Political Justice
- (b) A Vindication of the Rights of Woman
- (c) Rights of Man
- (d) Reflections on the Revolution in France
Answer and explanation
(b) Wollstonecraft (1792). Political Justice is Godwin’s; Rights of Man is Paine’s; Reflections is Burke’s.
Q4. (Practice) In Hegel’s philosophy of history, the “Greek and Roman world” corresponds to the stage at which:
- (a) one is free
- (b) some are free
- (c) all are free
- (d) none is free
Answer and explanation
(b) some are free: citizens were free, slaves were not. The Oriental world knew only that one is free; the Germanic world that all are free.
Q5. (Practice) Which of the following is not one of Mill’s grounds, in On Liberty, for freedom of opinion?
- (a) The silenced opinion may be true.
- (b) A false opinion may contain part of the truth.
- (c) Uncontested truths become dead dogma.
- (d) Every opinion is a natural right of the individual.
Answer and explanation
(d). Mill explicitly avoids arguing from abstract natural right; his grounds are about truth and utility.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Wollstonecraft argued that women should receive the same education as men. Reason (R): For Wollstonecraft, virtue is founded on reason, which belongs to human beings regardless of sex.
Answer and explanation
(a). Equal reason is the premise; equal education follows from it.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): For Hegel, civil society cannot by itself realise freedom fully. Reason (R): Civil society is the sphere of particular interests and produces poverty it cannot absorb.
Answer and explanation
(a). Hegel moves beyond civil society to the state because civil society, left to itself, is the battlefield of private interests and generates a rabble.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (Work) with List II (Author).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Phenomenology of Spirit | I. Mary Wollstonecraft |
| B. A Vindication of the Rights of Men | II. J.S. Mill |
| C. The Subjection of Women | III. G.W.F. Hegel |
| D. The Open Society and Its Enemies | IV. Karl Popper |
- (a) A-III, B-I, C-II, D-IV
- (b) A-III, B-II, C-I, D-IV
- (c) A-IV, B-I, C-II, D-III
- (d) A-III, B-IV, C-II, D-I
Answer and explanation
(a) A-III, B-I, C-II, D-IV.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following in chronological order of publication:
- The Subjection of Women
- A Vindication of the Rights of Woman
- On Liberty
- Elements of the Philosophy of Right
- (a) 2, 4, 3, 1
- (b) 4, 2, 3, 1
- (c) 2, 4, 1, 3
- (d) 2, 3, 4, 1
Answer and explanation
(a) 2, 4, 3, 1. 1792 → 1820 → 1859 → 1869.
Q5. (Practice) Arrange the moments of Hegel’s Philosophy of Right from the most abstract to the most concrete:
- Civil society
- Abstract right
- State
- Morality
- Family
- (a) 2, 4, 5, 1, 3
- (b) 4, 2, 5, 1, 3
- (c) 2, 4, 1, 5, 3
- (d) 2, 5, 4, 1, 3
Answer and explanation
(a) 2, 4, 5, 1, 3. Abstract right → morality → ethical life (family → civil society → state).
Quick Revision Table
| Thinker | Work (year) | Key ideas |
|---|---|---|
| Hegel (1770–1831) | Phenomenology of Spirit (1807) | Spirit; lord and bondsman; recognition |
| Hegel | Philosophy of Right (1820) | Rational is actual; owl of Minerva; abstract right → morality → ethical life; family → civil society → state; universal class; constitutional monarchy |
| Hegel | Philosophy of History (posthumous) | Progress of consciousness of freedom: one, some, all; cunning of reason; world-historical individuals |
| Wollstonecraft (1759–1797) | Rights of Men (1790) | Reply to Burke |
| Wollstonecraft | Rights of Woman (1792) | Reason has no sex; education; against Rousseau’s Sophie; power over themselves; divine right of husbands; co-educational national schools |
| Mill (1806–1873) | Logic (1843), Political Economy (1848) | Induction; production vs distribution |
| Mill | On Liberty (1859) | Harm principle; self- vs other-regarding; tyranny of majority; four grounds for free speech; individuality; not for “barbarians” |
| Mill | Representative Government (1861) | Best polity; watch and control; Hare’s PR; plural voting; open ballot; women’s suffrage |
| Mill | Utilitarianism (1861/1863) | Higher and lower pleasures; Socrates dissatisfied |
| Mill | Subjection of Women (1869) | Perfect equality; women’s “nature” artificial |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Marx, Gramsci and Mao: Hegel’s dialectic turned “right side up”, and two revolutionary adaptations
- Justice: Mill’s utilitarianism as the theory Rawls set out to replace
- Rights and Citizenship: Wollstonecraft and Mill in the history of women’s citizenship
- Political Thought: Quick Revision