Skip to content

State, Economy, Development and Globalisation

Nature of the Indian state, the planning model, the 1991 New Economic Policy, growth vs human development, and globalisation's impact on India for UGC NET.

  • 21 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 14 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: Two Budgets, One State
  3. 1. The Nature of the Indian State
  4. 2. The Development Planning Model
  5. 3. The New Economic Policy (1991)
  6. 4. Growth and Human Development
  7. 5. The Process of Globalisation: Social and Economic Implications
  8. Memory Tricks
  9. Don’t Confuse
  10. Common Mistakes
  11. Practice
  12. Quick Revision Table
  13. Key Takeaways
  14. What’s Next

Prerequisites

The Hook: Two Budgets, One State

How UGC NET asks it: author → concept matches (Bardhan’s three dominant proprietary classes, the Rudolphs’ demand polity, Myrdal’s soft state, Kohli’s fragmented-multiclass state); plans in sequence; features of the 1991 New Economic Policy; HDI dimensions; the three views of globalisation.


1. The Nature of the Indian State

The official syllabus line begins with the nature of the Indian state. There is no single answer; there are schools, and UGC NET asks you to match each school with its authors and key phrase.

1.1 The constitutional self-description

The Preamble describes India as a sovereign socialist secular democratic republic. “Socialist” and “secular” were added by the 42nd Amendment (1976). The Directive Principles (Part IV), especially Articles 38 and 39, commit the state to reducing inequalities and preventing the concentration of wealth. On paper, then, the state is a liberal-democratic welfare state with a developmental mandate.

1.2 The main interpretations

SchoolRepresentative authors and worksCore claim about the Indian state
Liberal / pluralistRajni Kothari, Politics in India (1970); W.H. Morris-Jones, The Government and Politics of India (1964)A democratic arena in which many groups bargain; the “Congress system” (Kothari, 1964 article) absorbed conflict through a dominant but internally plural party
Orthodox Marxist (party programmes)CPI(M) programmeAn organ of class rule of the bourgeoisie and landlords, led by the big bourgeoisie
Neo-Marxist: relative autonomyPranab Bardhan, The Political Economy of Development in India (1984)Three dominant proprietary classes — industrial capitalists, rich farmers, and professionals (including the bureaucracy) — pull the state in different directions; the state has autonomy in setting goals but is hemmed in by their competing demands for subsidies, which crowd out public investment
Post-colonial stateHamza Alavi, “The State in Post-Colonial Societies: Pakistan and Bangladesh” (1972)An “overdeveloped” state apparatus inherited from colonialism, mediating between several propertied classes (Alavi wrote on Pakistan and Bangladesh; Indian scholars applied the idea)
Passive revolutionPartha Chatterjee, Nationalist Thought and the Colonial World (1986); Sudipta KavirajUsing Gramsci, the transition to capitalism was managed from above by a coalition, without a decisive bourgeois revolution
Demand vs command polityLloyd I. Rudolph and Susanne Hoeber Rudolph, In Pursuit of Lakshmi (1987)A “weak-strong” state; politics of “centrism”; demand polity (voters and groups press the state) vs command polity (the state sets the agenda); “bullock capitalists” (middle peasants); “involuted pluralism” of weak, fragmented labour
Soft stateGunnar Myrdal, Asian Drama (1968)South Asian states pass good laws but lack the will to enforce them; “social indiscipline” and corruption
Developmental state typologyAtul Kohli, State-Directed Development (2004)India is a “fragmented-multiclass” state (vs South Korea’s “cohesive-capitalist”), so its interventions are less effective
Crisis of governabilityAtul Kohli, Democracy and Discontent (1990)Growing demands, weakened institutions and personalised leadership produced a crisis of governability in the 1970s–80s
Political societyPartha Chatterjee, The Politics of the Governed (2004)Most Indians relate to the state not as rights-bearing citizens of civil society but as populations in political society, negotiating welfare and tolerance of illegality
Gradual revolutionFrancine Frankel, India’s Political Economy, 1947–1977: The Gradual Revolution (1978)Nehruvian strategy tried to achieve social transformation by consent, without class conflict; the attempt stalled on agrarian structure

1.3 Why this debate matters for the other lines

Each later line of this unit assumes a view of the state. The planning model assumes a state able to direct the economy. The New Economic Policy asked the state to step back from production. Identity politics and social movements press demands on the state (the Rudolphs’ demand polity). Regionalisation asks which level of the state, Union or state, is the real economic actor.


2. The Development Planning Model

2.1 Before 1950: rival plans

PlanYearSponsorEmphasis
National Planning Committee1938Indian National Congress (Subhas Chandra Bose as Congress president); chaired by Jawaharlal NehruFirst national effort at economic planning
Bombay Plan1944Leading industrialists, including J.R.D. Tata and G.D. BirlaRapid industrialisation with a large state role in infrastructure
Gandhian Plan1944S.N. AgarwalDecentralised village economy, cottage industry
People’s Plan1944–45M.N. RoyAgriculture-led, from a radical humanist / labour standpoint
Sarvodaya Plan1950Jayaprakash NarayanGandhian, decentralised

2.2 The institutions

  • Planning Commission: set up in March 1950 by a resolution of the Union Cabinet, so it was neither constitutional nor statutory. The Prime Minister was its chairman; the Deputy Chairman ran it.
  • National Development Council (NDC): set up in 1952, bringing the Prime Minister, Union ministers and state Chief Ministers together to approve plans. It was the federal face of planning.
  • NITI Aayog (National Institution for Transforming India) replaced the Planning Commission on 1 January 2015, also by Cabinet resolution. It is a think-tank, not an allocator of plan funds; the Twelfth Plan (2012–17) was the last Five-Year Plan.

2.3 The Nehru–Mahalanobis model

  • Mixed economy, with the public sector at the “commanding heights” (heavy industry, infrastructure, basic goods).
  • Import-substituting industrialisation: build capital goods at home rather than import them.
  • Industrial Policy Resolution, 1956: industries grouped into three schedules — Schedule A (17 industries, exclusive state responsibility), Schedule B (12 industries, progressively state-owned, with private participation), Schedule C (the rest, open to the private sector). The earlier Industrial Policy Resolution of 1948 had set out the mixed economy.
  • Licensing under the Industries (Development and Regulation) Act, 1951; later the MRTP Act (1969) and FERA (1973) tightened control. Critics called the result the “licence-permit raj”, a phrase associated with C. Rajagopalachari, founder of the pro-market Swatantra Party (1959).
  • The slow average growth of the planned decades was nicknamed the “Hindu rate of growth” by the economist Raj Krishna.

2.4 The Five-Year Plans at a glance

PlanPeriodEmphasis / model
First1951–56Agriculture, irrigation, power; Harrod–Domar growth model
Second1956–61Heavy industry; Mahalanobis model
Third1961–66“Self-reliant, self-generating” economy; derailed by the 1962 and 1965 wars and drought
Plan holiday1966–69Three annual plans; Green Revolution begins
Fourth1969–74Growth with stability; progressive self-reliance; bank nationalisation (1969)
Fifth1974–79Removal of poverty (garibi hatao) and self-reliance; ended early by the Janata government in 1978
Rolling Plan1978–80Janata government’s annual rolling plans
Sixth1980–85Poverty alleviation, employment
Seventh1985–90Food, work and productivity
Annual Plans1990–92Political instability and the 1991 crisis
Eighth1992–97First plan after 1991; indicative planning, human development
Ninth1997–2002Growth with social justice and equity
Tenth2002–07Monitorable targets
Eleventh2007–12“Faster and more inclusive growth”
Twelfth2012–17“Faster, more inclusive and sustainable growth” — the last plan

2.5 Assessments of the planning model

  • Achievements: an industrial base, public institutions (IITs, steel plants), food self-sufficiency after the Green Revolution, and democracy preserved while planning (unlike many planned economies).
  • Criticisms: slow growth, neglect of agriculture and primary education relative to East Asia, inefficient public enterprises, rent-seeking under licensing (Bardhan’s subsidy-seeking classes), and the failure of land reform (Frankel).
  • Gandhian and Lohiaite critiques: centralised, urban and heavy-industry bias, against village self-sufficiency.

3. The New Economic Policy (1991)

3.1 The crisis

By mid-1991 India faced a balance-of-payments crisis: foreign-exchange reserves had fallen to barely a few weeks of imports, the Gulf War had raised oil prices and cut remittances, and political instability had scared lenders. The government pledged gold to raise foreign exchange and turned to the IMF for a stabilisation loan.

3.2 The content: LPG

ElementWhat changed
LiberalisationIndustrial licensing abolished for all but a short list of industries; MRTP restrictions on large firms’ expansion relaxed; reservation for the public sector cut sharply (now essentially atomic energy and railway operations)
PrivatisationDisinvestment of shares in public sector enterprises; later strategic sales
GlobalisationAutomatic approval for foreign direct investment in priority sectors; tariff cuts; rupee devalued (July 1991) and later made convertible on the current account (1994); India a founder member of the WTO (1995)
StabilisationFiscal deficit reduction (IMF conditions)
Structural adjustmentSupply-side reforms in trade, industry, finance (World Bank-style)

Committees to remember: Narasimham Committee (banking, 1991 and 1998); Chelliah Committee (tax reform, 1991); Malhotra Committee (insurance; led to the IRDA, now IRDAI, in 1999); Rangarajan Committee (disinvestment, 1993). SEBI received statutory powers in 1992. FERA was replaced by FEMA (1999), and the MRTP Act by the Competition Act (2002).

Second-generation reforms include the Goods and Services Tax (101st Amendment, 2016; GST in force from 1 July 2017) and the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (2016).

3.3 The politics of reform

AuthorWorkArgument
Rob JenkinsDemocratic Politics and Economic Reform in India (1999)“Reform by stealth”: governments pushed reforms through quietly, using federalism and political skill to divide opponents
Ashutosh Varshney“Mass Politics or Elite Politics?” (1999)Reforms touching elites (trade, industry) went fast; those touching mass politics (labour laws, agricultural subsidies, privatisation) went slow
Atul KohliState-Directed Development (2004) and later workThe state’s turn began in the 1980s as a pro-business tilt before the pro-market reforms of 1991
Dani Rodrik and Arvind Subramanian“From ‘Hindu Growth’ to Productivity Surge” (2004)Growth accelerated around 1980, a decade before 1991, driven by an attitudinal shift towards business

4. Growth and Human Development

4.1 Two ways to measure “development”

GrowthHuman development
MeasuresGDP / GNP and per capita incomeCapabilities: health, knowledge, living standards
Intellectual sourceGrowth economics; Harrod–Domar; SolowAmartya Sen’s capability approach; Mahbub ul Haq
Key documentNational accountsUNDP Human Development Report, first published 1990
Indian championsJagdish Bhagwati and Arvind Panagariya, Why Growth Matters (2013)Jean Drèze and Amartya Sen, An Uncertain Glory: India and Its Contradictions (2013)
Policy stressGrowth first (“Track I”), which funds redistributionPublic provision of health, education, nutrition alongside growth

The Bhagwati–Sen debate of 2013 is a favourite assertion–reason theme. Both sides value growth and human development; they disagree on sequence and emphasis.

4.2 The Human Development Index

The HDI has three dimensions:

  1. A long and healthy life — life expectancy at birth;
  2. Knowledge — expected years of schooling and mean years of schooling;
  3. A decent standard of living — GNI per capita (PPP).

Since 2010 the HDI has been the geometric mean of the three dimension indices:

$$\text{HDI} = \left(I_{\text{health}} \times I_{\text{education}} \times I_{\text{income}}\right)^{1/3}$$

India is in the UNDP’s “medium human development” category. Within India, Kerala is the classic case of high human development at modest per capita income (the “Kerala model”), built on public education, health and land reform.

4.3 Growth with or without inclusion?

  • Poverty estimates: expert groups have repeatedly redrawn the poverty line: Lakdawala (1993), Tendulkar (2009) and Rangarajan (2014). For 2011–12 the Tendulkar method gave about 21.9% of the population below the line, and the Rangarajan method about 29.5%.
  • Informal work: the National Commission for Enterprises in the Unorganised Sector (chaired by Arjun Sengupta) reported in 2007 that a large majority of Indians lived on very low daily consumption and that most workers were in the unorganised sector.
  • “Jobless growth” and regional divergence (see Regionalisation of Indian Politics) are the two most cited costs of post-1991 growth.
  • Inclusive growth was the slogan of the Eleventh Plan (2007–12); rights-based welfare laws followed: MGNREGA (2005), the Right to Information Act (2005), the Forest Rights Act (2006), the Right to Education Act (2009) and the National Food Security Act (2013).

5. The Process of Globalisation: Social and Economic Implications

5.1 What globalisation is: three positions

Anthony Giddens (The Consequences of Modernity, 1990) defined globalisation as the intensification of worldwide social relations that link distant localities, so that local happenings are shaped by events many miles away.

PositionAuthorsClaim
HyperglobalistsKenichi Ohmae, The Borderless World (1990), The End of the Nation State (1995)A borderless global market is making the nation-state obsolete
ScepticsPaul Hirst and Grahame Thompson, Globalization in Question (1996)Today’s economy is no more open than before 1914; it is “internationalised”, not global; states still matter
TransformationalistsDavid Held, Anthony McGrew and colleagues, Global Transformations (1999)Globalisation is real but uneven; it transforms state power rather than ending it

Other names: Arjun Appadurai’s five “scapes” (ethnoscapes, mediascapes, technoscapes, financescapes, ideoscapes) in Modernity at Large (1996); Roland Robertson’s glocalisation; George Ritzer’s The McDonaldization of Society (1993); Joseph Stiglitz, Globalization and Its Discontents (2002); Thomas Friedman, The World Is Flat (2005).

5.2 Economic implications for India

Gains claimedCosts and criticisms
Faster growth after 1991, especially in services (IT, software, business process outsourcing)Jobless or low-employment growth; manufacturing share stayed low
Rising foreign-exchange reserves, FDI and portfolio inflowsExposure to global shocks (2008 financial crisis) and volatile capital
Large remittances from the diasporaAgrarian distress: falling public investment in agriculture, price volatility, indebtedness and farmer suicides
Consumer choice; telecom revolutionInformalisation and contract labour; weaker unions
Competition among states for investmentRising income and wealth inequality; regional divergence
Integration into global value chainsDisplacement by mining, dams and Special Economic Zones

5.3 Social implications

  • The “new middle class”: consumption-based identity, private schooling and health care, and growing distance from public services (Leela Fernandes, India’s New Middle Class, 2006).
  • Culture: fears of homogenisation (westernisation, Ritzer’s McDonaldization) alongside glocalisation (global brands adapted to local taste) and the global spread of Indian cinema and diaspora culture.
  • Gender: new jobs for women in IT, export garments and services, but also the “feminisation” of insecure, low-paid work; see Gender and Politics in India.
  • Caste and identity: markets loosened some caste occupations but did not dissolve caste; identity politics intensified in the same decade (“Mandal, Mandir and Market” describes the 1990s).
  • Migration: internal migration to cities and overseas migration (Gulf, North America) reshaped families and regions.

5.4 Political responses: resistance and adaptation

  • Swadeshi Jagaran Manch (formed 1991, linked to the Sangh Parivar) opposed foreign capital from the right; Left parties and trade unions opposed privatisation from the left.
  • Anti-globalisation and anti-displacement movements: the Narmada Bachao Andolan; the Plachimada campaign against a Coca-Cola plant in Kerala (from 2002); protests against land acquisition for SEZs and industry at Singur (2006) and Nandigram (2007) in West Bengal, which helped end the Left Front’s rule in 2011; the Niyamgiri case, in which the Supreme Court (2013) left the decision on bauxite mining to the gram sabhas of the Dongria Kondh area.
  • The state adapts, not retreats: welfare legislation, cash transfers and the “competition state” (states competing for investment) show the transformationalist point that the state changes form rather than withering.

Memory Tricks

Don’t Confuse

ThisvsThat
Planning Commission (1950) — executive resolution; allocated plan fundsvsFinance Commission — constitutional (Article 280); recommends tax devolution
NITI Aayog (2015) — think-tank, no plan fundsvsPlanning Commission — made and financed Five-Year Plans
Bombay Plan (1944) — industrialistsvsPeople’s Plan (1944–45) — M.N. Roy
Gandhian Plan (1944) — S.N. AgarwalvsSarvodaya Plan (1950) — Jayaprakash Narayan
Industrial Policy Resolution 1948 — first mixed-economy statementvsIndustrial Policy Resolution 1956 — Schedules A, B, C
Why Growth Matters — Bhagwati and Panagariya (2013)vsAn Uncertain Glory — Drèze and Sen (2013)
Soft state — Myrdal, Asian Drama (1968)vsOverdeveloped state — Alavi (1972)
Political society — Chatterjee (2004)vsCivil society — rights-bearing citizens in Chatterjee’s contrast
Current-account convertibility (1994)vsCapital-account convertibility — not fully adopted

Common Mistakes


Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. Who described South Asian states as “soft states”?
  2. Name the three dominant proprietary classes in Pranab Bardhan’s analysis.
  3. On what date did NITI Aayog replace the Planning Commission?
Answers
  1. Gunnar Myrdal, Asian Drama (1968).
  2. Industrial capitalists, rich farmers and professionals (including the bureaucracy).
  3. 1 January 2015.

Level 2: Exam-style MCQs

Q1. (Practice) The concepts of “demand polity”, “command polity” and “bullock capitalists” are associated with:

  • (a) Atul Kohli
  • (b) Lloyd I. Rudolph and Susanne Hoeber Rudolph
  • (c) Francine Frankel
  • (d) Pranab Bardhan
Answer and explanation

(b). All three come from In Pursuit of Lakshmi: The Political Economy of the Indian State (1987). Kohli is associated with the “fragmented-multiclass” state and the “crisis of governability”; Frankel with the “gradual revolution”; Bardhan with the three dominant proprietary classes.

Q2. (Practice) Consider the following statements about the Human Development Index:

  1. It was introduced in the first UNDP Human Development Report of 1990.
  2. Its knowledge dimension uses expected and mean years of schooling.
  3. Since 2010, it is the arithmetic mean of three dimension indices.

Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  • (a) 1 and 2 only
  • (b) 2 and 3 only
  • (c) 1 and 3 only
  • (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation

(a) 1 and 2 only. Statement 3 is wrong: since 2010 the HDI is the geometric mean, which penalises uneven achievement across dimensions.

Q3. (Practice) A state’s three HDI dimension indices are 0.90 (health), 0.50 (education) and 0.80 (income). Its HDI, computed by the post-2010 method, is closest to:

  • (a) 0.733
  • (b) 0.711
  • (c) 0.690
  • (d) 0.650
Answer and explanation

(b) 0.711. \( (0.90 \times 0.50 \times 0.80)^{1/3} = (0.36)^{1/3} \approx 0.711 \). Option (a), 0.733, is the arithmetic mean \( (0.90 + 0.50 + 0.80)/3 \), the trap for anyone who forgets the geometric mean.

Q4. (Practice) Which of the following was not part of the 1991 New Economic Policy package?

  • (a) Abolition of industrial licensing for most industries
  • (b) Disinvestment in public sector enterprises
  • (c) Nationalisation of major commercial banks
  • (d) Liberal approval of foreign direct investment
Answer and explanation

(c). Bank nationalisation (1969, and again in 1980) belongs to the planning era. The 1991 policy moved in the opposite direction.

Q5. (Practice) Which work argues that globalisation is exaggerated and that the international economy before 1914 was in some respects as open as today’s?

  • (a) The Borderless World
  • (b) Global Transformations
  • (c) Globalization in Question
  • (d) The World Is Flat
Answer and explanation

(c) Hirst and Thompson (1996), the leading sceptics. (a) Ohmae and (d) Friedman are hyperglobalist in tone; (b) Held, McGrew and colleagues are transformationalists.

Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence

For assertion–reason questions, use these options:

  • (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
  • (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
  • (c) A is true, but R is false
  • (d) A is false, but R is true

Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Pranab Bardhan argued that competition among dominant proprietary classes slowed India’s growth before the 1980s. Reason (R): The demands of these classes for subsidies and rents diverted public resources away from productive investment.

Answer and explanation

(a). R gives Bardhan’s mechanism: the state, pulled by three classes, spent on subsidies and transfers that crowded out public investment.

Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): The Planning Commission of India was a constitutional body. Reason (R): The Planning Commission was chaired by the Prime Minister.

Answer and explanation

(d). A is false: it was created by a Cabinet resolution in 1950. R is true: the Prime Minister was its chairman.

Q3. (Practice) Match List I (Author) with List II (Concept).

List IList II
A. Gunnar MyrdalI. Fragmented-multiclass state
B. Atul KohliII. Political society
C. Partha ChatterjeeIII. Soft state
D. Hamza AlaviIV. Overdeveloped post-colonial state
  • (a) A-III, B-I, C-II, D-IV
  • (b) A-I, B-III, C-II, D-IV
  • (c) A-III, B-II, C-I, D-IV
  • (d) A-III, B-I, C-IV, D-II
Answer and explanation

(a) A-III, B-I, C-II, D-IV.

Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following in chronological order:

  1. Industrial Policy Resolution introducing Schedules A, B and C
  2. Bombay Plan
  3. Nationalisation of fourteen major banks
  4. Goods and Services Tax comes into force
  • (a) 2, 1, 3, 4
  • (b) 1, 2, 3, 4
  • (c) 2, 3, 1, 4
  • (d) 2, 1, 4, 3
Answer and explanation

(a). Bombay Plan (1944) → IPR 1956 → bank nationalisation (1969) → GST (2017).

Q5. (Practice) Arrange the following Five-Year Plans by their period, earliest first, using their emphasis:

  1. “Faster and more inclusive growth”
  2. Mahalanobis heavy-industry model
  3. Removal of poverty (garibi hatao)
  4. Indicative planning after the 1991 crisis
  • (a) 2, 3, 4, 1
  • (b) 2, 4, 3, 1
  • (c) 3, 2, 4, 1
  • (d) 2, 3, 1, 4
Answer and explanation

(a). Second Plan (1956–61) → Fifth (1974–79) → Eighth (1992–97) → Eleventh (2007–12).


Quick Revision Table

ItemKey fact
Preamble“Socialist”, “secular” added by 42nd Amendment (1976)
Bardhan (1984)Three dominant proprietary classes: industrialists, rich farmers, professionals
Rudolphs (1987)In Pursuit of Lakshmi: demand vs command polity, bullock capitalists, centrism
Myrdal (1968)Asian Drama: soft state
KohliDemocracy and Discontent (1990): crisis of governability; State-Directed Development (2004): fragmented-multiclass
Chatterjee (2004)The Politics of the Governed: political society
Alavi (1972)Overdeveloped post-colonial state
Frankel (1978)The gradual revolution
Pre-1950 plansNPC 1938 (Nehru), Bombay 1944, Gandhian 1944 (Agarwal), People’s 1944–45 (Roy), Sarvodaya 1950 (JP)
Planning CommissionMarch 1950, Cabinet resolution; NDC 1952
NITI Aayog1 January 2015
IPR 1956Schedules A (17), B (12), C (rest)
Plans1st Harrod–Domar; 2nd Mahalanobis; 1966–69 plan holiday; 5th garibi hatao; 8th indicative; 11th inclusive; 12th last
NEP 199124 July 1991; LPG; Rao–Manmohan Singh; IMF loan
Reform politicsJenkins: reform by stealth (1999); Varshney: elite vs mass politics
HDI1990 HDR; life expectancy, schooling, GNI per capita; geometric mean since 2010
Growth vs HDBhagwati–Panagariya vs Drèze–Sen (both 2013)
Globalisation viewsOhmae (hyper), Hirst and Thompson (sceptic), Held and McGrew (transformationalist)
DefinitionGiddens (1990): intensification of worldwide social relations

Key Takeaways

What’s Next