Public Policy, Monitoring, Evaluation and Social Audit
Public policy for development: housing, health, water, NFSA, MGNREGA, NRHM and RTE; the policy cycle, monitoring and evaluation, social audit and jan sunwai.
- 20 min
On this page · 13 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: A Muster Roll Read Aloud
- 1. Public Policy: Concepts and the Policy Cycle
- 2. Flagship Social-Sector Policies
- 3. Monitoring and Evaluation of Public Policy
- 4. Making Governance Accountable: Social Audit and Jan Sunwai
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Planning, Development, E-Governance and NITI Aayog — the planning frame within which these policies sit, and the DMEO.
- Panchayati Raj Institutions and Their Functioning — the Gram Sabha, which conducts social audits.
- Methods and Steps of Research (Paper 1) — experimental and quasi-experimental designs, the toolkit of impact evaluation.
The Hook: A Muster Roll Read Aloud
How UGC NET asks it: definitions of public policy matched to thinkers; stages of the policy cycle in order; provisions of MGNREGA, NFSA and RTE (numbers, sections, years); NRHM’s community institutions; scheme → launch year → ministry matches; formative vs summative evaluation; social audit and jan sunwai (MKSS, Section 17 of MGNREGA, Meghalaya’s 2017 Act).
1. Public Policy: Concepts and the Policy Cycle
1.1 Definitions
| Thinker | Definition / idea |
|---|---|
| Harold Lasswell | Politics is “who gets what, when, how” (1936); founder of the policy sciences (The Policy Sciences, with Daniel Lerner, 1951) |
| David Easton | Policy is the “authoritative allocation of values for the whole society” (The Political System, 1953) |
| Thomas R. Dye | Public policy is “whatever governments choose to do or not to do” (Understanding Public Policy, 1972), so inaction is also policy |
| Theodore Lowi | Policy types: distributive, regulatory, redistributive (1964); constituent added later. “Policy determines politics” |
1.2 The policy cycle
graph LR
A["1. Agenda setting
problem recognised"] --> B["2. Formulation
options designed"]
B --> C["3. Decision / adoption
law, scheme, budget"]
C --> D["4. Implementation
ministries, states, PRIs"]
D --> E["5. Monitoring and
evaluation"]
E --> F["6. Feedback: continue,
revise or terminate"]
F --> A| Model of decision-making | Thinker | Core idea |
|---|---|---|
| Rational-comprehensive | — | All alternatives and consequences weighed; the best chosen |
| Bounded rationality | Herbert Simon | Decision-makers “satisfice” rather than maximise |
| Incrementalism | Charles Lindblom, “The Science of ‘Muddling Through’” (1959) | Small changes from the status quo; successive limited comparisons |
| Mixed scanning | Amitai Etzioni (1967) | Broad scan for fundamental decisions, then incremental detail |
| Optimal model | Yehezkel Dror | Rational plus extra-rational (intuition, judgement) elements |
| Multiple streams | John Kingdon, Agendas, Alternatives, and Public Policies (1984) | Problem, policy and politics streams meet in a “policy window” |
| Implementation gap | Pressman and Wildavsky, Implementation (1973) | Great expectations in Washington dashed in Oakland: many decision points multiply failure |
| Street-level bureaucracy | Michael Lipsky (1980) | Teachers, police, health workers effectively make policy through their discretion |
1.3 Public policy as an instrument of socio-economic development
In India, policy for development has moved through three broad phases: state-led planning (welfare as a by-product of growth and public investment), targeted anti-poverty programmes (from the 1970s: IRDP, food-for-work), and, from the 2000s, rights-based legislation: employment (2005), information (2005), forest rights (2006), education (2009) and food (2013). These justiciable entitlements turn Directive Principles into legal rights, often after Supreme Court pressure (for example PUCL v Union of India on the right to food, from 2001).
2. Flagship Social-Sector Policies
2.1 Housing
| Policy | Detail |
|---|---|
| Indira Awaas Yojana (IAY) | Rural housing for BPL households; began in 1985–86 as part of the Rural Landless Employment Guarantee Programme; independent scheme from 1996 |
| National Urban Housing and Habitat Policy | 2007 |
| PMAY–Urban | Launched 25 June 2015; four verticals: in-situ slum redevelopment, credit-linked subsidy scheme, affordable housing in partnership, beneficiary-led construction; houses preferably in the name of, or jointly with, a woman |
| PMAY–Gramin | IAY restructured from 1 April 2016; assistance Rs 1.20 lakh (plains) and Rs 1.30 lakh (hilly and difficult areas); beneficiaries identified from the Socio-Economic and Caste Census (SECC) 2011 and verified by the Gram Sabha; convergence with MGNREGA (unskilled labour) and Swachh Bharat (toilet) |
| Courts | Right to livelihood (Olga Tellis, 1985) and right to shelter read into Art. 21 |
2.2 Health: NRHM and the National Health Mission
The syllabus says “NRHM” (written “NHRM” in the official text). The National Rural Health Mission was launched on 12 April 2005 to provide accessible, affordable and accountable health care to rural people, especially the poor, women and children. In 2013 it became a sub-mission of the National Health Mission (NHM), alongside the National Urban Health Mission.
| NRHM component | What it is |
|---|---|
| ASHA (Accredited Social Health Activist) | A woman volunteer from the village, roughly one per 1,000 population, paid performance-based incentives; the link between community and health system |
| Janani Suraksha Yojana (2005) | Cash assistance for institutional delivery |
| Village Health, Sanitation and Nutrition Committee (VHSNC) | Village-level planning and monitoring, linked to the panchayat; receives untied funds |
| Rogi Kalyan Samiti (patient welfare committee) | Hospital management society with local representatives; can raise and use funds |
| Indian Public Health Standards (IPHS) | Norms for sub-centres, PHCs, CHCs |
| Decentralised health planning | District Health Action Plans |
| Community action / monitoring | Communities review services against entitlements (a social-accountability tool) |
| AYUSH mainstreaming | Traditional systems integrated into public facilities |
Later milestones: National Health Policy 2017 (public health spending target of 2.5% of GDP by 2025); Ayushman Bharat (2018): Health and Wellness Centres (renamed Ayushman Arogya Mandirs) and PM-JAY (insurance cover of Rs 5 lakh per family per year for secondary and tertiary care).
2.3 Drinking water
| Programme | Year | Detail |
|---|---|---|
| Accelerated Rural Water Supply Programme | 1972–73 | Central assistance to states for rural water supply |
| National Rural Drinking Water Programme | 2009 | Sustainability, water quality, community management |
| Swachh Bharat Mission | 2 October 2014 | Sanitation; open-defecation-free villages (complements water) |
| Jal Jeevan Mission (Har Ghar Jal) | Announced 15 August 2019 | Functional household tap connection to every rural household; service norm of 55 litres per capita per day; Pani Samitis / VWSCs as sub-committees of the Gram Panchayat, with at least half women members; water-quality testing by trained village women; the original 2024 target was extended to 2028 in the Union Budget 2025–26 |
The Supreme Court has read the right to clean water into Art. 21 (Subhash Kumar v State of Bihar, 1991). Water supply is in the Eleventh Schedule, so panchayats are the natural owners of village schemes.
2.4 Food security: National Food Security Act, 2013
| Provision | Detail |
|---|---|
| Coverage | Up to 75% of the rural and 50% of the urban population |
| Priority households | 5 kg of foodgrains per person per month |
| Antyodaya Anna Yojana (AAY) households | 35 kg per household per month |
| Issue prices (as enacted) | Rs 3/kg rice, Rs 2/kg wheat, Rs 1/kg coarse grains; since 1 January 2023, grains are free under the PM Garib Kalyan Anna Yojana (extended in 2023 for five years from January 2024) |
| Pregnant women and lactating mothers | Meal through anganwadi; maternity benefit of not less than Rs 6,000 |
| Children | 6 months–6 years: meal through ICDS; 6–14 years: mid-day meal in school |
| Women’s empowerment | Eldest woman aged 18 or above is the head of household for the ration card |
| Grievance redress | District Grievance Redressal Officer; State Food Commission |
| Food security allowance | Payable if entitled grains are not supplied |
| Transparency | Social audits of fair price shops and TPDS by local authorities (Section 28); vigilance committees |
PDS history: universal PDS → Revamped PDS (1992) → Targeted PDS (1997) → AAY (2000) → NFSA (2013); One Nation One Ration Card for portability.
2.5 Employment: MGNREGA
The National Rural Employment Guarantee Act was passed in 2005 (assent September 2005) and came into force on 2 February 2006 in 200 districts, extended to all rural districts by 1 April 2008. It was renamed the Mahatma Gandhi NREGA on 2 October 2009. (The syllabus text writes “MNREGA”.)
| Provision | Detail |
|---|---|
| Guarantee | At least 100 days of wage employment per household per financial year to adult members willing to do unskilled manual work |
| Demand-driven | Work to be provided within 15 days of application, else unemployment allowance (not less than one-fourth of the wage rate for the first 30 days, and not less than half thereafter) |
| Distance | Within 5 km of residence; else 10% extra wages |
| Women | At least one-third of beneficiaries to be women; worksite facilities (crèche, drinking water, shade) |
| Wages | Paid within 15 days; delay compensation; wage rates notified by the Centre |
| Wage–material ratio | 60:40: at least 60% of the cost of works goes on wages for unskilled labour, at most 40% on materials |
| No contractors, minimal machinery | To maximise employment |
| Gram Panchayat | Executes at least 50% of works (by cost); plans approved by the Gram Sabha |
| Social audit | Section 17: the Gram Sabha monitors works and conducts regular social audits |
| Funding | Centre bears the full cost of unskilled wages and most material cost; states pay unemployment allowance |
2.6 Education: the Right to Education
| Step | Detail |
|---|---|
| Mohini Jain (1992), Unni Krishnan (1993) | Supreme Court: right to education flows from Art. 21; free education up to age 14 |
| 86th Amendment, 2002 | Art. 21A (free and compulsory education for children 6–14), Art. 45 substituted (early childhood care and education below 6), Art. 51A(k) (parents’ duty) |
| RTE Act, 2009 | Passed August 2009; in force 1 April 2010 |
Key provisions of the RTE Act:
| Section | Provision |
|---|---|
| 3 | Free and compulsory elementary education (classes 1–8) for every child aged 6–14 in a neighbourhood school |
| 12(1)(c) | Private unaided (and specified) schools to admit at least 25% of the entry class from disadvantaged groups and weaker sections, reimbursed by the state |
| 13 | No capitation fee; no screening of child or parents |
| 16 | No detention till class 8, as enacted; amended in 2019 to let states hold back students who fail exams in classes 5 and 8 |
| 17 | No physical punishment or mental harassment |
| 19, 25 and Schedule | School norms, including pupil–teacher ratios (roughly 30:1 primary, 35:1 upper primary) |
| 21 | School Management Committee: three-fourths parents or guardians, with 50% women |
| 23 | Teacher qualifications laid down by an academic authority (NCTE) |
| 29 | Curriculum and evaluation by an academic authority; continuous and comprehensive evaluation |
| 31 | NCPCR and SCPCRs monitor the right |
The Supreme Court upheld the 25% quota in Society for Unaided Private Schools of Rajasthan (2012) and exempted minority schools from the Act in Pramati Educational and Cultural Trust (2014). Implementation now runs through Samagra Shiksha (2018) and the National Education Policy 2020 (which extends the vision to ages 3–18).
3. Monitoring and Evaluation of Public Policy
3.1 Monitoring vs evaluation
| Monitoring | Evaluation | |
|---|---|---|
| Question | Are we doing things right? On track? | Are we doing the right things? Did it work, and why? |
| Timing | Continuous, during implementation | Periodic: before (ex ante), mid-term, after (ex post) |
| Focus | Inputs, activities, outputs | Outcomes, impact, relevance, sustainability |
| Done by | Managers, MIS, dashboards | Often independent evaluators |
3.2 Types and tools
- Formative vs summative evaluation: Michael Scriven (1967): formative improves a programme while it runs; summative judges its worth at the end.
- Process evaluation (was it implemented as designed?) vs impact evaluation (what difference did it make compared with a counterfactual?). Impact designs: randomised controlled trials, difference-in-differences, regression discontinuity, matching.
- Results chain / logical framework: inputs → activities → outputs → outcomes → impact.
- OECD-DAC criteria: relevance, coherence, effectiveness, efficiency, impact, sustainability.
- Participatory evaluation: beneficiaries help define success and judge results.
3.3 Indian machinery
| Institution / tool | Detail |
|---|---|
| Programme Evaluation Organisation (PEO) | Set up in 1952 under the Planning Commission to evaluate Community Development |
| Independent Evaluation Office (IEO) | Created in the last years of the Planning Commission |
| Development Monitoring and Evaluation Office (DMEO) | Under NITI Aayog, formed in 2015 by merging the PEO and IEO; runs the Output-Outcome Monitoring Framework (from 2017–18) linking scheme budgets to measurable outputs and outcomes |
| Outcome budget | From 2005–06 |
| PRAGATI | Pro-Active Governance And Timely Implementation (2015): PM’s video-conference reviews of projects and grievances |
| CAG performance audit | Independent, reported to Parliament |
| MIS and dashboards | NREGASoft, PFMS, geo-tagging of assets, real-time dashboards (e.g. Aspirational Districts’ Champions of Change) |
| Third-party and household surveys | NFHS, NSSO rounds, ASER (by Pratham, on learning) |
4. Making Governance Accountable: Social Audit and Jan Sunwai
4.1 Social audit
A social audit is a process in which the people affected by a scheme, along with the implementing agency, verify records against reality (muster rolls against workers, bills against assets) in a public forum, and the findings are acted upon. It is social accountability: citizens audit the state, not auditors alone.
graph LR
A["Records obtained
(RTI / proactive disclosure)"] --> B["Door-to-door and
worksite verification
by trained resource persons"]
B --> C["Gram Sabha / public
hearing: findings read out"]
C --> D["Officials respond;
discrepancies recorded"]
D --> E["Action taken:
recovery, disciplinary action,
corrections"]
E --> F["Report placed in public
domain; follow-up"]| Landmark | Detail |
|---|---|
| MKSS jan sunwai (Rajasthan, 1990s) | Public hearings on local works using official records; origin of social audit practice in India |
| MGNREGA Section 17 (2005) | Gram Sabha to conduct regular social audits of all projects in the panchayat |
| Audit of Schemes Rules, 2011 | Framed under MGNREGA in consultation with the CAG: independent social audit units in each state, social audit at least once in six months in every gram panchayat |
| Andhra Pradesh | Early large-scale model: a state society dedicated to social audit of MGNREGA |
| Auditing standards for social audit | Issued jointly by the Ministry of Rural Development and the CAG |
| NFSA Section 28 | Periodic social audits of fair price shops and TPDS |
| Meghalaya Community Participation and Public Services Social Audit Act, 2017 | First state law to make social audit of government schemes and services mandatory across departments |
4.2 Jan sunwai (public hearing)
- Who: the Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan (MKSS), founded in 1990 at Devdungri, Rajsamand district, Rajasthan, by Aruna Roy, Nikhil Dey, Shankar Singh and others.
- What: villagers, officials and the press gather; records (muster rolls, bills, vouchers) obtained from the administration are read aloud; villagers testify; discrepancies are recorded; officials are asked to respond.
- Slogan: “Hamara paisa, hamara hisaab” (our money, our accounts).
- Results: recoveries of embezzled funds, Rajasthan’s amendments to its panchayat law to give access to records, and the national campaign for RTI (2005).
- Other public hearings: the Environment Impact Assessment process includes a mandatory public hearing (introduced by a 1997 amendment; now under the EIA Notification, 2006); many districts hold weekly grievance jan sunwai.
4.3 Other social accountability tools
| Tool | Detail |
|---|---|
| Citizen Report Card (CRC) | Pioneered in Bangalore by Samuel Paul (first CRC on the city’s public services, 1993) and taken forward by the Public Affairs Centre he founded (1994): users rate services, results published |
| Community Score Card | Users and providers score services together and agree on reforms |
| Community monitoring | Under NHM, communities review health entitlements |
| Participatory budgeting | Citizens decide part of a local budget; Porto Alegre, Brazil (from 1989) |
| Vigilance and monitoring committees | At village, block and district levels for PDS, MGNREGA |
| Proactive disclosure | RTI Section 4; wall paintings of MGNREGA works at worksites |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Dye — whatever governments choose to do or not to do | vs | Easton — authoritative allocation of values |
| Lindblom — incrementalism, “muddling through” (1959) | vs | Etzioni — mixed scanning (1967) |
| Monitoring — continuous, outputs | vs | Evaluation — periodic, outcomes and impact |
| Formative — improve during | vs | Summative — judge at the end |
| Social audit — by the people (Gram Sabha) | vs | CAG audit — by the constitutional auditor |
| NRHM (2005) — rural health mission | vs | NHM (2013) — umbrella of NRHM + NUHM |
| AAY — 35 kg per household | vs | Priority household — 5 kg per person |
| PEO (1952, Planning Commission) | vs | DMEO (2015, NITI Aayog) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Which section of MGNREGA provides for social audit by the Gram Sabha?
- Who defined public policy as “whatever governments choose to do or not to do”?
- Which state passed the first law making social audit mandatory across government schemes?
Answers
- Section 17.
- Thomas R. Dye.
- Meghalaya (2017).
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) A priority household under the National Food Security Act has four members. How much foodgrain is it entitled to per month, and how much would an Antyodaya household of the same size receive?
- (a) 20 kg and 35 kg
- (b) 20 kg and 20 kg
- (c) 35 kg and 35 kg
- (d) 5 kg and 35 kg
Answer and explanation
(a). Priority households get 5 kg per person: \(4 \times 5 = 20\) kg. AAY households get a flat 35 kg per household, whatever their size.
Q2. (Practice) A gram panchayat plans MGNREGA works costing Rs 50 lakh in a year. Under the 60:40 wage–material norm, the minimum amount that must be spent on wages is:
- (a) Rs 20 lakh
- (b) Rs 25 lakh
- (c) Rs 30 lakh
- (d) Rs 40 lakh
Answer and explanation
(c) Rs 30 lakh. At least 60% goes to wages: \(0.60 \times 50 = 30\) lakh. Material may be at most Rs 20 lakh.
Q3. (Practice) Consider the following statements about the RTE Act, 2009:
- It requires specified private unaided schools to admit at least 25% of the entry class from disadvantaged groups and weaker sections.
- It prohibits screening procedures for admission.
- The Supreme Court has held that it applies fully to minority educational institutions.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 only
- (b) 1 and 2 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b). In Pramati (2014) the Court held that the Act does not apply to minority schools, aided or unaided.
Q4. (Practice) Under MGNREGA, the notified wage rate in a state is Rs 240 per day. If work is not provided within 15 days of application, the minimum daily unemployment allowance for the first 30 days is:
- (a) Rs 40
- (b) Rs 60
- (c) Rs 120
- (d) Rs 240
Answer and explanation
(b) Rs 60. The allowance is not less than one-fourth of the wage rate for the first 30 days: \(240 \div 4 = 60\). After 30 days it rises to not less than half (Rs 120).
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Social audit is a tool of social accountability. Reason (R): In a social audit, the people affected by a programme verify official records against reality in a public forum and demand answers.
Answer and explanation
(a). R describes the mechanism that makes social audit a form of social (citizen-driven) accountability.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): According to Thomas Dye, a government’s decision not to act on an issue is also public policy. Reason (R): Lindblom argued that policy-makers proceed by successive limited comparisons.
Answer and explanation
(b). Both are true, but Lindblom’s incrementalism does not explain Dye’s inclusion of inaction in his definition.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (Thinker) with List II (Concept).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Charles Lindblom | I. Street-level bureaucracy |
| B. Amitai Etzioni | II. Policy windows and multiple streams |
| C. John Kingdon | III. Mixed scanning |
| D. Michael Lipsky | IV. Muddling through |
- (a) A-IV, B-III, C-II, D-I
- (b) A-III, B-IV, C-II, D-I
- (c) A-IV, B-III, C-I, D-II
- (d) A-IV, B-II, C-III, D-I
Answer and explanation
(a) A-IV, B-III, C-II, D-I.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following in chronological order:
- National Food Security Act
- NREGA comes into force in 200 districts
- RTE Act comes into force
- Targeted Public Distribution System
- (a) 4, 2, 3, 1
- (b) 2, 4, 3, 1
- (c) 4, 3, 2, 1
- (d) 4, 2, 1, 3
Answer and explanation
(a). 1997 → 2006 → 2010 → 2013.
Q5. (Practice) Arrange the stages of the policy cycle in order:
- Implementation
- Agenda setting
- Evaluation
- Formulation
- Adoption
- (a) 2, 4, 5, 1, 3
- (b) 4, 2, 5, 1, 3
- (c) 2, 5, 4, 1, 3
- (d) 2, 4, 1, 5, 3
Answer and explanation
(a). Agenda setting → formulation → adoption (decision) → implementation → evaluation.
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Key point |
|---|---|
| Policy definitions | Lasswell (who gets what); Easton (authoritative allocation of values, 1953); Dye (do or not do, 1972) |
| Lowi | Distributive, regulatory, redistributive (1964) |
| Decision models | Simon (satisficing); Lindblom (incremental, 1959); Etzioni (mixed scanning, 1967); Kingdon (streams, 1984) |
| Implementation | Pressman and Wildavsky 1973; Lipsky 1980 |
| PMAY | Urban 25 June 2015; Gramin 1 April 2016 (IAY restructured) |
| NRHM | 12 April 2005; NHM 2013; ASHA; JSY; VHSNC; Rogi Kalyan Samiti |
| Jal Jeevan Mission | 15 August 2019; tap water to every rural household; 55 lpcd |
| NFSA | 2013; 75% rural / 50% urban; 5 kg/person; AAY 35 kg; eldest woman head; Sec. 28 social audit |
| MGNREGA | 2005; in force 2 Feb 2006; renamed 2 Oct 2009; 100 days/household; Sec. 17 social audit; replacement law passed Dec 2025 |
| RTE | 86th Amendment 2002 (Art. 21A); Act 2009, in force 1 April 2010; 25% quota; SMC; 2019 no-detention amendment |
| M&E | Scriven formative/summative 1967; PEO 1952; DMEO 2015; PRAGATI 2015 |
| Social audit | MKSS; MGNREGA Sec. 17; Audit of Schemes Rules 2011; Meghalaya Act 2017 |
| Jan sunwai | MKSS (1990), Rajasthan; “hamara paisa, hamara hisaab” |
| Citizen Report Card | PAC Bangalore, Samuel Paul, 1993 |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Governance and Public Policy — Quick Revision — the whole unit on one page
- RTI, Consumer Protection, Citizen’s Charter and Lokpal — the RTI side of the MKSS story
- Data and Governance (Paper 1) — data systems behind monitoring
- Chapter overview