State Theory and Structures of Power
Capitalist and socialist states, Miliband–Poulantzas, the post-colonial state, welfare state, globalisation, ruling class, power elite and democratic elitism.
- 19 min
On this page · 11 sections
Prerequisites
- Democracy and Power — Mosca, Pareto, Michels, Schumpeter and Dahl are introduced there; this page applies them to the state.
- Liberalism, Conservatism, Socialism and Marxism — base and superstructure, Lenin, Gramsci and Althusser.
- Colonialism, Decolonisation and Nationalism — the origins of the post-colonial state.
The Hook: Two Marxists, One Question
How UGC NET asks it: instrumentalist vs structuralist Marxism; Alavi’s overdeveloped post-colonial state; Esping-Andersen’s three worlds; hyperglobalists vs sceptics vs transformationalists; Mills’s three elites; Bachrach’s critique of democratic elitism; matching debates on the Soviet state (Trotsky, Djilas, Cliff).
Part A: Theories of the State
1. The main families
| Theory | The state is… | Key thinkers |
|---|---|---|
| Liberal / pluralist | A neutral arbiter among competing groups; power is dispersed | Locke (consent); Bentley, Truman, Dahl |
| Neo-pluralist | Still plural, but business has a privileged position | Charles Lindblom, Politics and Markets (1977); J.K. Galbraith (countervailing power) |
| Marxist | An instrument or structure of class domination | Marx, Engels, Lenin, Gramsci, Miliband, Poulantzas, Althusser, Offe, Jessop |
| Elitist | Controlled by a minority whatever the formal constitution | Mosca, Pareto, Michels, C. Wright Mills |
| New Right | An overloaded, self-interested leviathan that should be rolled back | Hayek, Nozick (minimal state), public choice (William Niskanen’s budget-maximising bureaucrat, 1971), Anthony King’s “overload” (1975) |
| Neo-Weberian / statist | An autonomous actor with its own interests and capacities | Theda Skocpol, States and Social Revolutions (1979); Eric Nordlinger, On the Autonomy of the Democratic State (1981); Michael Mann |
| Feminist | A patriarchal institution | Catharine MacKinnon, Toward a Feminist Theory of the State (1989): the state is male |
2. The state in capitalist societies: the Marxist debate
Classical Marxism
- The Communist Manifesto (1848): “The executive of the modern state is but a committee for managing the common affairs of the whole bourgeoisie.”
- The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte (1852): when classes are evenly balanced, the state (under Louis Bonaparte) can gain relative independence — the germ of later “relative autonomy” arguments (Bonapartism).
- Engels, The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State (1884): the state arises where class antagonisms cannot be reconciled.
Twentieth-century positions
| Position | Thinker and work | Argument |
|---|---|---|
| Hegemony | Gramsci, Prison Notebooks (written 1929–35) | The integral state = political society (coercion) + civil society (consent); rule by hegemony “protected by the armour of coercion” |
| Instrumentalism | Ralph Miliband, The State in Capitalist Society (1969) | The state serves capital because the state elite and the capitalist class share social origins, education and personal ties, and because business has superior pressure-group resources |
| Structuralism | Nicos Poulantzas, Political Power and Social Classes (French 1968; English 1973) | The state’s function is determined by the structure of the capitalist mode of production; it has relative autonomy from particular capitalists so that it can organise the long-term interest of the capitalist class as a whole and disorganise the working class |
| Ideological state apparatuses | Louis Althusser, “Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses” (1970) | Repressive state apparatus (government, army, police, courts, prisons) works mainly by violence; ISAs (church, school, family, law, parties, unions, media, culture) work mainly by ideology; in capitalism the educational ISA is dominant |
| Fiscal crisis | James O’Connor, The Fiscal Crisis of the State (1973) | The state must perform two contradictory functions, accumulation and legitimation; spending on both outruns revenue |
| Contradictions of the welfare state | Claus Offe, Contradictions of the Welfare State (1984) | Capitalism cannot coexist with, yet cannot exist without, the welfare state |
| Strategic-relational | Bob Jessop, The Capitalist State (1982) | The state is a social relation; its structure favours some strategies over others |
3. The state in socialist societies
Marxist-Leninist theory
- Engels, Anti-Dühring (1878): the state “is not abolished, it withers away”.
- Lenin, The State and Revolution (written 1917): the bourgeois state must be smashed, replaced by the dictatorship of the proletariat (on the model of the Paris Commune of 1871), which then withers away as classes disappear.
- In practice the Soviet model became a party-state: the Communist Party’s “leading role”, democratic centralism, the nomenklatura system of appointments, a planned economy.
The debate over the nature of the Soviet state
| Interpretation | Thinker and work | Claim |
|---|---|---|
| Degenerated workers’ state | Leon Trotsky, The Revolution Betrayed (1936) | Property is nationalised (so still a workers’ state), but a bureaucratic caste has usurped political power |
| State capitalism | Tony Cliff (from 1948) | The bureaucracy acts as a collective capitalist, accumulating under pressure of military competition with the West |
| Bureaucratic collectivism | Bruno Rizzi (1939), Max Shachtman | A new form of class society, neither capitalist nor socialist |
| New class | Milovan Djilas, The New Class (1957) | The party bureaucracy is a new ruling class through its control (not legal ownership) of collective property |
| Totalitarian model | Carl Friedrich and Zbigniew Brzezinski, Totalitarian Dictatorship and Autocracy (1956) | Soviet and fascist states share a six-point syndrome (see Political Regimes) |
| Interest-group / institutional pluralism | H. Gordon Skilling and Franklyn Griffiths (eds.), Interest Groups in Soviet Politics (1971); Jerry Hough | Behind the monolith, bureaucratic and professional groups competed |
| “Actually existing socialism” | Rudolf Bahro, The Alternative in Eastern Europe (German 1977) | A critique from inside East Germany of the gap between socialist theory and reality |
| Economics of shortage | János Kornai, Economics of Shortage (1980); The Socialist System (1992) | Soft budget constraint: state firms are bailed out, so they hoard inputs and chronic shortage follows |
The collapse of the Soviet bloc (1989–91) and China’s socialist market economy (endorsed by the Communist Party’s 14th Congress, 1992) changed the debate from “what is the socialist state?” to “how does a communist party-state reform its economy and survive?”.
4. The post-colonial state
| Thinker | Work (year) | Argument |
|---|---|---|
| Hamza Alavi | “The State in Post-Colonial Societies: Pakistan and Bangladesh” (New Left Review 74, 1972) | The colonial state was overdeveloped relative to colonial society, because it was built to rule the whole society from outside. After independence its military-bureaucratic oligarchy enjoys relative autonomy, mediating among three propertied classes: the metropolitan bourgeoisie, the indigenous bourgeoisie and the landed classes |
| Gunnar Myrdal | Asian Drama (1968) | The soft state: laws are made but not enforced; low social discipline |
| Joel Migdal | Strong Societies and Weak States (1988) | Post-colonial states often lack capacity because local strongmen control social life ("state in society") |
| Robert Jackson and Carl Rosberg / Jackson | “Why Africa’s Weak States Persist” (1982); Quasi-States (1990) | Quasi-states possess juridical (negative) sovereignty, recognised internationally, but little empirical (positive) capacity |
| Jean-François Bayart | The State in Africa: The Politics of the Belly (French 1989) | Accumulation through the state; patronage networks |
| Mahmood Mamdani | Citizen and Subject (1996) | Indirect rule left a bifurcated state |
| Chalmers Johnson | MITI and the Japanese Miracle (1982) | The developmental state: a capable bureaucracy guiding industrialisation |
| Peter Evans | Embedded Autonomy (1995) | Developmental states combine bureaucratic autonomy with dense ties to business (embedded autonomy); contrast with predatory states (Mobutu’s Zaire) |
The Indian state
- Pranab Bardhan, The Political Economy of Development in India (1984): a coalition of three dominant proprietary classes — industrial capitalists, rich farmers, and professionals (including the bureaucracy) — whose competing demands for subsidies slowed public investment.
- Lloyd and Susanne Rudolph, In Pursuit of Lakshmi (1987): a “weak-strong” state; demand polity (pressure from mobilised groups) vs command polity (state-led); “involuted pluralism”.
- Partha Chatterjee used Gramsci’s passive revolution to describe India’s transition: the bourgeoisie gained power without a full social revolution, through the state.
5. The welfare state
Origins: Bismarck’s social insurance in Germany (sickness 1883, accidents 1884, old age and invalidity 1889); Britain’s Liberal reforms before 1914; the Beveridge Report (1942), which named five giants to be slain: Want, Disease, Ignorance, Squalor and Idleness. T.H. Marshall’s Citizenship and Social Class (1950) made social rights the third stage of citizenship (see Rights and Citizenship).
Gøsta Esping-Andersen, The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism (1990)
Key measures: decommodification (how far people can maintain a livelihood without relying on the market) and stratification (how far welfare reproduces or reduces status differences).
| Regime | Decommodification | Features | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|
| Liberal | Low | Means-tested, modest benefits; market encouraged | USA, Canada, Australia, UK |
| Conservative-corporatist | Medium | Social insurance tied to occupation and status; family and church influence (subsidiarity) | Germany, France, Austria, Italy |
| Social democratic | High | Universal benefits at high standards; full employment; equality | Sweden, Norway, Denmark |
Richard Titmuss, Social Policy (1974), had earlier given three models: residual welfare (state steps in only when family and market fail), industrial achievement-performance (welfare tied to work), and institutional redistributive (universal services as of right).
Critiques and transformations
| Critique | Argument |
|---|---|
| New Right | Welfare creates dependency, crowds out enterprise, overloads government (Hayek, Friedman, Murray) |
| Marxist | Fiscal crisis (O’Connor); Offe’s contradiction; welfare as legitimation of capitalism |
| Feminist | Welfare designed around a male breadwinner; unpaid care ignored |
| Third Way | Anthony Giddens, The Third Way (1998): a social investment state, “no rights without responsibilities”; welfare-to-work |
In India, the Directive Principles (Article 38: a social order of justice, social, economic and political) set the welfare goal; since 2005 rights-based statutes — the rural employment guarantee (NREGA, 2005), the Right to Education Act (2009) and the National Food Security Act (2013) — turned some welfare goals into legal entitlements.
6. Globalisation and the nation-state
David Held, Anthony McGrew, David Goldblatt and Jonathan Perraton, Global Transformations (1999), sorted the debate into three camps:
| Camp | Claim about the nation-state | Key works |
|---|---|---|
| Hyperglobalists | Nation-states are becoming obsolete in a borderless global market | Kenichi Ohmae, The Borderless World (1990), The End of the Nation State (1995) |
| Sceptics | Globalisation is exaggerated; the world economy was as open before 1914; states remain decisive | Paul Hirst and Grahame Thompson, Globalization in Question (1996); Linda Weiss, The Myth of the Powerless State (1998) |
| Transformationalists | States are not disappearing but are being reconstituted; sovereignty is shared and layered | Held et al. (1999); Anthony Giddens |
Other positions
- Susan Strange, The Retreat of the State (1996): authority has shifted from states to markets and non-state actors.
- Philip Cerny: the welfare state becomes a competition state, competing for mobile capital.
- Thomas Friedman, The Lexus and the Olive Tree (1999): the “golden straitjacket” of market-friendly policies.
- Dani Rodrik, The Globalization Paradox (2011): the trilemma — of hyperglobalisation, democracy and national sovereignty, a country can fully have only two.
- After the 2008 financial crisis and the COVID-19 pandemic, many writers noted the return of the state (bailouts, industrial policy, border closures).
Part B: Structures of Power
This official line asks who rules: a class, an elite, or competing elites checked by voters? The classical elitists (Mosca, Pareto, Michels) are covered in detail in Democracy and Power; here they are placed in a comparative frame.
7. Ruling class
| Version | Thinker | Idea |
|---|---|---|
| Marxist ruling class | Marx and Engels, The German Ideology (written 1845–46) | “The ideas of the ruling class are in every epoch the ruling ideas”; the class that owns the means of material production controls the means of mental production |
| Elitist ruling class | Gaetano Mosca, Elementi di scienza politica (1896; English The Ruling Class, 1939) | Every society has an organised minority that rules and an unorganised majority that is ruled; the political formula legitimates rule |
| Circulation of elites | Vilfredo Pareto (1916) | Elites decline and are replaced; lions and foxes |
| Iron law of oligarchy | Robert Michels, Political Parties (1911) | “Who says organisation, says oligarchy” |
| Managerial elite | James Burnham, The Managerial Revolution (1941) | Control of large organisations passes from owners to managers |
Marxists and elitists agree that a minority rules, but differ on why: for Marxists, because of economic ownership (rule is historical and can end with classless society); for classical elitists, because of organisation and psychology (rule by a minority is inevitable).
8. The power elite
C. Wright Mills, The Power Elite (1956), studied post-war America.
- At the top: three interlocking institutional hierarchies — the corporate rich, the military (“warlords”) and the political directorate. Their leaders share social background, education and career movement between institutions.
- In the middle: Congress, pressure groups and local powers, a “semi-organised stalemate”.
- At the bottom: an increasingly mass society, manipulated rather than represented.
Mills wrote from the left: elite rule in America was a fact to be criticised, not a law of nature.
Related studies
- Floyd Hunter, Community Power Structure (1953): Atlanta, using the reputational method (ask informed people who has power); found a business elite.
- G. William Domhoff, Who Rules America? (1967): an upper class dominates through corporations, policy-planning networks and party funding.
- Robert Dahl, “A Critique of the Ruling Elite Model” (APSR, 1958) and Who Governs? (1961): the decisional method found different groups winning in different issue areas — pluralism, not a power elite.
9. Democratic elitism
Democratic elitism (also “competitive elitism” or “elite pluralism”) accepts that elites rule but holds that competition among elites for popular votes makes a system democratic.
| Thinker | Contribution |
|---|---|
| Joseph Schumpeter, Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy (1942) | Democracy as a method: a competitive struggle for the people’s vote; voters choose leaders, not policies |
| Robert Dahl | Polyarchy (1971): rule by multiple minorities in competition |
| Giovanni Sartori, Democratic Theory (English 1962) | Democracy as a selective polyarchy of leaders chosen on merit |
| Seymour Martin Lipset, Political Man (1960) | Some voter apathy may stabilise democracy |
| Karl Mannheim | Democracy as elite selection with open access |
The critique
Peter Bachrach, The Theory of Democratic Elitism: A Critique (1967), argued that democratic elitism had abandoned the classical aim of self-development through participation and turned democracy into a conservative defence of the status quo. Carole Pateman’s Participation and Democratic Theory (1970) and C.B. Macpherson’s participatory model (1977) continued the attack.
graph TD
A["Classical elitism
Mosca 1896, Michels 1911, Pareto 1916:
minority rule is inevitable"] --> B["Power elite
Mills 1956: corporate, military,
political elites in the US"]
A --> C["Democratic elitism
Schumpeter 1942: elites compete
for votes"]
C --> D["Pluralism
Dahl 1958, 1961: power dispersed
across issue areas"]
D -.critique of.-> B
C --> E["Participatory critique
Bachrach 1967, Pateman 1970"]Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Miliband — instrumentalist (1969) | vs | Poulantzas — structuralist, relative autonomy (1968) |
| Althusser — RSA vs ISAs (1970) | vs | Gramsci — political vs civil society (hegemony) |
| Trotsky — degenerated workers’ state | vs | Djilas — the new class; Cliff — state capitalism |
| Alavi — overdeveloped state | vs | Myrdal — soft state; Jackson — quasi-states |
| Johnson — developmental state (Japan, 1982) | vs | Evans — embedded autonomy (1995) |
| Esping-Andersen — three worlds (1990) | vs | Titmuss — three models (1974) |
| Mills — power elite (1956) | vs | Hunter — community power, reputational method (1953) |
| Schumpeter — democratic elitism (1942) | vs | Bachrach — critique of democratic elitism (1967) |
| O’Connor — accumulation vs legitimation | vs | Offe — can’t live with or without the welfare state |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Who described the post-colonial state as “overdeveloped”?
- What are Esping-Andersen’s three welfare regimes?
- Which three institutional orders make up Mills’s power elite?
Answers
- Hamza Alavi (New Left Review, 1972).
- Liberal, conservative-corporatist, social democratic.
- Corporate (economic), military and political.
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) The view that the state in capitalist society enjoys “relative autonomy” because of its place in the structure of the capitalist mode of production is most associated with:
- (a) Ralph Miliband
- (b) Nicos Poulantzas
- (c) Robert Dahl
- (d) C. Wright Mills
Answer and explanation
(b) Nicos Poulantzas. Miliband stressed the class background and connections of state personnel (instrumentalism).
Q2. (Practice) Consider the following statements about Althusser’s theory of the state:
- The army and the police belong to the repressive state apparatus.
- The school and the family are ideological state apparatuses.
- Ideological state apparatuses function mainly by violence.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 only
- (b) 1 and 2 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 1 and 2 only. ISAs work mainly by ideology; the repressive state apparatus works mainly by violence. Althusser adds that each works secondarily by the other.
Q3. (Practice) “Of hyperglobalisation, democracy and national sovereignty, a country can fully combine only two.” This trilemma was proposed by:
- (a) Kenichi Ohmae
- (b) Susan Strange
- (c) Dani Rodrik
- (d) Paul Hirst
Answer and explanation
(c) Dani Rodrik, The Globalization Paradox (2011).
Q4. (Practice) Who argued that the Soviet Union was a “degenerated workers’ state”?
- (a) Milovan Djilas
- (b) Leon Trotsky
- (c) Tony Cliff
- (d) János Kornai
Answer and explanation
(b) Leon Trotsky, The Revolution Betrayed (1936). Djilas: the new class; Cliff: state capitalism; Kornai: economics of shortage.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Hamza Alavi held that the military-bureaucratic oligarchy in post-colonial Pakistan enjoyed relative autonomy. Reason (R): It mediated between the competing interests of the metropolitan bourgeoisie, the indigenous bourgeoisie and the landed classes, none of which could dominate alone.
Answer and explanation
(a). Relative autonomy follows from the oligarchy’s mediating role among three propertied classes.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): Peter Bachrach criticised the theory of democratic elitism. Reason (R): Democratic elitism holds that a single unified elite rules regardless of elections.
Answer and explanation
(c). A is true (The Theory of Democratic Elitism: A Critique, 1967). R is false: democratic elitism stresses competition among elites for votes; the single unified elite is Mills’s power elite.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (Thinker) with List II (Concept).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Gunnar Myrdal | I. Embedded autonomy |
| B. Peter Evans | II. Soft state |
| C. Michael Mann | III. Bifurcated state |
| D. Mahmood Mamdani | IV. Infrastructural power |
- (a) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
- (b) A-I, B-II, C-IV, D-III
- (c) A-II, B-IV, C-I, D-III
- (d) A-II, B-I, C-III, D-IV
Answer and explanation
(a) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following works in chronological order:
- Miliband, The State in Capitalist Society
- Mills, The Power Elite
- Esping-Andersen, The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism
- Schumpeter, Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy
- (a) 4, 2, 1, 3
- (b) 2, 4, 1, 3
- (c) 4, 1, 2, 3
- (d) 4, 2, 3, 1
Answer and explanation
(a). Schumpeter 1942 → Mills 1956 → Miliband 1969 → Esping-Andersen 1990.
Quick Revision Table
| Thinker | Work | Year | Key idea |
|---|---|---|---|
| Marx and Engels | Communist Manifesto | 1848 | State as committee of the bourgeoisie |
| Marx | Eighteenth Brumaire | 1852 | Bonapartism; relative independence |
| Mosca | Elementi di scienza politica | 1896 | Ruling class; political formula |
| Trotsky | The Revolution Betrayed | 1936 | Degenerated workers’ state |
| Burnham | The Managerial Revolution | 1941 | Managers as new elite |
| Schumpeter | Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy | 1942 | Democratic (competitive) elitism |
| Beveridge | Report | 1942 | Five giants |
| Hunter | Community Power Structure | 1953 | Reputational method |
| Mills | The Power Elite | 1956 | Corporate, military, political |
| Djilas | The New Class | 1957 | Bureaucracy as ruling class |
| Bachrach | The Theory of Democratic Elitism | 1967 | Critique |
| Myrdal | Asian Drama | 1968 | Soft state |
| Poulantzas | Political Power and Social Classes | 1968 | Structuralism; relative autonomy |
| Miliband | The State in Capitalist Society | 1969 | Instrumentalism |
| Althusser | “Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses” | 1970 | RSA vs ISAs |
| Alavi | “The State in Post-Colonial Societies” | 1972 | Overdeveloped state |
| O’Connor | The Fiscal Crisis of the State | 1973 | Accumulation vs legitimation |
| Lindblom | Politics and Markets | 1977 | Privileged position of business |
| Skocpol | States and Social Revolutions | 1979 | State autonomy |
| Johnson | MITI and the Japanese Miracle | 1982 | Developmental state |
| Bardhan | The Political Economy of Development in India | 1984 | Three dominant proprietary classes |
| Offe | Contradictions of the Welfare State | 1984 | Can’t live with or without it |
| Rudolph and Rudolph | In Pursuit of Lakshmi | 1987 | Weak-strong state; demand polity |
| Migdal | Strong Societies and Weak States | 1988 | State in society |
| Esping-Andersen | The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism | 1990 | Decommodification; three regimes |
| Ohmae | The End of the Nation State | 1995 | Hyperglobalism |
| Evans | Embedded Autonomy | 1995 | Developmental vs predatory |
| Hirst and Thompson | Globalization in Question | 1996 | Sceptics |
| Held et al. | Global Transformations | 1999 | Transformationalists |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Political Regimes and Constitutionalism — democratic and non-democratic regimes, and the constitutional limits on state power
- Development and Democratisation — the developmental state in the debate on development
- Democracy and Power — classical elitists and the three faces of power
- Comparative Political Analysis — Quick Revision