Comparative Political Analysis Short Notes
One-page UGC NET revision for Comparative Political Analysis: approaches, nationalism, state, regimes, constitutionalism, development, democratisation, parties.
- 13 min
On this page · 12 sections
The whole of Unit 4 on one page. For explanations, go back to the chapter.
1. Approaches and Comparative Methods
| Thinker | Work | Year | Key idea |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mill | A System of Logic | 1843 | Methods of agreement, difference, concomitant variations |
| Bryce | Modern Democracies | 1921 | Traditional institutional comparison |
| Easton | The Political System | 1953 | Systems approach |
| Macridis | The Study of Comparative Government | 1955 | Non-comparative, descriptive, parochial, static, monographic |
| Banfield | The Moral Basis of a Backward Society | 1958 | Amoral familism |
| Almond and Coleman | The Politics of the Developing Areas | 1960 | Input and output functions |
| Almond and Verba | The Civic Culture | 1963 | Parochial, subject, participant; USA, UK, W. Germany, Italy, Mexico |
| Barrington Moore | Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy | 1966 | Three routes; “no bourgeois, no democracy” |
| Sartori | “Concept Misformation in Comparative Politics” | 1970 | Conceptual stretching; ladder of abstraction |
| Przeworski and Teune | The Logic of Comparative Social Inquiry | 1970 | MSSD (difference) and MDSD (agreement) |
| Lijphart | “Comparative Politics and the Comparative Method” | 1971 | Many variables, small N; six case-study types |
| Inglehart | The Silent Revolution | 1977 | Post-materialism |
| DiMaggio and Powell | “The Iron Cage Revisited” | 1983 | Coercive, mimetic, normative isomorphism |
| March and Olsen | “The New Institutionalism” | 1984 | Logic of appropriateness |
| Evans, Rueschemeyer, Skocpol | Bringing the State Back In | 1985 | State as actor |
| Ragin | The Comparative Method | 1987 | QCA |
| North | Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance | 1990 | Rules of the game |
| Putnam | Making Democracy Work | 1993 | Social capital, Italian regions |
| Hall and Taylor | “Political Science and the Three New Institutionalisms” | 1996 | Historical, rational choice, sociological |
| Hall and Soskice | Varieties of Capitalism | 2001 | LMEs vs CMEs |
Moore’s routes: bourgeois revolution → democracy (England, France, US); revolution from above → fascism (Germany, Japan); peasant revolution → communism (Russia, China).
Design rule: most similar systems ↔ method of difference; most different systems ↔ method of agreement.
2. Colonialism and Decolonisation
| Form of colonialism | Example |
|---|---|
| Settler | North America, Australia, Algeria, South Africa |
| Exploitation | British India, Belgian Congo |
| Plantation | Caribbean, Mauritius, Fiji |
| Protectorate | Indian princely states, Morocco |
| Mandate / trusteeship | League Article 22 (A, B, C); UN Charter Chapters XII–XIII |
| Informal empire | Gallagher and Robinson (1953) |
| Internal colonialism | Hechter (1975), Celtic fringe |
| Thinker / event | Work / detail | Year | Key idea |
|---|---|---|---|
| Berlin Conference | Partition of Africa | 1884–85 | Arbitrary borders |
| Hobson | Imperialism: A Study | 1902 | Underconsumption |
| Naoroji | Poverty and Un-British Rule in India | 1901 | Drain of wealth |
| Hilferding | Finance Capital | 1910 | Finance capital |
| Luxemburg | The Accumulation of Capital | 1913 | Need for non-capitalist areas |
| Lenin | Imperialism, the Highest Stage of Capitalism | 1917 | Monopoly stage; five features |
| Schumpeter | “The Sociology of Imperialisms” | 1919 | Atavism |
| Lugard | The Dual Mandate | 1922 | Indirect rule |
| Pan-African Congress | Manchester | 1945 | Pan-Africanism |
| Césaire | Discourse on Colonialism | 1950 | Négritude |
| Fanon | Black Skin, White Masks | 1952 | Psychology of racism |
| Bandung | Asian–African Conference | 1955 | 29 states |
| Memmi | The Colonizer and the Colonized | 1957 | Mutual dehumanisation |
| UNGA | Resolution 1514 (XV), 14 December | 1960 | Independence declaration |
| Fanon | The Wretched of the Earth | 1961 | Violence; distrust of national bourgeoisie |
| NAM | Belgrade summit | 1961 | Non-alignment |
| Nkrumah | Neo-Colonialism | 1965 | Last stage of imperialism |
| Said | Orientalism | 1978 | Constructed Orient |
| Guha (ed.) | Subaltern Studies I | 1982 | History from below |
| Nandy | The Intimate Enemy | 1983 | Colonised mind |
| Spivak | “Can the Subaltern Speak?” | 1988 | Silenced subaltern |
| Bhabha | The Location of Culture | 1994 | Hybridity, mimicry |
Decolonisation waves: Americas (1776–1820s) → post-1918 empires → Asia (1946–49) → Africa (1957–60s) → Portuguese Africa (1974–75), Zimbabwe (1980), Namibia (1990) → Hong Kong (1997), Macau (1999), Timor-Leste (2002).
3. Nationalism
| Thinker | Work | Year | Key idea |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fichte | Addresses to the German Nation | 1807–08 | Cultural nationalism |
| Renan | “What Is a Nation?” | 1882 | Daily plebiscite |
| Tagore | Nationalism | 1917 | Critique of the nation-state |
| Stalin | Marxism and the National Question | 1913 | Language, territory, economic life, psychological make-up |
| Kohn | The Idea of Nationalism | 1944 | Civic (West) vs ethnic (East) |
| Desai | Social Background of Indian Nationalism | 1948 | Marxist interpretation |
| Kedourie | Nationalism | 1960 | Invented in Europe, early nineteenth century |
| Seal | The Emergence of Indian Nationalism | 1968 | Cambridge School |
| Nairn | The Break-up of Britain | 1977 | Modern Janus |
| Breuilly | Nationalism and the State | 1982 | Nationalism as politics |
| Gellner | Nations and Nationalism | 1983 | Political and national unit congruent |
| Anderson | Imagined Communities | 1983 | Imagined, limited, sovereign; print capitalism |
| Hobsbawm and Ranger | The Invention of Tradition | 1983 | Invented traditions |
| Smith | The Ethnic Origins of Nations | 1986 | Ethnie; ethno-symbolism |
| Chatterjee | Nationalist Thought and the Colonial World | 1986 | Departure (Bankim), manoeuvre (Gandhi), arrival (Nehru) |
| Hobsbawm | Nations and Nationalism since 1780 | 1990 | Modernist |
| Chatterjee | The Nation and Its Fragments | 1993 | Inner vs outer domain |
Schools: primordialism (Shils, Geertz) · perennialism (Hastings) · modernism (Gellner, Anderson, Hobsbawm, Breuilly) · ethno-symbolism (Smith, Hutchinson, Armstrong). Hroch: phases A (scholarly), B (agitation), C (mass).
4. State Theory
| Thinker | Work | Year | Key idea |
|---|---|---|---|
| Marx and Engels | Communist Manifesto | 1848 | Committee of the bourgeoisie |
| Marx | Eighteenth Brumaire | 1852 | Bonapartism |
| Engels | Anti-Dühring / Origin of the Family… | 1878 / 1884 | State withers away; class origin of state |
| Lenin | The State and Revolution | 1917 | Smash the state; dictatorship of proletariat |
| Weber | “Politics as a Vocation” | 1919 | Monopoly of legitimate force |
| Trotsky | The Revolution Betrayed | 1936 | Degenerated workers’ state |
| Beveridge | Report | 1942 | Want, Disease, Ignorance, Squalor, Idleness |
| Marshall | Citizenship and Social Class | 1950 | Social rights |
| Friedrich and Brzezinski | Totalitarian Dictatorship and Autocracy | 1956 | Six-point syndrome |
| Djilas | The New Class | 1957 | Bureaucracy as ruling class |
| Myrdal | Asian Drama | 1968 | Soft state |
| Poulantzas | Political Power and Social Classes | 1968 | Structuralism; relative autonomy |
| Miliband | The State in Capitalist Society | 1969 | Instrumentalism |
| Althusser | “Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses” | 1970 | RSA vs ISAs |
| Alavi | “The State in Post-Colonial Societies” | 1972 | Overdeveloped state; military-bureaucratic oligarchy; three classes |
| O’Connor | The Fiscal Crisis of the State | 1973 | Accumulation vs legitimation |
| Titmuss | Social Policy | 1974 | Residual, achievement-performance, institutional |
| Lindblom | Politics and Markets | 1977 | Privileged position of business |
| Skocpol | States and Social Revolutions | 1979 | State autonomy |
| Kornai | Economics of Shortage | 1980 | Soft budget constraint |
| Johnson | MITI and the Japanese Miracle | 1982 | Developmental state |
| Bardhan | The Political Economy of Development in India | 1984 | Three dominant proprietary classes |
| Mann | “The Autonomous Power of the State” | 1984 | Despotic vs infrastructural power |
| Offe | Contradictions of the Welfare State | 1984 | Can’t live with or without it |
| Rudolph and Rudolph | In Pursuit of Lakshmi | 1987 | Weak-strong state; demand vs command polity |
| Migdal | Strong Societies and Weak States | 1988 | State in society |
| Esping-Andersen | The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism | 1990 | Liberal, conservative-corporatist, social democratic; decommodification |
| Jackson | Quasi-States | 1990 | Negative sovereignty |
| Ohmae | The End of the Nation State | 1995 | Hyperglobalist |
| Evans | Embedded Autonomy | 1995 | Developmental vs predatory |
| Hirst and Thompson | Globalization in Question | 1996 | Sceptic |
| Strange | The Retreat of the State | 1996 | Authority shifts to markets |
| Mamdani | Citizen and Subject | 1996 | Bifurcated state |
| Giddens | The Third Way | 1998 | Social investment state |
| Held et al. | Global Transformations | 1999 | Transformationalist |
| Rodrik | The Globalization Paradox | 2011 | Trilemma |
5. Structures of Power
| Thinker | Work | Year | Key idea |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mosca | Elementi di scienza politica | 1896 | Ruling class; political formula |
| Michels | Political Parties | 1911 | Iron law of oligarchy |
| Pareto | Trattato di sociologia generale | 1916 | Circulation of elites |
| Burnham | The Managerial Revolution | 1941 | Managerial elite |
| Schumpeter | Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy | 1942 | Democratic (competitive) elitism |
| Hunter | Community Power Structure | 1953 | Reputational method, Atlanta |
| Mills | The Power Elite | 1956 | Corporate, military, political |
| Dahl | “A Critique of the Ruling Elite Model” / Who Governs? | 1958 / 1961 | Pluralism |
| Sartori | Democratic Theory (English) | 1962 | Selective polyarchy |
| Domhoff | Who Rules America? | 1967 | Upper-class dominance |
| Bachrach | The Theory of Democratic Elitism: A Critique | 1967 | Critique of democratic elitism |
6. Political Regimes
| Thinker | Work | Year | Key idea |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arendt | The Origins of Totalitarianism | 1951 | Ideology and terror |
| Friedrich and Brzezinski | Totalitarian Dictatorship and Autocracy | 1956 | Ideology, single party, terror, media, weapons, economy |
| Huntington | The Soldier and the State | 1957 | Objective vs subjective control |
| Finer | The Man on Horseback | 1962 | Influence → pressure → displacement → supplantment |
| Nolte | Three Faces of Fascism | 1963 | Action Française, Fascism, Nazism |
| Linz | “An Authoritarian Regime: Spain” | 1964 | Limited pluralism, mentalities, low mobilisation |
| Huntington | Political Order in Changing Societies | 1968 | Praetorianism |
| O’Donnell | Modernization and Bureaucratic-Authoritarianism | 1973 | Brazil 1964, Argentina 1966; technocrats; exclusion; deepening |
| Eisenstadt | Traditional Patrimonialism and Modern Neopatrimonialism | 1973 | Neo-patrimonialism |
| Nordlinger | Soldiers in Politics | 1977 | Moderators, guardians, rulers |
| Dahl | Democracy and Its Critics | 1989 | Six institutions of polyarchy |
| Griffin | The Nature of Fascism | 1991 | Palingenetic ultranationalism |
| O’Donnell | “Delegative Democracy” | 1994 | Weak horizontal accountability |
| Linz and Stepan | Problems of Democratic Transition and Consolidation | 1996 | Post-totalitarian, sultanistic |
| Zakaria | “The Rise of Illiberal Democracy” | 1997 | Illiberal democracy |
| Chehabi and Linz | Sultanistic Regimes | 1998 | Sultanism |
| Lijphart | Patterns of Democracy | 1999 | Majoritarian vs consensus (ten variables) |
| Levitsky and Way | Competitive authoritarianism | 2002 / 2010 | Hybrid regime |
| Paxton | The Anatomy of Fascism | 2004 | Stages of fascism |
| Schedler (ed.) | Electoral Authoritarianism | 2006 | Hybrid regime |
Democratic types: electoral (minimal) · liberal (rights and limits) · majoritarian (Westminster) · participatory (Pateman; Porto Alegre from 1989). Non-democratic: patrimonial/sultanistic · bureaucratic-authoritarian · military · totalitarian · fascist.
7. Constitutions and Constitutionalism
| Thinker / source | Work | Year | Key idea |
|---|---|---|---|
| Act of Settlement | — | 1701 | Judicial tenure during good behaviour |
| Montesquieu | The Spirit of the Laws | 1748 | Separation of powers |
| Madison / Hamilton | Federalist Nos. 51 / 78 | 1788 | Checks and balances / least dangerous branch |
| Marbury v. Madison | US Supreme Court | 1803 | Judicial review |
| Dicey | Introduction to the Study of the Law of the Constitution | 1885 | Supremacy of law, equality before law, constitution from ordinary law |
| Bryce | “Flexible and Rigid Constitutions” | 1901 | Rigid vs flexible |
| Schmitt | Dictatorship / Political Theology | 1921 / 1922 | Commissarial vs sovereign / decides on the exception |
| McIlwain | Constitutionalism: Ancient and Modern | 1940 | Legal limitation on government |
| Rossiter | Constitutional Dictatorship | 1948 | Crisis government |
| Wheare | Modern Constitutions | 1951 | Classification |
| Loewenstein | Political Power and the Governmental Process | 1957 | Normative, nominal, semantic |
| Sartori | “Constitutionalism: A Preliminary Discussion” | 1962 | Garantiste, nominal, façade |
| Fuller | The Morality of Law | 1964 | Eight principles of legality |
| Raz | “The Rule of Law and its Virtue” | 1977 | Formal rule of law |
| Bangalore Principles | Judicial conduct | 2002 | Six values |
| Agamben | State of Exception | 2003 | Exception as paradigm |
| Bellamy | Political Constitutionalism | 2007 | Against legal constitutionalism |
| Bingham | The Rule of Law | 2010 | Eight principles |
| Landau | “Abusive Constitutionalism” | 2013 | Erosion through amendment |
| Levitsky and Ziblatt | How Democracies Die | 2018 | Toleration and forbearance |
India: Art. 352 (national emergency: war, external aggression, armed rebellion), 356 (President’s Rule; S.R. Bommai, 1994), 360 (financial; never used). Emergency 25 June 1975 – March 1977. 44th Amendment (1978): “armed rebellion” for “internal disturbance”; written Cabinet advice; Arts. 20 and 21 not suspendable. ADM Jabalpur (1976) overruled in Puttaswamy (2017). Collegium: Second Judges case (1993); NJAC struck down (2015).
8. Development
| Thinker | Work | Year | Key idea |
|---|---|---|---|
| Prebisch / Singer | ECLA report / article | 1950 | Declining terms of trade; ISI |
| Parsons | The Social System | 1951 | Pattern variables |
| Baran | The Political Economy of Growth | 1957 | Surplus |
| Lerner | The Passing of Traditional Society | 1958 | Empathy |
| Rostow | The Stages of Economic Growth | 1960 | Traditional → preconditions → take-off → maturity → high mass consumption |
| Organski | The Stages of Political Development | 1965 | Four stages |
| Pye | Aspects of Political Development | 1966 | Equality, capacity, differentiation |
| Frank | “The Development of Underdevelopment” | 1966 | Metropolis–satellite |
| Rudolph and Rudolph | The Modernity of Tradition | 1967 | Tradition adapts |
| Huntington | Political Order in Changing Societies | 1968 | Institutionalisation: adaptability, complexity, autonomy, coherence |
| Cardoso and Faletto | Dependency and Development in Latin America | 1969 | Associated dependent development |
| Emmanuel | Unequal Exchange | 1969 | Wage-based unequal exchange |
| dos Santos | “The Structure of Dependence” | 1970 | Definition of dependence |
| Amin | Accumulation on a World Scale | 1970 | Delinking |
| Galtung | “A Structural Theory of Imperialism” | 1971 | Centre–periphery within nations |
| Binder et al. | Crises and Sequences in Political Development | 1971 | Identity, legitimacy, participation, penetration, distribution, integration |
| Rodney | How Europe Underdeveloped Africa | 1972 | Africa underdeveloped |
| Wallerstein | The Modern World-System I | 1974 | Core, semi-periphery, periphery; hegemonic cycles |
| Evans | Dependent Development | 1979 | Triple alliance (Brazil) |
| Warren | Imperialism: Pioneer of Capitalism | 1980 | Marxist critique of dependency |
| Brundtland | Our Common Future | 1987 | Sustainable development |
| UNDP | First Human Development Report | 1990 | HDI |
| Arrighi | The Long Twentieth Century | 1994 | Systemic cycles |
| Escobar | Encountering Development | 1995 | Post-development |
| Sen | Development as Freedom | 1999 | Capabilities; no famine in democracy |
Development and democracy: Lipset (1959) wealth sustains democracy · Moore (1966) class routes · O’Donnell (1973) growth → authoritarianism · Rueschemeyer et al. (1992) working class · Przeworski and Limongi (1997) exogenous survival · Boix (2003) inequality · Acemoglu and Robinson (2006, 2012) inclusive vs extractive institutions.
9. Democratisation
| Thinker | Work | Year | Key idea |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rustow | “Transitions to Democracy” | 1970 | National unity → preparatory → decision → habituation |
| Dahl | Polyarchy | 1971 | Liberalisation before inclusiveness |
| O’Donnell, Schmitter, Whitehead | Transitions from Authoritarian Rule | 1986 | Hard-liners vs soft-liners; pacts; liberalisation vs democratisation |
| Huntington | The Third Wave | 1991 | Waves; transformation, replacement, transplacement; two-turnover test |
| Przeworski | Democracy and the Market | 1991 | Parties lose elections; only game in town |
| Linz and Stepan | Problems of Democratic Transition and Consolidation | 1996 | Behavioural, attitudinal, constitutional; five arenas |
| Schedler | “What Is Democratic Consolidation?” | 1998 | Avoiding breakdown and erosion |
| Carothers | “The End of the Transition Paradigm” | 2002 | Grey zone |
| McFaul | Fourth wave | 2002 | Post-communist outcomes |
| Diamond | “Facing Up to the Democratic Recession” | 2015 | Democratic recession |
| Lührmann and Lindberg | “A Third Wave of Autocratization Is Here” | 2019 | Autocratisation |
Huntington’s waves: 1st 1828–1926 · reverse 1922–42 · 2nd 1943–62 · reverse 1958–75 · 3rd from 1974 (Portugal, 25 April).
10. Actors and Processes
| Thinker | Work | Year | Key idea |
|---|---|---|---|
| Burke | Thoughts on the Cause of the Present Discontents | 1770 | Party as union on principle |
| Bentley | The Process of Government | 1908 | Group theory |
| Brinton | The Anatomy of Revolution | 1938 | Moderates → extremists → terror → Thermidor |
| Duverger | Political Parties | 1951 | Plurality → two-party (law); PR → multiparty; cadre vs mass |
| Truman | The Governmental Process | 1951 | Potential groups |
| Neumann | Modern Political Parties | 1956 | Representation vs integration parties |
| Downs | An Economic Theory of Democracy | 1957 | Office-seeking teams |
| Schattschneider | The Semisovereign People | 1960 | Upper-class accent |
| Davies | “Toward a Theory of Revolution” | 1962 | J-curve |
| Smelser | Theory of Collective Behavior | 1962 | Value-added model |
| Arendt | On Revolution | 1963 | American vs French |
| Kothari | “The Congress ‘System’ in India” | 1964 | Party of consensus, parties of pressure |
| Olson | The Logic of Collective Action | 1965 | Free rider; selective incentives |
| Kirchheimer | Catch-all party | 1966 | De-ideologisation |
| Almond and Powell | Comparative Politics | 1966 | Anomic, non-associational, institutional, associational |
| C. Johnson | Revolutionary Change | 1966 | Disequilibrated system |
| Lipset and Rokkan | “Cleavage Structures…” | 1967 | Centre–periphery, state–church, land–industry, owner–worker; freezing |
| Rae | The Political Consequences of Electoral Laws | 1967 | Electoral effects |
| Blondel | Party system types | 1968 | Two-and-a-half party |
| Gurr | Why Men Rebel | 1970 | Relative deprivation |
| Schmitter | “Still the Century of Corporatism?” | 1974 | Representational monopoly |
| Sartori | Parties and Party Systems | 1976 | Seven classes; polarised pluralism |
| McCarthy and Zald | Resource mobilisation | 1977 | SMOs |
| Tilly | From Mobilization to Revolution | 1978 | Multiple sovereignty |
| Laakso and Taagepera | Effective number of parties | 1979 | \( N = 1 / \sum p_i^2 \) |
| Skocpol | States and Social Revolutions | 1979 | France, Russia, China; state breakdown + peasant revolt |
| McAdam | Political Process and the Development of Black Insurgency | 1982 | Political opportunity |
| Offe | “New Social Movements” | 1985 | NSMs |
| Melucci | Nomads of the Present | 1989 | Collective identity |
| Tarrow | Power in Movement | 1994 | Political opportunity, cycles of protest |
| Katz and Mair | Cartel party | 1995 | State-financed parties |
| Keck and Sikkink | Activists Beyond Borders | 1998 | Boomerang pattern |
| McAdam, Tarrow, Tilly | Dynamics of Contention | 2001 | Contentious politics |
| Tilly | Social Movements, 1768–2004 | 2004 | WUNC |
| Chatterjee | The Politics of the Governed | 2004 | Political society |
Electoral systems: FPTP (UK, Lok Sabha) · two-round (France) · AV (Australian House) · list PR (Israel, Netherlands) · STV (Ireland, Malta; Indian President, Vice-President, Rajya Sabha) · MMP (Germany, NZ) · parallel (Japan).
Formulas: Hare = votes ÷ seats · Droop = ⌊votes ÷ (seats + 1)⌋ + 1 · D’Hondt divisors 1, 2, 3… (favours large parties) · Sainte-Laguë 1, 3, 5… · \( N = 1 / \sum p_i^2 \).
Campaigns: ICBL → Ottawa Treaty and Nobel (1997) · ICAN → TPNW and Nobel (2017) · MKSS (1990) → RTI Act (2005) · India Against Corruption (2011) → Lokpal Act (2013).
Ten Traps in One Box
Where to Go Next
- Comparative Political Analysis chapter — all six topic pages
- Political Theory — Quick Revision — Unit 1 on one page
- Democracy and Power — elitism, pluralism and power
- Research Aptitude — research design behind the comparative method