Approaches and Comparative Methods
Institutional, political culture, political economy and new institutionalist approaches, plus Mill's methods, MSSD/MDSD, Sartori and Lijphart, for UGC NET.
- 20 min
On this page · 15 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Five Countries, One Questionnaire
- 1. From Comparative Government to Comparative Politics
- 2. The Institutional Approach (Old Institutionalism)
- 3. The Political Culture Approach
- 4. The Political Economy Approach
- 5. New Institutionalism
- 6. Comparative Methods
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Research Meaning, Types and Approaches — positivism, induction and the logic of explanation, which the comparative method borrows.
- Democracy and Power — Easton’s “authoritative allocation of values” and Dahl’s pluralism, which framed the behavioural turn in comparative politics.
The Hook: Five Countries, One Questionnaire
How UGC NET asks it: match the approach to its founder and book (Almond and Verba → civic culture, March and Olsen → new institutionalism, Barrington Moore → social origins), identify Mill’s methods and the most similar / most different designs, Sartori’s ladder of abstraction, and assertion–reason on why the traditional approach was criticised.
1. From Comparative Government to Comparative Politics
The field changed its name, and its method, in the 1950s and 1960s.
graph LR
A["Traditional
formal-legal, institutional
(to the 1940s)"] --> B["Behavioural
systems, structural-functional,
political culture (1950s-60s)"]
B --> C["Post-behavioural
Easton 1969: relevance
and action"]
C --> D["Political economy
and the state
(1970s-80s)"]
D --> E["New institutionalism
March and Olsen 1984;
three variants (1990s)"]| Phase | Unit of study | Method | Typical works |
|---|---|---|---|
| Traditional (comparative government) | Formal institutions of a few Western states: constitutions, legislatures, executives, courts | Legal, historical, descriptive; country-by-country | Woodrow Wilson, Congressional Government (1885); James Bryce, The American Commonwealth (1888) and Modern Democracies (1921); Herman Finer, The Theory and Practice of Modern Government (1932); Carl J. Friedrich on constitutional government |
| Behavioural (comparative politics) | Political behaviour and functions in all societies, including the new states of Asia and Africa | Empirical, quantitative, value-free, interdisciplinary | Easton, The Political System (1953); Almond and Coleman, The Politics of the Developing Areas (1960); Almond and Verba (1963); Almond and Powell, Comparative Politics: A Developmental Approach (1966) |
| Post-behavioural | Same, with concern for relevance | “Relevance and action” | Easton’s presidential address to the American Political Science Association, “The New Revolution in Political Science” (1969) |
| Political economy / state-centred | Classes, markets and states | Historical-structural, Marxist and rational choice | Barrington Moore (1966); dependency theory; Bringing the State Back In (1985) |
| New institutionalism | Institutions as rules, norms and routines | Historical, rational choice, sociological | March and Olsen (1984, 1989); Hall and Taylor (1996) |
Macridis’s critique of the traditional approach
Roy Macridis, The Study of Comparative Government (1955), complained that traditional comparative government was essentially:
- Non-comparative — it described one country after another;
- Descriptive — it reported rules, not explanations;
- Parochial — it studied only Western Europe and the United States;
- Static — it ignored change and development;
- Monographic — it produced single-country studies.
2. The Institutional Approach (Old Institutionalism)
The oldest approach studies formal institutions: constitutions, legislatures, executives, courts, bureaucracies, federal arrangements and electoral laws.
Features
- Formal-legal: institutions are what the constitution and the law say they are.
- Historical: institutions are explained by their origins (the British constitution by its evolution since 1688).
- Structural: the structure of an institution is assumed to determine behaviour within it.
- Normative: writers often asked which arrangement was best (Bryce on democracy, Dicey on the rule of law).
- Configurative: whole national systems described one at a time.
Strengths: precise knowledge of how governments are organised; still the basis of comparing presidential and parliamentary systems, federations and electoral systems (see Actors and Processes).
Weaknesses: ignores informal politics (parties, groups, patronage, the military); assumes that the written constitution is the working constitution; Western bias; little theory.
The behavioural alternatives (context)
Two general frameworks replaced the old institutionalism before the syllabus’s named approaches took over. Questions often mix them in:
- Systems approach — David Easton: the political system converts inputs (demands and supports) into outputs (authoritative decisions and actions), with feedback returning to the environment; A Framework for Political Analysis and A Systems Analysis of Political Life (both 1965).
- Structural-functional approach — Gabriel Almond: every political system performs the same functions through different structures. In Almond and Coleman (1960) the input functions are political socialisation and recruitment, interest articulation, interest aggregation and political communication; the output functions are rule making, rule application and rule adjudication.
3. The Political Culture Approach
Political culture is the pattern of attitudes, beliefs and values towards politics held by members of a political system. Almond first used the term in this sense in “Comparative Political Systems” (Journal of Politics, 1956).
Almond and Verba, The Civic Culture (1963)
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Full title | The Civic Culture: Political Attitudes and Democracy in Five Nations |
| Countries | USA, UK, West Germany, Italy, Mexico |
| Orientations | Cognitive (knowledge), affective (feelings), evaluative (judgements) |
| Objects | The system as a whole; input objects (parties, groups, elections); output objects (bureaucracy, courts); the self as participant |
Three pure types of political culture
| Type | Orientation | Example given |
|---|---|---|
| Parochial | Little or no awareness of the national political system; politics not separated from religion or kinship | Traditional, tribal or village societies |
| Subject | Aware of the system and its outputs, but passive towards inputs; sees self as subject, not participant | Authoritarian or colonial settings |
| Participant | Oriented to the system, inputs, outputs and an active self | Modern democracies |
The civic culture is a mixed culture: participant orientations balanced by subject and parochial ones, so that citizens are active enough to hold government accountable but deferential enough to let it govern. Almond and Verba found it closest in Britain and the United States; Italy was described as alienated, Mexico as aspirational, and West Germany as detached and subject-oriented.
Later political culture research
| Author | Work (year) | Idea |
|---|---|---|
| Edward Banfield | The Moral Basis of a Backward Society (1958) | “Amoral familism” in a southern Italian village: maximise the short-run interest of the nuclear family, assume others will do the same |
| Lucian Pye and Sidney Verba (eds.) | Political Culture and Political Development (1965) | Political culture in ten countries; culture and development |
| Almond and Verba (eds.) | The Civic Culture Revisited (1980) | The authors’ and critics’ reassessment |
| Ronald Inglehart | The Silent Revolution (1977) | Shift from materialist to post-materialist values (self-expression, environment, quality of life) in generations raised in security |
| Robert Putnam | Making Democracy Work: Civic Traditions in Modern Italy (1993) | Italy’s regional governments (created 1970) performed better in the north because of civic community and social capital: networks, norms of reciprocity and trust |
| Robert Putnam | Bowling Alone (2000) | Decline of social capital in the United States |
Criticisms
- Ethnocentrism: the Anglo-American model is treated as the ideal.
- Causality: does culture produce stable democracy, or does long experience of stable democracy produce civic attitudes? (The “chicken and egg” objection.)
- Static and homogeneous: a nation is given one culture, ignoring class, gender, region and subcultures.
- Methodological individualism: a national culture is inferred by adding up individual survey answers.
- Conservative bias: deference and passivity are praised as stabilising; radical critics (Carole Pateman among them) argued that low participation reflects inequality, not civic virtue.
4. The Political Economy Approach
The political economy approach explains politics through the production and distribution of wealth: classes, markets, property and the relationship between state and economy. It has several streams.
| Stream | Core claim | Key works |
|---|---|---|
| Classical political economy | Markets as self-regulating; the state’s limited role | Adam Smith, The Wealth of Nations (1776); David Ricardo (1817) |
| Marxist political economy | The economic base (forces and relations of production) shapes the political and ideological superstructure; the state reflects class power | Marx, Preface to A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy (1859); Capital I (1867) |
| Historical-structural comparative analysis | Class coalitions in the transition to modern agriculture decide whether a country becomes democratic, fascist or communist | Barrington Moore Jr., Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy (1966) |
| Rational choice / public choice | Political actors are self-interested utility maximisers; apply economic models to voting, parties, bureaucracy | Anthony Downs, An Economic Theory of Democracy (1957); Buchanan and Tullock, The Calculus of Consent (1962); Mancur Olson, The Logic of Collective Action (1965) |
| Dependency and world-systems | Underdevelopment produced by a country’s place in the world capitalist economy | Frank, Cardoso and Faletto, Wallerstein (see Development and Democratisation) |
| Comparative capitalisms | Capitalist economies are organised differently and these differences are stable | Esping-Andersen, The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism (1990); Hall and Soskice, Varieties of Capitalism (2001): liberal market economies (US, UK) vs coordinated market economies (Germany, Japan) |
Barrington Moore’s three routes to the modern world
| Route | Decisive class configuration | Outcome | Cases |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bourgeois revolution | Strong commercial bourgeoisie; landed class commercialised or broken | Parliamentary democracy | England, France, United States |
| Revolution from above | Weak bourgeoisie allied with a landed upper class and the state | Fascism | Germany, Japan |
| Peasant revolution | Weak bourgeoisie; large, cohesive peasantry | Communism | Russia, China |
His slogan: “No bourgeois, no democracy.” India appears as a separate case: a democracy that arrived without the usual bourgeois revolution, with a heavy price paid in stagnant agriculture.
5. New Institutionalism
James March and Johan Olsen announced “The New Institutionalism: Organizational Factors in Political Life” in the American Political Science Review (1984) and developed it in Rediscovering Institutions (1989). Their argument: behaviouralism and rational choice had reduced politics to the sum of individual choices; in fact institutions shape preferences, identities and behaviour.
How the new differs from the old
| Old institutionalism | New institutionalism |
|---|---|
| Formal, legal institutions | Formal and informal rules, norms, routines |
| Description of structures | Explanation, with explicit theory |
| Institutions as given | Institutions as independent variables that shape actors, and as products of history and choice |
| Holistic national studies | Comparison of specific institutions (welfare regimes, central banks, electoral rules) |
| Normative, often implicit | Analytical; values made explicit |
March and Olsen’s two logics
- Logic of consequences: actors calculate the costs and benefits of options (rational choice).
- Logic of appropriateness: actors follow the rules and roles that fit their identity in a situation (“what does a person like me do here?”). March and Olsen stress this one.
The three new institutionalisms (Hall and Taylor, 1996)
Peter Hall and Rosemary Taylor, “Political Science and the Three New Institutionalisms” (Political Studies, 1996):
| Variant | What institutions are | Key mechanisms | Key names |
|---|---|---|---|
| Historical institutionalism | Formal and informal procedures embedded in the polity, formed over time | Path dependence, critical junctures, increasing returns, unequal power | Steinmo, Thelen and Longstreth, Structuring Politics (1992); Theda Skocpol; Paul Pierson (“Increasing Returns, Path Dependence, and the Study of Politics”, 2000); Collier and Collier, Shaping the Political Arena (1991) |
| Rational choice institutionalism | Rules of the game that structure strategic choices and lower transaction costs | Strategic calculation, equilibrium, principal–agent, veto players | Douglass North, Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance (1990); Kenneth Shepsle (structure-induced equilibrium); George Tsebelis, Veto Players (2002) |
| Sociological institutionalism | Cultural templates, symbols, scripts and norms that give meaning | Legitimacy, isomorphism, logic of appropriateness | March and Olsen; DiMaggio and Powell, “The Iron Cage Revisited” (1983): coercive, mimetic and normative isomorphism |
A fourth variant, discursive (constructivist) institutionalism, is associated with Vivien Schmidt (2008): ideas and discourse explain institutional change.
Bringing the State Back In: Peter Evans, Dietrich Rueschemeyer and Theda Skocpol (eds., 1985) argued that the state is an actor with its own interests and capacities, not just an arena for groups (pluralism) or an instrument of a class (Marxism). This “statist” turn fed historical institutionalism.
6. Comparative Methods
Comparison is the political scientist’s substitute for the laboratory: we cannot run experiments on whole countries, so we compare them.
Why compare?
- Contextual description — knowing other systems makes one’s own visible.
- Classification — Aristotle’s six forms; democratic and non-democratic regimes.
- Hypothesis testing — does PR produce multiparty systems?
- Prediction — what will follow a given reform?
Lijphart’s place for the comparative method
Arend Lijphart, “Comparative Politics and the Comparative Method” (APSR, 1971), named four basic methods: experimental, statistical, comparative and case study. The comparative method is used when there are many variables and a small number of cases (“many variables, small N”). Remedies: increase the number of cases, reduce the property-space (combine variables), focus on comparable cases, and reduce the number of variables.
He also classified case studies into six types: atheoretical, interpretative, hypothesis-generating, theory-confirming, theory-infirming and deviant.
J.S. Mill’s methods
John Stuart Mill, A System of Logic (1843), set out five methods of experimental inquiry. Two are the basis of comparative design:
| Method | Logic | Comparative use |
|---|---|---|
| Method of agreement | Cases that differ in most respects but share the outcome; the one factor they also share is the likely cause | Basis of the most different systems design |
| Method of difference | Cases alike in most respects but differing in the outcome; the one factor in which they differ is the likely cause | Basis of the most similar systems design |
| Joint method of agreement and difference | Combines the two | — |
| Method of residues | Subtract known causes; the remainder explains the rest | — |
| Method of concomitant variations | When two phenomena vary together, they are causally connected | Basis of correlation and statistical comparison |
Mill himself doubted that these methods could be applied strictly to society, because social causes are many and interact.
Most similar vs most different systems designs
Adam Przeworski and Henry Teune, The Logic of Comparative Social Inquiry (1970):
| Design | Case selection | Logic | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Most similar systems design (MSSD) | Countries similar in as many background features as possible but differing in the outcome | Mill’s method of difference: similarities are “controlled”; look for the key difference | Scandinavian countries; Indian states (Kerala vs Uttar Pradesh on social development) |
| Most different systems design (MDSD) | Countries as different as possible that share the outcome (or a relationship) | Mill’s method of agreement: look for the common factor that survives across very different systems | Revolutions in France, Russia and China (Skocpol, 1979) |
Sartori’s ladder of abstraction
Giovanni Sartori, “Concept Misformation in Comparative Politics” (APSR, 1970), warned against conceptual stretching: taking a concept built for one context (“party”, “pluralism”) and applying it everywhere until it means nothing.
- Every concept has an intension (connotation: its defining attributes) and an extension (denotation: the cases it covers).
- Moving up the ladder of abstraction, intension falls and extension rises (fewer attributes, more cases).
- To travel to more cases without stretching, climb the ladder by dropping attributes, rather than keeping the attributes and pretending they fit.
Problems of comparison
| Problem | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Small N / many variables | Too few countries for the number of possible causes (Lijphart) |
| Selection bias | Choosing cases on the dependent variable (only successful revolutions, only democracies); Barbara Geddes, “How the Cases You Choose Affect the Answers You Get” (1990) |
| Galton’s problem | Cases may not be independent: a similarity may come from diffusion (borrowing) rather than a common cause; named after Francis Galton |
| Conceptual stretching | Sartori (1970) |
| Ethnocentrism | Western categories imposed on non-Western societies |
| Equivalence | Does the same survey question, or institution, mean the same thing in two cultures? |
Qualitative and quantitative tools
- Charles Ragin, The Comparative Method (1987): qualitative comparative analysis (QCA) using Boolean algebra to find combinations of conditions that produce an outcome (conjunctural causation).
- King, Keohane and Verba, Designing Social Inquiry (1994): one logic of inference for qualitative and quantitative research.
- Process tracing: following the causal chain within a case.
- Large-N statistical comparison: cross-national datasets (Freedom House, Polity, V-Dem, World Values Survey).
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Almond and Verba, The Civic Culture (1963) — five nations | vs | Almond and Coleman, The Politics of the Developing Areas (1960) — functional categories |
| Old institutionalism — formal, legal, descriptive | vs | New institutionalism — rules and norms, explanatory (March and Olsen 1984) |
| Method of difference — MSSD | vs | Method of agreement — MDSD |
| Sartori 1970 — conceptual stretching | vs | Lijphart 1971 — comparative method, small N, case-study types |
| Putnam — social capital, Italian regions (1993) | vs | Banfield — amoral familism, one southern Italian village (1958) |
| Hall and Taylor — three institutionalisms (1996) | vs | Hall and Soskice — varieties of capitalism (2001) |
| Logic of appropriateness — sociological | vs | Logic of consequences — rational choice |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Which five countries did Almond and Verba survey in The Civic Culture?
- Who wrote “The New Institutionalism: Organizational Factors in Political Life” (1984)?
- Which of Mill’s methods underlies the most different systems design?
Answers
- USA, UK, West Germany, Italy and Mexico.
- James March and Johan Olsen (APSR, 1984).
- The method of agreement: very different cases share an outcome, so look for the factor they have in common.
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) In Almond and Verba’s scheme, a political culture in which citizens are aware of the political system and its outputs but have little orientation towards inputs or towards themselves as active participants is called:
- (a) Parochial
- (b) Subject
- (c) Participant
- (d) Civic
Answer and explanation
(b) Subject. Parochial citizens have little awareness of the national system at all; participant citizens are oriented to inputs, outputs and the self; the civic culture is the mixture.
Q2. (Practice) Consider the following statements about Roy Macridis’s critique of the traditional study of comparative government (1955):
- It was largely confined to Western countries.
- It was mainly descriptive and formal-legal.
- It relied heavily on cross-national survey research.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 only
- (b) 1 and 2 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 1 and 2 only. Macridis called traditional work parochial, descriptive, non-comparative, static and monographic. Cross-national surveys came with the behavioural approach that replaced it (statement 3 is false).
Q3. (Practice) “Institutions are the rules of the game in a society.” This definition is associated with:
- (a) Douglass North
- (b) Johan Olsen
- (c) Theda Skocpol
- (d) Gabriel Almond
Answer and explanation
(a) Douglass North, Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance (1990), the key text of rational choice (economic) institutionalism.
Q4. (Practice) In Barrington Moore’s Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy (1966), the route of “revolution from above” led to:
- (a) Parliamentary democracy in England
- (b) Communism in China
- (c) Fascism in Germany and Japan
- (d) Military rule in Latin America
Answer and explanation
(c). A weak bourgeoisie allied with landed elites and the state produced fascism. Bourgeois revolution led to democracy and peasant revolution to communism. Latin America was not one of his main cases.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Sartori warned comparativists against conceptual stretching. Reason (R): Applying a concept to more cases without reducing its defining attributes distorts the concept.
Answer and explanation
(a). That is exactly the argument of “Concept Misformation in Comparative Politics” (1970): to cover more cases, climb the ladder of abstraction by dropping attributes.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): The political culture approach has been criticised for ethnocentrism. Reason (R): The Civic Culture found the closest approximation to the civic culture in Mexico and Italy.
Answer and explanation
(c). A is true: the Anglo-American pattern was treated as the model. R is false: the civic culture was found closest in Britain and the United States.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (Variant of new institutionalism) with List II (Associated idea).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Historical institutionalism | I. Isomorphism and cultural scripts |
| B. Rational choice institutionalism | II. Path dependence and critical junctures |
| C. Sociological institutionalism | III. Ideas and discourse explain change |
| D. Discursive institutionalism | IV. Rules of the game and strategic calculation |
- (a) A-II, B-IV, C-I, D-III
- (b) A-IV, B-II, C-I, D-III
- (c) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
- (d) A-III, B-IV, C-I, D-II
Answer and explanation
(a) A-II, B-IV, C-I, D-III. Historical → path dependence; rational choice → North’s rules of the game; sociological → DiMaggio and Powell’s isomorphism; discursive → Vivien Schmidt.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following works in chronological order of publication:
- Almond and Verba, The Civic Culture
- Macridis, The Study of Comparative Government
- Putnam, Making Democracy Work
- March and Olsen, “The New Institutionalism”
- (a) 2, 1, 4, 3
- (b) 1, 2, 4, 3
- (c) 2, 1, 3, 4
- (d) 2, 4, 1, 3
Answer and explanation
(a). Macridis 1955 → Almond and Verba 1963 → March and Olsen 1984 → Putnam 1993.
Quick Revision Table
| Thinker | Work | Year | Key idea |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bryce | Modern Democracies | 1921 | Traditional institutional comparison |
| Finer (Herman) | The Theory and Practice of Modern Government | 1932 | Formal-legal institutions |
| Easton | The Political System | 1953 | Systems, authoritative allocation of values |
| Macridis | The Study of Comparative Government | 1955 | Five charges against the traditional approach |
| Almond | “Comparative Political Systems” | 1956 | Term “political culture” |
| Banfield | The Moral Basis of a Backward Society | 1958 | Amoral familism |
| Almond and Coleman | The Politics of the Developing Areas | 1960 | Input and output functions |
| Almond and Verba | The Civic Culture | 1963 | Parochial, subject, participant; civic culture |
| Barrington Moore | Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy | 1966 | Three routes; “no bourgeois, no democracy” |
| Sartori | “Concept Misformation in Comparative Politics” | 1970 | Conceptual stretching; ladder of abstraction |
| Przeworski and Teune | The Logic of Comparative Social Inquiry | 1970 | MSSD and MDSD |
| Lijphart | “Comparative Politics and the Comparative Method” | 1971 | Small N; six types of case study |
| Inglehart | The Silent Revolution | 1977 | Post-materialism |
| DiMaggio and Powell | “The Iron Cage Revisited” | 1983 | Coercive, mimetic, normative isomorphism |
| March and Olsen | “The New Institutionalism” | 1984 | Logic of appropriateness |
| Evans, Rueschemeyer, Skocpol | Bringing the State Back In | 1985 | State as actor |
| Ragin | The Comparative Method | 1987 | QCA, Boolean |
| North | Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance | 1990 | Rules of the game |
| Putnam | Making Democracy Work | 1993 | Social capital |
| Hall and Taylor | “Political Science and the Three New Institutionalisms” | 1996 | Historical, rational choice, sociological |
| Hall and Soskice | Varieties of Capitalism | 2001 | LMEs vs CMEs |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Colonialism, Decolonisation and Nationalism — the historical context that made comparative politics global
- State Theory and Structures of Power — the “state back in” debate in full
- Comparative Political Analysis — Quick Revision
- Paper 1 link: Methods and Steps of Research — case study, sampling and hypothesis testing in general form