Teaching Support Systems and Evaluation Systems
UGC NET Paper 1: traditional, modern and ICT-based teaching aids, Dale's cone, types of evaluation, test qualities, CBCS grading and computer-based testing.
- 18 min
On this page · 11 sections
Prerequisites
- Teaching: Concept, Objectives, Levels and Characteristics: Bloom’s objectives are what evaluation measures.
- Factors Affecting Teaching and Methods: support material and instructional facilities are two of the six factors; SWAYAM and MOOCs are covered there.
The Hook: Chalk, Slides, and a Marks Sheet
How UGC NET asks it: classify aids (projected or non-projected; traditional or ICT), Dale’s cone order, formative vs summative vs diagnostic, norm- vs criterion-referenced, validity vs reliability, compute an SGPA, identify the features of CBCS and of computer-based testing, and pick “innovations in evaluation” from a list.
Part A: Teaching Support Systems
A teaching support system is everything that helps a teacher communicate and a learner learn beyond the teacher’s own voice: aids, materials, equipment and platforms. Good aids make learning concrete, interesting and lasting, save time, reach several senses, and support learners with different needs.
Three generations of support
| Type | Examples | Strength | Limitation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Traditional | Chalkboard/blackboard, textbooks, charts, maps, globes, models, specimens, flannel board, bulletin board, flash cards, real objects | Cheap, simple, always available, no power needed | Static, limited to one room, slow to update |
| Modern (electronic, pre-internet) | Overhead projector (OHP), slide and film-strip projectors, epidiascope, radio, tape recorder, television, film, video player, language laboratory | Motion and sound; large audiences | Equipment cost, mostly one-way |
| ICT-based | Computer and multimedia projector, interactive whiteboard (smart board), internet, learning management systems (e.g. Moodle, Google Classroom), video conferencing, e-books, simulations and virtual labs, MOOCs, mobile apps, AR/VR, AI tools | Interactive, individualised, updatable, anytime-anywhere, two-way | Cost, connectivity, digital skills, digital divide, distraction |
Other standard classifications
| Basis | Categories | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Sense used | Audio | Radio, podcast, audio recording, language lab |
| Visual | Blackboard, chart, map, model, slide, OHP transparency | |
| Audio-visual | Television, film, video, multimedia presentation | |
| Projection | Projected | OHP, slide projector, film, LCD/multimedia projector, epidiascope |
| Non-projected | Blackboard, chart, model, map, globe, flannel board, specimen | |
| Educational technology approach | Hardware approach | Machines and equipment: projectors, computers, TV |
| Software approach | Learning principles and materials: programmed instruction, instructional design, lesson content | |
| Systems approach | Plans the whole instructional system (input, process, output, feedback) |
Edgar Dale’s Cone of Experience
Edgar Dale, in Audio-Visual Methods in Teaching (1946), arranged learning experiences in a cone from the most concrete at the base to the most abstract at the top.
graph BT
A["Direct, purposeful experiences (base: most concrete)"] --> B["Contrived experiences (models, mock-ups)"]
B --> C["Dramatised experiences"]
C --> D["Demonstrations"]
D --> E["Field trips, exhibits"]
E --> F["Television, motion pictures"]
F --> G["Recordings, radio, still pictures"]
G --> H["Visual symbols"]
H --> I["Verbal symbols (top: most abstract)"]The bands above are simplified: Dale’s editions (1946, 1954, 1969) differ slightly in how many bands they show and what they call them (field trips and exhibits are separate bands; television was added in the 1954 edition). The base, the top and the concrete-to-abstract order are the same in all of them.
- Base: direct, purposeful experience. Top: verbal symbols (words).
- Moving up the cone, experiences become more abstract; moving down, more concrete. The cone is a visual model, not a ranking of value: abstract verbal teaching is efficient once learners have enough concrete experience to understand the words.
ICT-based support in Indian higher education
| Resource | What it offers |
|---|---|
| SWAYAM, SWAYAM Prabha, NPTEL, e-PG Pathshala | Courses and e-content (see Methods: offline vs online) |
| Shodhganga (INFLIBNET) | Repository of Indian PhD theses; deposit was mandated by UGC’s 2009 PhD regulations |
| National Digital Library of India | Single-window search of digital resources (IIT Kharagpur) |
| Virtual Labs, Spoken Tutorial | Simulated experiments; tutorials on open-source software |
| Open Educational Resources (OER) | Teaching material free to use, adapt and share; the term was adopted at a UNESCO forum in 2002; often licensed under Creative Commons |
| Learning Management System (LMS) | Courses, assignments, quizzes, gradebook, forums in one place |
Choosing an aid: match the aid to the objective, learners and class size; prepare and test it in advance; keep it simple and visible; use it at the right moment and remove it after; make it accessible (captions, readable fonts, alt text). An aid supports teaching; it never replaces the teacher’s planning.
Part B: Evaluation Systems
Measurement, assessment, evaluation
| Term | Meaning | Nature |
|---|---|---|
| Measurement | Assigning numbers to a trait (“scored 42 out of 50”) | Quantitative, limited |
| Assessment | Collecting and interpreting evidence about learning, often to improve it | Process-focused, ongoing |
| Evaluation | Judging the worth of learning against objectives, using measurement and other evidence | Comprehensive, includes value judgement |
A widely used formulation (from N.E. Gronlund’s work on measurement and evaluation): Evaluation = quantitative description (measurement) and/or qualitative description (non-measurement) + value judgement.
Elements of evaluation
The evaluation triangle, associated with Bloom, links three elements: educational objectives → learning experiences → evaluation (change in behaviour). Each points to the other two: objectives decide experiences and evaluation; evaluation shows whether objectives were met and how experiences should change.
A complete evaluation system also needs: clear objectives, valid and reliable tools, criteria and standards, data collection, interpretation and judgement, and feedback to learners and teachers.
Types of evaluation
By function and timing:
| Type | When | Purpose | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Placement | Before instruction | Find entry level; place the learner | Entrance or bridge-course test |
| Formative | During instruction | Improve learning and teaching; feedback | Weekly quizzes, assignments, class questions |
| Diagnostic | During, when difficulties persist | Identify causes of learning difficulty for remedial teaching | Error analysis test |
| Summative | At the end | Certify, grade, judge overall achievement | End-semester exam |
The terms formative and summative were introduced by Michael Scriven (1967) for curriculum evaluation; Bloom, Hastings and Madaus (1971) applied them to student learning.
By reference point:
| Type | Compares a learner with | Use |
|---|---|---|
| Norm-referenced | Other learners (rank, percentile) | Selection, competitive exams; UGC NET reports a percentile score alongside marks |
| Criterion-referenced | A fixed standard of mastery | Mastery learning, licensing, pass/fail on objectives |
| Ipsative | The learner’s own earlier performance | Tracking personal progress |
The term criterion-referenced measurement is credited to Robert Glaser (1963).
Other pairs: internal vs external; continuous vs terminal; oral, written and practical; self-assessment and peer assessment; assessment of learning (summative), for learning (formative) and as learning (learners monitoring themselves).
Continuous and Comprehensive Evaluation (CCE): continuous = regular formative plus summative; comprehensive = scholastic plus co-scholastic areas. The Right to Education Act, 2009 (Section 29) required CCE in elementary education.
Qualities of a good evaluation tool
| Quality | Meaning | Kinds / notes |
|---|---|---|
| Validity | Measures what it claims to measure | Content, construct, criterion-related (concurrent and predictive), face validity |
| Reliability | Consistency of scores | Test–retest, parallel/equivalent forms, split-half (corrected by Spearman–Brown), internal consistency (Kuder–Richardson, Cronbach’s alpha) |
| Objectivity | Score does not depend on who marks it | Objective items are highest; essays lowest |
| Usability (practicability) | Easy to administer, score and interpret; economical | |
| Discrimination | Separates high and low achievers | Item analysis |
| Comprehensiveness / adequacy | Covers the content and objectives sufficiently | Blueprint (table of specifications) |
Item analysis
For each objective item, compare the upper and lower groups (commonly the top and bottom 27% of scorers).
- Difficulty index: \( P = \frac{R_U + R_L}{N} \), where \( R_U \) and \( R_L \) are correct answers in the upper and lower groups and \( N \) is the total number in both groups. A higher P means an easier item.
- Discrimination index: \( D = \frac{R_U - R_L}{N/2} \). It ranges from \(-1\) to \(+1\); a negative D means weaker students did better on the item, so the item is faulty.
Worked example: 40 students in the two groups (20 each); 16 in the upper and 6 in the lower group answer correctly. \( P = \frac{16 + 6}{40} = 0.55 \) (moderate difficulty) and \( D = \frac{16 - 6}{20} = 0.5 \) (discriminates well).
Tools and techniques of evaluation
| Tool | Best for |
|---|---|
| Essay-type test | Organisation, expression, higher-order thinking; low objectivity, limited coverage |
| Short-answer test | Wider coverage than essays, moderate objectivity |
| Objective test (MCQ, true/false, matching, completion) | Wide coverage, high objectivity and reliability; guessing possible |
| Rating scale | Degree of a trait (e.g. 1–5) |
| Checklist | Presence or absence of a behaviour (yes/no) |
| Anecdotal record | Brief factual notes of significant incidents |
| Cumulative record | A learner’s progress over years |
| Rubric | Criteria with performance levels for projects, presentations |
| Portfolio | Collection of a learner’s work showing growth |
| Observation, interview, questionnaire | Behaviour, attitudes, opinions |
| Sociometry (J.L. Moreno) | Social relationships within a group (sociogram) |
Evaluation in the Choice Based Credit System (CBCS)
UGC issued guidelines for CBCS in 2015, for implementation from the 2015–16 session. The aim: student choice, mobility, uniform grading and credit transfer.
| Feature | Detail |
|---|---|
| Semester system | Learning and evaluation by semester |
| Credit | 1 credit = 1 hour of lecture or tutorial per week, or 2 hours of practical/field work per week, in a semester |
| Course types | Core; Elective (Discipline Specific Elective, Generic Elective from another discipline, Project/Dissertation); Ability Enhancement (Compulsory: Environmental Science and English/MIL communication; Skill Enhancement Courses) |
| Evaluation | Continuous internal assessment plus end-semester examination |
| Grading | Letter grades on a 10-point scale, reported as SGPA and CGPA |
| Mobility | Credits earned can be transferred; later reinforced by the Academic Bank of Credits (UGC regulations, 2021) and SWAYAM credit transfer |
UGC’s 10-point grading scale (CBCS guidelines):
| Letter grade | Meaning | Grade point |
|---|---|---|
| O | Outstanding | 10 |
| A+ | Excellent | 9 |
| A | Very Good | 8 |
| B+ | Good | 7 |
| B | Above Average | 6 |
| C | Average | 5 |
| P | Pass | 4 |
| F | Fail | 0 |
| Ab | Absent | 0 |
Computing SGPA and CGPA:
- SGPA \( = \frac{\sum (C_i \times G_i)}{\sum C_i} \), where \( C_i \) is the credits of the i-th course and \( G_i \) its grade point.
- CGPA \( = \frac{\sum (C_i \times S_i)}{\sum C_i} \), where \( S_i \) is the SGPA of the i-th semester and \( C_i \) the total credits of that semester.
Worked example (the SGPA in the hook): four courses with credits 4, 4, 3, 3 and grades A (8), B+ (7), O (10), B (6). \( \sum C_i G_i = 32 + 28 + 30 + 18 = 108 \); \( \sum C_i = 14 \); SGPA \( = \frac{108}{14} \approx 7.71 \).
Computer-based testing (CBT)
In a CBT, questions appear on a computer screen and the candidate answers on the computer. UGC NET itself is a CBT: per the December 2026 information bulletin, the exam is in Computer Based Test mode only, objective multiple-choice, answers by mouse click, and when a subject runs over several shifts, marks are normalised by the equi-percentile method.
| Feature | Benefit |
|---|---|
| Item banks | Many parallel questions; different sets for different shifts |
| Randomised order of questions and options | Reduces copying |
| Automated scoring | Fast, error-free results |
| Question palette, mark-for-review | Candidate can navigate and revise |
| Secure delivery | Encrypted papers, biometric checks, CCTV |
| Data for analysis | Item statistics, time spent per item |
Kinds: linear CBT (same fixed set, as in UGC NET) vs computer-adaptive testing (CAT), where the next question’s difficulty depends on the previous answers, based on item response theory. Also internet-based tests and remotely proctored online exams.
Limitations: needs infrastructure and power; unfamiliar for some candidates; technical glitches; mainly suits objective items; screen fatigue.
Innovations in evaluation
- Continuous internal assessment and CCE in place of a single final exam
- Grading (CGPA) in place of raw marks; credit transfer and the Academic Bank of Credits
- Open-book and take-home examinations, testing application rather than recall
- On-demand and online examinations; question banks
- Rubrics, portfolios and e-portfolios; project and practical work
- Self-assessment and peer assessment; 360-degree feedback
- Competency- and outcome-based assessment, aligned with learning outcomes
- Digital (on-screen) evaluation of scanned answer scripts
- AI-assisted proctoring, automated scoring and learning analytics
- Digital certificates stored in DigiLocker and the National Academic Depository
- Transparency: access to evaluated answer sheets; the Supreme Court held in CBSE v. Aditya Bandopadhyay (2011) that evaluated answer books are “information” under the RTI Act
- Student feedback on teaching and courses
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Formative: during, to improve | vs | Summative: at end, to certify |
| Diagnostic: finds causes of difficulty | vs | Formative: monitors progress |
| Norm-referenced: compared with others | vs | Criterion-referenced: compared with a standard (Glaser, 1963) |
| Validity: measures the right thing | vs | Reliability: measures consistently |
| Rating scale: degree of a trait | vs | Checklist: present or absent |
| Projected aids: OHP, LCD projector | vs | Non-projected aids: blackboard, chart, model |
| Hardware approach: machines | vs | Software approach: learning materials and principles |
| Dale’s cone base: direct experience | vs | Dale’s cone top: verbal symbols |
| SGPA: one semester | vs | CGPA: all semesters so far |
| Linear CBT: fixed set | vs | Computer-adaptive test: difficulty adapts |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET style. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
Practice 1.1. Who introduced the terms formative and summative evaluation, and in which year?
Practice 1.2. In the UGC 10-point grading scale, what grade point does “A+” carry?
Practice 1.3. What is at the base of Dale’s Cone of Experience?
Answers
- Michael Scriven, 1967 (for curriculum evaluation).
- 9 (Excellent).
- Direct, purposeful experiences, the most concrete.
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Practice 2.1. A student earns grades O, A, B+ and C in four courses of 4, 4, 2 and 2 credits respectively. Her SGPA is:
(1) 7.50 (2) 8.00 (3) 8.33 (4) 8.50
Answer and explanation
(2) 8.00. \( \sum C_i G_i = 4(10) + 4(8) + 2(7) + 2(5) = 40 + 32 + 14 + 10 = 96 \); \( \sum C_i = 4 + 4 + 2 + 2 = 12 \); SGPA \( = \frac{96}{12} = 8.00 \). Option (1), 7.50, is the plain average of the four grade points \( \frac{10 + 8 + 7 + 5}{4} \); SGPA must be weighted by credits.
Practice 2.2. Which of the following are non-projected teaching aids?
A. Flannel board B. Overhead projector C. Globe D. Epidiascope E. Chart
Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
(1) A, C and E only (2) A, B and C only (3) B, D and E only (4) C, D and E only
Answer and explanation
(1) A, C and E only. The overhead projector and epidiascope throw an image onto a screen, so they are projected aids.
Practice 2.3. A teacher finds that a test gives almost the same scores when repeated after two weeks, but the scores do not match students’ actual laboratory skill. The test is:
(1) Valid and reliable (2) Reliable but not valid (3) Valid but not reliable (4) Neither valid nor reliable
Answer and explanation
(2) Reliable but not valid. Consistent scores show test–retest reliability; failure to reflect the skill it should measure shows lack of validity.
Practice 2.4. Which of the following statements about computer-based testing are correct?
A. Question and option order can be randomised. B. In a computer-adaptive test, the difficulty of later items depends on earlier responses. C. CBT eliminates the need for valid and reliable test items. D. Automated scoring allows faster results.
(1) A, B and D only (2) A, C and D only (3) B and C only (4) A, B, C and D
Answer and explanation
(1) A, B and D only. CBT changes delivery and scoring, not the need for good items; validity and reliability still depend on item quality.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
Practice 3.1 (Assertion–reason). Given below are two statements:
Assertion (A): Formative evaluation is more useful than summative evaluation for improving teaching during a course. Reason (R): Formative evaluation is carried out at the end of a course to certify achievement.
(1) Both (A) and (R) are true and (R) is the correct explanation of (A) (2) Both (A) and (R) are true but (R) is NOT the correct explanation of (A) (3) (A) is true but (R) is false (4) (A) is false but (R) is true
Answer and explanation
(3). A is true: formative evaluation gives feedback while there is still time to act. R describes summative evaluation, so it is false.
Practice 3.2 (Match the following).
| List I (Concept) | List II (Associated with) |
|---|---|
| A. Cone of Experience | I. Robert Glaser |
| B. Criterion-referenced measurement | II. Edgar Dale |
| C. Formative and summative evaluation | III. J.L. Moreno |
| D. Sociometry | IV. Michael Scriven |
(1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III (2) A-II, B-IV, C-I, D-III (3) A-III, B-I, C-IV, D-II (4) A-II, B-III, C-IV, D-I
Answer and explanation
(1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III. Dale (1946); Glaser (1963); Scriven (1967); Moreno’s sociometry.
Practice 3.3 (Sequence). Arrange these experiences of Dale’s Cone from most concrete to most abstract:
A. Verbal symbols B. Demonstrations C. Direct, purposeful experiences D. Visual symbols E. Contrived experiences
(1) C, E, B, D, A (2) C, B, E, D, A (3) E, C, B, A, D (4) C, E, D, B, A
Answer and explanation
(1) C, E, B, D, A. Direct experience → contrived experience → demonstration → visual symbols → verbal symbols.
Practice 3.4 (Sequence). Arrange the types of evaluation in the order they are normally used in a course:
A. Summative B. Placement C. Formative D. Diagnostic
(1) B, C, D, A (2) C, B, D, A (3) B, D, C, A (4) D, B, C, A
Answer and explanation
(1) B, C, D, A. Placement before teaching; formative during; diagnostic when formative checks reveal persistent difficulties; summative at the end.
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Key fact |
|---|---|
| Traditional aids | Blackboard, textbook, chart, map, model, specimen |
| Modern aids | OHP, slide/film projector, radio, TV, film, language lab |
| ICT aids | Smart board, LMS, MOOCs, video conferencing, simulations, AR/VR, AI |
| Projected / non-projected | OHP, LCD, epidiascope / blackboard, chart, model, globe |
| Dale’s cone | 1946; base direct experience, top verbal symbols; percentages not Dale’s |
| ET approaches | Hardware, software, systems |
| Evaluation | Measurement + qualitative description + value judgement |
| Evaluation triangle | Objectives, learning experiences, evaluation |
| Placement / formative / diagnostic / summative | Before / during / persistent difficulty / end |
| Formative and summative | Scriven, 1967; Bloom, Hastings and Madaus, 1971 |
| Criterion-referenced | Glaser, 1963 |
| Validity types | Content, construct, criterion (concurrent, predictive), face |
| Reliability types | Test–retest, parallel forms, split-half, internal consistency |
| Item analysis | \( P = \frac{R_U + R_L}{N} \); \( D = \frac{R_U - R_L}{N/2} \); top and bottom 27% |
| CBCS | UGC 2015; 1 credit = 1 h lecture or 2 h practical per week; 10-point scale O to F |
| SGPA / CGPA | Credit-weighted mean of grade points / of SGPAs |
| CBT | UGC NET is CBT only; normalisation by equi-percentile method (Dec 2026 bulletin) |
| CAT | Adaptive; item response theory |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Quick Revision: the whole Teaching Aptitude unit on one page
- Teaching: Concept, Objectives, Levels and Characteristics: Bloom’s objectives, which evaluation measures
- Factors Affecting Teaching and Methods: SWAYAM, SWAYAM Prabha and MOOCs in detail
- Paper 1 overview: the other nine units