Thesis and Article Writing, Referencing and ICT
UGC NET Paper 1: thesis and article format, IMRAD, APA, MLA and Chicago referencing, ibid. and op. cit., ICT tools, Shodhganga and research metrics.
- 16 min
On this page · 13 sections
Prerequisites
- Methods and Steps of Research — writing the report is the last step of the research process.
- Research: Meaning, Types and Approaches — replicability is why methods and sources must be reported fully.
The Hook: The Chapter That Came Back
1. The Thesis
In Indian universities a thesis usually means the document submitted for a PhD, and a dissertation the shorter one for an MPhil or Master’s degree. Usage varies across countries (in the US the terms are often reversed), so the exam does not turn on the label but on the structure.
Structure of a thesis
| Part | Contents, in order |
|---|---|
| Preliminary pages | Title page → declaration by the candidate → certificate by the supervisor → acknowledgements → table of contents → list of tables → list of figures → list of abbreviations → abstract (position varies by university) |
| Main text | 1. Introduction (background, problem, objectives, hypotheses, significance, scope and delimitations) → 2. Review of literature → 3. Research methodology (design, population and sample, tools, procedure, analysis) → 4. Data analysis and results → 5. Discussion → 6. Summary, conclusions, recommendations and suggestions for further research |
| End matter | References or bibliography → appendices (questionnaires, raw tables, permissions) → index (if any) |
The research proposal (synopsis)
Before registration, a scholar submits a synopsis: title, introduction and rationale, brief review of literature, research gap, objectives, hypotheses or research questions, methodology, chapter plan, timeline and tentative references. It is a plan; the thesis is the report.
2. The Research Article
Journal articles in the sciences and most social sciences follow IMRAD (Introduction, Methods, Results and Discussion):
| Section | Answers |
|---|---|
| Introduction | Why was the study done? What gap does it fill? |
| Methods | How was it done? (enough detail to replicate) |
| Results | What was found? (facts, tables, figures, without interpretation) |
| Discussion | What do the findings mean, how do they relate to earlier work, and what are the limits? |
Around IMRAD sit the title, abstract (a single-paragraph summary, usually with a word limit set by the journal), keywords, conclusion, acknowledgements, conflict-of-interest and funding statements, and references.
Types of articles: original research article, review article (synthesises earlier studies), short communication, case report or case study, book review, and letter to the editor.
Peer review
| Type | Who knows whom |
|---|---|
| Single-blind | Reviewers know the author; the author does not know the reviewers |
| Double-blind | Neither side knows the other |
| Open | Identities are disclosed, and reviews are sometimes published |
A preprint is a version shared publicly before peer review (for example on arXiv). A postprint is the accepted, peer-reviewed version.
Seminar, symposium, workshop, conference
These ways of communicating research were named in the earlier version of the Paper 1 syllabus and still appear in options.
| Format | Feature |
|---|---|
| Seminar | A small group discusses a paper presented by one person; emphasis on discussion |
| Symposium | Several experts present different aspects of one topic, followed by discussion |
| Workshop | Hands-on, skill-oriented sessions where participants practise |
| Conference | A large formal gathering with many papers in parallel sessions, often with published proceedings |
| Panel discussion | A small group of experts discuss a topic before an audience under a moderator |
3. Referencing: Why and How
Referencing acknowledges other people’s work (and so avoids plagiarism), lets readers verify claims, and shows the scholarly basis of the study. Every system has two parts: a short in-text citation and a full entry in a list at the end.
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| References | Only the works actually cited in the text (APA uses this title) |
| Bibliography | All works consulted, cited or not (traditional in Chicago’s notes-bibliography system) |
| Works Cited | MLA’s title for the list of cited works |
| Footnote / endnote | A note at the bottom of the page / at the end of the chapter or work |
| Annotated bibliography | Each entry followed by a short summary or evaluation |
APA style
Published by the American Psychological Association; the current edition is the 7th (2019). Used in psychology, education and most social sciences. It is an author–date system.
- In-text: (Sharma, 2020) or (Sharma, 2020, p. 45); narrative form Sharma (2020).
- Two authors: (Sharma & Rao, 2021). Three or more: (Sharma et al., 2021) from the first citation.
- Reference list: titled References, alphabetical by first author’s surname, hanging indent. Article and book titles in sentence case; the 7th edition drops the publisher’s location and gives DOIs as URLs.
MLA style
Published by the Modern Language Association; the current edition is the 9th (2021). Used in literature, languages and the humanities. It is an author–page system.
- In-text: (Sharma 45), with no comma and no year.
- List: titled Works Cited, alphabetical, built from MLA’s core elements: author, title of source, title of container, other contributors, version, number, publisher, publication date, location.
- Titles in title case; the author’s full first name is given.
Chicago style
The Chicago Manual of Style is published by the University of Chicago Press; the current edition is the 18th (2024). It offers two systems:
- Notes and bibliography — footnotes or endnotes plus a bibliography; favoured in history and the humanities.
- Author–date — (Sharma 2020, 45) in the text plus a reference list; used in the sciences and social sciences.
One source, three styles
The source below is fictitious, made up only to show the patterns.
| Style | In-text | List entry (book) |
|---|---|---|
| APA 7 | (Sharma, 2020, p. 45) | Sharma, A. (2020). Learning in Indian colleges. Example Press. |
| MLA 9 | (Sharma 45) | Sharma, Anita. Learning in Indian Colleges. Example Press, 2020. |
| Chicago (notes) | Footnote: 1. Anita Sharma, Learning in Indian Colleges (New Delhi: Example Press, 2020), 45. | Sharma, Anita. Learning in Indian Colleges. New Delhi: Example Press, 2020. |
| Chicago (author–date) | (Sharma 2020, 45) | Sharma, Anita. 2020. Learning in Indian Colleges. New Delhi: Example Press. |
The Chicago entries show the place of publication (New Delhi) in the traditional form; the 18th edition no longer requires it, so “Example Press, 2020” alone is also acceptable.
And a fictitious journal article in APA and MLA:
- APA: Sharma, A., & Rao, K. (2021). Assessment reform in undergraduate colleges. Journal of Higher Education Studies, 12(3), 45–60. https://doi.org/10.0000/example
- MLA: Sharma, Anita, and Kiran Rao. “Assessment Reform in Undergraduate Colleges.” Journal of Higher Education Studies, vol. 12, no. 3, 2021, pp. 45–60.
Other styles
| Style | System | Field |
|---|---|---|
| Harvard | Author–date; no single official manual, many institutional versions | Widely used in the UK and Australia |
| Vancouver | Numbered in order of first citation | Medicine and biomedical sciences |
| IEEE | Numbered in square brackets, in order of first citation | Engineering, computer science |
Latin abbreviations in notes
| Abbreviation | Latin | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| ibid. | ibidem | In the same place: the same source as the immediately preceding note |
| op. cit. | opere citato | In the work cited: a work already cited earlier, but not in the preceding note |
| loc. cit. | loco citato | In the place cited: the same work and the same page cited earlier |
| et al. | et alii | And others |
| cf. | confer | Compare |
| viz. | videlicet | Namely |
| passim | Here and there throughout the work | |
| sic | Thus: the error is in the original quotation | |
| i.e. / e.g. | id est / exempli gratia | That is / for example |
4. Application of ICT in Research
Information and communication technology now touches every step of the research process.
| Step of research | ICT tools |
|---|---|
| Literature search | Google Scholar, Scopus (Elsevier), Web of Science (Clarivate), JSTOR, ERIC (education), PubMed (biomedicine), Shodhganga |
| Reference management | Zotero (free, open source), Mendeley, EndNote; they store sources and format citations in any style |
| Data collection | Online forms and survey platforms (Google Forms, SurveyMonkey), mobile data-collection apps, sensors |
| Quantitative analysis | SPSS, R, Stata, SAS, Python, spreadsheets such as MS Excel |
| Qualitative analysis | NVivo, ATLAS.ti, MAXQDA (CAQDAS: computer-assisted qualitative data analysis software) |
| Writing | Word processors, LaTeX and Overleaf, grammar tools |
| Similarity checking | Turnitin, iThenticate, DrillBit |
| Dissemination | Online journals, institutional repositories, preprint servers (arXiv), academic profiles, conferences online |
Indian research infrastructure
| Platform | What it is |
|---|---|
| INFLIBNET Centre | Information and Library Network Centre, Gandhinagar; an autonomous Inter-University Centre of the UGC that runs most of the services below |
| Shodhganga | INFLIBNET’s open repository of Indian PhD theses (electronic theses and dissertations) |
| Shodhgangotri | INFLIBNET’s repository of synopses / research proposals submitted for PhD registration |
| e-ShodhSindhu | Consortium that gives higher education institutions access to e-journals and databases |
| Shodh Shuddhi | INFLIBNET’s programme giving universities access to plagiarism-detection software |
| Vidwan | Database of experts and their profiles |
| IRINS | Indian Research Information Network System: institutional research profiles |
| National Digital Library of India (NDLI) | Single-window digital library, developed at IIT Kharagpur under the Ministry of Education |
| e-PG Pathshala | e-content for postgraduate courses across subjects |
Identifiers
| Identifier | Identifies | Note |
|---|---|---|
| DOI | A digital object, usually an article; a persistent link | Managed through the International DOI Foundation |
| ORCID | A researcher | A 16-character ID that stays with a person across institutions |
| ISSN | A serial (journal, magazine) | 8 digits |
| ISBN | A book | 13 digits since 2007 (10 earlier) |
Research metrics
Journal Impact Factor (JIF), associated with Eugene Garfield and now published by Clarivate in the Journal Citation Reports, is a two-year ratio for a journal:
\( \text{JIF}_{2025} = \dfrac{\text{citations in 2025 to items published in 2023 and 2024}}{\text{citable items published in 2023 and 2024}} \)
For example, if a journal published 80 citable items in 2023 and 2024 and these received 200 citations in 2025, its 2025 impact factor is \( 200 \div 80 = 2.5 \).
| Metric | Measures | Definition |
|---|---|---|
| Impact factor | A journal | Average citations per recent article over two years |
| h-index | A researcher | The largest h such that h papers have at least h citations each (proposed by physicist Jorge Hirsch, 2005) |
| i10-index | A researcher | Number of publications with at least 10 citations (used by Google Scholar) |
| Altmetrics | Attention | Mentions in news, policy documents, social media and reference managers |
Worked h-index: a researcher’s six papers have 25, 12, 8, 5, 3 and 1 citations. Four papers have at least 4 citations (25, 12, 8, 5), but only four (not five) have at least 5, so \( h = 4 \). Their i10-index is 2 (25 and 12).
Open access
| Route | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Gold | The article is free on the publisher’s site, often after an article processing charge (APC) |
| Green | The author self-archives a version in a repository |
| Diamond (platinum) | Free to read and free to publish; costs borne by an institution or society |
| Hybrid | A subscription journal that makes individual articles open for a fee |
Predatory journals charge fees but provide little or no genuine peer review or editing. Warning signs: guaranteed acceptance, very fast “review”, spam invitations, fake impact metrics and misleading indexing claims.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| References: cited works only | vs | Bibliography: all works consulted |
| APA: (Author, Year, p. x) | vs | MLA: (Author x) |
| Chicago notes-bibliography: footnotes | vs | Chicago author–date: (Author Year, page) |
| Vancouver / IEEE: numbered | vs | Harvard / APA: author–date |
| ISSN: journals, 8 digits | vs | ISBN: books, 13 digits |
| Impact factor: a journal | vs | h-index: a researcher |
| Shodhganga: theses | vs | Shodhgangotri: synopses |
| Single-blind: reviewer anonymous | vs | Double-blind: both anonymous |
| Symposium: experts on aspects of one topic | vs | Workshop: hands-on skill practice |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Expand IMRAD.
- How many digits does an ISSN have?
- Which referencing style titles its list “Works Cited”?
Answers
- Introduction, Methods, Results and Discussion.
- Eight.
- MLA.
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) Which of the following in-text citations follows MLA style?
- (a) (Sharma, 2020, p. 45)
- (b) (Sharma 45)
- (c) [4]
- (d) (Sharma 2020, 45)
Answer and explanation
(b). MLA uses author and page with no comma and no year. (a) is APA, (c) is IEEE or another numbered system, (d) is Chicago author–date.
Q2. (Practice) In a footnote, “ibid.” indicates:
- (a) A work cited much earlier, at a different page
- (b) The same source as in the immediately preceding note
- (c) A source to be compared with the present one
- (d) An error reproduced from the original
Answer and explanation
(b). Ibidem means “in the same place”. (a) is op. cit., (c) is cf., (d) is sic.
Q3. (Practice) Shodhganga is:
- (a) A plagiarism-detection software of the UGC
- (b) A repository of synopses of proposed PhD research
- (c) A repository of Indian PhD theses maintained by INFLIBNET
- (d) A consortium for subscription to e-journals
Answer and explanation
(c). (a) describes the software made available through Shodh Shuddhi, (b) is Shodhgangotri, (d) is e-ShodhSindhu.
Q4. (Practice) A researcher’s papers have received 30, 15, 9, 6, 6, 4 and 2 citations. What is her h-index?
- (a) 4
- (b) 5
- (c) 6
- (d) 7
Answer and explanation
(b) 5. Five papers have at least 5 citations each (30, 15, 9, 6, 6). Six papers do not have at least 6 each (the sixth has 4), so \( h = 5 \).
Q5. (Practice) Consider the following statements:
- A bibliography may include works consulted but not cited in the text.
- APA style requires the year of publication in in-text citations.
- Chicago style offers both a notes-bibliography system and an author–date system.
Which of the statements given above are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 2 and 3 only
- (c) 1 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(d) 1, 2 and 3. All three are standard features of the styles.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): In IEEE style, the reference list is arranged in the order in which sources are first cited in the text. Reason (R): IEEE is a numbered system in which each source receives a number according to its first citation.
Answer and explanation
(a). Because numbers are assigned in order of first citation, the list follows that order. R explains A.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): The impact factor of a journal measures the quality of each individual article published in it. Reason (R): The impact factor is calculated from citations received in one year by items the journal published in the two preceding years.
Answer and explanation
(d). A is false: the impact factor is a journal-level average and does not measure any single article. R correctly describes the calculation.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I with List II.
| List I (Software) | List II (Main use) |
|---|---|
| A. Zotero | I. Statistical analysis |
| B. SPSS | II. Similarity detection |
| C. NVivo | III. Reference management |
| D. Turnitin | IV. Qualitative data analysis |
- (1) A-III, B-I, C-IV, D-II
- (2) A-I, B-III, C-IV, D-II
- (3) A-III, B-IV, C-I, D-II
- (4) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
Answer and explanation
(1) A-III, B-I, C-IV, D-II.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following parts of a PhD thesis in the order in which they appear:
A. Review of literature
B. Title page
C. Appendices
D. Research methodology
E. Table of contents
(1) B, E, A, D, C
(2) B, A, E, D, C
(3) E, B, A, D, C
(4) B, E, D, A, C
Answer and explanation
(1) B, E, A, D, C. Title page and contents are preliminary pages; the literature review precedes the methodology chapter; appendices come at the end.
Quick Revision Table
| Fact | Detail |
|---|---|
| Thesis order | Preliminary pages → introduction → literature → methodology → results → discussion → conclusions → references → appendices |
| IMRAD | Introduction, Methods, Results and Discussion |
| Peer review | Single-blind, double-blind, open |
| APA | American Psychological Association; 7th ed. (2019); author–date; “References” |
| MLA | Modern Language Association; 9th ed. (2021); author–page; “Works Cited” |
| Chicago | University of Chicago Press; 18th ed. (2024); notes-bibliography or author–date |
| Vancouver / IEEE | Numbered: medicine / engineering |
| ibid. / op. cit. / loc. cit. | Preceding note / earlier work / earlier work, same page |
| INFLIBNET | Gandhinagar; inter-university centre of UGC |
| Shodhganga / Shodhgangotri / e-ShodhSindhu / Shodh Shuddhi | Theses / synopses / e-journals / plagiarism software |
| NDLI | IIT Kharagpur, Ministry of Education |
| ISSN / ISBN / ORCID / DOI | Journal, 8 digits / book, 13 digits / researcher / digital object |
| Impact factor | Journal; two-year window |
| h-index | Hirsch (2005); h papers with at least h citations |
| i10-index | Google Scholar; papers with 10+ citations |
| Open access | Gold, green, diamond, hybrid |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Research Ethics and Plagiarism — why referencing is an ethical duty, and the UGC 2018 penalties when it fails
- Methods and Steps of Research — the steps that the thesis reports
- Quick Revision
- ICT — Unit 8 of Paper 1, where ICT has its own questions