Fallacies, Deduction, Induction and Analogies
UGC NET Paper 1: deductive vs inductive reasoning, validity, soundness and strength, Mill's methods, formal and informal fallacies, and analogy questions.
- 18 min
On this page · 13 sections
Prerequisites
- Arguments, Argument Forms and Uses of Language — premises, conclusions and the formal fallacies of conditional arguments.
- Syllogism: Mood, Figure and Venn Diagrams — the syllogistic fallacies (undistributed middle, illicit process).
- Research: Meaning, Types and Approaches — inductive and deductive reasoning in research design.
The Hook: The Turkey and the Professor
How UGC NET asks it: classify an argument as deductive or inductive; say whether a valid argument can have a false conclusion; name an informal fallacy from a short passage; or complete an analogy (word, letter or number).
1. Deductive and Inductive Reasoning
The difference is in the claim
A deductive argument claims that its conclusion follows necessarily from its premises: if the premises are true, the conclusion cannot be false. An inductive argument claims only that its premises make the conclusion probable.
| Feature | Deductive | Inductive |
|---|---|---|
| Claim | Conclusion follows necessarily | Conclusion is probable |
| Typical direction | General → particular (but not always) | Particular → general (but not always) |
| Content of conclusion | Already contained in the premises; makes explicit | Goes beyond the premises (the “inductive leap”) |
| Effect of new premises | Cannot make a valid argument invalid | Can strengthen or weaken it |
| Evaluated as | Valid / invalid (yes or no, no degrees) | Strong / weak (a matter of degree) |
| With true premises | Sound (valid + all premises true) | Cogent (strong + all premises true) |
| Examples | Syllogism, modus ponens, mathematical proof, argument from definition | Generalisation, prediction, causal inference, analogy, statistical argument |
Validity, truth and soundness
Validity is about form, truth is about content. Premises and conclusions are true or false; arguments are valid or invalid.
| Valid? | Premises | Conclusion | Possible? | Example |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Valid | All true | True | Yes (sound) | All mammals breathe; whales are mammals; so whales breathe. |
| Valid | At least one false | False | Yes | All birds can fly; penguins are birds; so penguins can fly. |
| Valid | At least one false | True | Yes | All fish are mammals; whales are fish; so whales are mammals. |
| Valid | All true | False | Never | — |
| Invalid | Any | Any | Yes | All dogs are animals; all cats are animals; so all cats are dogs. |
Kinds of inductive argument
| Kind | Pattern | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Inductive generalisation | Sample → whole population | 80% of 500 surveyed students use smartphones; so about 80% of students do |
| Statistical syllogism | General statistic → individual | 90% of NET-qualified candidates had prepared Paper 1; Asha qualified; so she probably prepared Paper 1 |
| Prediction | Past → future | It has rained every July; it will rain next July |
| Causal inference | Correlation or pattern → cause | Plants given fertiliser grew taller; the fertiliser caused growth |
| Argument from analogy | Similar in known respects → similar in another | See section 4 |
| Argument from authority | An expert says so → probably true | Strength depends on the authority’s relevance |
The strength of a generalisation depends on the size and representativeness of the sample, which is why the sampling methods of research methodology matter.
The problem of induction
David Hume (18th century) argued that no inductive inference can be justified without assuming that the future will resemble the past, and that this assumption can itself be supported only by induction: a circle. Karl Popper’s response, that science proceeds by falsifying rather than verifying hypotheses, is covered under research approaches.
Mill’s methods of experimental inquiry
J.S. Mill, in A System of Logic (1843), set out five methods for finding causes. They are the standard account of causal induction.
| Method | Idea | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Agreement | If cases of an effect share only one circumstance, it is probably the cause | All the students who fell ill ate at the same stall, and had nothing else in common |
| Difference | If a case with the effect and one without differ in only one circumstance, that circumstance is the cause (or part of it) | Two identical plots, only one fertilised; only that one yields more |
| Joint method of agreement and difference | Combine the two | — |
| Residues | Subtract the effects of known causes; the remainder is due to the remaining cause | The discovery of an unknown planet from unexplained disturbances in a known orbit is the classic textbook case |
| Concomitant variation | If one phenomenon varies whenever another varies, they are causally linked | More hours of practice, higher mock scores |
2. Formal Fallacies
A fallacy is an error in reasoning that makes an argument look better than it is. A formal fallacy is an error in the form: it can be detected by looking at the structure alone.
| Formal fallacy | Form | Covered in |
|---|---|---|
| Affirming the consequent | \( p \to q \); \( q \); so \( p \) | Topic 1 |
| Denying the antecedent | \( p \to q \); \( \sim p \); so \( \sim q \) | Topic 1 |
| Affirming a disjunct | \( p \lor q \); \( p \); so \( \sim q \) | Topic 1 |
| Undistributed middle | Middle term never distributed | Topic 3 |
| Illicit major / illicit minor | Term distributed in conclusion only | Topic 3 |
| Four terms | Four terms in a syllogism | Topic 3 |
| Exclusive premises | Two negative premises | Topic 3 |
| Existential fallacy | Particular conclusion from universal premises (Boolean) | Topic 3 |
| Illicit conversion | Converting A or O simply | Topic 2 |
3. Informal Fallacies
An informal fallacy lies in the content, language or context of an argument, not in its form. You detect it by reading what is said. The grouping below broadly follows the four families used in Copi and Cohen’s Introduction to Logic (relevance, defective induction, presumption, ambiguity); textbooks differ on where some fallacies sit (accident, for instance, appears under relevance in some editions), but the individual names are stable.
Fallacies of relevance: the premises are irrelevant to the conclusion
| Fallacy | What happens | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Ad hominem (against the person) | Attacks the arguer instead of the argument. Abusive: insults; circumstantial: points to the arguer’s interests; tu quoque: “you do it too” | “Ignore his proposal on exam reform; he failed NET twice.” |
| Ad baculum (appeal to force) | Threat in place of reasons | “Accept the new timetable, or think about your increment.” |
| Ad misericordiam (appeal to pity) | Pity in place of reasons | “Give me grace marks; I studied all night.” |
| Ad populum (appeal to the people) | Popularity or group feeling as proof; includes the bandwagon | “Everyone is buying this guidebook, so it must be the best.” |
| Red herring | Diverts attention to a different issue | Asked about falling results, the principal speaks about the new auditorium. |
| Straw man | Distorts the opponent’s position, then attacks the distortion | “She wants fewer exams; so she wants students to learn nothing.” |
| Ignoratio elenchi (missing the point, irrelevant conclusion) | Premises support a different conclusion from the one drawn | Arguing that plagiarism is wrong, to conclude that the software should be bought from one vendor |
Fallacies of defective induction: the premises are relevant but too weak
| Fallacy | What happens | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Ad ignorantiam (appeal to ignorance) | Something is true because not proved false (or false because not proved true) | “No one has shown that the method fails, so it works.” |
| Ad verecundiam (appeal to inappropriate authority) | Authority cited outside their competence | “A famous cricketer says this hair oil cures baldness.” |
| False cause | Wrong causal link. Post hoc ergo propter hoc: after this, therefore because of this; non causa pro causa: mistaking a non-cause for a cause; slippery slope: an unsupported chain of consequences | “Results improved after the new uniform; the uniform improved results.” |
| Hasty generalisation (converse accident) | A general rule from too few or untypical cases | “Two students from that college copied; that college’s students are dishonest.” |
Fallacies of presumption: an unjustified assumption is built in
| Fallacy | What happens | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Accident | A general rule applied to an exceptional case it was not meant for | “Everyone must keep promises, so I must return the knife to my friend though he is now in a murderous rage.” |
| Complex question (loaded question) | A question that presupposes an answer to an earlier question | “Have you stopped copying in exams?” |
| Petitio principii (begging the question, circular reasoning) | The conclusion is assumed in a premise | “The Vedas are true because they say so, and what they say is true.” |
| False dilemma (false dichotomy) | Only two options offered when more exist | “Either we ban phones in class or students will learn nothing.” |
Fallacies of ambiguity: a shift in meaning
| Fallacy | What happens | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Equivocation | A word used in two senses | “The end of life is its perfection; death is the end of life; so death is its perfection.” |
| Amphiboly | A sentence ambiguous through its grammar | “Wanted: a room for a student with a fan.” |
| Accent | Meaning shifted by emphasis or quoting out of context | “We should not speak ill of our colleagues” (so others may?) |
| Composition | What is true of the parts is said of the whole | “Each player is excellent, so the team is excellent.” |
| Division | What is true of the whole is said of each part | “The university is famous, so every department in it is famous.” |
4. Analogies
The syllabus line “Analogies” is asked in two ways: as argument by analogy (a kind of induction) and as analogy completion (a reasoning puzzle).
Argument by analogy
“A and B are alike in respects x, y and z. A also has w. So B probably has w.”
“This new course resembles last year’s in syllabus, faculty and student intake; last year’s had a high pass rate; so this one probably will too.”
Standard criteria for judging its strength (as set out in Copi’s textbook tradition):
| Criterion | Stronger when… |
|---|---|
| Number of entities compared | More cases share the feature |
| Variety among those cases | The cases are varied in other respects |
| Number of similarities | More respects of resemblance |
| Relevance of the similarities | The shared respects are causally relevant to the conclusion (the most important criterion) |
| Disanalogies | Fewer relevant differences |
| Modesty of the conclusion | The conclusion claims less, relative to the premises |
A false analogy (weak analogy) is the informal fallacy of resting a conclusion on resemblances that are irrelevant: “A school is like a factory; factories maximise output per hour; so classes should be timed by the minute.”
Analogy completion
The format is A : B :: C : ? (“A is to B as C is to ?”). Identify the relationship between A and B, state it as a sentence, and find the option that makes the same sentence true for C.
| Relationship | Example |
|---|---|
| Synonym | Brave : Courageous :: Honest : Truthful |
| Antonym | Ancient : Modern :: Scarce : Abundant |
| Part : whole | Page : Book :: Petal : Flower |
| Worker : tool | Carpenter : Saw :: Surgeon : Scalpel |
| Worker : product | Poet : Poem :: Architect : Building (design) |
| Cause : effect | Fire : Smoke :: Virus : Disease |
| Instrument : measure | Thermometer : Temperature :: Barometer : Pressure |
| Young one | Cow : Calf :: Horse : Foal |
| Degree | Warm : Hot :: Cool : Cold |
| Raw material : product | Cotton : Cloth :: Clay : Pot |
| Group : member | Flock : Sheep :: Pride : Lion |
| Place : what is stored there | Library : Books :: Granary : Grain |
Letter and number analogies apply the same idea to positions and operations. Number the alphabet A = 1 … Z = 26.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Valid: true premises guarantee the conclusion | vs | Sound: valid and premises actually true |
| Strong inductive argument | vs | Cogent: strong and premises true |
| Formal fallacy: in the form | vs | Informal fallacy: in content or language |
| Hasty generalisation: few cases → rule | vs | Accident: rule → exceptional case |
| Composition: parts → whole | vs | Division: whole → parts |
| Equivocation: one word, two senses | vs | Amphiboly: one sentence, two grammatical readings |
| Ad hominem: attacks the person | vs | Straw man: attacks a distorted version of the argument |
| Red herring: changes the subject | vs | Ignoratio elenchi: proves a different conclusion |
| Post hoc: after, so because of | vs | Begging the question: conclusion in the premise |
| Method of agreement: one shared circumstance | vs | Method of difference: one differing circumstance |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- A valid deductive argument whose premises are all true is called ______.
- Name the fallacy: “This ritual must work, since nobody has ever proved it does not.”
- Complete: Page : Book :: Brick : ?
Answers
- Sound.
- Appeal to ignorance (argumentum ad ignorantiam).
- Wall (part : whole).
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) Which of the following combinations is impossible for a deductive argument?
- (a) Valid, with false premises and a true conclusion
- (b) Valid, with true premises and a false conclusion
- (c) Invalid, with true premises and a true conclusion
- (d) Valid, with false premises and a false conclusion
Answer and explanation
(b). By definition, a valid argument cannot have all true premises and a false conclusion. All the others can occur.
Q2. (Practice) “Every brick in this building is light. Therefore, the building is light.” The argument commits the fallacy of:
- (a) Division
- (b) Composition
- (c) Hasty generalisation
- (d) Accident
Answer and explanation
(b) Composition. A property of each part is wrongly transferred to the whole.
Q3. (Practice) Consider the following statements:
- In an inductive argument, the conclusion goes beyond the information contained in the premises.
- Adding a premise can never weaken an inductive argument.
- A deductive argument is either valid or invalid; there are no degrees of validity.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 only
- (b) 1 and 3 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 1 and 3 only. Statement 2 is false: new evidence can weaken an inductive argument (a counter-example to a generalisation), while it cannot make a valid deduction invalid.
Q4. (Practice) A researcher notes that in five villages where an outbreak occurred, the only common factor was a single water source. Which of Mill’s methods is she using?
- (a) Method of difference
- (b) Method of residues
- (c) Method of agreement
- (d) Method of concomitant variation
Answer and explanation
(c) Method of agreement: several cases of the effect share only one circumstance.
Q5. (Practice) Choose the pair that has the same relationship as Thermometer : Temperature.
- (a) Clock : Wall
- (b) Speedometer : Speed
- (c) Pen : Ink
- (d) Microscope : Laboratory
Answer and explanation
(b). An instrument and the quantity it measures.
Q6. (Practice) ACE : BDF :: GIK : ?
- (a) HIJ
- (b) HJL
- (c) IKM
- (d) GHI
Answer and explanation
(b) HJL. Each letter moves one place forward.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): An inductive argument can be strong even if its conclusion turns out to be false. Reason (R): Inductive arguments claim only that their premises make the conclusion probable, not certain.
Answer and explanation
(a). Because induction claims only probability, a well-supported conclusion can still be false (the turkey). R explains A.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): “Have you given up your habit of plagiarising?” commits the fallacy of complex question. Reason (R): Any question that contains an emotive word is a complex question.
Answer and explanation
(c). A is true: either answer admits past plagiarism. R is false: a complex question presupposes an answer to a prior question; emotive wording is neither necessary nor sufficient.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (fallacy) with List II (example).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Ad hominem | I. “After the new principal joined, it rained heavily; she brings good luck.” |
| B. Post hoc ergo propter hoc | II. “Either you support every reform or you are against progress.” |
| C. False dilemma | III. “His theory of inflation is worthless; he is a known gambler.” |
| D. Equivocation | IV. “A good surgeon must cut people; so a good surgeon is a violent person.” |
- (1) A-III, B-I, C-II, D-IV
- (2) A-I, B-III, C-II, D-IV
- (3) A-III, B-II, C-I, D-IV
- (4) A-IV, B-I, C-II, D-III
Answer and explanation
(1) A-III, B-I, C-II, D-IV. In D, “cut” shifts from “operate on” to “wound”.
Q4. (Practice) Match List I (term) with List II (meaning).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Sound | I. Strong inductive argument with true premises |
| B. Cogent | II. Valid deductive argument with true premises |
| C. Valid | III. Conclusion is claimed to be only probable |
| D. Inductive | IV. True premises guarantee the conclusion |
- (1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
- (2) A-I, B-II, C-IV, D-III
- (3) A-II, B-I, C-III, D-IV
- (4) A-IV, B-III, C-II, D-I
Answer and explanation
(1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III.
Q5. (Practice) Arrange the stages of evaluating a deductive argument in the logical order:
A. Check whether the premises are actually true
B. Identify the premises and the conclusion
C. Declare the argument sound or unsound
D. Test whether the form is valid
(1) B, D, A, C
(2) B, A, D, C
(3) D, B, A, C
(4) A, B, D, C
Answer and explanation
(1) B, D, A, C. Find the structure, test validity, then (only for a valid argument) test the truth of the premises, and finally pronounce on soundness.
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Key point |
|---|---|
| Deductive | Conclusion claimed necessary; valid / invalid; sound |
| Inductive | Conclusion claimed probable; strong / weak; cogent |
| Impossible case | Valid + true premises + false conclusion |
| Inductive kinds | Generalisation, statistical syllogism, prediction, causal, analogy, authority |
| Hume | Problem of induction |
| Mill (1843) | Agreement, difference, joint, residues, concomitant variation |
| Formal fallacies | Affirming consequent, denying antecedent, undistributed middle, illicit process, four terms, exclusive premises, existential |
| Relevance | Ad hominem, ad baculum, ad misericordiam, ad populum, red herring, straw man, ignoratio elenchi |
| Defective induction | Ad ignorantiam, ad verecundiam, false cause (post hoc, slippery slope), hasty generalisation |
| Presumption | Accident, complex question, begging the question, false dilemma |
| Ambiguity | Equivocation, amphiboly, accent, composition, division |
| Analogy (argument) | Relevance of similarities is the key criterion |
| Analogy (completion) | State the A : B relation as a sentence; keep the order |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Indian Logic: Pramanas, the Means of Knowledge — how the Indian schools classified the sources of valid knowledge
- Anumana, Vyapti and Hetvabhasa — the Indian theory of inference and its fallacies, compared with what you learnt here
- Quick Revision — fallacies and reasoning types on one page