Constitutional Changes, 1909–1935
UGC NET History Unit 7: Morley–Minto, Montagu–Chelmsford dyarchy, Simon Commission, Nehru Report, Round Tables, Communal Award, Poona Pact, 1935 Act.
- 18 min
On this page · 15 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Reforms “With Strong Brakes but No Engine”
- 1. Timeline
- 2. The Morley–Minto Reforms: Indian Councils Act, 1909
- 3. The Montagu–Chelmsford Reforms: Government of India Act, 1919
- 4. From Simon to the Round Tables (1927–1932)
- 5. The Government of India Act, 1935
- 6. The Reforms Compared
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Company and Crown Administration — the Councils Acts of 1861 and 1892, on which the 1909 Act built.
- Making of the Constitution (Political Science) — the same Acts read for what the Constitution of 1950 took from them.
- Federalism in India (Political Science) — the three lists and the federal scheme of 1935 in their later form.
The Hook: Reforms “With Strong Brakes but No Engine”
How UGC NET asks it: match the reform with its provision (separate electorates, dyarchy, provincial autonomy, Federal Court); the order of events from the Simla deputation to the 1935 Act; Round Table Conferences and who attended; the Communal Award and the Poona Pact; assertion–reason on dyarchy or on the failure of the federation; famous remarks on the reforms.
1. Timeline
timeline
title Constitutional change, 1906-1937
1906 : Simla deputation; Muslim League founded
1909 : Indian Councils Act (Morley-Minto)
1911 : Partition of Bengal annulled; capital to Delhi
1916 : Lucknow Pact
1917 : Montagu's August declaration
1919 : Government of India Act (Montagu-Chelmsford)
1927-28 : Simon Commission appointed and arrives
1928 : Nehru Report
1930-32 : Round Table Conferences
1932 : Communal Award; Poona Pact
1935 : Government of India Act
1937 : Provincial elections; Federal Court2. The Morley–Minto Reforms: Indian Councils Act, 1909
2.1 Background
| Event | Detail |
|---|---|
| Partition of Bengal (1905) and the Swadeshi movement | Unrest; Moderate–Extremist split at Surat (1907) |
| Simla deputation (1 October 1906) | Muslim delegation led by the Aga Khan met Viceroy Minto, asking for separate electorates and representation beyond numerical strength, in view of their “political importance” |
| All-India Muslim League | Founded at Dacca, December 1906 |
| The architects | John Morley (Secretary of State) and Lord Minto (Viceroy) |
2.2 Provisions
| Provision | Detail |
|---|---|
| Enlarged councils | The Imperial Legislative Council and the provincial councils enlarged; the number of additional members of the Imperial council raised substantially (to a maximum of sixty) |
| Majorities | Official majority retained in the Imperial council; non-official majority allowed in the provincial councils (but non-officials included nominated members) |
| Election | Elected members chosen indirectly, through bodies such as municipalities, district boards, landholders, chambers of commerce and universities |
| Separate electorates | Muslims given separate electorates: Muslim members elected only by Muslim voters; a lower qualification for Muslim voters |
| Powers | Members could discuss the budget, move resolutions and ask supplementary questions; no power over the executive |
| Executive council | S.P. Sinha became the first Indian member of the Viceroy’s Executive Council (law member). Morley had already appointed two Indians to the Secretary of State’s Council in London (1907) |
2.3 Between 1909 and 1919
| Year | Event |
|---|---|
| 1911 | Delhi Durbar (George V): partition of Bengal annulled; capital to be moved from Calcutta to Delhi (announced December 1911) |
| 1916 | Lucknow Pact: Congress accepts separate electorates and weightage for Muslims; joint demand for self-government; Congress reunited (Moderates and Extremists) |
| 1916 | Home Rule Leagues of Tilak (April) and Annie Besant (September) |
| 20 August 1917 | Montagu’s declaration in the House of Commons: the goal is the “increasing association of Indians in every branch of the administration” and the “gradual development of self-governing institutions with a view to the progressive realisation of responsible government in India as an integral part of the British Empire” |
| 1918 | Montagu–Chelmsford Report published (July) |
3. The Montagu–Chelmsford Reforms: Government of India Act, 1919
Passed in December 1919, in force from 1921. Edwin Montagu was Secretary of State and Lord Chelmsford Viceroy.
3.1 The provinces: dyarchy
| Feature | Detail |
|---|---|
| Division of subjects | Central and provincial subjects separated (by the Devolution Rules); provinces given their own sources of revenue |
| Dyarchy (“double rule”) | Provincial subjects divided into reserved and transferred |
| Reserved subjects | Administered by the Governor and his executive council, not responsible to the legislature: e.g. law and order (police, justice), finance, land revenue, irrigation |
| Transferred subjects | Administered by the Governor acting with Indian ministers responsible to the legislative council: e.g. education, public health, local self-government, agriculture, industries |
| Legislative councils | Enlarged, with about 70 per cent elected members, by direct election on a limited property franchise |
3.2 The centre
| Feature | Detail |
|---|---|
| Bicameral legislature | A Legislative Assembly (lower house) and a Council of State (upper house), each with an elected majority |
| Election | Direct election on a narrow, property-based franchise |
| Powers | Members could vote on part of the budget, but the Governor-General could certify a law or restore a cut grant; no responsible government at the centre |
| Executive council | Three of the Viceroy’s executive councillors (other than the Commander-in-Chief) to be Indians |
3.3 Other provisions
| Provision | Detail |
|---|---|
| Communal representation extended | Separate electorates for Sikhs, Indian Christians, Anglo-Indians and Europeans, in addition to Muslims |
| High Commissioner for India | Appointed in London to take over some agency functions from the Secretary of State |
| Secretary of State’s salary | Paid from British revenues |
| Public Service Commission | Provided for (set up in 1926) |
| Statutory commission | To review the working of the Act after ten years (this became the Simon Commission) |
| Women’s franchise | Left to the provincial councils; Madras was the first to grant it (1921) |
4. From Simon to the Round Tables (1927–1932)
4.1 The Simon Commission
| Point | Detail |
|---|---|
| Appointed | November 1927, two years before the ten-year review was due, by the Conservative government (Secretary of State Lord Birkenhead) |
| Composition | Seven British MPs under Sir John Simon (Clement Attlee among them); no Indian member |
| Reception | Arrived in Bombay on 3 February 1928; met with “Simon go back” demonstrations and a boycott by the Congress and a section of the League; Lala Lajpat Rai injured in a police lathi charge at Lahore (October 1928) and died soon after |
| Report (1930) | Abolish dyarchy in the provinces and establish representative government there; a federation of British India and the princely states as an eventual goal; no responsible government at the centre; separate electorates to continue; Burma to be separated from India |
4.2 The Indian answer: the Nehru Report (1928)
| Point | Detail |
|---|---|
| Origin | Birkenhead challenged Indians to produce a constitution acceptable to all; an All Parties Conference set up a committee under Motilal Nehru (Jawaharlal Nehru was secretary) |
| Proposals | Dominion status; joint electorates with reservation of seats for minorities (not separate electorates); fundamental rights; linguistic provinces; responsible government at the centre and in provinces; universal adult suffrage |
| Response | Rejected by sections of Muslim opinion; Jinnah’s Fourteen Points (March 1929) set out the League’s demands (federal constitution with residuary powers in provinces, separate electorates, one-third of seats at the centre for Muslims). Younger Congress leaders (Jawaharlal Nehru, Subhas Bose) wanted complete independence rather than dominion status |
| Sequel | Irwin’s declaration (31 October 1929) that dominion status was the natural goal; the Lahore Congress (December 1929) declared Purna Swaraj |
4.3 The Round Table Conferences (London)
| Conference | Dates | Congress | Key points |
|---|---|---|---|
| First | November 1930 – January 1931 | Did not attend (Civil Disobedience under way) | Opened by King George V; chaired by Prime Minister Ramsay MacDonald. Princes agreed in principle to an all-India federation; agreement on responsible government in provinces |
| Second | September – December 1931 | Gandhi as the sole Congress representative, after the Gandhi–Irwin Pact (5 March 1931) | Deadlock on the minorities question: Muslims, depressed classes (B.R. Ambedkar), Sikhs and others demanded separate electorates; Gandhi opposed separate electorates for the depressed classes. Gandhi returned empty-handed; Civil Disobedience resumed |
| Third | November – December 1932 | Did not attend | A small conference; its work fed into the White Paper (1933) |
4.4 The Communal Award and the Poona Pact (1932)
| Event | Detail |
|---|---|
| Communal Award (16 August 1932, Ramsay MacDonald) | Separate electorates confirmed for Muslims, Sikhs, Indian Christians, Anglo-Indians and Europeans, and extended to the depressed classes, who were also to vote in general constituencies (a double vote) |
| Gandhi’s fast (from 20 September 1932, Yerawada jail) | Opposed separating the depressed classes from the Hindu electorate |
| Poona Pact (24 September 1932, Gandhi and Ambedkar) | Separate electorates for the depressed classes abandoned; instead, reserved seats within the general electorate: 148 seats in the provincial legislatures (against 71 under the Award), and 18 per cent of the general seats for British India in the central legislature; a primary election among depressed-class voters to choose a panel of candidates |
5. The Government of India Act, 1935
5.1 The route to the Act
White Paper (March 1933) → Joint Select Committee of Parliament (chaired by Lord Linlithgow, 1933–34) → Act passed August 1935. It was the longest Act passed by the British Parliament up to that time, with 321 sections and 10 schedules.
5.2 Provisions
| Area | Provision |
|---|---|
| All-India Federation | A federation of the British Indian provinces and the princely states; states to join by signing an Instrument of Accession; it would come into being only when enough states acceded. It never came into being: the princes held back and the war intervened |
| Division of powers | Three lists: Federal (59 items), Provincial (54) and Concurrent (36); residuary powers with the Governor-General |
| Dyarchy at the centre | Federal subjects divided: reserved (defence, external affairs, ecclesiastical affairs, tribal areas) under the Governor-General and counsellors; the rest under ministers responsible to the federal legislature (never implemented, as the federation never formed) |
| Provincial autonomy | Dyarchy abolished in the provinces; all provincial subjects under ministers responsible to the legislature; the Governor kept special responsibilities and discretionary powers |
| Legislatures | Bicameral federal legislature (Federal Assembly and Council of State); bicameral legislatures in six provinces (Bengal, Bombay, Madras, Bihar, Assam, United Provinces); others unicameral |
| Franchise | Extended, but still limited by property and education: about a tenth of the population could vote |
| Communal representation | Separate electorates extended further (including women and labour); reserved seats for the depressed classes according to the Poona Pact |
| Federal Court | Set up at Delhi, began work in 1937 (Chief Justice Sir Maurice Gwyer); appeals lay to the Privy Council |
| Other bodies | Federal and provincial public service commissions; a Federal Railway Authority; the Reserve Bank of India was set up in 1935 (under the RBI Act, 1934) |
| India Office | Council of India abolished; the Secretary of State to have a body of advisers |
| Provinces | Burma separated from India (effective 1937); new provinces of Sind and Orissa created (1936) |
| Rigidity | The Act could be amended only by the British Parliament |
5.3 Reactions and working
| Reaction | By |
|---|---|
| “A machine with strong brakes but no engine”; also called it a “charter of slavery” | Jawaharlal Nehru |
| Described the Act as thoroughly rotten and unacceptable, especially its federal part | M.A. Jinnah and the Muslim League |
| Princes hesitated to accede on the terms offered | Princely states |
Working: elections were held in 1937. The Congress formed ministries in a majority of the provinces (seven at first, later eight). The ministries resigned in October–November 1939 in protest against India being declared a party to the Second World War without consultation. The Muslim League observed “Day of Deliverance” (22 December 1939).
6. The Reforms Compared
| Feature | 1909 | 1919 | 1935 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Popular name | Morley–Minto | Montagu–Chelmsford (Montford) | — |
| Centre | Official majority; unicameral council | Bicameral; elected majority; not responsible | Federation (never formed); dyarchy at centre (never implemented) |
| Provinces | Non-official majority | Dyarchy | Provincial autonomy |
| Election | Indirect | Direct (narrow franchise) | Direct; wider franchise (about a tenth) |
| Separate electorates | Muslims | + Sikhs, Indian Christians, Anglo-Indians, Europeans | + depressed classes’ reserved seats (Poona Pact), women, labour |
| Courts | — | — | Federal Court (1937) |
| London | — | High Commissioner; Secretary of State paid by Britain | Council of India abolished |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Dyarchy in provinces — 1919 | vs | Dyarchy at the centre — 1935 (never implemented) |
| Simla deputation (1906) — Aga Khan to Minto | vs | Simla Conference (1945) — Wavell |
| August declaration (1917) — Montagu | vs | August Offer (1940) — Linlithgow |
| Irwin’s declaration (1929) — dominion status | vs | Gandhi–Irwin Pact (1931) — Congress to attend Second RTC |
| Communal Award — MacDonald, separate electorates for depressed classes | vs | Poona Pact — reserved seats in joint electorate |
| Nehru Report — Motilal Nehru, 1928 | vs | Fourteen Points — Jinnah, 1929 |
| Muddiman Committee (1924) — reviewed dyarchy | vs | Simon Commission (1927) — statutory review |
| Federal Court (1937) — 1935 Act | vs | Supreme Court, Calcutta (1774) — Regulating Act |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Which Act introduced dyarchy in the provinces?
- Who led the Simla deputation of 1906?
- How many seats did the Poona Pact reserve for the depressed classes in the provincial legislatures?
Answers
- The Government of India Act, 1919.
- The Aga Khan.
- 148 (compared with 71 under the Communal Award).
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) Who was the first Indian to become a member of the Viceroy’s Executive Council?
- (a) Gopal Krishna Gokhale
- (b) S.P. Sinha
- (c) Tej Bahadur Sapru
- (d) Surendranath Banerjea
Answer and explanation
(b) S.P. Sinha, as law member, following the Morley–Minto reforms of 1909.
Q2. (Practice) Consider the following statements about the Government of India Act, 1935:
- It provided for an All-India Federation including the princely states.
- It vested residuary powers in the provincial legislatures.
- It provided for a Federal Court.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 only
- (b) 1 and 3 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 1 and 3 only. Residuary powers lay with the Governor-General.
Q3. (Practice) The Nehru Report of 1928 recommended:
- (a) Complete independence and separate electorates
- (b) Dominion status and joint electorates with reservation of seats for minorities
- (c) Dyarchy at the centre
- (d) Residuary powers with the provinces
Answer and explanation
(b). Residuary powers with the provinces was one of Jinnah’s Fourteen Points.
Q4. (Practice) Under the 1919 Act, which of the following was a transferred subject in the provinces?
- (a) Police
- (b) Land revenue
- (c) Local self-government
- (d) Finance
Answer and explanation
(c) Local self-government. Police, land revenue and finance were reserved.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Ministers in charge of transferred subjects under dyarchy found it difficult to carry out their programmes. Reason (R): Finance remained a reserved subject under a member not responsible to the legislature.
Answer and explanation
(a). Without control over finance (R), ministers in charge of education, health and local self-government could not fund their policies (A).
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): The federal part of the Government of India Act, 1935 was never implemented. Reason (R): The Act abolished dyarchy in the provinces.
Answer and explanation
(b). Both are true, but R does not explain A. The federation failed because enough princes did not accede and the Second World War intervened.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (event) with List II (year).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Simla deputation | I. 1932 |
| B. Montagu’s August declaration | II. 1906 |
| C. Simon Commission’s arrival in India | III. 1917 |
| D. Poona Pact | IV. 1928 |
- (1) A-II, B-III, C-IV, D-I
- (2) A-III, B-II, C-IV, D-I
- (3) A-II, B-III, C-I, D-IV
- (4) A-II, B-IV, C-III, D-I
Answer and explanation
(1) A-II, B-III, C-IV, D-I.
Q4. (Practice) Match List I (person) with List II (association).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. John Simon | I. Chairman of the Round Table Conferences as Prime Minister |
| B. Ramsay MacDonald | II. Statutory commission of 1927 |
| C. Lord Linlithgow | III. Joint Select Committee on the White Paper |
| D. Motilal Nehru | IV. All Parties Conference report, 1928 |
- (1) A-II, B-I, C-III, D-IV
- (2) A-I, B-II, C-III, D-IV
- (3) A-II, B-III, C-I, D-IV
- (4) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
Answer and explanation
(1) A-II, B-I, C-III, D-IV.
Q5. (Practice) Arrange in chronological order:
- Communal Award
- Gandhi–Irwin Pact
- Nehru Report
- First Round Table Conference
- (a) 3, 4, 2, 1
- (b) 3, 2, 4, 1
- (c) 4, 3, 2, 1
- (d) 3, 4, 1, 2
Answer and explanation
(a) 3, 4, 2, 1. Nehru Report (August 1928) → First RTC (November 1930) → Gandhi–Irwin Pact (March 1931) → Communal Award (August 1932).
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Key fact |
|---|---|
| Simla deputation | 1 October 1906; Aga Khan; Minto |
| Muslim League | Dacca, December 1906 |
| 1909 Act | Morley–Minto; separate electorates for Muslims; S.P. Sinha |
| 1911 | Bengal partition annulled; capital to Delhi |
| Lucknow Pact | 1916; Congress accepts separate electorates |
| August declaration | 20 August 1917; “progressive realisation of responsible government” |
| 1919 Act | Provincial dyarchy; bicameral centre; direct election; Sikhs and others get separate electorates |
| Muddiman Committee | 1924; reviewed dyarchy |
| Simon Commission | Nov 1927; arrived 3 Feb 1928; all-white; report 1930 |
| Nehru Report | 1928; dominion status; joint electorates |
| Fourteen Points | Jinnah, March 1929 |
| RTCs | 1930–31, 1931 (Gandhi), 1932 |
| Communal Award | 16 August 1932; MacDonald |
| Poona Pact | 24 September 1932; 148 seats; 18% at centre |
| 1935 Act | Federation (never formed); provincial autonomy; 59/54/36 lists; residuary with Governor-General; Federal Court 1937; Burma separated; Sind and Orissa |
| Nehru’s remark | “Machine with strong brakes but no engine” |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
Revise the whole chapter on one page: Quick Revision: Modern India, Rise of British Power and Administration. For how these Acts shaped the Constitution of 1950, read Making of the Constitution, and for local government after 1950, Panchayati Raj Institutions. Back to the chapter overview or the History hub.