Ashoka's Dhamma, the Edicts, Mauryan Decline and Mauryan Art
UGC NET History Unit 2: nature of Ashoka's Dhamma, edicts by type, language and script, theories of Mauryan decline, pillars, caves and yaksha art.
- 18 min
On this page · 13 sections
Prerequisites
- From Magadha to the Mauryan Empire — Ashoka’s predecessors, the extent of the empire and its officials.
- Jainism, Buddhism and the Ajivikas — Buddhist doctrine and the councils, especially the Third Council at Pataliputra.
- Sources of Ancient Indian History — James Prinsep’s decipherment of Brahmi (1837) and the Maski edict (1915).
The Hook: A King Who Published His Regret
How UGC NET asks it: match edict numbers with their content; match sites with edict types or scripts; statements on the nature of Dhamma; assertion–reason on theories of decline; match pillar sites with their capital animals.
1. Ashoka’s Inscriptions
1.1 Classification
| Category | Number / sites | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Major Rock Edicts (14) | Kalsi, Shahbazgarhi, Mansehra, Girnar, Sopara, Dhauli, Jaugada, Yerragudi; fragments elsewhere (e.g. Sannati) | The core statement of Dhamma. A Greek version of parts of XII and XIII was found at Kandahar |
| Separate Kalinga Edicts (2) | Dhauli and Jaugada (Odisha) | Replace XI, XII and XIII there; addressed to the mahamatras of Tosali and Samapa; “All men are my children” |
| Minor Rock Edicts | Maski, Gujarra, Brahmagiri, Siddapura, Jatinga-Rameshwara, Rupnath, Sahasram, Bairat, Ahraura, Yerragudi and others | Ashoka’s personal turn to Buddhism (became an upasaka, a lay follower, and grew more zealous after joining the sangha). Maski (found 1915) and Gujarra name him as Asoka |
| Bhabru (Calcutta–Bairat) inscription | Bairat, Rajasthan; now in Kolkata | Ashoka’s faith in the Buddha, Dhamma and Sangha; recommends seven Buddhist texts for monks and lay people |
| Major Pillar Edicts (7 edicts, 6 pillar sites) | Delhi–Topra, Delhi–Meerut, Allahabad–Kosam, Lauriya–Araraj, Lauriya–Nandangarh, Rampurva | Only Delhi–Topra carries Pillar Edict VII, the summary of his Dhamma work |
| Minor Pillar Inscriptions | Schism edict (Sarnath, Sanchi, Allahabad–Kosam); Queen’s edict (Allahabad: gifts of Karuvaki, mother of Tivara); Rummindei (Lumbini); Nigali Sagar (Nigliva) | Rummindei: Ashoka visited the Buddha’s birthplace in his 20th regnal year; Nigali Sagar: he enlarged the stupa of the past Buddha Konagamana |
| Cave dedications | Barabar hills (Bihar) | Caves given to the Ajivikas in his 12th and 19th regnal years |
1.2 What the fourteen rock edicts say
| Edict | Content |
|---|---|
| I | Ban on animal sacrifice and on festive gatherings (samaja) of certain kinds; the royal kitchen cut to two peacocks and one deer a day, and even these to stop |
| II | Medical treatment for humans and animals; herbs, roots and fruits planted; wells dug and trees planted on roads; names the Cholas, Pandyas, Satiyaputras, Keralaputras, Tamraparni and the Greek king Antiochus |
| III | Yuktas, rajukas and pradeshikas to tour every five years; liberality to brahmanas and shramanas; spending little and owning little |
| IV | The sound of the war drum (bherighosha) replaced by the sound of Dhamma (dhammaghosha) |
| V | Appointment of dhamma-mahamatras in the 13th regnal year |
| VI | The king available for public business at all times, even in the harem or the garden |
| VII | All sects may live everywhere; self-control and purity of mind |
| VIII | Dhamma-yatras replace pleasure tours (vihara-yatras); visit to Sambodhi (Bodh Gaya) in his 10th regnal year |
| IX | Useless ceremonies (mangalas) criticised; the ceremony of Dhamma praised |
| X | Fame and glory worthless unless won through Dhamma |
| XI | The gift of Dhamma is the best gift |
| XII | Tolerance of all sects; restraint of speech (vachaguti): no praise of one’s own sect and no censure of others' |
| XIII | Kalinga war, remorse, dhammavijaya; five Greek kings; warning to forest peoples |
| XIV | The edicts written in brief, medium and full versions; errors may be the engraver’s |
The five Greek kings of Rock Edict XIII: Amtiyoga (Antiochus II of Syria), Turamaya (Ptolemy II of Egypt), Amtikini (Antigonus Gonatas of Macedonia), Maka (Magas of Cyrene) and Alikasudara (Alexander of Epirus or of Corinth; the identification is debated). Because these kings’ reigns overlap only for a few years, the edict helps date Ashoka.
1.3 Language and script
| Feature | Detail |
|---|---|
| Language | Prakrit throughout India, in regional dialects (an eastern Magadhi variety at Dhauli and Jaugada, western forms at Girnar, north-western forms at Shahbazgarhi); Greek and Aramaic in Afghanistan |
| Brahmi | Most edicts; written left to right; deciphered by James Prinsep in 1837 |
| Kharosthi | Shahbazgarhi and Mansehra (north-west Pakistan); written right to left; derived from Aramaic |
| Greek | Kandahar: a bilingual Greek–Aramaic rock inscription (Shar-i-Kuna), and a Greek version of parts of Edicts XII–XIII |
| Aramaic | Kandahar, Laghman, and Taxila |
| Name | Usually Devanampiya Piyadasi; the name Asoka occurs in the Maski and Gujarra minor rock edicts (and a few later finds) |
2. Ashoka’s Dhamma and Its Nature
2.1 What the Dhamma contained
Ashoka never defines Dhamma as a doctrine. His edicts list practices:
| Category | Content |
|---|---|
| Social ethics | Obedience to mother and father; respect for elders and teachers; courtesy to relatives, friends, brahmanas and shramanas; kindness to slaves and servants (dasa-bhataka) |
| Non-violence | Restraint in killing animals (RE I; Pillar Edict V lists protected animals and closed days) |
| Tolerance | Honour all sects; restraint of speech (RE XII); all sects may live everywhere (RE VII) |
| Personal virtues | Compassion (daya), liberality (dana), truthfulness (sacha), purity (sochaye), many good deeds (bahukayane) and few sins (apasinave), named in Pillar Edict II; gentleness (madava) is added in Pillar Edict VII |
| Welfare works | Medical care for humans and animals, wells, rest-houses, shade trees (RE II, PE VII) |
| Institutions | Dhamma-mahamatras; dhamma-yatras; officials’ tours; inscriptions to be read publicly |
| Diplomacy | Dhammavijaya (conquest by dhamma) in place of military conquest (RE XIII). Dharmavijaya is a syllabus concept |
2.2 Ashoka and Buddhism
- Personal faith: the Minor Rock Edicts say he became an upasaka and later grew zealous; the Bhabru edict professes faith in the Buddha, Dhamma and Sangha; he visited Sambodhi and Lumbini.
- Sangha discipline: the Schism edict orders dissident monks and nuns to be expelled from the sangha.
- Third Buddhist Council at Pataliputra under Moggaliputta Tissa (c. 250 BCE) and missions to Sri Lanka (Mahinda and Sanghamitta) and elsewhere: these come from the Sri Lankan chronicles (Dipavamsa, Mahavamsa), not from Ashoka’s own inscriptions.
- Patronage of others: caves at Barabar for the Ajivikas; RE XII honours all sects; brahmanas are consistently named for respect.
2.3 Interpretations
| Interpretation | Main argument | Associated with |
|---|---|---|
| Dhamma = Buddhism | Dhamma is Buddhist lay ethics (the upasaka code); Ashoka was a Buddhist propagandist | Older scholarship; D.R. Bhandarkar (Asoka, 1925) saw it as Buddhism for the laity |
| Universal ethics | Dhamma contains no Buddhist doctrines (no Four Noble Truths, no nirvana); it is a moral code acceptable to all sects | Many historians since the mid-20th century |
| A state policy / ideology | Dhamma was Ashoka’s answer to ruling a heterogeneous empire: a common ethic to bind diverse peoples, reduce sectarian conflict and strengthen loyalty to the king | Romila Thapar (Asoka and the Decline of the Mauryas, 1961) |
| Paternalist kingship | “All men are my children” (separate edicts): the king as father, responsible for subjects’ welfare in this world and the next | Reading of the Kalinga edicts |
3. Decline and Disintegration of the Mauryan Empire
3.1 Ashoka’s successors
The Puranic and Buddhist lists disagree, but the names include Kunala, Dasharatha (who dedicated the Nagarjuni caves to the Ajivikas), Samprati (remembered in Jain tradition as a great patron), Shalishuka, Devavarman, Shatadhanvan and Brihadratha. The empire seems to have split after Ashoka: Kalhana’s Rajatarangini gives Kashmir to Jalauka, said to be a son of Ashoka, and other traditions give separate eastern and western lines. In c. 185 BCE (some write 187 BCE), the last Maurya, Brihadratha, was killed by his brahmana commander Pushyamitra Shunga while reviewing the army (Bana’s Harshacharita).
Using the Puranic total of 137 years and a start of c. 321 BCE gives an end around c. 184 BCE, consistent with the conventional date.
3.2 Theories of decline
| Theory | Argument | Main proponent | Criticism |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brahmanical reaction | Ashoka’s ban on sacrifices and favour to Buddhism (and the dhamma-mahamatras intruding on brahmana privileges) provoked a brahmana revolt, symbolised by Pushyamitra’s coup | Haraprasad Shastri | Ashoka honoured brahmanas; the ban targeted some sacrifices only; the brahmana Pushyamitra was a Mauryan general, and the revolt came half a century after Ashoka |
| Ashoka’s pacifism | Abandoning war and the war drum weakened the army and invited invasions | H.C. Raychaudhuri | Ashoka kept the army and warned the forest peoples; decline came decades later |
| Administrative structure | An over-centralised administration depending on the king’s personality; loyalty to the king, not the state; no representative institutions; no regular recruitment beyond royal patronage | Romila Thapar | Stresses structure over events; widely accepted as part of the explanation |
| Economic crisis | Pressure on the treasury: debasement of later punch-marked coins, the Arthashastra’s emergency levies, the cost of a huge army and bureaucracy | D.D. Kosambi | Evidence of debasement is partly debated; the Ganga plain remained prosperous under the Shungas |
| Weak successors and partition | Short reigns, division between heirs (Kashmir, the west), provincial revolts (Taxila revolts are in Buddhist legends) | Many historians | Describes how, not why |
| Foreign invasions | Bactrian Greeks pressed into the north-west in the early 2nd century BCE; the Yuga Purana (in the Gargi Samhita) and Patanjali mention Yavana attacks reaching Saketa and Madhyamika | Many historians | More a consequence of weakness than a cause |
4. Mauryan Art and Architecture
Indian art history commonly divides Mauryan art into court art (sponsored by the king: pillars, capitals, caves, the palace) and popular art (yaksha and yakshi figures, terracottas, made by local patrons and guilds).
4.1 Ashokan pillars
| Feature | Mauryan pillar |
|---|---|
| Material | Monolithic shaft of fine Chunar sandstone (near Varanasi), transported great distances |
| Finish | The famous Mauryan polish, a mirror-like gloss |
| Shaft | Plain, slightly tapering, without a base |
| Capital | Inverted lotus (“bell”) → abacus (round or square, sometimes with friezes) → animal crowning figure |
| Inscriptions | Some pillars carry edicts; others (e.g. Rampurva bull) are uninscribed or carry later records |
| Site | Capital |
|---|---|
| Sarnath | Four lions back to back; abacus with four animals (elephant, bull, horse, lion) separated by 24-spoked wheels; originally crowned by a large wheel. Adopted as India’s national emblem (26 January 1950) |
| Rampurva (Bihar) | Two pillars: a bull capital (now at Rashtrapati Bhavan) and a lion capital |
| Lauriya–Nandangarh | Single lion on a round abacus with a row of geese |
| Sankissa (UP) | Elephant |
| Vaishali (Kolhua) | Single lion on a short, uninscribed pillar |
| Sanchi | Four lions (like Sarnath, broken) |
4.2 Rock-cut caves
| Cave | Hills | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Sudama | Barabar | Dedicated by Ashoka to the Ajivikas in his 12th regnal year; polished interior |
| Karna Chaupar | Barabar | Dedication in his 19th regnal year |
| Lomas Rishi | Barabar | Not dedicated by Ashoka, but in the same style; its doorway imitates a wooden hut entrance with an ogee (curved) arch and a frieze of elephants venerating stupas: a model for later chaitya façades |
| Nagarjuni caves (e.g. Gopika) | Nagarjuni | Dedicated by Dasharatha to the Ajivikas |
The caves show the shift from wooden to stone architecture: the masons copied timber forms in rock.
4.3 Stupas, palace and other monuments
- Stupas: Buddhist tradition credits Ashoka with 84,000 stupas (a symbolic number). The brick core of the Sanchi great stupa goes back to the Mauryan period and was enlarged and cased in stone later; the stupa at Bharhut may also have had a Mauryan beginning, though its surviving railings and gateways are post-Mauryan (see post-Mauryan art). Stupa/Chaitya/Vihara is a syllabus concept.
- Palace at Pataliputra: the Kumrahar excavations (D.B. Spooner, early 1910s) revealed a large pillared hall with polished sandstone pillars; remains of a wooden palisade at Bulandibagh match Megasthenes’ wooden city wall.
- Dhauli elephant: the forepart of an elephant carved out of the rock above the Dhauli edicts.
4.4 Popular art: yakshas and yakshis
| Sculpture | Note |
|---|---|
| Didarganj yakshi (Patna, found 1917) | Life-size chauri-bearer in polished sandstone; long regarded as Mauryan because of the polish; some scholars date it later (Shunga or Kushana). Say “dated variously” |
| Parkham yaksha (near Mathura) | Massive standing male figure; its date and inscription are debated, usually placed in the 2nd–1st century BCE |
| Besnagar yakshi, Patna yakshas | Similar monumental folk deities |
| Terracottas | Mother goddesses, toys and animals from Pataliputra, Bulandibagh and other urban sites |
The yaksha cult (local guardian deities, wealth and fertility) fed directly into later Buddhist, Jain and Brahmanical iconography: the chauri-bearer, the pot-bellied Kubera and the tree-goddess (shalabhanjika).
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Maski, Gujarra — name “Asoka” | vs | Bhabru — faith in Buddha, Dhamma, Sangha; seven texts |
| Delhi–Topra — only pillar with PE VII | vs | Allahabad–Kosam — also Queen’s and Schism edicts, Samudragupta’s prashasti |
| Rummindei — Lumbini, bhaga to 1/8 | vs | Nigali Sagar — Konagamana stupa enlarged |
| Sudama — Ashoka, 12th year, Ajivikas | vs | Nagarjuni — Dasharatha, Ajivikas |
| Separate edicts — Dhauli, Jaugada | vs | Rock Edict XIII — omitted in Kalinga |
| Haraprasad Shastri — brahmanical reaction | vs | H.C. Raychaudhuri — pacifism |
| Sarnath — four lions, national emblem | vs | Rampurva — bull (and a lion) |
| Dhammavijaya — conquest by dhamma | vs | Dhamma-yatra — tour for dhamma instead of pleasure |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- In which script are the Shahbazgarhi and Mansehra rock edicts written?
- Which pillar carries Ashoka’s Pillar Edict VII?
- Which rock edict announces the appointment of dhamma-mahamatras?
Answers
- Kharosthi (right to left).
- Delhi–Topra.
- Rock Edict V (in his 13th regnal year).
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) In which of the following inscriptions does Ashoka declare his faith in the Buddha, the Dhamma and the Sangha and recommend specific Buddhist texts?
- (a) Rock Edict XIII
- (b) Bhabru (Calcutta–Bairat) inscription
- (c) Rummindei pillar inscription
- (d) Delhi–Topra Pillar Edict VII
Answer and explanation
(b). The Bhabru inscription, addressed to the sangha, names seven texts. RE XIII is about Kalinga and dhammavijaya; Rummindei records his Lumbini visit and tax concession.
Q2. (Practice) Consider the following statements about Ashoka’s inscriptions:
- The Kandahar inscriptions include texts in Greek and Aramaic.
- Rock Edict XIII is found at Dhauli and Jaugada.
- The Maski minor rock edict names the king as Asoka.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 1 and 3 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b). In Kalinga (Dhauli and Jaugada), Edicts XI–XIII are replaced by the two separate edicts, so statement 2 is wrong.
Q3. (Practice) The theory that the Mauryan empire declined because of a brahmanical reaction to Ashoka’s policies is associated with:
- (a) H.C. Raychaudhuri
- (b) Romila Thapar
- (c) Haraprasad Shastri
- (d) D.D. Kosambi
Answer and explanation
(c) Haraprasad Shastri. Raychaudhuri blamed Ashoka’s pacifism (and rebutted Shastri), Thapar the administrative structure, Kosambi economic crisis.
Q4. (Practice) Which feature does not belong to an Ashokan pillar?
- (a) Monolithic shaft of Chunar sandstone
- (b) Inverted lotus capital crowned by an animal
- (c) Fluted shaft standing on a moulded base
- (d) High polish
Answer and explanation
(c). Fluting and a base are features of Achaemenid columns. Ashokan shafts are plain and base-less.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Ashoka’s Dhamma was not identical with Buddhist doctrine. Reason (R): The edicts do not mention the Four Noble Truths, the Eightfold Path or nirvana, and they ask respect for brahmanas and all sects.
Answer and explanation
(a). The content of the public Dhamma is ethical and non-sectarian, which explains why it is not simply Buddhism, even though Ashoka was personally a Buddhist.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): The Mauryan empire collapsed immediately after Ashoka’s death because he had disbanded the army. Reason (R): In Rock Edict IV Ashoka speaks of replacing the sound of the war drum with the sound of Dhamma.
Answer and explanation
(d). A is false: the empire lasted about half a century after Ashoka, and there is no evidence that he disbanded the army (RE XIII still warns the forest peoples of his power). R is a true statement of RE IV.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (rock edict) with List II (subject).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Rock Edict I | I. Tolerance of all sects; restraint of speech |
| B. Rock Edict II | II. Prohibition of animal sacrifice |
| C. Rock Edict XII | III. Kalinga war and conquest by dhamma |
| D. Rock Edict XIII | IV. Medical care for humans and animals |
- (1) A-II, B-IV, C-I, D-III
- (2) A-IV, B-II, C-I, D-III
- (3) A-II, B-IV, C-III, D-I
- (4) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
Answer and explanation
(1) A-II, B-IV, C-I, D-III.
Q4. (Practice) Match List I (pillar site) with List II (crowning animal).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Sarnath | I. Elephant |
| B. Sankissa | II. Four lions |
| C. Lauriya–Nandangarh | III. Bull (one of two pillars) |
| D. Rampurva | IV. Single lion |
- (1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
- (2) A-II, B-IV, C-I, D-III
- (3) A-IV, B-I, C-II, D-III
- (4) A-II, B-I, C-III, D-IV
Answer and explanation
(1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III. Rampurva has both a bull and a lion pillar; the bull is the famous one.
Q5. (Practice) Arrange the following events in Ashoka’s reign in chronological order (by regnal year):
- Conquest of Kalinga
- Visit to Sambodhi (Bodh Gaya)
- Appointment of dhamma-mahamatras
- Visit to Lumbini
- (a) 1, 2, 3, 4
- (b) 2, 1, 3, 4
- (c) 1, 3, 2, 4
- (d) 1, 2, 4, 3
Answer and explanation
(a). Kalinga (8th year, RE XIII) → Sambodhi (10th year, RE VIII) → dhamma-mahamatras (13th year, RE V) → Lumbini (20th year, Rummindei).
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Key fact |
|---|---|
| Major Rock Edicts | 14; Kalsi, Shahbazgarhi, Mansehra, Girnar, Sopara, Dhauli, Jaugada, Yerragudi |
| Separate Kalinga edicts | Dhauli, Jaugada; replace XI–XIII; “All men are my children” |
| Name “Asoka” | Maski (1915), Gujarra |
| Bhabru | Buddha, Dhamma, Sangha; seven texts |
| Pillar Edict VII | Delhi–Topra only |
| Scripts | Brahmi (Prinsep 1837); Kharosthi at Shahbazgarhi, Mansehra; Greek and Aramaic at Kandahar |
| Regnal years | Kalinga 8; Sambodhi 10; Barabar 12; dhamma-mahamatras 13; Barabar 19; Lumbini 20 |
| Dhamma | Ethics, tolerance (RE XII), non-violence (RE I), welfare (RE II), dhammavijaya (RE XIII) |
| Interpretations | Bhandarkar (Buddhist lay ethics); Thapar (policy for a diverse empire) |
| Decline theories | Shastri (brahmanical reaction), Raychaudhuri (pacifism), Thapar (administration), Kosambi (economy) |
| End | Brihadratha killed by Pushyamitra Shunga, c. 185 BCE; 137 years (Puranas) |
| Pillars | Chunar sandstone, polish, no base; Sarnath four lions (emblem 1950); Rampurva bull |
| Caves | Barabar (Sudama, Karna Chaupar; Lomas Rishi ogee arch); Nagarjuni (Dasharatha) |
| Popular art | Didarganj yakshi (date debated), Parkham yaksha |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
When the empire broke up, its frontiers filled with new rulers: Greeks, Shungas, Satavahanas, Sakas and Kushanas. Continue with Regional Powers after the Mauryas, or return to the chapter overview.