Philosophies of History: Ranke, Positivism, Marx, Spengler and Toynbee
UGC NET History Unit 10: positive and negative schools, Ranke's Berlin revolution, Marxist materialism, Spengler's cycles, Toynbee's challenge and response.
- 17 min
On this page · 15 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Archive, Law, Organism, Challenge
- 1. Negative and Positive Schools of Historical Writing
- 2. The “Berlin Revolution”: Leopold von Ranke
- 3. The Marxist Philosophy of History
- 4. Cyclical Theories Before Spengler
- 5. Oswald Spengler: The Cyclical Theory
- 6. Arnold Joseph Toynbee: Challenge and Response
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Greek, Roman, Church and Renaissance Historiography — Polybius’ cycles, Augustine’s linear time and Renaissance criticism, which this page builds on.
- Nature of History — the science-or-art debate and theories of causation.
- For Marx as a political thinker, see Marx, Gramsci and Mao; for Comte’s positivism as research philosophy, see Research: Meaning, Types and Approaches.
The Hook: Archive, Law, Organism, Challenge
How UGC NET asks it: match thinker and work (Der Untergang des Abendlandes → Spengler; A Study of History → Toynbee); match term and thinker (“creative minority”, “Faustian soul”, “base and superstructure”, wie es eigentlich gewesen); sequence Marx’s modes of production or Toynbee’s stages; assertion–reason on why Ranke is called the father of scientific history.
1. Negative and Positive Schools of Historical Writing
The syllabus pairs a negative and a positive school. Neither label names a single, agreed school in Western historiography, and Indian textbooks read them in slightly different ways. The most defensible reading is this:
1.1 The positive school (positivism)
| Thinker | Work | Idea |
|---|---|---|
| Auguste Comte (1798–1857) | Course in Positive Philosophy (1830–1842) | Knowledge passes through the theological, metaphysical and positive stages (the law of three stages); society can be studied by the methods of natural science; he coined “sociology” |
| Henry Thomas Buckle (1821–1862) | History of Civilization in England (2 vols, 1857 and 1861) | History can discover general laws; climate, food, soil and the “general aspect of nature” shape societies; statistical regularities in human behaviour |
| Hippolyte Taine (1828–1893) | Literary and historical works | Culture explained by race, milieu and moment |
| Fustel de Coulanges (1830–1889) | The Ancient City (1864) | History as a pure science of facts drawn from texts |
Features of positivist history: facts first, gathered from documents and tested; then generalisation and the search for laws; the historian’s personality suppressed; history modelled on natural science.
Criticisms: human action is not law-governed like matter; “facts” do not exist independently of selection; the method often produced accumulation of facts without explanation, and R.G. Collingwood rejected the positivist modelling of history on natural science (he separately mocked “scissors-and-paste” history, compiled from the statements of earlier authorities).
1.2 The negative school (the critical, sceptical tradition)
The “negative” side of historical writing is the work of doubt and criticism: testing, discarding and demolishing what the sources cannot support.
| Strand | Example |
|---|---|
| Historical scepticism (Pyrrhonism) of the 17th century | Writers who doubted that certain knowledge of the past was possible; Pierre Bayle’s Historical and Critical Dictionary (1697) catalogued the errors and contradictions of earlier authorities |
| Critical demolition of legends | Barthold Georg Niebuhr’s Roman History (from 1811), from his lectures at the new University of Berlin, rejected the legendary early history of Rome as told by Livy |
| Negative internal criticism in method | Langlois and Seignobos (1898) named the stage that tests an author’s good faith and accuracy “negative internal criticism” (see Historical Method) |
2. The “Berlin Revolution”: Leopold von Ranke
2.1 Life and works
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Dates | 1795–1886 |
| University | Berlin, from 1825, where he taught until 1871; ennobled (von) in 1865 |
| First book | Histories of the Latin and Germanic Peoples from 1494 to 1514 (1824), with an appendix, Critique of Modern Historians, attacking Guicciardini and others for unreliable use of sources |
| Famous line | In the preface: not to judge the past or instruct the present, but to show wie es eigentlich gewesen (“how it actually was”; eigentlich can also mean “essentially”) |
| Major works | The Roman Popes (1834–36); German History in the Age of the Reformation (1839–47); histories of France and England; Weltgeschichte (World History), unfinished |
| Essay | “The Great Powers” (1833): European history as the interplay of great states |
| Lectures | 1854 lectures to King Maximilian II of Bavaria: “every epoch is immediate to God” — each age has its own value, not merely as a step to the next |
2.2 Why “revolution”?
| Innovation | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Primacy of primary sources | History must rest on contemporary documents, above all archival records, rather than earlier histories; he prized the reports (relazioni) of Venetian ambassadors |
| Source criticism | Applied philological and critical methods (developed by Niebuhr and classical scholars) to modern history |
| The seminar | Trained students in small groups to criticise sources: the research seminar became the model for professional training |
| Professionalisation | History became a university discipline with doctoral training; his students spread the method across Germany and beyond |
| Impartiality | The historian’s task is to understand, not to judge or preach |
| Historicism | Each age is to be understood on its own terms (“immediate to God”), not measured against the present |
Ranke’s pupils and followers included Heinrich von Sybel, who founded the journal Historische Zeitschrift (1859), and Georg Waitz; the seminar method was later adopted by American universities. The title “father of scientific history” usually goes to Ranke.
2.3 Criticisms
- State-centred and political: diplomacy, wars, great powers; little economic or social history.
- Elite sources: archives record rulers and officials, not peasants or workers.
- Not value-free: a conservative Lutheran view of providence and of the Prussian state colours his work.
- Naive objectivity: later critics (Carr, the postmodernists) argued that facts are selected and framed by the historian; many scholars now hold that Ranke’s own position was subtler than the “naive empiricist” image his followers created.
3. The Marxist Philosophy of History
3.1 Key texts
| Year | Text | Authors | Key idea for history |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1845–46 | The German Ideology (published in full only in 1932) | Marx and Engels | Material production as the basis of history |
| 1848 | The Communist Manifesto | Marx and Engels | “The history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggles” |
| 1852 | The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte | Marx | People make their own history, but not in circumstances of their choosing |
| 1859 | A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy (Preface) | Marx | Classic summary of base and superstructure; social being determines consciousness; lists the Asiatic, ancient, feudal and modern bourgeois modes of production |
| 1867 | Capital, Volume I | Marx | Analysis of capitalism; surplus value |
| 1880 | Socialism: Utopian and Scientific | Engels | Marxism as “scientific” socialism, based on the materialist conception of history |
3.2 Historical materialism (“scientific materialism”)
The syllabus calls Marx’s philosophy of history “scientific materialism”. Marx and Engels presented their materialist conception of history as scientific because it claimed to rest on observable material conditions rather than ideas or providence; Engels used the term historical materialism for it.
| Concept | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Forces of production | Labour, tools, technology, raw materials, skills |
| Relations of production | Property and class relations: who owns, who works, who takes the surplus |
| Mode of production | The combination of forces and relations; the economic base |
| Superstructure | Law, state, politics, religion, art, ideology, which rest on and broadly reflect the base |
| Class struggle | Conflict between owners and producers is the motor of change |
| Contradiction | When forces of production outgrow relations of production, a period of social revolution begins |
| Dialectic | Change through contradiction, taken from Hegel but turned “right side up”: material, not spiritual |
| Ideology / false consciousness | Ruling ideas are the ideas of the ruling class |
| Alienation | Workers separated from the products and process of their labour |
3.3 The sequence of modes of production
graph LR
A["Primitive
communism"] --> B["Ancient
(slave)"]
B --> C["Feudal"]
C --> D["Capitalist
(bourgeois)"]
D --> E["Socialist /
Communist"]The Asiatic mode of production, mentioned in the 1859 Preface, was Marx’s term for societies (including India) where he believed village communities, absence of private property in land and a despotic state blocked change. Indian historians have criticised it as a version of the colonial idea of an unchanging Orient.
3.4 Influence on historiography
| Strand | Historians |
|---|---|
| British Marxist historians | Maurice Dobb, Christopher Hill, Rodney Hilton, Eric Hobsbawm, E.P. Thompson (“history from below”) |
| Western Marxism | Antonio Gramsci (hegemony, subaltern classes), whose ideas later shaped Subaltern Studies |
| India | D.D. Kosambi, R.S. Sharma, Irfan Habib and others; see Postmodernism and Recent Trends |
3.5 Criticisms
- Economic determinism: ideas, religion and individuals reduced to reflections of the base (Marx and Engels themselves allowed for interaction; later Marxists debated “determination in the last instance”).
- Teleology: history pictured as marching to a fixed end.
- Eurocentric stages: the sequence fits European history poorly elsewhere.
- Karl Popper: The Open Society and Its Enemies (1945) and The Poverty of Historicism (1957) attacked the claim to predict history by laws.
4. Cyclical Theories Before Spengler
| Thinker | Work | Cycle |
|---|---|---|
| Indian tradition | Puranas | Four yugas (Krita/Satya, Treta, Dvapara, Kali) repeating in vast cosmic cycles |
| Polybius | Histories | Anacyclosis of constitutions |
| Ibn Khaldun (1332–1406) | Muqaddimah (1377) | Dynasties rise on asabiyya (group solidarity) of nomadic peoples, grow soft in cities and fall, usually within a few generations |
| Giambattista Vico (1668–1744) | New Science (1725) | Age of gods → age of heroes → age of men, followed by a return (corsi e ricorsi) |
5. Oswald Spengler: The Cyclical Theory
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Dates | 1880–1936, German |
| Work | Der Untergang des Abendlandes (The Decline of the West), vol. 1 1918, vol. 2 1922 |
| Method | Morphology of world history: comparing the “forms” of cultures as a biologist compares organisms; influenced by Goethe and Nietzsche |
5.1 Core ideas
- Cultures are organisms. Each high culture is born, grows, matures, decays and dies, like a living being or the seasons (spring, summer, autumn, winter). The life span of a culture is roughly a millennium.
- Culture vs civilisation. Kultur is the creative, youthful phase (religion, art, philosophy). Zivilisation is the late, rigid, exhausted phase: world-cities, money, mass society, technology, imperialism and Caesarism. Civilisation is the inevitable destiny of every culture.
- Rejection of the linear “ancient–medieval–modern” scheme, which he called a “Ptolemaic” view centred on Europe; he proposed a “Copernican” view in which all cultures are equal and parallel.
- The high cultures: he counted eight (Egyptian, Babylonian, Indian, Chinese, Classical, Arabian, Mexican and Western), with a Russian culture still to come.
- Souls of cultures: the Apollonian (Classical, the bounded body, the present moment), the Magian (Arabian, a world-cavern of spirit) and the Faustian (Western, infinite space and striving).
- Contemporaneity: phases in different cultures are “contemporary” in a morphological sense, so Alexander and Napoleon, or the late Roman world and the modern West, occupy equivalent positions.
- The West entered its civilisation phase around the 19th century; its decline was destiny, not a choice.
5.2 Criticisms
- Fatalistic determinism: no room for human will or creative renewal.
- Biological analogy stretched too far: societies are not organisms.
- Selective and impressionistic use of evidence; little archival grounding.
- Cultures treated as sealed units, ignoring contacts and borrowings.
- His language of destiny and Caesarism was used by authoritarian nationalists.
6. Arnold Joseph Toynbee: Challenge and Response
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Dates | 1889–1975, British |
| Work | A Study of History, 12 volumes, 1934–1961 (vol. 12, Reconsiderations, answered critics) |
| Abridgement | By D.C. Somervell, in two volumes (1946 and 1957); this made Toynbee widely read |
| Unit of study | The civilisation, not the nation-state (“an intelligible field of study”) |
| Number | About twenty-one civilisations in the original scheme (plus “arrested” and “abortive” ones); the list was revised in later volumes |
6.1 The four stages
| Stage | Toynbee’s explanation |
|---|---|
| Genesis | Civilisations arise not from race or easy environment but as a response to a challenge: a hard country, new ground, blows (military defeat), pressures (frontier threats) or penalisations (discrimination). The challenge must be at the “golden mean”: too weak gives no stimulus, too severe crushes |
| Growth | Led by a creative minority whose successful responses are copied by the majority through mimesis; growth means increasing self-determination and etherialisation (shift from material to spiritual); creative individuals show withdrawal and return |
| Breakdown | The creative minority loses creativity and becomes a dominant minority ruling by force; the majority withdraws mimesis; causes include the “nemesis of creativity” and idolisation of past success. Civilisations die by suicide, not by murder |
| Disintegration | Schism in the body social: dominant minority vs internal proletariat (alienated majority within) and external proletariat (barbarians beyond the frontier); a “time of troubles” ends in a universal state (e.g. the Roman empire), while the internal proletariat creates a universal church that may carry seeds of a new civilisation |
6.2 Spengler and Toynbee compared
| Spengler | Toynbee | |
|---|---|---|
| Work | The Decline of the West (1918–22) | A Study of History (1934–61) |
| Unit | Culture | Civilisation |
| Number | Eight high cultures | About twenty-one (revised later) |
| Model | Biological / seasonal life cycle | Challenge and response |
| Determinism | Fatalistic: decline is destiny | Free will: decline is failure of response, not fate |
| Mechanism of growth | Inner “soul” unfolding | Creative minority and mimesis |
| Decline | Culture hardens into civilisation | Creative minority becomes dominant minority |
| Outlook | Pessimistic | Religious hope: universal churches and spiritual progress |
| Interaction | Cultures closed and separate | Civilisations related (“affiliated”, “apparented”) |
6.3 Criticisms of Toynbee
- Empirical looseness: facts chosen to fit the scheme; the Dutch historian Pieter Geyl debated him publicly.
- “Challenge and response” is so flexible it explains everything and therefore predicts nothing.
- Growing religious and moralising tone in later volumes.
- Professional historians, among them Hugh Trevor-Roper, were sharply critical, though the work was enormously popular with general readers.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Ranke — archives, seminar, wie es eigentlich gewesen | vs | Comte / Buckle — positivist laws of history |
| Niebuhr — critique of early Roman legends, Berlin lectures | vs | Ranke — critique of modern historians (1824), seminar |
| Spengler — Decline of the West; culture → civilisation; fatalistic | vs | Toynbee — A Study of History; challenge and response; free will |
| Creative minority (growth) | vs | Dominant minority (breakdown) |
| Internal proletariat — within the civilisation | vs | External proletariat — barbarians outside |
| Base — mode of production | vs | Superstructure — law, state, ideology |
| Forces of production — technology, labour | vs | Relations of production — property, class |
| Ibn Khaldun — asabiyya, Muqaddimah (1377) | vs | Vico — New Science (1725), corsi e ricorsi |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Who wrote The Decline of the West?
- In which year did Ranke publish his first book, with its critique of earlier historians?
- What did Toynbee call the group that leads a civilisation’s growth?
Answers
- Oswald Spengler (1918, 1922).
- 1824.
- The creative minority.
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) The phrase wie es eigentlich gewesen is associated with:
- (a) Hegel
- (b) Leopold von Ranke
- (c) Karl Marx
- (d) Oswald Spengler
Answer and explanation
(b) Ranke, preface to his 1824 Histories of the Latin and Germanic Peoples.
Q2. (Practice) Consider the following statements about Toynbee:
- He took the civilisation, not the nation-state, as the intelligible unit of historical study.
- He held that the decline of every civilisation is predetermined by an organic life cycle.
- In his scheme, a universal church may arise from the internal proletariat during disintegration.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 only
- (b) 1 and 3 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 1 and 3 only. Statement 2 describes Spengler. Toynbee held that breakdown results from a failure of response, not from destiny.
Q3. (Practice) Which work contains Marx’s classic summary of the relation between the economic base and the superstructure?
- (a) The Communist Manifesto (1848)
- (b) Preface to A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy (1859)
- (c) Capital, Volume I (1867)
- (d) Socialism: Utopian and Scientific (1880)
Answer and explanation
(b). The 1859 Preface. (d) is by Engels.
Q4. (Practice) H.T. Buckle’s History of Civilization in England is best described as an example of:
- (a) Providential history
- (b) Positivist history seeking general laws
- (c) Postmodern history
- (d) Church historiography
Answer and explanation
(b). Buckle sought laws of history and stressed climate, food, soil and statistical regularities.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Ranke is often called the father of scientific history. Reason (R): Ranke insisted that history be based on critically examined contemporary sources, and trained historians in research seminars.
Answer and explanation
(a). R explains A.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): Spengler distinguished Kultur from Zivilisation. Reason (R): For Spengler, Zivilisation is the creative, youthful phase of a culture.
Answer and explanation
(c). A is true. R is false: Zivilisation is the late, rigid, declining phase; Kultur is the creative one.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (thinker) with List II (concept).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Ibn Khaldun | I. Faustian soul |
| B. Spengler | II. Asabiyya |
| C. Toynbee | III. Law of three stages |
| D. Comte | IV. Withdrawal and return |
- (1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
- (2) A-I, B-II, C-IV, D-III
- (3) A-II, B-IV, C-I, D-III
- (4) A-II, B-I, C-III, D-IV
Answer and explanation
(1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following works in chronological order:
- The Decline of the West (first volume)
- History of Civilization in England (first volume)
- A Study of History (first volumes)
- The New Science
- (a) 4, 2, 1, 3
- (b) 2, 4, 1, 3
- (c) 4, 1, 2, 3
- (d) 4, 2, 3, 1
Answer and explanation
(a) 4, 2, 1, 3. Vico 1725 → Buckle 1857 → Spengler 1918 → Toynbee 1934.
Q5. (Practice) Arrange Toynbee’s phases of a civilisation in order: breakdown, genesis, disintegration, growth.
Answer and explanation
Genesis → growth → breakdown → disintegration.
Quick Revision Table
| Thinker | Work and year | Key terms |
|---|---|---|
| Comte | Course in Positive Philosophy (1830–42) | Law of three stages; positivism |
| Buckle | History of Civilization in England (1857, 1861) | Laws of history; climate, food, soil |
| Niebuhr | Roman History (from 1811) | Critique of early Roman legend; Berlin |
| Ranke (1795–1886) | Latin and Germanic Peoples (1824); Roman Popes (1834–36) | Wie es eigentlich gewesen; archives; seminar; “every epoch is immediate to God” |
| Sybel | Historische Zeitschrift (1859) | Ranke’s pupil |
| Marx and Engels | Manifesto (1848); 1859 Preface; Capital I (1867) | Base, superstructure, class struggle, modes of production |
| Ibn Khaldun | Muqaddimah (1377) | Asabiyya |
| Vico | New Science (1725) | Gods, heroes, men; corsi e ricorsi |
| Spengler (1880–1936) | Decline of the West (1918, 1922) | Culture → civilisation; eight cultures; Apollonian, Magian, Faustian |
| Toynbee (1889–1975) | A Study of History (12 vols, 1934–61) | Challenge and response; creative minority; mimesis; withdrawal and return; internal and external proletariat; universal state and church |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
The grand schemes of Marx, Spengler and Toynbee were the “metanarratives” that postmodernism attacked. Continue with Postmodernism and Recent Trends in Historiography, which also covers regional history and recent Indian historiography.