Nature of History: Scope, Objectivity, Causation and Auxiliary Sciences
UGC NET History Unit 10: scope and importance of history, objectivity and bias, science or art, causation, imagination and the auxiliary sciences.
- 19 min
On this page · 16 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Two Lectures, Sixty Years Apart
- 1. What History Is
- 2. Scope and Importance of History
- 3. Objectivity and Bias in History
- 4. History: A Science, an Art or a Social Science?
- 5. Causation in History
- 6. Imagination in History
- 7. History and Its Auxiliary Sciences
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Unit 10 overview — the twenty-one official syllabus lines and the page that covers each.
- Research: Meaning, Types and Approaches (Paper 1) — positivism, induction and deduction, which this page applies to history.
- A working memory of the sources of ancient Indian history helps: the auxiliary sciences below are the tools used there.
The Hook: Two Lectures, Sixty Years Apart
How UGC NET asks it: match the thinker with the definition or quotation (“All history is contemporary history” → Croce); statements on objectivity and bias; assertion–reason on why history is not an experimental science; classification of auxiliary sciences (diplomatics, sphragistics, palaeography).
1. What History Is
1.1 The word
The English history comes, through Latin, from the Greek historia, “inquiry” or “knowledge gained by inquiry”. Herodotus opens his work by calling it the setting-out of his historia. The word therefore began as a name for a method (asking, investigating) before it became a name for the past itself.
Two senses are still worth separating:
| Sense | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| History as events (res gestae) | What actually happened in the past | The Revolt of 1857 itself |
| History as account (historia rerum gestarum) | What historians write about what happened | Savarkar’s, Sen’s or Mukherjee’s books on 1857 |
| Historiography | The study of how history has been written: methods, schools, debates | A survey of nationalist, Marxist and subaltern readings of 1857 |
1.2 Definitions to know by author
| Thinker | Definition or claim | Where |
|---|---|---|
| Cicero | History is magistra vitae, “the teacher of life” (with lux veritatis, “light of truth”) | De Oratore |
| Leopold von Ranke | The historian’s task is to show wie es eigentlich gewesen, “how it actually (essentially) was” | Preface to his first book, 1824 |
| J.B. Bury | History is “a science, no less and no more” | Cambridge inaugural lecture, 1903 |
| Benedetto Croce | “All history is contemporary history”: the past is written from present concerns | Theory and History of Historiography (Italian, 1917) |
| R.G. Collingwood | “All history is the history of thought”; the historian re-enacts past thought | The Idea of History (posthumous, 1946) |
| Marc Bloch | History is the “science of men in time” | The Historian’s Craft (posthumous, 1949) |
| E.H. Carr | “An unending dialogue between the present and the past”; study the historian before the facts | What is History? (1961) |
| Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels | The history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggles | Communist Manifesto (1848) |
| Thomas Carlyle | History is at bottom the biography of great men | On Heroes, Hero-Worship and the Heroic in History (1841) |
| Hegel | Peoples and governments have never learned anything from history | Lectures on the Philosophy of History |
2. Scope and Importance of History
2.1 Scope
The scope of history has widened from past politics (the 19th-century view; E.A. Freeman’s maxim “history is past politics” is the usual example) to every human activity that has left evidence.
| Dimension | Range |
|---|---|
| Subject matter | Political, constitutional, administrative, military, diplomatic, economic, social, religious, intellectual, cultural, art, science and technology, environmental, gender, labour, caste, urban |
| Space | World and global, regional (South Asia, the Indian Ocean), national, regional within the nation (Bengal, the Deccan), local, a single village |
| Time | Prehistory (no writing), protohistory (writing undeciphered or known only from others), history (written records); ancient, medieval, modern, contemporary |
| Scale | Macro (civilisations, empires, centuries) to micro (one village, one trial, one life) |
| Actors | Rulers and elites, and also peasants, workers, women, tribes, Dalits, the “people without history” |
| Sources | Texts, inscriptions, coins, monuments, artefacts, oral testimony, images, landscapes, statistics, digital records |
Periodisation is itself part of the scope debate. James Mill’s History of British India (1817) split India’s past into Hindu, Muslim and British periods. Historians now prefer ancient, early medieval, medieval, modern or periods defined by economy and society, because religious labels impose a communal reading on the past.
2.2 Importance (uses of history)
| Use | What it means |
|---|---|
| Understanding the present | Present institutions (caste, land tenure, the Constitution) are the outcome of past processes |
| Identity and memory | Nations, communities and regions define themselves through a shared past |
| Citizenship | History trains judgement on public questions and resistance to propaganda |
| Lessons and perspective | Not exact repetition, but comparison: famines, epidemics, partitions, reforms |
| Critical thinking | Weighing evidence, detecting bias, holding competing explanations in mind |
| Cultural heritage | Monuments, archives, oral traditions preserved and interpreted |
| Base for other disciplines | Economics, sociology, political science and law all need historical data |
| Moral and humanistic education | Lord Acton argued that the historian should not suspend moral judgement |
3. Objectivity and Bias in History
3.1 The objectivity debate
Objectivity means representing the past as the evidence shows it, free from the historian’s personal, group or ideological preferences.
| Position | Thinkers | Argument |
|---|---|---|
| Strong objectivity | Ranke (as usually read); J.B. Bury; Lord Acton’s plan for the Cambridge Modern History, where an account of Waterloo should satisfy French, English, Germans and Dutch alike | Facts exist independently; critical method, archives and impartial narrative can recover them |
| Relativism | Carl Becker, “Everyman His Own Historian” (American Historical Association address, 1931); Charles Beard, “That Noble Dream” (1935); Croce | Every age and every historian rewrites the past from its own standpoint; complete objectivity is a “noble dream” |
| Middle position | E.H. Carr | Facts do not “speak for themselves”; the historian selects them. But an objective historian is one who rises above the limits of his own time and selects the facts that matter for the long-term direction of history |
| Empiricist reply | G.R. Elton, The Practice of History (1967) | The archive disciplines the historian; method can produce reliable knowledge |
| Postmodern challenge | Hayden White, Keith Jenkins | History is a narrative construct; see Postmodernism and Recent Trends |
Peter Novick’s That Noble Dream: The “Objectivity Question” and the American Historical Profession (1988) is the standard survey of this debate; its title borrows Beard’s phrase.
Carr’s well-known images: the common-sense view he rejects treats facts like fish on a fishmonger’s slab, which the historian simply collects, takes home and cooks. His own view is that facts are like fish swimming in a vast ocean: what the historian catches depends on where he chooses to fish and what tackle he uses. Not every fact about the past is a historical fact: millions crossed the Rubicon, but Caesar’s crossing became a historical fact because historians decided it mattered.
3.2 Kinds of bias
| Bias | Description | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Personal | The historian’s likes, dislikes, temperament | A biographer who admires his subject |
| Group / national | Loyalty to nation, region, community | Imperial histories that praise “civilising” rule; nationalist histories that hide internal conflict |
| Religious / communal | Viewing the past through religious identity | Reading medieval politics only as Hindu versus Muslim |
| Racial | Hierarchies of race | Theories of Aryan racial superiority |
| Ideological / theoretical | Prior commitment to a theory | Forcing evidence into a fixed scheme of stages |
| Source bias | What survived and who wrote it | Court chronicles praising patrons; colonial records written by those who suppressed revolts |
| Presentism / anachronism | Judging or explaining the past by present values or concepts | Calling an ancient gana-sangha a “democracy” in the modern sense |
| Whig interpretation | Reading the past as steady progress towards the present | Named by Herbert Butterfield, The Whig Interpretation of History (1931) |
| Confirmation bias | Seeking only evidence that supports one’s thesis | Ignoring documents that contradict the hypothesis |
3.3 Controlling bias
- Source criticism: test every document for authenticity and credibility (see Historical Method).
- Corroboration: two independent sources are stronger than ten that copy one another.
- Multiple perspectives: read the sources of rulers and ruled, colonisers and colonised.
- Transparency: footnotes let readers check every claim.
- Self-awareness: state your assumptions; Carr’s advice to study the historian applies to oneself.
- Peer review and debate: the profession corrects individual bias over time.
4. History: A Science, an Art or a Social Science?
4.1 The case for science
| Argument | Who made it |
|---|---|
| History uses a critical method of collecting and testing evidence | Ranke and the 19th-century German school |
| History can find general laws of social development | Comte’s positivism; H.T. Buckle, History of Civilization in England (1857–61); Marx |
| “Science” means systematic, organised knowledge (German Wissenschaft), not laboratory science | Bury; Collingwood called history a science in this sense |
| Explanations in history use general laws like any science (the covering-law model) | Carl Hempel, “The Function of General Laws in History” (1942) |
4.2 The case against
| Difference from natural science | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| No experiment | Past events cannot be repeated under controlled conditions |
| Uniqueness | Each event is individual; the French Revolution happened once |
| No direct observation | The historian knows the past only through surviving traces |
| No reliable prediction | History cannot forecast the future as physics forecasts an eclipse |
| Human will and chance | Actors choose; accidents intervene |
| The historian is part of the subject | Values and selection enter at every step |
Wilhelm Windelband’s distinction (1894) is the classic formula: the natural sciences are nomothetic (law-making, seeking the general), history is idiographic (describing the particular). Wilhelm Dilthey separated the human sciences (Geisteswissenschaften), which seek understanding (Verstehen) of meaning, from the natural sciences, which seek explanation.
4.3 The case for art
- History must be written: selection, arrangement, narrative and style are literary skills.
- It needs imagination to recreate past life (see section 6).
- G.M. Trevelyan’s essay “Clio, a Muse” defended history as a literary art against Bury’s science.
- Great historians from Herodotus to Macaulay and Gibbon are read as literature.
4.4 The case for social science
- Since the 20th century, history borrows concepts and methods from economics, sociology, anthropology, demography and geography.
- The Annales school (from 1929) practised history as a social science of long-term structures.
- Quantitative history (cliometrics) uses statistics like economics.
4.5 The balanced answer
| Feature | Science | Art | Social science |
|---|---|---|---|
| Method | Critical, evidence-based | — | Concepts, models, comparison |
| Aim | True knowledge of the past | Recreation and communication | Explanation of social structures and change |
| Product | Verified facts | Narrative | Analysis and generalisation |
History is all three in different respects: scientific in its method, artistic in its presentation, and a social science in its concepts and subject matter. It is not a natural science, because it cannot experiment or predict.
5. Causation in History
5.1 Why causation matters
To write history is to explain, and to explain is to give causes. Thucydides set the pattern: behind the stated grievances of the Peloponnesian War he placed the “truest cause”, the growth of Athenian power and the fear it caused in Sparta. Carr put it plainly in his chapter on causation: the study of history is a study of causes.
5.2 Kinds of causes
| Distinction | Meaning | Example (Revolt of 1857) |
|---|---|---|
| Immediate (proximate) vs remote (underlying) | The trigger vs the long-term conditions | Greased cartridges vs annexations, revenue policy, social reform anxieties |
| Necessary vs sufficient | Without which the event could not happen vs which alone guarantees it | Sepoy grievances were necessary but not by themselves sufficient |
| Material vs ideal | Economic and structural vs ideas, beliefs, intentions | Revenue burden vs fears for religion and caste |
| Accidental (chance) vs rational | Unrepeatable contingencies vs causes that can be generalised | A particular officer’s decision vs grievances shared across regiments |
5.3 Monocausal theories
| Theory | Single determining factor | Associated with |
|---|---|---|
| Providential | The will of God | Augustine, City of God; medieval chroniclers |
| Great man | Heroic individuals | Carlyle |
| Geographical | Climate, soil, terrain | Montesquieu; Buckle |
| Economic / materialist | Mode of production, class struggle | Marx and Engels |
| Racial | Race | Gobineau (19th century); discredited |
| Cyclical | Fixed life cycles of cultures | Spengler; see Philosophies of History |
Modern historians prefer multiple causation: several interacting causes, ranked in a hierarchy of importance. Carr insisted that the historian’s job is not to list causes but to arrange them, deciding which is the ultimate cause.
5.4 Chance and accident
Pascal’s quip that if Cleopatra’s nose had been shorter the face of the world would have changed is the standard example of the “chance” view. Carr’s reply uses the story of Robinson, killed by a drunk driver with faulty brakes on a blind corner while going out to buy cigarettes. Nobody would say the cigarettes caused his death: the historian selects rational causes that can be generalised and acted on (drink-driving, brakes, road design), and treats accidents as real but not explanatory.
5.5 Fallacies of causation
- Post hoc ergo propter hoc: “after this, therefore because of this”.
- Single-cause reduction: ignoring interacting factors.
- Teleology: explaining events by an outcome nobody at the time could foresee.
- Determinism versus free will: total determinism leaves no room for choice; total voluntarism ignores structures. Marx’s own line in The Eighteenth Brumaire (1852) is the usual middle: people make their own history, but not in circumstances they choose.
- Counterfactuals (“what if?”) can test causal claims but cannot be verified.
6. Imagination in History
Evidence never tells the whole story. Between two fixed points (Caesar in Rome on one date, in Gaul on another) the historian infers the journey. R.G. Collingwood called this the historical or a priori imagination in his Oxford inaugural lecture “The Historical Imagination” (1935): a web of imaginative construction stretched between fixed points supplied by evidence.
| Historical imagination | Fiction |
|---|---|
| Bound by evidence: every inference must be consistent with sources | Free to invent |
| Fills gaps by reasoned inference | Fills gaps by creative choice |
| Aims at truth | Aims at aesthetic effect |
| Open to checking by other historians | Not checkable against evidence |
Uses of imagination: reconstructing motives (Collingwood’s re-enactment of past thought), picturing everyday life, framing questions and hypotheses, choosing a narrative form. Its danger is romanticisation and anachronism. The safe formula: imagination is disciplined by evidence.
7. History and Its Auxiliary Sciences
Auxiliary sciences (German Hilfswissenschaften) are the specialised disciplines that help the historian find, read, date and authenticate sources.
7.1 Classical auxiliary sciences
| Discipline | Studies | Use to the historian |
|---|---|---|
| Palaeography | Ancient and medieval handwriting and scripts | Reading and dating manuscripts and inscriptions |
| Epigraphy | Inscriptions on stone, metal, etc. | Ashokan edicts, prashastis, land grants |
| Diplomatics | Form and authenticity of official documents (charters, grants) | Detecting forged charters; founded as a method by Jean Mabillon, De re diplomatica (1681) |
| Numismatics | Coins and currency | Rulers, dates, extent of territory, economy |
| Sphragistics (sigillography) | Seals | Authentication of documents; Harappan seals |
| Chronology | Systems of dating and eras | Converting Shaka, Vikrama, Gupta and Hijri dates |
| Genealogy | Family descent | Dynastic history; Puranic lists |
| Heraldry | Coats of arms | European medieval and early modern history |
| Philology | Historical development of languages and texts | Dating texts by language; Lorenzo Valla’s exposure of the Donation of Constantine (1440) |
| Codicology | The manuscript book as a physical object | Dating and placing manuscripts |
| Metrology | Historical weights and measures | Harappan weights, revenue units |
| Archival science | Arrangement and preservation of records | Finding and citing archival material |
| Toponymy | Place names | Tracing settlement and migration |
7.2 Allied disciplines
| Discipline | Contribution |
|---|---|
| Archaeology | Material evidence, especially for periods without writing |
| Geography | Physical setting, routes, resources; historical geography |
| Economics | Concepts of production, trade, prices; economic history |
| Sociology and social anthropology | Caste, kinship, class, social structure; ethnography |
| Political science | State, power, institutions |
| Psychology | Motives and mentalities; psychohistory |
| Literature and linguistics | Texts as evidence; reading meanings and genres |
| Statistics and demography | Population, prices, quantitative history |
| Natural sciences | Radiocarbon and other dating, DNA, palaeoclimate, pollen analysis |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Palaeography — handwriting and scripts | vs | Epigraphy — inscriptions as documents |
| Diplomatics — authenticity and form of documents (Mabillon) | vs | Diplomacy — relations between states |
| Sphragistics — seals | vs | Numismatics — coins |
| Nomothetic (law-seeking, natural science) | vs | Idiographic (particular, history) — Windelband |
| Croce — “all history is contemporary history” | vs | Collingwood — “all history is the history of thought” |
| Becker — “Everyman His Own Historian” (1931) | vs | Beard — “That Noble Dream” (1935); Novick — book of that title (1988) |
| Butterfield — Whig Interpretation of History (1931) | vs | Carr — What is History? (1961) |
| Immediate cause (trigger) | vs | Remote cause (underlying conditions) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- What does the Greek word historia mean?
- Who described history as “an unending dialogue between the present and the past”?
- Which auxiliary science studies seals?
Answers
- Inquiry (knowledge gained by inquiry).
- E.H. Carr, What is History? (1961).
- Sphragistics (sigillography).
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) “All history is the history of thought” is associated with:
- (a) Benedetto Croce
- (b) R.G. Collingwood
- (c) Leopold von Ranke
- (d) J.B. Bury
Answer and explanation
(b) R.G. Collingwood, The Idea of History. Croce’s line is “all history is contemporary history”; Ranke’s is wie es eigentlich gewesen; Bury’s is “a science, no less and no more”.
Q2. (Practice) Consider the following statements:
- History cannot be a natural science because past events cannot be reproduced experimentally.
- Windelband described history as a nomothetic discipline.
- Collingwood regarded history as a science in the sense of organised, evidence-based inquiry.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 only
- (b) 1 and 3 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 1 and 3 only. Windelband called history idiographic (concerned with the particular); the natural sciences are nomothetic.
Q3. (Practice) Jean Mabillon’s De re diplomatica (1681) laid the foundation of which auxiliary science?
- (a) Palaeography only
- (b) Diplomatics
- (c) Numismatics
- (d) Heraldry
Answer and explanation
(b) Diplomatics, the critical study of the form and authenticity of documents. Mabillon’s work also advanced the study of medieval scripts, but the discipline it founded is diplomatics.
Q4. (Practice) A historian explains a 19th-century reform movement as a necessary step towards present-day democracy, ignoring what contemporaries intended. This is an example of:
- (a) Source bias
- (b) The Whig interpretation of history
- (c) External criticism
- (d) Idiographic method
Answer and explanation
(b). Reading the past as progress towards the present is what Herbert Butterfield (1931) called the Whig interpretation.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): According to E.H. Carr, not every fact about the past is a historical fact. Reason (R): A fact becomes historical when historians select it as significant.
Answer and explanation
(a). Carr’s Rubicon example: many people crossed the river, but only Caesar’s crossing was selected as significant. R explains A.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): Historical imagination is a legitimate part of historical method. Reason (R): The historian is free to invent events where the sources are silent.
Answer and explanation
(c). A is true (Collingwood’s a priori imagination). R is false: imagination fills gaps by inference consistent with evidence, not by invention.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (thinker) with List II (idea).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Benedetto Croce | I. History as the biography of great men |
| B. Thomas Carlyle | II. All history is contemporary history |
| C. Carl Becker | III. Covering-law model of explanation |
| D. Carl Hempel | IV. “Everyman His Own Historian” |
- (1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
- (2) A-I, B-II, C-IV, D-III
- (3) A-II, B-I, C-III, D-IV
- (4) A-IV, B-I, C-II, D-III
Answer and explanation
(1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following in chronological order:
- Carl Becker, “Everyman His Own Historian”
- J.B. Bury, Cambridge inaugural lecture on the science of history
- E.H. Carr, What is History?
- Carl Hempel, “The Function of General Laws in History”
- (a) 2, 1, 4, 3
- (b) 2, 4, 1, 3
- (c) 1, 2, 4, 3
- (d) 4, 2, 1, 3
Answer and explanation
(a) 2, 1, 4, 3. Bury 1903 → Becker 1931 → Hempel 1942 → Carr 1961.
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Key fact |
|---|---|
| Historia | Greek, “inquiry” |
| Ranke | Wie es eigentlich gewesen (1824) |
| Bury | “A science, no less and no more” (1903) |
| Croce | “All history is contemporary history” |
| Collingwood | History of thought; re-enactment; historical imagination (1935); The Idea of History (1946) |
| Bloch | “Science of men in time”; The Historian’s Craft (1949) |
| Carr | What is History? (1961); dialogue; fish in the ocean, not on the fishmonger’s slab; Rubicon; Robinson; hierarchy of causes |
| Becker / Beard / Novick | 1931 / 1935 / 1988 — relativism and the “noble dream” |
| Butterfield | Whig interpretation (1931) |
| Windelband | Nomothetic vs idiographic (1894) |
| Dilthey | Verstehen; human sciences |
| Hempel | Covering-law model (1942) |
| Mabillon | Diplomatics, 1681 |
| Valla | Donation of Constantine exposed by philology, 1440 |
| Sphragistics | Seals |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
From what history is to how it is done: heuristics, external and internal criticism, synthesis and the classification of sources in Historical Method: Sources, Criticism and Synthesis. The chapter overview lists every topic, and Paper 1’s Methods and Steps of Research gives the general research process this unit specialises.