Polity, Kingship and Debates on State Formation
UGC NET History Unit 3: samanta system, administration, legitimation of kingship, and feudal, segmentary and integrative models of the early medieval state.
- 15 min
On this page · 11 sections
Prerequisites
- Agrarian Economy, Trade and Urbanisation — land grants, coin paucity and urban decay are the evidence the feudal model rests on.
- Kingdoms of the Deccan and South India — the Chola material behind the segmentary model.
- Vedic and Later Vedic Periods — earlier theories of the state (saptanga, divine and contract theories) that early medieval kings drew on.
The Hook: One Chola Inscription, Three Readings
How UGC NET asks it: match historian with model or book; statement questions on features of each model; assertion–reason on the critiques (Mukhia, Sircar, Chattopadhyaya); terms like samanta, mahasamanta, ritual sovereignty, nuclear area.
1. Characteristics of Early Medieval Polity
1.1 Political structure
| Feature | Detail |
|---|---|
| Many regional kingdoms | No all-India empire after Harsha (d. 647); the Pratiharas, Rashtrakutas and Cholas were the largest |
| Grandiose titles | Maharajadhiraja paramabhattaraka parameshvara for overlords; samanta, mahasamanta, mahamandaleshvara for subordinates |
| Samanta system | Defeated kings and chiefs kept their lands as samantas, owing tribute, military service and court attendance |
| Land for service | Officials and soldiers increasingly paid by land assignments (bhoga, jivita) |
| Rise of regional elites | Rajput clans in the north, nayakas and vellala landholders in the south, brahmana and temple corporations everywhere |
| Copper plates | Royal grants became the normal record of royal action and the chief evidence of administration |
1.2 The samanta: from neighbour to vassal
The word samanta originally meant a neighbouring ruler. From about the 6th century it came to mean a subordinate ruler or vassal. The obligations of a samanta, as gathered from inscriptions and texts such as the Harshacharita and the Aparajitaprichchha:
| Obligation | Example |
|---|---|
| Attend the overlord’s court and pay homage | Samantas bowing at Harsha’s camp in Banabhatta’s Harshacharita |
| Pay tribute | Fixed or occasional |
| Provide troops in war | Feudatory contingents in Pratihara and Rashtrakuta armies |
| Mention the overlord in their own grants | Grants dated “in the victorious reign of” the overlord |
| Use the overlord’s era and titles | Feudatories date by the overlord’s era |
| Give daughters in marriage | Alliance by marriage |
Ranks within the system multiplied: mahasamanta, samanta, mandaleshvara, raja, ranaka, thakkura, in rough order of status; the 12th-century Aparajitaprichchha (a text on architecture) ranks feudatories and the size of their palaces.
1.3 Administration
| Level | North (Pratihara, Pala, Paramara) | Deccan (Rashtrakuta) | South (Chola) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Province | Bhukti | Rashtra (under a rashtrapati) | Mandalam |
| District | Vishaya / mandala | Vishaya (vishayapati) | Valanadu |
| Locality | Pattala / pathaka | Bhukti (smaller unit here) | Nadu |
| Village | Grama (gramapati, gramakuta) | Grama (gramakuta) | Ur, sabha, nagaram |
Central officials recorded in grants include the mahasandhivigrahika (minister of peace and war, who often drafted grants), the mahadandanayaka (commander), the mahakshapatalika (keeper of records), the mahapratihara (chamberlain) and the purohita. The Pala grants list unusually long rosters of officials.
1.4 Legitimation of kingship
New dynasties, many of them of humble or tribal origin, needed to justify their rule. The tools:
| Means | Examples |
|---|---|
| Genealogy | Descent from the Solar (Suryavamsha) or Lunar (Chandravamsha) lines, or from epic heroes; Pratiharas from Lakshmana (the “door-keeper” of Rama); Varmans of Kamarupa from Naraka and Bhagadatta |
| Origin myths | The Agnikula fire-pit story (earliest version for the Paramaras in Padmagupta’s Navasahasankacharita); the Pala claim that Gopala was chosen by the prakriti (Khalimpur plate) |
| Prashasti | Court poems in inscriptions: Aihole (Pulakeshin II), Gwalior (Mihira Bhoja), Deopara (Vijayasena) |
| Vedic and Puranic rituals | Ashvamedha (Pulakeshin I), hiranyagarbha (Dantidurga at Ujjayini), tulapurusha (weighing the king against gold) and the other mahadanas |
| Land grants to brahmanas | Gifts bought ritual support and created brahmana settlements that spread royal authority |
| Temple building and state cults | Brihadeshvara (Rajarajeshvaram) at Thanjavur tied the Chola king to Shiva; the Eastern Ganga king Anangabhima III declared Jagannath the true ruler of Odisha and himself the god’s deputy (rauta) |
| Patronage of learning | Court poets, Sanskrit colleges, regional literature |
2. Debates on State Formation
2.1 The feudal model
Who: D.D. Kosambi (An Introduction to the Study of Indian History, 1956), R.S. Sharma (Indian Feudalism, c. 300–1200, 1965; Urban Decay in India, 1987; Early Medieval Indian Society: A Study in Feudalisation, 2001), B.N.S. Yadava (Society and Culture in Northern India in the Twelfth Century, 1973), with D.N. Jha and others.
Kosambi’s two phrases:
- Feudalism from above: the king creates feudatories by grants and by subordinating chiefs.
- Feudalism from below: a class of landholders grows within the village, between the state and the peasant.
R.S. Sharma’s argument as a chain:
graph TD
A["Land grants to brahmanas, temples, officials
(with fiscal, administrative, judicial rights)"] --> B["Parcellisation of sovereignty
rise of landed intermediaries"]
C["Decline of long-distance trade
paucity of coins"] --> D["Officials paid in land
urban decay"]
D --> B
B --> E["Peasants subjected to forced labour (vishti),
new taxes, restrictions on movement"]
E --> F["Self-sufficient closed village economy"]
G["Social crisis of the Kali age
(varna order threatened)"] --> A- Kali age crisis: Sharma read the Puranic descriptions of the Kali age (shudras refusing to pay taxes or serve, varna mixing) as a real social crisis of the 3rd–4th centuries, to which the ruling class responded by granting land: giving the land and its peasants to brahmanas and officials to keep order.
- Features claimed: subinfeudation, military service, forced labour, decline of trade and towns, decline of coins, regional cultures and languages, and the dominance of a landed aristocracy.
- Second phase: Sharma saw a revival of trade and towns from c. 1000, weakening the feudal order.
Critiques of the feudal model:
| Critic | Argument |
|---|---|
| Harbans Mukhia, “Was there feudalism in Indian history?” (Journal of Peasant Studies, 1981) | No serfdom: Indian peasants controlled the process of production; fertile land and simple technology meant surplus was extracted by tax, not by labour rent. European feudalism was a specific system; India had a “free peasant” economy |
| D.C. Sircar | Grants transferred revenue rights, not ownership or political power; terms were misread; “landlordism” is not feudalism |
| B.D. Chattopadhyaya | The model assumes a pre-existing centralised state that broke down; but in many regions grants created state society where none existed; urban decline was not universal |
| Burton Stein | The European model does not fit south India’s peasant localities |
| Numismatists (J.S. Deyell) | Coinage did not disappear; the paucity premise is weak |
| Defenders’ reply | R.S. Sharma (in “How feudal was Indian feudalism?”, Journal of Peasant Studies) answered that feudalism need not copy Europe; the core is a landed intermediary class living off a subject peasantry |
2.2 The segmentary model
Who: Burton Stein, Peasant State and Society in Medieval South India (1980), using the Chola state; he borrowed the idea from the anthropologist Aidan Southall, Alur Society (1956), a study of an East African people.
| Feature | Meaning in Stein’s model |
|---|---|
| Segments | The nadu (peasant locality of vellala landholders) was the basic political unit, largely self-governing |
| Centre and periphery | Power was concentrated at a core (around Thanjavur) and became weaker towards the periphery |
| Ritual vs political sovereignty | The king held real political power only at the centre; elsewhere his sovereignty was ritual, acknowledged through temple worship, gifts and titles |
| Pyramidal segments | Many centres of power with similar structures, nested like a pyramid |
| Brahmana–peasant alliance | The alliance of brahmanas (brahmadeyas, temples) and dominant peasants (vellalas) underpinned the order, not a royal bureaucracy |
| Shifting allegiance | Peripheral segments could transfer loyalty to another centre |
Critiques:
- Chola inscriptions record revenue surveys, land assessments, a revenue department, officials and royal orders reaching localities: Y. Subbarayalu, Noboru Karashima, R. Champakalakshmi and Kesavan Veluthat argue for a real, if limited, bureaucratic state with growing centralisation under Rajaraja I and Rajendra I.
- Applying an African stateless-society model to a large, literate agrarian kingdom is questioned.
- The model underplays conflict and change over time.
Stein later extended the idea to Vijayanagara.
2.3 The integrative model
Who: B.D. Chattopadhyaya (The Making of Early Medieval India, 1994; essays from the 1970s–80s), Hermann Kulke (the “processual” model; The State in India 1000–1700, ed. 1995; Kings and Cults, 1993), and others such as Surajit Sinha on state formation among tribes.
| Feature | Meaning |
|---|---|
| State formation as a process | Not the decline of an older empire, but the spread of state society to new regions: local chiefdoms became kingdoms |
| Agrarian expansion | Land grants and brahmana settlements pushed settled agriculture into forested and tribal areas |
| Integration of local elites | Tribal and local chiefs absorbed as samantas or Rajput lineages; new genealogies |
| Integration of cults | Local deities (often tribal) Sanskritised and linked to Shiva, Vishnu or the goddess; regional cult centres like Jagannath |
| Integration of peoples | Tribes drawn into the varna order as peasants or castes |
| Regional identity | Regional languages, scripts, temple styles and kingdoms grew together |
Kulke’s stages (processual model):
graph LR
A["Chieftaincy
tribal or local chief"] --> B["Early kingdom
nuclear area, grants, temples"]
B --> C["Imperial regional kingdom
absorbs neighbouring nuclear areas
samantas, state cult"]Critiques: the model can make the process look harmonious, playing down coercion, conflict and exploitation (a point made by defenders of the feudal model); and “integration” can be a description rather than an explanation.
2.4 The three models side by side
| Feudal | Segmentary | Integrative | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Key scholars | Kosambi, R.S. Sharma, B.N.S. Yadava, D.N. Jha | Burton Stein (after Aidan Southall) | B.D. Chattopadhyaya, Hermann Kulke |
| Main region | North India | South India (Cholas) | Orissa, Rajasthan, Bengal; all-India |
| Direction | Decentralisation, decline | Weak centre, ritual sovereignty | Expansion and integration |
| Land grants mean | Fragmenting sovereignty | Brahmana–peasant alliance | Agrarian expansion, new state society |
| Towns and trade | Decline (c. 300–1000) | Not central | Growth of new centres |
| Peasant | Subjected, near-serf | Dominant peasant (vellala) locality | Expanding, includes tribes |
| Main critics | Mukhia, Sircar, Chattopadhyaya | Subbarayalu, Karashima, Veluthat | Feudalism school (coercion ignored) |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Feudalism from above — state creates vassals | vs | Feudalism from below — landholders rise inside the village (both Kosambi) |
| Ritual sovereignty — Stein, periphery | vs | Political sovereignty — Stein, core |
| Aidan Southall — Alur (Africa), origin of the segmentary idea | vs | Burton Stein — applied it to the Cholas |
| Harbans Mukhia — no serfdom, free peasant | vs | D.C. Sircar — grants were revenue rights only |
| Samanta (early) — neighbouring king | vs | Samanta (from c. 6th century) — vassal |
| Bhukti (north) — province | vs | Bhukti (Rashtrakuta) — sub-district |
| Hiranyagarbha — Dantidurga’s rebirth from a golden womb | vs | Tulapurusha — king weighed against gold |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Who wrote Indian Feudalism, c. 300–1200?
- From whose study of an African society did Burton Stein borrow the segmentary model?
- What did the word samanta originally mean?
Answers
- R.S. Sharma (1965).
- Aidan Southall, Alur Society (1956).
- A neighbouring ruler; later it came to mean a subordinate ruler or vassal.
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) The phrases “feudalism from above” and “feudalism from below” were used by:
- (a) R.S. Sharma
- (b) D.D. Kosambi
- (c) Harbans Mukhia
- (d) B.N.S. Yadava
Answer and explanation
(b) D.D. Kosambi, in An Introduction to the Study of Indian History (1956).
Q2. (Practice) Consider the following statements about Burton Stein’s segmentary state:
- The nadu was the basic unit of the political order.
- The king’s sovereignty in the periphery was mainly ritual.
- A strong centralised bureaucracy controlled revenue in every locality.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 only
- (b) 1 and 2 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 1 and 2 only. Statement 3 is the view of Stein’s critics, not of Stein.
Q3. (Practice) Which historian argued that early medieval state formation was a process of integrating local and tribal societies, cults and elites into regional kingdoms?
- (a) R.S. Sharma
- (b) B.D. Chattopadhyaya
- (c) D.C. Sircar
- (d) K.A. Nilakanta Sastri
Answer and explanation
(b) B.D. Chattopadhyaya (The Making of Early Medieval India, 1994).
Q4. (Practice) The Rashtrakuta founder Dantidurga legitimised his new power by performing which ritual at Ujjayini?
- (a) Ashvamedha
- (b) Rajasuya
- (c) Hiranyagarbha
- (d) Vajapeya
Answer and explanation
(c) Hiranyagarbha, recorded in the later Sanjan copper plates of Amoghavarsha I (871), which say that kings such as the Gurjara ruler served as door-keepers at the ceremony.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Harbans Mukhia rejected the application of the feudal model to India. Reason (R): Mukhia argued that Indian peasants, unlike European serfs, retained control over the process of production.
Answer and explanation
(a). The absence of serfdom (peasant control of production, surplus extracted as tax) is the core of Mukhia’s argument.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): The integrative model treats the multiplication of land grants as a sign of political decline. Reason (R): Land grants often carried settled agriculture and brahmana communities into previously tribal areas.
Answer and explanation
(d). A is false: decline is the feudal reading. R is true and is in fact the integrative reading.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (historian) with List II (work).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Burton Stein | I. Indian Feudalism |
| B. R.S. Sharma | II. The Making of Early Medieval India |
| C. B.D. Chattopadhyaya | III. Peasant State and Society in Medieval South India |
| D. B.N.S. Yadava | IV. Society and Culture in Northern India in the Twelfth Century |
- (1) A-III, B-I, C-II, D-IV
- (2) A-I, B-III, C-II, D-IV
- (3) A-III, B-II, C-I, D-IV
- (4) A-IV, B-I, C-II, D-III
Answer and explanation
(1) A-III, B-I, C-II, D-IV.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following works in chronological order of publication: (1) Mukhia, “Was there feudalism in Indian history?”, (2) Kosambi, An Introduction to the Study of Indian History, (3) Stein, Peasant State and Society, (4) Sharma, Indian Feudalism.
- (a) 2, 4, 3, 1
- (b) 4, 2, 3, 1
- (c) 2, 4, 1, 3
- (d) 2, 3, 4, 1
Answer and explanation
(a). 1956 → 1965 → 1980 → 1981.
Q5. (Practice) Match List I (administrative unit) with List II (dynasty in whose records it is the province or top-level unit).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Mandalam | I. Rashtrakutas |
| B. Rashtra | II. Cholas |
| C. Bhukti | III. Palas |
- (1) A-II, B-I, C-III
- (2) A-I, B-II, C-III
- (3) A-III, B-I, C-II
- (4) A-II, B-III, C-I
Answer and explanation
(1) A-II, B-I, C-III.
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Key fact |
|---|---|
| Samanta | Neighbour → vassal (from c. 6th century); tribute, troops, homage, overlord’s name and era |
| Ranks | Mahasamanta, samanta, mandaleshvara, ranaka, thakkura; Aparajitaprichchha |
| Units | North bhukti–vishaya–grama; Rashtrakuta rashtra–vishaya–bhukti; Chola mandalam–valanadu–nadu–ur |
| Legitimation | Genealogy, Agnikula, prashasti, hiranyagarbha, tulapurusha, grants, state cults (Brihadeshvara, Jagannath) |
| Feudal model | Kosambi 1956 (from above/below); R.S. Sharma 1965; Yadava 1973; Kali age crisis |
| Feudal critics | Mukhia 1981 (no serfdom); Sircar (revenue rights); Chattopadhyaya; Deyell |
| Segmentary | Stein 1980, after Southall 1956; nadu; ritual vs political sovereignty; brahmana–peasant alliance |
| Segmentary critics | Subbarayalu, Karashima, Veluthat, Champakalakshmi |
| Integrative | Chattopadhyaya 1994; Kulke (chieftaincy → early kingdom → imperial kingdom); Jagannath |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
Royal cults, temple building and pilgrimage were central to legitimation. Continue with Brahminical Religions, Temples and Bhakti. For the general method of comparing historical models, see Research: Meaning, Types and Approaches in Paper 1.