Marxist Criticism, New Historicism and Cultural Materialism
UGC NET English Unit 9: Lukács, Goldmann, Althusser, Macherey, Eagleton, Jameson; Greenblatt's new historicism, Montrose, Hayden White, cultural materialism.
- 14 min
On this page · 15 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Whose Tempest Is It?
- 1. The Marxist Toolkit
- 2. Before and Just After the War
- 3. Structuralist Marxism: Althusser and Macherey
- 4. Anglophone Marxist Criticism
- 5. New Historicism
- 6. Cultural Materialism
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Frankfurt School, Gramsci, Althusser, Barthes and Bourdieu — the cultural-studies treatment of ideology, hegemony and interpellation; this page uses those terms for reading literary texts
- Poststructuralism, Deconstruction and Postmodernism — Foucault’s discourse and power, and Jameson on postmodernism
- Literary Theory post World War II: chapter overview
The Hook: Whose Tempest Is It?
1. The Marxist Toolkit
| Concept | Source | Meaning for literary study |
|---|---|---|
| Base and superstructure | Marx, Preface to A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy (1859) | The economic base (forces and relations of production) conditions the superstructure (law, politics, religion, art) |
| Ideology | Marx and Engels, The German Ideology (written 1845–46) | The ideas of the ruling class are in every epoch the ruling ideas |
| Reification | Lukács, History and Class Consciousness (1923) | Social relations appear as relations between things |
| Hegemony | Gramsci, Prison Notebooks (written 1929–35) | Rule by consent as well as force; culture is where consent is won |
| Relative autonomy | Althusser | Superstructures are not mechanical reflections of the base; they have their own effectivity |
| Overdetermination | Althusser (from Freud) | Every event has many interacting causes |
| Interpellation | Althusser (1970) | Ideology “hails” individuals and constitutes them as subjects |
2. Before and Just After the War
| Critic | Work | Year | Key idea |
|---|---|---|---|
| Georg Lukács (Hungarian) | The Theory of the Novel | 1916 (book 1920) | Pre-Marxist; the novel as the epic of a world abandoned by God; “transcendental homelessness” |
| Lukács | The Historical Novel | Written 1936–37 (English 1962) | Walter Scott as the founder of the historical novel; historical characters as social types |
| Lukács | The Meaning of Contemporary Realism | 1957–58 (English 1963) | Critical realism (Thomas Mann) against modernism (Kafka, Joyce), which he attacks for its subjectivism and static view of humanity; “The Ideology of Modernism” |
| Bertolt Brecht | Theatre writings | 1930s–50s | Against Lukács: realism is not one form; alienation effect (Verfremdungseffekt) and epic theatre |
| Walter Benjamin | “The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction” | 1935–36 | Loss of aura (treated in cultural studies) |
| Jean-Paul Sartre | What Is Literature? | 1947–48 | Committed literature (littérature engagée); prose writing as action |
| Lucien Goldmann (Romanian-French) | The Hidden God (Le Dieu caché) | 1955 | Genetic structuralism: a homology between the structure of a work and the world vision of a social group; Pascal’s Pensées and Racine’s tragedies express the tragic vision of the Jansenist noblesse de robe |
| Goldmann | Towards a Sociology of the Novel | 1964 | The novel’s structure homologous with the market economy |
The Lukács–Brecht debate of the 1930s (over realism versus modernist experiment) and the Frankfurt School’s attack on the culture industry (Adorno and Horkheimer, Dialectic of Enlightenment, 1947) are the background to everything that follows. The Frankfurt School is treated in the cultural studies chapter.
3. Structuralist Marxism: Althusser and Macherey
Louis Althusser
| Work | Year | Key concepts |
|---|---|---|
| For Marx; Reading Capital (with Étienne Balibar and others) | 1965 | Symptomatic reading: reading a text for what it cannot say; the “epistemological break” in Marx |
| “A Letter on Art in Reply to André Daspre” | 1966 | Art is not ideology, but lets us “see” the ideology from which it is born |
| “Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses” | 1970 | RSA (Repressive State Apparatus: army, police, courts, prisons) works by violence; ISAs (schools, family, church, media, culture) work by ideology. The educational ISA is dominant in mature capitalism. Ideology represents the imaginary relationship of individuals to their real conditions of existence; it interpellates individuals as subjects |
The policeman’s call “Hey, you there!” and the individual who turns round is Althusser’s image of interpellation: in recognising that the call was meant for him, he becomes a subject.
Pierre Macherey
A Theory of Literary Production (Pour une théorie de la production littéraire, 1966; English 1978):
- The writer does not create but produces, working on given materials (language, ideology, literary forms).
- A literary work is not a unified whole: it is decentred, marked by gaps, absences and contradictions.
- The critic’s task is to read what the work does not say: its silences. In giving ideology a form, literature exposes its limits.
- His examples include Jules Verne, whose novels of scientific conquest reveal the contradictions of French imperial ideology.
4. Anglophone Marxist Criticism
Raymond Williams
Williams (Welsh, Cambridge) is the founding figure of cultural materialism. His concepts are covered in the Birmingham School page; for theory questions, remember Marxism and Literature (1977): dominant, residual and emergent cultures; structure of feeling; and The Country and the City (1973), on the pastoral’s concealment of rural labour.
Terry Eagleton
| Work | Year | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Marxism and Literary Criticism | 1976 | Short introduction |
| Criticism and Ideology | 1976 | A “science of the text” built on Althusser and Macherey |
| Walter Benjamin, or Towards a Revolutionary Criticism | 1981 | — |
| Literary Theory: An Introduction | 1983 | The bestselling survey; argues that “literature” has no fixed essence and that all theory is political; ends by calling for “political criticism” |
| The Ideology of the Aesthetic | 1990 | — |
| After Theory | 2003 | — |
In Criticism and Ideology, Eagleton sets out a series of categories through which a text is produced: General Mode of Production (GMP), Literary Mode of Production (LMP), General Ideology (GI), Authorial Ideology (AuI), Aesthetic Ideology (AI) and the Text.
Fredric Jameson
| Work | Year | Key ideas |
|---|---|---|
| Marxism and Form | 1971 | The Frankfurt School and Lukács introduced to American readers |
| The Prison-House of Language | 1972 | Critique of Formalism and structuralism |
| The Political Unconscious: Narrative as a Socially Symbolic Act | 1981 | Opens with the slogan “Always historicize!”; every text is a symbolic resolution of real social contradictions; the political unconscious is the repressed history that texts manage |
| “Third-World Literature in the Era of Multinational Capitalism” | 1986 | All third-world texts are national allegories (attacked by Aijaz Ahmad, 1987) |
| Postmodernism, or, The Cultural Logic of Late Capitalism | 1991 | See the poststructuralism page |
The Political Unconscious reads a text within three widening horizons: (1) political history, where the text is a symbolic act; (2) society, where it is an utterance in a dialogue of class discourses (its minimal unit the ideologeme); (3) history as the sequence of modes of production, where form itself carries ideology (the ideology of form).
5. New Historicism
Origins and name
Stephen Greenblatt (Berkeley, later Harvard) published Renaissance Self-Fashioning: From More to Shakespeare in 1980 and is credited with naming the approach “New Historicism” in his introduction to a special issue of the journal Genre on Renaissance literature (1982). He later preferred to call it a “poetics of culture” (essay “Towards a Poetics of Culture”, 1987).
Sources
| Influence | What it gave |
|---|---|
| Michel Foucault | Discourse, power/knowledge, power as productive and dispersed (not just repressive or owned by the state) |
| Clifford Geertz, The Interpretation of Cultures (1973) | Thick description: reading a culture’s practices as a text |
| Poststructuralism | No sharp line between literary and non-literary texts; history is accessible only as texts |
Method and key terms
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Self-fashioning | Renaissance identities (More, Tyndale, Wyatt, Spenser, Marlowe, Shakespeare) were shaped in relation to authority and an alien “other” |
| The anecdote | Essays often open with a striking anecdote from a non-literary source, then turn to a literary text |
| Co-text / parallel reading | Literary and non-literary texts read side by side, with no hierarchy |
| Circulation of social energy | Shakespearean Negotiations (1988): theatre and society exchange and negotiate power, prestige, desire |
| Subversion and containment | “Invisible Bullets” (1981; in Shakespearean Negotiations): power produces subversion in order to contain it. Greenblatt reads Thomas Harriot’s account of the Virginia colony beside the Henry IV and Henry V plays |
| “The historicity of texts and the textuality of history” | Louis Montrose’s formula: texts are rooted in history; history reaches us only through texts |
Other names: Catherine Gallagher (with Greenblatt, Practicing New Historicism, 2000); Louis Montrose (“Professing the Renaissance”, 1989); H. Aram Veeser (ed.), The New Historicism (1989).
Hayden White: history as narrative
Metahistory: The Historical Imagination in Nineteenth-Century Europe (1973) argues that historians shape events into stories through emplotment:
| Mode of emplotment | Trope |
|---|---|
| Romance | Metaphor |
| Tragedy | Metonymy |
| Comedy | Synecdoche |
| Satire | Irony |
The pairing of emplotment and trope is a tendency, not a fixed rule. White’s Tropics of Discourse (1978) collects related essays. His point, that historical writing is also a literary artefact, supports the new historicist claim that history is textual.
6. Cultural Materialism
The British counterpart, named after Williams’s term. Its manifesto is Jonathan Dollimore and Alan Sinfield (eds), Political Shakespeare: New Essays in Cultural Materialism (1985), whose foreword names four features: historical context, theoretical method, political commitment and textual analysis. Dollimore’s Radical Tragedy (1984) and Sinfield’s Faultlines (1992) are the key monographs.
| New historicism (USA) | Cultural materialism (Britain) | |
|---|---|---|
| Founding text | Greenblatt, Renaissance Self-Fashioning (1980) | Dollimore and Sinfield, Political Shakespeare (1985) |
| Main sources | Foucault, Geertz | Williams, Gramsci, Althusser |
| Power | Tends to find subversion contained | Stresses dissidence and the possibility of change |
| Focus | Texts in their own time | Texts in their time and how they are used now (Shakespeare in schools, the heritage industry) |
| Politics | Less overtly political | Openly committed |
A fuller comparison from the cultural studies side is in The Birmingham School.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| RSA: works by violence (police, army) | vs | ISA: works by ideology (school, family, media) |
| Macherey: silences, literary production | vs | Goldmann: homology, world vision |
| Critical realism (Lukács’s ideal, Mann) | vs | Socialist realism (Soviet official doctrine) |
| The Political Unconscious (Jameson, 1981) | vs | Criticism and Ideology (Eagleton, 1976) |
| New historicism (Greenblatt, American) | vs | Cultural materialism (Dollimore and Sinfield, British) |
| Thick description (Geertz) | vs | Close reading (New Criticism) |
| Historicity of texts (texts are historical) | vs | Textuality of history (history is textual) |
| Metahistory (White, 1973): emplotment | vs | Metanarrative (Lyotard, 1979): grand legitimating story |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Which work opens with the injunction “Always historicize!”?
- Who used the phrase “the historicity of texts and the textuality of history”?
- Name the book that served as the manifesto of cultural materialism.
Answers
- Fredric Jameson, The Political Unconscious (1981).
- Louis Montrose.
- Political Shakespeare (1985), edited by Jonathan Dollimore and Alan Sinfield.
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) In Althusser’s “Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses”, which of the following is a Repressive State Apparatus?
- (a) The school
- (b) The family
- (c) The courts
- (d) The press
Answer and explanation
(c) The courts. The RSA comprises government, army, police, courts and prisons; the others are ISAs.
Q2. (Practice) The concept of a “homology” between the structure of a literary work and the world vision of a social group belongs to:
- (a) Pierre Macherey
- (b) Lucien Goldmann
- (c) Raymond Williams
- (d) Stephen Greenblatt
Answer and explanation
(b) Goldmann, The Hidden God (1955), on Pascal and Racine.
Q3. (Practice) Consider the following statements about new historicism:
- It reads literary texts alongside non-literary texts of the same period.
- It draws on Foucault’s view of power as dispersed and productive.
- Its founding text is Dollimore and Sinfield’s Political Shakespeare.
Which of the statements given above are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 2 and 3 only
- (c) 1 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(a) 1 and 2 only. Political Shakespeare (1985) is the manifesto of British cultural materialism.
Q4. (Practice) In Hayden White’s Metahistory, which mode of emplotment is paired with the trope of irony?
- (a) Romance
- (b) Comedy
- (c) Tragedy
- (d) Satire
Answer and explanation
(d) Satire.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Macherey directs the critic to what a literary work does not say. Reason (R): In giving form to ideology, the work exposes the gaps and contradictions that ideology conceals.
Answer and explanation
(a). The silences matter because they are where ideology’s contradictions show. R explains A.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): Lukács praised Kafka as the model of critical realism. Reason (R): Lukács valued literature that represented individuals as social types within a historical totality.
Answer and explanation
(d). A is false: Lukács attacked Kafka’s modernism and held up Thomas Mann. R correctly states his criterion.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (Critic) with List II (Work).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Pierre Macherey | I. Renaissance Self-Fashioning |
| B. Stephen Greenblatt | II. Metahistory |
| C. Hayden White | III. A Theory of Literary Production |
| D. Jonathan Dollimore | IV. Radical Tragedy |
- (1) A-III, B-I, C-II, D-IV
- (2) A-I, B-III, C-II, D-IV
- (3) A-III, B-II, C-I, D-IV
- (4) A-III, B-I, C-IV, D-II
Answer and explanation
(1) A-III, B-I, C-II, D-IV.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following in chronological order:
A. Jameson, The Political Unconscious
B. Althusser, “Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses”
C. Goldmann, The Hidden God
D. Eagleton, Criticism and Ideology
(1) C, B, D, A
(2) B, C, D, A
(3) C, D, B, A
(4) C, B, A, D
Answer and explanation
(1) C, B, D, A. Goldmann (1955) → Althusser (1970) → Eagleton (1976) → Jameson (1981).
Quick Revision Table
| Critic | Work and year | Key term |
|---|---|---|
| Lukács | Historical Novel (1936–37); Meaning of Contemporary Realism (1957–58) | Typicality; critical realism vs modernism |
| Sartre | What Is Literature? (1947–48) | Committed literature |
| Goldmann | The Hidden God (1955) | Genetic structuralism; homology; world vision |
| Althusser | For Marx, Reading Capital (1965); ISAs essay (1970) | Symptomatic reading; RSA/ISA; interpellation |
| Macherey | A Theory of Literary Production (1966) | Production; silences; decentred work |
| Williams | Marxism and Literature (1977) | Dominant/residual/emergent; structure of feeling |
| Eagleton | Criticism and Ideology (1976); Literary Theory (1983) | GMP, LMP, GI, AuI, AI |
| Jameson | The Political Unconscious (1981) | “Always historicize!”; three horizons; ideologeme |
| Greenblatt | Renaissance Self-Fashioning (1980); “New Historicism” (1982); Shakespearean Negotiations (1988) | Self-fashioning; social energy; subversion/containment; poetics of culture |
| Montrose | — | Historicity of texts / textuality of history |
| Geertz | Interpretation of Cultures (1973) | Thick description |
| Hayden White | Metahistory (1973) | Emplotment: romance, tragedy, comedy, satire |
| Dollimore and Sinfield | Political Shakespeare (1985) | Cultural materialism; dissidence |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Next topic: Feminist, Gender and Queer Theory — patriarchy as the other great structure of power
- Postcolonial Theory and Ecocriticism — Aijaz Ahmad’s Marxist critique of Jameson and of postcolonial theory
- The Birmingham School — Williams, Hall and the cultural-studies side of the same debates
- Chapter overview · Quick Revision