The New Criticism: Ransom, Brooks, Tate, Wimsatt and Beardsley
UGC NET English: New Criticism: Ransom's structure and texture, Brooks's paradox and heresy of paraphrase, Tate's tension, the two fallacies.
- 15 min
On this page · 13 sections
Prerequisites
- Eliot, Richards, Leavis and Empson — the New Critics’ taste comes from Eliot and their method from Richards and Empson
- Romantic and Victorian Criticism — Coleridge’s “reconciliation of opposite or discordant qualities” is the root of paradox and organic unity
- Literary Criticism: chapter overview
The Hook: Reading a Poem Without the Poet
1. Origins and Name
From Vanderbilt to the classroom
| Stage | What happened |
|---|---|
| The Fugitives (Vanderbilt University, Nashville) | A group of poets, including John Crowe Ransom, Allen Tate, Robert Penn Warren and Donald Davidson, published the poetry magazine The Fugitive (1922–25) |
| The Agrarians | Several of the same men contributed to I’ll Take My Stand (1930), a defence of the traditional, agrarian South against industrialism |
| Journals | The Southern Review (founded 1935 at Louisiana State University by Brooks and Warren); The Kenyon Review (founded 1939 by Ransom) |
| Textbooks | Brooks and Warren’s Understanding Poetry (1938) and Understanding Fiction (1943) carried close reading into American classrooms |
The name
The movement took its name from John Crowe Ransom’s The New Criticism (1941), a book that discussed I.A. Richards, T.S. Eliot, Yvor Winters (and, more briefly, William Empson) as “the new critics”, and ended by calling for an “ontological critic” who would treat the poem as a distinct kind of object. Ransom was critical of all of them: the name was attached to the American school later.
2. Core Principles
| Principle | Meaning |
|---|---|
| The poem as an autonomous object | The poem is a self-contained verbal structure; its meaning lies within it |
| Close reading | Slow, detailed attention to words, images, syntax, rhythm and their interrelations |
| Intrinsic vs extrinsic | Biography, history, psychology, sociology and the author’s intentions are extrinsic; criticism should attend to intrinsic features |
| Organic unity | Every part contributes to the whole, and the whole is more than the sum of the parts (a debt to Coleridge) |
| Complexity valued | Good poetry holds opposed attitudes in balance: paradox, irony, tension, ambiguity |
| Against paraphrase | The meaning of a poem cannot be restated in prose without loss (Brooks’s heresy of paraphrase) |
| Against intention and affect | Neither what the author meant nor what the reader feels is the standard of meaning or value (Wimsatt and Beardsley) |
| Preferred texts | Lyric poetry, especially the metaphysicals, Shakespeare’s sonnets, the modernists |
3. The Critics
John Crowe Ransom (1888–1974)
| Work | Year | Key idea |
|---|---|---|
| God Without Thunder | 1930 | A defence of myth and religion against scientism |
| “Criticism, Inc.” | 1937 | Criticism should become professional, systematic and precise, carried on by professors of literature; it should exclude personal response, synopsis, historical and linguistic studies, and moral judgement |
| The World’s Body | 1938 | Poetry restores the “world’s body”, the concrete richness of experience that science abstracts away; essays include “Poetry: A Note in Ontology” |
| The New Criticism | 1941 | Gave the movement its name; calls for the “ontological critic”; develops the distinction of structure and texture |
Structure and texture. A poem is a logical structure (the paraphrasable argument, the “prose core”) with a local texture (the particular details, images and sounds that do not serve the argument but give the poem its density). Ransom compared it to a house: the structure is its walls and rooms; the texture is its paint, paper and tapestries. Poetry’s value lies in the texture, the irrelevant richness that science and prose discard.
Allen Tate (1899–1979)
| Work | Year | Key idea |
|---|---|---|
| Reactionary Essays on Poetry and Ideas | 1936 | Southern traditionalism |
| “Tension in Poetry” | 1938 | Tension |
Tension. Tate coined the term by removing the prefixes from two logical terms, extension and intension. A good poem holds together the extension (the literal, denotative reach of its language) and the intension (its connotations, its figurative depth). Its meaning is the full organised body of all the extension and intension we can find in it. Tate’s examples of failure are poems that indulge only connotation (“mass language”, sentimental verse) or only abstract statement.
Cleanth Brooks (1906–1994)
| Work | Year | Key idea |
|---|---|---|
| Understanding Poetry (with Robert Penn Warren) | 1938 | Textbook of close reading |
| Modern Poetry and the Tradition | 1939 | The modern poets (Eliot, Yeats) recover the metaphysical tradition of wit, against the Romantic and Victorian line |
| The Well Wrought Urn: Studies in the Structure of Poetry | 1947 | Close readings of poems from Donne to Yeats; “The Language of Paradox”; “The Heresy of Paraphrase” |
| “Irony as a Principle of Structure” | Essay, c. 1949 (sources vary) | Irony as the pressure of context on every statement |
| Literary Criticism: A Short History (with W.K. Wimsatt) | 1957 | A history of criticism from Plato to the twentieth century |
The Well Wrought Urn. The title comes from Donne’s “The Canonization”. Each chapter reads one poem:
| Chapter | Poem read |
|---|---|
| “The Language of Paradox” | Donne, “The Canonization” (and Wordsworth’s sonnet “Composed upon Westminster Bridge”) |
| “The Naked Babe and the Cloak of Manliness” | Shakespeare, Macbeth |
| “The Light Symbolism in ‘L’Allegro–Il Penseroso’” | Milton, the companion poems |
| “What Does Poetry Communicate?” | Herrick, “Corinna’s Going A-Maying” |
| “The Case of Miss Arabella Fermor” | Pope, The Rape of the Lock |
| “Gray’s Storied Urn” | Gray, Elegy Written in a Country Churchyard |
| “Wordsworth and the Paradox of the Imagination” | Wordsworth, “Intimations of Immortality” Ode |
| “Keats’s Sylvan Historian” | Keats, “Ode on a Grecian Urn” |
| “The Motivation of Tennyson’s Weeper” | Tennyson, “Tears, Idle Tears” |
| “Yeats’s Great Rooted Blossomer” | Yeats, “Among School Children” |
| “The Heresy of Paraphrase” | Theoretical conclusion |
Brooks’s key ideas:
- Paradox: the language of poetry is the language of paradox. Even an apparently simple poem, such as Wordsworth’s Westminster Bridge sonnet, depends on paradox (the city is most alive when it seems dead).
- The heresy of paraphrase: a poem’s meaning cannot be stated in a prose summary. A paraphrase is at best a scaffolding; the poem is a pattern of resolved stresses, a structure of attitudes, not a statement.
- Irony: the acknowledgment of the pressures of the context. A good poem is one whose statements survive ironical qualification by the rest of the poem.
- Organic unity and the poem as a dramatic structure: a poem is like a little drama, not a container of a message.
W.K. Wimsatt (1907–1975) and Monroe C. Beardsley (1915–1985)
Wimsatt was a literary scholar at Yale; Beardsley was a philosopher of aesthetics. Together they wrote the two essays that gave the New Criticism its theoretical backbone.
| Essay | First published | Collected in |
|---|---|---|
| “The Intentional Fallacy” | The Sewanee Review, 1946 | Wimsatt’s The Verbal Icon: Studies in the Meaning of Poetry (1954) |
| “The Affective Fallacy” | The Sewanee Review, 1949 | The Verbal Icon (1954) |
The intentional fallacy is the confusion between the poem and its origins: judging a poem by what the author intended. Wimsatt and Beardsley argue:
- The author’s design or intention is neither available nor desirable as a standard for judging the success of a literary work.
- If the poet succeeded, the poem itself shows what he was trying to do; if he failed, the poem is not adequate evidence, and the critic must go outside the poem.
- The poem belongs to the public: it is embodied in language, the peculiar possession of the public.
- They separate internal evidence (the semantics and syntax of the poem, public knowledge of the language) from external evidence (diaries, letters, reported conversations about intention); an intermediate kind (the author’s private associations with words) is to be used with care.
The affective fallacy is the confusion between the poem and its results, between what it is and what it does. It begins by trying to derive the standard of criticism from the psychological effects of the poem and ends in impressionism and relativism. The target is partly Richards’s psychological theory of value. The outcome of either fallacy, they say, is that the poem itself, as an object of critical judgment, tends to disappear.
The “verbal icon”: a poem is a verbal image that, like an icon, embodies its meaning in its very form.
Robert Penn Warren, R.P. Blackmur and Yvor Winters
| Critic | Work | Year | Remember |
|---|---|---|---|
| Robert Penn Warren | “Pure and Impure Poetry” (essay) | 1943 | Good poetry is “impure”: it admits irony, contradiction and the unpoetic; co-author of the Understanding textbooks; novelist (All the King’s Men, 1946) |
| R.P. Blackmur | The Double Agent | 1935 | Language as gesture; brilliant close reader of modern poets |
| Language as Gesture | 1952 | ||
| Yvor Winters | Primitivism and Decadence | 1937 | Moralist among the formalists: a poem is a moral evaluation of experience |
| In Defense of Reason | 1947 | Attacks the “fallacy of imitative form” (writing chaotically about chaos) |
The wider formalist circle
| Work | Year | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| René Wellek and Austin Warren, Theory of Literature | 1949 | Systematic distinction between extrinsic approaches (biography, psychology, society, ideas, other arts) and the intrinsic study of literature |
| R.S. Crane (ed.), Critics and Criticism: Ancient and Modern | 1952 | The Chicago School of neo-Aristotelians, who attacked the New Critics’ narrow focus on paradox and irony and asked for attention to plot, genre and the whole work |
4. Criticisms of the New Criticism
| Objection | Who made it, broadly |
|---|---|
| Ahistorical: ignores the social and historical context of literature | Marxist and historicist critics; later new historicists |
| Lyric bias: works well for short poems, poorly for novels, drama and long poems | The Chicago neo-Aristotelians |
| Conservative politics disguised as neutrality: rooted in Southern Agrarian traditionalism, favours order and resolution | Later political critics |
| Unity imposed: assumes every good poem resolves its tensions into organic unity | Deconstructionists, who stressed undecidability |
| The reader ignored: the affective fallacy rules out the reader’s role | Reader-response critics |
| Elitist canon: metaphysicals and modernists favoured; much else marginalised | Feminist and postcolonial critics |
Even so, close reading survived every reaction against it, and remains the basic skill of literary study and of the comprehension passages in UGC NET English.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Intentional fallacy (1946): poem vs its origins | vs | Affective fallacy (1949): poem vs its results |
| Ransom’s structure/texture: paraphrasable core plus detail | vs | Brooks’s heresy of paraphrase: no separable core |
| Tate’s tension (extension + intension) | vs | Empson’s ambiguity (alternative reactions) |
| The Well Wrought Urn (Brooks, 1947) | vs | The Verbal Icon (Wimsatt, 1954) |
| Understanding Poetry (Brooks and Warren, 1938) | vs | Modern Poetry and the Tradition (Brooks, 1939) |
| The World’s Body (Ransom, 1938) | vs | The New Criticism (Ransom, 1941) |
| The Southern Review (Brooks and Warren, 1935) | vs | The Kenyon Review (Ransom, 1939) |
| Pathetic fallacy (Ruskin) | vs | Intentional / affective fallacy (Wimsatt and Beardsley) |
| New Critics (close reading, irony, paradox) | vs | Chicago School (neo-Aristotelian: plot, genre, whole work) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Which book gave the New Criticism its name?
- From which poem does The Well Wrought Urn take its title?
- In which journal did “The Intentional Fallacy” first appear?
Answers
- John Crowe Ransom, The New Criticism (1941).
- Donne’s “The Canonization”.
- The Sewanee Review (1946).
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) Allen Tate derived the term “tension” from:
- (a) intention and attention
- (b) extension and intension
- (c) tenor and vehicle
- (d) structure and texture
Answer and explanation
(b). Tate removed the prefixes from the logical terms extension and intension. (c) is Richards; (d) is Ransom.
Q2. (Practice) The “heresy of paraphrase” is a phrase used by:
- (a) John Crowe Ransom
- (b) Cleanth Brooks
- (c) W.K. Wimsatt
- (d) R.P. Blackmur
Answer and explanation
(b) Cleanth Brooks, title of the final chapter of The Well Wrought Urn (1947).
Q3. (Practice) Consider the following statements:
- The affective fallacy confuses the poem with its psychological results.
- Wimsatt and Beardsley regard the author’s intention as the best standard of a poem’s success.
- “The Affective Fallacy” was first published after “The Intentional Fallacy”.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 1 and 3 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 1 and 3 only. Statement 2 reverses their argument: intention is neither available nor desirable as a standard. The affective essay (1949) followed the intentional one (1946).
Q4. (Practice) Which of the following journals was founded by John Crowe Ransom?
- (a) The Southern Review
- (b) The Kenyon Review
- (c) Scrutiny
- (d) The Criterion
Answer and explanation
(b) The Kenyon Review (1939). The Southern Review was Brooks and Warren’s; Scrutiny was Leavis’s; The Criterion was Eliot’s.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Wimsatt and Beardsley rejected the author’s intention as a standard for judging a poem. Reason (R): They held that a poem, once published, belongs to the public and its meaning is embodied in public language.
Answer and explanation
(a). Because the poem’s meaning is public, private intention is neither available nor needed as a standard.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): Cleanth Brooks argued that the meaning of a poem cannot be adequately paraphrased. Reason (R): Brooks held that a poem is a structure of attitudes and resolved stresses rather than a logical statement.
Answer and explanation
(a). Since the poem’s meaning is its whole structure, any prose statement abstracted from it is a “heresy”.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (critic) with List II (concept).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. John Crowe Ransom | I. Tension |
| B. Allen Tate | II. Heresy of paraphrase |
| C. Cleanth Brooks | III. Structure and texture |
| D. Yvor Winters | IV. Poem as moral evaluation of experience |
- (1) A-III, B-I, C-II, D-IV
- (2) A-I, B-III, C-II, D-IV
- (3) A-III, B-II, C-I, D-IV
- (4) A-IV, B-I, C-II, D-III
Answer and explanation
(1) A-III, B-I, C-II, D-IV.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following in chronological order of first publication:
A. The Verbal Icon
B. Understanding Poetry
C. The Well Wrought Urn
D. The New Criticism
(1) B, D, C, A
(2) D, B, C, A
(3) B, C, D, A
(4) B, D, A, C
Answer and explanation
(1) B, D, C, A. 1938 → 1941 → 1947 → 1954.
Quick Revision Table
| Fact | Detail |
|---|---|
| Roots | Fugitives (The Fugitive, 1922–25), Agrarians (I’ll Take My Stand, 1930), Vanderbilt |
| Journals | Southern Review (1935, Brooks and Warren); Kenyon Review (1939, Ransom) |
| Name | Ransom, The New Criticism (1941); “ontological critic” |
| Ransom | “Criticism, Inc.” (1937); The World’s Body (1938); structure and texture |
| Tate | “Tension in Poetry” (1938); extension + intension |
| Brooks and Warren | Understanding Poetry (1938); Understanding Fiction (1943) |
| Brooks | Modern Poetry and the Tradition (1939); The Well Wrought Urn (1947): paradox, heresy of paraphrase, irony |
| Wimsatt and Beardsley | “Intentional Fallacy” (1946); “Affective Fallacy” (1949); both Sewanee Review |
| Wimsatt | The Verbal Icon (1954); with Brooks, Literary Criticism: A Short History (1957) |
| Blackmur | The Double Agent (1935); Language as Gesture (1952) |
| Winters | Primitivism and Decadence (1937); In Defense of Reason (1947); fallacy of imitative form |
| Wellek and Warren | Theory of Literature (1949); extrinsic vs intrinsic |
| Chicago School | R.S. Crane, Critics and Criticism (1952); neo-Aristotelian |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Quick Revision — the whole chapter on one page
- Plato and Aristotle — the Chicago neo-Aristotelians sent critics back to the Poetics
- English: all units — Unit 9 takes up literary theory after the Second World War