Eliot, Richards, Leavis and Empson: The Modern Critical Revolution
UGC NET English: Eliot's tradition, impersonality and objective correlative; Richards's Practical Criticism; Leavis and Scrutiny; Empson's ambiguity.
- 16 min
On this page · 13 sections
Prerequisites
- Romantic and Victorian Criticism — Eliot’s impersonality is a reply to Wordsworth; his tradition and Leavis’s moral seriousness descend from Arnold
- Renaissance and Neoclassical Criticism — Johnson on the metaphysical poets, which Eliot reverses
- Literary Criticism: chapter overview
The Hook: Thirteen Poems Without Names
1. T.S. Eliot (1888–1965)
American-born, settled in England from 1914, Eliot edited The Criterion (1922–39) and won the Nobel Prize in 1948. In the preface to For Lancelot Andrewes (1928) he called himself classicist in literature, royalist in politics and Anglo-Catholic in religion. His early essays were collected in The Sacred Wood (1920) and Selected Essays (1932).
“Tradition and the Individual Talent” (1919)
Published in The Egoist in two parts in 1919 and collected in The Sacred Wood (1920).
Part I: tradition.
- Tradition cannot be inherited; it must be obtained by great labour.
- It involves the historical sense: a perception not only of the pastness of the past but of its presence. A writer should write with the whole literature of Europe from Homer, and of his own country, in his bones; it has a simultaneous existence and composes a simultaneous order.
- Existing monuments form an ideal order among themselves, which is modified by the introduction of the new, really new, work. So the past is altered by the present as much as the present is directed by the past.
- No poet has his complete meaning alone: he must be set, for contrast and comparison, among the dead.
Part II: impersonality.
- Honest criticism and sensitive appreciation are directed not upon the poet but upon the poetry.
- The catalyst analogy: when a filament of platinum is introduced into a chamber containing oxygen and sulphur dioxide, they combine to form sulphurous acid, yet the platinum remains unchanged. The poet’s mind is the catalyst: the more perfect the artist, the more completely separate in him will be the man who suffers and the mind which creates.
- The poet has not a personality to express, but a particular medium.
- Against Wordsworth: “emotion recollected in tranquillity” is an inexact formula; poetry is a concentration of experiences, and it is not a turning loose of emotion, but an escape from emotion; not the expression of personality, but an escape from personality.
Part III (a short coda): the emotion of art is impersonal, and the poet cannot reach impersonality without surrendering himself to the work to be done.
“Hamlet and His Problems” (1919)
Published in The Athenaeum (1919) and reprinted in The Sacred Wood.
- Eliot calls Hamlet “most certainly an artistic failure” and “the Mona Lisa of literature”.
- The only way of expressing emotion in art is by finding an objective correlative: a set of objects, a situation, a chain of events which shall be the formula of that particular emotion, so that when the external facts are given, the emotion is immediately evoked.
- Hamlet’s emotion (disgust occasioned by his mother) is in excess of the facts as they appear; Shakespeare could not find an objective correlative for it.
- Macbeth (Lady Macbeth’s sleepwalking scene) is his example of the formula working.
“The Metaphysical Poets” (1921)
Written as a review of H.J.C. Grierson’s anthology Metaphysical Lyrics and Poems of the Seventeenth Century (1921), in the Times Literary Supplement.
- The metaphysical poets (Donne and others) had a mechanism of sensibility which could devour any kind of experience. For Donne, a thought was an experience; it modified his sensibility.
- In the seventeenth century a dissociation of sensibility set in, from which English poetry never recovered: thought and feeling came apart. It was aggravated by the influence of Milton and Dryden.
- After the dissociation, poets thought and felt by fits, unbalanced. Tennyson and Browning think, but they do not feel their thought as immediately as the odour of a rose.
- Poets in our civilisation, which has great variety and complexity, must be difficult.
Eliot’s other essays and books
| Work | Year | Key idea |
|---|---|---|
| “The Function of Criticism” | 1923 | Reply to John Middleton Murry’s “inner voice”; criticism’s ends are the elucidation of works of art and the correction of taste; the critic needs a highly developed sense of fact |
| Homage to John Dryden | 1924 | Includes “The Metaphysical Poets”, “Andrew Marvell” (on wit) and the Dryden essay |
| The Use of Poetry and the Use of Criticism | 1933 | Harvard lectures; auditory imagination |
| After Strange Gods | 1934 | Orthodoxy and tradition |
| “Religion and Literature” | 1935 | Literary criticism should be completed by criticism from a definite ethical and theological standpoint |
| “Milton I” / “Milton II” | 1936 / 1947 | First attack on Milton’s influence, later partial recantation |
| “What is a Classic?” | 1944 | Virgil as the classic of all Europe; maturity of mind, manners and language |
| Notes Towards the Definition of Culture | 1948 | Culture as a whole way of life |
| “The Three Voices of Poetry” | 1953 | The poet talking to himself, to an audience, and through a dramatic character |
| “The Frontiers of Criticism” | 1956 | Criticises the “lemon-squeezer school” of over-ingenious close reading |
2. I.A. Richards (1893–1979)
Richards taught at Cambridge (Magdalene College) and later at Harvard. He tried to put criticism on a scientific, psychological basis, and his Practical Criticism founded the method of close reading.
The works
| Work | Year | Key idea |
|---|---|---|
| The Foundations of Aesthetics (with C.K. Ogden and James Wood) | 1922 | Beauty as synaesthesis, a harmony of impulses |
| The Meaning of Meaning (with C.K. Ogden) | 1923 | The semantic triangle: symbol, thought (reference) and referent |
| Principles of Literary Criticism | 1924 | A psychological theory of value: experience is a system of impulses; valuable art organises and balances them; the two uses of language |
| Science and Poetry | 1926 | Poetry consists of pseudo-statements, which are not true or false but valuable for their emotional effect; poetry “is capable of saving us” in a world without belief |
| Practical Criticism: A Study of Literary Judgment | 1929 | The protocols experiment; the four kinds of meaning; the ten difficulties |
| Coleridge on Imagination | 1934 | Coleridge’s imagination re-read in psychological terms |
| The Philosophy of Rhetoric | 1936 | Metaphor as the omnipresent principle of language; tenor and vehicle |
Two uses of language (Principles, 1924)
| Use | Purpose | Test |
|---|---|---|
| Referential (scientific) | To make a statement, true or false, about things | Verifiability: correspondence to fact |
| Emotive | To evoke feelings and attitudes | The value of the attitudes it organises |
Poetry is the supreme form of emotive language. Its statements are pseudo-statements (Science and Poetry, 1926).
Poetry of inclusion and exclusion. The best poetry (such as tragedy) includes opposed and discordant impulses and brings them into balance; lesser poetry excludes whatever might upset a single attitude. This idea passed directly into the New Critics’ irony and paradox.
Practical Criticism (1929)
The four kinds of meaning:
| Kind | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Sense | What is said: the plain content |
| Feeling | The speaker’s attitude to what he is talking about |
| Tone | The speaker’s attitude to his listener |
| Intention | The speaker’s aim, conscious or unconscious, the effect he is trying to promote |
The ten difficulties of criticism (why the students misread):
- Making out the plain sense of the poem
- Sensuous apprehension: hearing its rhythm and movement
- Imagery, especially visual images, unreliably relied on
- Mnemonic irrelevances: personal memories intruding
- Stock responses: ready-made reactions triggered by a theme
- Sentimentality: excess of response
- Inhibition: deficiency of response (hardness of heart)
- Doctrinal adhesions: agreeing or disagreeing with the poem’s beliefs
- Technical presuppositions: judging means as if they were ends (e.g. rhyme)
- General critical preconceptions: prior theories about what poetry should be
Tenor and vehicle (The Philosophy of Rhetoric, 1936)
In a metaphor, the tenor is the underlying subject, and the vehicle is the image used to convey it. In “the ship ploughs the sea”, the ship’s motion is the tenor; ploughing is the vehicle. Meaning arises from their interaction, not from either alone.
3. F.R. Leavis (1895–1978)
Leavis, a Cambridge don, was the most influential and combative English critic of the mid-century. For him literary criticism was a moral discipline, and the study of English the centre of a humane education.
The works
| Work | Year | Key idea |
|---|---|---|
| Mass Civilisation and Minority Culture | 1930 | A small minority keeps the standards of culture alive against mass civilisation |
| Scrutiny (quarterly, edited by Leavis and others) | 1932–1953 | The journal that spread his views |
| New Bearings in English Poetry | 1932 | Champions Eliot, Pound and Hopkins as the poets who broke with Victorian and Georgian verse |
| Culture and Environment (with Denys Thompson) | 1933 | Critical reading of advertising and the press for schools |
| Revaluation: Tradition and Development in English Poetry | 1936 | Re-maps English poetry along Eliot’s lines; argues for the line of wit (Donne, Pope) and against Milton’s influence |
| Education and the University | 1943 | English as the centre of the university |
| The Great Tradition | 1948 | The great English novelists are Jane Austen, George Eliot, Henry James and Joseph Conrad; D.H. Lawrence their successor |
| The Common Pursuit | 1952 | Title from Eliot’s phrase “the common pursuit of true judgment” |
| D.H. Lawrence: Novelist | 1955 | Lawrence as the great novelist of the age |
| Two Cultures? The Significance of C.P. Snow | 1962 | Attack on Snow’s “Two Cultures” lecture |
| Dickens the Novelist (with Q.D. Leavis) | 1970 | Revises his earlier dismissal of Dickens (in The Great Tradition only Hard Times had been admitted) |
Q.D. Leavis, his wife and collaborator, wrote Fiction and the Reading Public (1932), a sociological study of popular reading.
Leavis’s critical vocabulary
- “Life” and “felt life”: the great writer shows a reverent openness before life and a marked moral intensity.
- Concreteness and enactment: in the best poetry the words do not just describe but enact what they mean.
- Maturity and seriousness.
- Distrust of theory: he refused to state his criteria in the abstract (a famous exchange with the critic René Wellek in Scrutiny, 1937).
4. William Empson (1906–1984)
Empson studied mathematics and then English at Magdalene College, Cambridge, under I.A. Richards. Seven Types of Ambiguity (1930) grew out of his undergraduate work and was published when he was in his early twenties.
Ambiguity for Empson means any verbal nuance, however slight, that gives room for alternative reactions to the same piece of language. Far from a fault, it is the source of poetry’s richness.
The seven types (in order of increasing complexity)
| Type | What happens | Typical example |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | A detail is effective in several ways at once (metaphor, comparison with several points of likeness) | Shakespeare’s “bare ruined choirs” (Sonnet 73) |
| 2 | Two or more alternative meanings are fully resolved into one | Syntactic double meanings |
| 3 | Two apparently unconnected meanings are given in one word: the pun | Puns, allegory |
| 4 | Alternative meanings combine to make clear a complicated state of mind in the author | |
| 5 | A fortunate confusion: the author discovers his idea in the act of writing | A simile that shifts halfway |
| 6 | A statement that says nothing (tautology, contradiction, irrelevance), so the reader must invent statements | |
| 7 | Full contradiction, showing a fundamental division in the author’s mind | Herbert’s “The Sacrifice” |
Empson’s other books
| Work | Year | Key idea |
|---|---|---|
| Some Versions of Pastoral | 1935 | Pastoral as “putting the complex into the simple”; proletarian literature, Alice in Wonderland and The Beggar’s Opera treated as versions of pastoral |
| The Structure of Complex Words | 1951 | Key words (“wit”, “honest” in Othello, “sense”) and their structure of meanings |
| Milton’s God | 1961 | Milton’s God as morally repugnant |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Objective correlative: “Hamlet and His Problems” | vs | Impersonality / catalyst: “Tradition and the Individual Talent” |
| Dissociation of sensibility: Eliot, 1921 | vs | Unified sensibility: what the metaphysicals had |
| Principles of Literary Criticism (1924): theory of value | vs | Practical Criticism (1929): the protocols experiment |
| The Meaning of Meaning (1923, with Ogden) | vs | The Philosophy of Rhetoric (1936): tenor and vehicle |
| Feeling: attitude to the subject | vs | Tone: attitude to the listener |
| Leavis, The Great Tradition (1948): novel | vs | Leavis, Revaluation (1936): poetry |
| Q.D. Leavis, Fiction and the Reading Public (1932) | vs | F.R. Leavis, Mass Civilisation and Minority Culture (1930) |
| Empson, ambiguity (1930) | vs | Brooks, paradox and irony (1947) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- In which collection were “Tradition and the Individual Talent” and “Hamlet and His Problems” collected in 1920?
- Which two terms did Richards introduce for the parts of a metaphor?
- Who was Empson’s teacher at Cambridge?
Answers
- The Sacred Wood (1920).
- Tenor and vehicle (The Philosophy of Rhetoric, 1936).
- I.A. Richards.
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) In Eliot’s analogy in “Tradition and the Individual Talent”, the mind of the poet is compared to:
- (a) oxygen
- (b) sulphur dioxide
- (c) a filament of platinum
- (d) sulphurous acid
Answer and explanation
(c). The platinum acts as a catalyst and remains unaffected, as the creating mind stays separate from the man who suffers.
Q2. (Practice) Which of the following is not one of Richards’s four kinds of meaning?
- (a) Sense
- (b) Tone
- (c) Intention
- (d) Texture
Answer and explanation
(d) Texture is Ransom’s term (structure and texture). Richards’s four are sense, feeling, tone and intention.
Q3. (Practice) Consider the following statements about F.R. Leavis:
- He was the leading editor of the journal Scrutiny.
- New Bearings in English Poetry championed Eliot, Pound and Hopkins.
- The Great Tradition names Hardy and Dickens as the greatest English novelists.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 2 and 3 only
- (c) 1 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(a) 1 and 2 only. The Great Tradition names Austen, George Eliot, James and Conrad.
Q4. (Practice) According to Eliot, the “dissociation of sensibility” was aggravated by the influence of:
- (a) Donne and Marvell
- (b) Milton and Dryden
- (c) Wordsworth and Coleridge
- (d) Tennyson and Browning
Answer and explanation
(b) Milton and Dryden (“The Metaphysical Poets”, 1921). Tennyson and Browning are cited as poets who suffered from it.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Eliot judged Hamlet to be an artistic failure. Reason (R): Hamlet’s emotion is in excess of the facts as they appear, and Shakespeare found no objective correlative for it.
Answer and explanation
(a). The lack of an objective correlative is precisely Eliot’s ground for calling the play a failure.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): Richards called the statements of poetry “pseudo-statements”. Reason (R): Richards held that poetic statements are false and should be rejected.
Answer and explanation
(c). A is true. R is false: pseudo-statements are not to be judged as true or false at all; they are valued for the attitudes they organise.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (work) with List II (author).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Some Versions of Pastoral | I. T.S. Eliot |
| B. The Sacred Wood | II. F.R. Leavis |
| C. Revaluation | III. I.A. Richards |
| D. Science and Poetry | IV. William Empson |
- (1) A-IV, B-I, C-II, D-III
- (2) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
- (3) A-IV, B-III, C-II, D-I
- (4) A-I, B-IV, C-II, D-III
Answer and explanation
(1) A-IV, B-I, C-II, D-III.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following works in chronological order:
A. Practical Criticism
B. The Great Tradition
C. The Sacred Wood
D. Seven Types of Ambiguity
(1) C, A, D, B
(2) C, D, A, B
(3) A, C, D, B
(4) C, A, B, D
Answer and explanation
(1) C, A, D, B. 1920 → 1929 → 1930 → 1948.
Quick Revision Table
| Fact | Detail |
|---|---|
| “Tradition and the Individual Talent” | 1919, The Egoist; historical sense, ideal order, impersonality, catalyst (platinum) |
| “Hamlet and His Problems” | 1919; objective correlative; Hamlet an artistic failure, “Mona Lisa of literature” |
| “The Metaphysical Poets” | 1921, review of Grierson; dissociation of sensibility (17th c., Milton and Dryden) |
| The Sacred Wood | 1920 |
| “The Function of Criticism” | 1923; elucidation of works of art and correction of taste |
| “What is a Classic?” | 1944; Virgil |
| Richards | Meaning of Meaning (1923, with Ogden); Principles (1924); Science and Poetry (1926); Practical Criticism (1929); Philosophy of Rhetoric (1936) |
| Richards’s terms | Emotive vs referential; pseudo-statement; synaesthesis; inclusion; sense–feeling–tone–intention; tenor–vehicle; stock response |
| Leavis | Scrutiny (1932–53); New Bearings (1932); Revaluation (1936); Great Tradition (1948); Common Pursuit (1952) |
| Great Tradition | Austen, George Eliot, James, Conrad (+ Lawrence) |
| Q.D. Leavis | Fiction and the Reading Public (1932) |
| Empson | Seven Types of Ambiguity (1930); Some Versions of Pastoral (1935); Structure of Complex Words (1951); Milton’s God (1961) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- The New Criticism — Ransom, Brooks, Tate, Wimsatt and Beardsley turn Eliot’s taste and Richards’s method into a school
- Romantic and Victorian Criticism — revisit Wordsworth and Arnold, whom Eliot argues against
- Quick Revision