Language Acquisition and Second Language Learning
UGC NET English: stages of child language, Skinner, Chomsky, Piaget, Vygotsky, critical period, contrastive and error analysis, interlanguage, Krashen.
- 16 min
On this page · 14 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: “I Goed to the Park”
- 1. Key Distinctions
- 2. How Children Acquire Their First Language
- 3. Theories of First Language Acquisition
- 4. Second Language Acquisition (SLA) Theories
- 5. Individual Differences in Language Learning
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Nature of Language and the Major Linguistic Theories — Bloomfield’s structuralism and Chomsky’s generative grammar are the linguistic halves of the behaviourist and nativist accounts
- Learner Characteristics and Individual Differences — learners and individual differences from the Paper 1 side
- Phonetics, Phonology, Morphology, Syntax and Semantics — terms such as morpheme and inflection are used throughout
The Hook: “I Goed to the Park”
1. Key Distinctions
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| First language (L1), mother tongue | Acquired from birth |
| Second language (L2) | Learned after the L1, and used in the community where the learner lives (English in India for many speakers) |
| Foreign language | Learned where it is not a language of the community (French in India) |
| Acquisition | Subconscious “picking up” through meaningful use (in Krashen’s sense) |
| Learning | Conscious study of rules and forms |
| SLA (second language acquisition) | The field that studies how people learn languages after the first |
2. How Children Acquire Their First Language
Stages (approximate ages; children vary widely)
| Stage | Approx. age | Features |
|---|---|---|
| Crying and cooing | 0–4 months | Reflex cries; vowel-like cooing sounds |
| Babbling | From about 6 months | Repeated consonant–vowel syllables (ba-ba-ba, da-da); later variegated babbling (ba-da-gu) |
| One-word (holophrastic) stage | Around 12 months | A single word stands for a whole sentence: “Milk!” = “I want milk” |
| Two-word stage | Around 18–24 months | “Daddy go”, “more juice”: semantic relations (agent–action, possessor–possessed) |
| Telegraphic stage | From about 2 to 3 years | Content words without function words or inflections: “Mummy give ball” |
| Later development | 3 years onward | Inflections, function words, questions, negatives, complex sentences |
Typical patterns
| Pattern | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Overgeneralisation (overregularisation) | Applying a rule to exceptions | goed, foots, mouses |
| U-shaped learning | Correct irregular form → overregularised form → correct again | went → goed → went |
| Overextension | Using a word for too wide a category | doggie for every four-legged animal |
| Underextension | Using a word for too narrow a category | shoes only for one’s own shoes |
Evidence from experiments.
- Jean Berko’s “wug test” (1958) showed children a made-up creature, “a wug”, then two of them: children supplied “wugs”, proving that they had rules, since they could not have heard the word before.
- Roger Brown, A First Language (1973), traced the order in which children acquire fourteen grammatical morphemes: the present progressive -ing and the prepositions in and on come early; the third person singular -s and contracted auxiliaries come late. The order was strikingly similar across children.
3. Theories of First Language Acquisition
3.1 Behaviourism: language as habit
B.F. Skinner, Verbal Behavior (1957): language is verbal behaviour learned like any other behaviour through operant conditioning. The child imitates, adults reinforce correct forms with approval or rewards, and through repetition the child forms habits.
| Key terms | Stimulus, response, reinforcement, imitation, practice, habit formation |
|---|
Problems. Children produce forms they never heard (goed); parents mostly correct truth, not grammar; children learn at the same pace across cultures with very different reinforcement; the input is limited but the output is unlimited.
3.2 Nativism (innatism): language as an innate faculty
Noam Chomsky’s review of Verbal Behavior (in the journal Language, 1959) argued that behaviourism could not explain the creativity of language. Children are born with a Language Acquisition Device (LAD) containing Universal Grammar (UG); exposure to a language simply triggers it and sets its parameters.
Arguments for nativism:
- Poverty of the stimulus: input is limited, fragmentary and full of performance errors, yet every normal child arrives at the full grammar.
- Universality and uniformity: all normal children acquire language, at broadly similar ages and stages.
- Speed: most of the grammar is in place by about five.
- Creativity and overgeneralisation: children produce rule-based forms they have never heard.
- Independence from intelligence: language develops even in children with limited general cognitive ability.
3.3 The Critical Period Hypothesis
Eric Lenneberg, Biological Foundations of Language (1967): there is a biologically determined period, from early childhood to around puberty, during which language can be acquired naturally and fully. He linked its end to the completion of lateralisation (the specialisation of language functions in the left hemisphere of the brain). After it, acquisition is slower and seldom native-like, especially in pronunciation.
Evidence often cited: the case of Genie, a girl discovered in the United States in 1970 after extreme isolation, who learned many words but never mastered normal grammar; and the persistent foreign accents of adults who learn a second language late. The strong form of the hypothesis is debated; many researchers speak of a sensitive period rather than a sharp cut-off.
3.4 Cognitivism: language follows thought
Jean Piaget (The Language and Thought of the Child, originally 1923) held that language depends on cognitive development. A child cannot use words for things that are absent until she has object permanence; she cannot use comparatives until she can compare. Early speech is egocentric, not addressed to anyone.
| Piaget’s stage | Approx. age | Relevance to language |
|---|---|---|
| Sensorimotor | 0–2 | Object permanence; first words |
| Pre-operational | 2–7 | Symbolic thought; rapid vocabulary growth; egocentric speech |
| Concrete operational | 7–11 | Logical operations on concrete things |
| Formal operational | 11 onward | Abstract and hypothetical reasoning |
3.5 Social interactionism: language through interaction
Lev Vygotsky (Thought and Language, Russian 1934, English translation 1962; Mind in Society, 1978): language develops through social interaction and then turns inward to become a tool of thought.
| Concept | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Zone of Proximal Development (ZPD) | The gap between what a learner can do alone and what she can do with help |
| More Knowledgeable Other (MKO) | The adult or peer who provides help |
| Private (inner) speech | Speech to oneself that guides thinking; for Vygotsky, social speech turned inward (against Piaget’s “egocentric” reading) |
| Scaffolding | Temporary support withdrawn as competence grows; the term comes from David Wood, Jerome Bruner and Gail Ross (1976), not from Vygotsky himself |
Jerome Bruner (Child’s Talk: Learning to Use Language, 1983) answered Chomsky’s LAD with a LASS (Language Acquisition Support System): the routines, games and formats (such as picture-book reading and peek-a-boo) through which caregivers support the child. The simplified, expressive way adults talk to young children is child-directed speech (also called caretaker speech or “motherese”).
Summary of L1 theories
| Theory | Key figure | Language is … | Role of environment | Role of the child |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Behaviourist | Skinner (1957) | Habit | Everything: imitation and reinforcement | Passive |
| Nativist | Chomsky (1959, 1965) | Innate faculty (LAD, UG) | Trigger only | Active, rule-forming |
| Cognitive | Piaget | Part of cognitive development | Experience of the world | Active explorer |
| Social interactionist | Vygotsky, Bruner | A social tool internalised as thought | Central: interaction, scaffolding | Active partner |
4. Second Language Acquisition (SLA) Theories
4.1 Contrastive Analysis Hypothesis (CAH)
Charles Fries (Teaching and Learning English as a Foreign Language, 1945) and Robert Lado (Linguistics Across Cultures, 1957): compare the L1 and L2 systematically; where they differ, learners will have difficulty because of negative transfer (interference); where they are similar, learning will be easy (positive transfer). Rooted in structural linguistics and behaviourism, it fed directly into the Audio-Lingual Method.
Problems. Many predicted errors never occur, and many errors occur that contrastive analysis cannot predict, such as overgeneralisations shared by learners of every L1.
4.2 Error Analysis
S. Pit Corder, “The Significance of Learners’ Errors” (1967), turned attention from comparing languages to studying what learners actually produce. Errors are not sins to be stamped out but evidence of the learner’s developing system, useful to the teacher, the researcher and the learner.
| Corder’s distinction | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Error | Systematic; reflects the learner’s current competence; the learner cannot self-correct |
| Mistake | A random performance slip (tiredness, haste); the learner can self-correct |
Types of error:
- Interlingual (transfer) errors: caused by the L1 (“He is having two sisters” from a language that uses a progressive form here).
- Intralingual (developmental) errors: caused by the L2 itself, such as overgeneralisation (He goed, She can sings), shared by learners of different L1s.
Steps of error analysis: collect a sample → identify errors → describe them → explain their sources → evaluate their seriousness.
4.3 Interlanguage
Larry Selinker, “Interlanguage” (1972): the learner’s language is a separate, rule-governed system, neither the L1 nor the target language, that develops over time.
- Five central processes shape it: language transfer, transfer of training, strategies of second language learning, strategies of second language communication, and overgeneralisation of target-language rules.
- Fossilisation: some interlanguage features stop developing and persist despite further instruction and exposure.
4.4 Krashen’s Monitor Model
Stephen Krashen (Principles and Practice in Second Language Acquisition, 1982) proposed five hypotheses, the most influential (and most criticised) theory in language teaching.
| Hypothesis | Claim |
|---|---|
| 1. Acquisition–Learning | Acquisition is subconscious, through meaningful communication; learning is conscious knowledge of rules. Learning does not turn into acquisition |
| 2. Natural Order | Grammatical structures are acquired in a predictable order, which teaching does not change |
| 3. Monitor | Learned knowledge acts only as an editor (monitor) that checks output, and only when the learner has time, is focused on form and knows the rule |
| 4. Input | We acquire by understanding comprehensible input a little beyond our current level: i + 1 (i = current competence). Speaking emerges on its own when the learner is ready |
| 5. Affective Filter | Anxiety, low motivation and low self-confidence raise a mental filter that blocks input from reaching the acquisition device |
With Tracy Terrell, Krashen turned the theory into the Natural Approach (The Natural Approach, 1983). See ELT Methods, Syllabus, Skills and Testing.
Criticisms: the acquisition–learning distinction cannot be tested; “comprehensible input” and “i + 1” are not defined precisely; input alone does not produce accurate output (immersion learners in Canada understood well but spoke with errors).
4.5 After Krashen
| Hypothesis | Proponent | Claim |
|---|---|---|
| Interaction Hypothesis | Michael Long (1980s; revised 1996) | Input becomes comprehensible through negotiation of meaning in conversation: comprehension checks, clarification requests, confirmation checks |
| Output Hypothesis (comprehensible output) | Merrill Swain (1985) | Having to produce language pushes learners to notice gaps and test hypotheses; based on Canadian French immersion students |
| Noticing Hypothesis | Richard Schmidt (1990) | Input becomes intake only when it is consciously noticed |
| Acculturation Model | John Schumann (1978) | Learners acquire the L2 to the degree they acculturate to the target-language group (social and psychological distance) |
| Sociocultural theory in SLA | James Lantolf and others | Applies Vygotsky’s ZPD and mediation to second language learning |
| UG in SLA | Various | Do adult learners still have access to Universal Grammar: full, partial or none? |
5. Individual Differences in Language Learning
| Factor | Key ideas and names |
|---|---|
| Age | Critical/sensitive period (Lenneberg); younger is better for pronunciation in the long run, older learners are faster at first |
| Aptitude | John Carroll and Stanley Sapon’s Modern Language Aptitude Test (MLAT, 1959); Carroll’s four components of aptitude: phonetic coding ability, grammatical sensitivity, rote learning ability, inductive language learning ability |
| Motivation | Robert Gardner and Wallace Lambert (from 1959; book Attitudes and Motivation in Second-Language Learning, 1972): integrative (to join the community) vs instrumental (for a job or exam); intrinsic vs extrinsic (Deci and Ryan) |
| Anxiety | Raises the affective filter; language anxiety is specific to speaking in a new language |
| Learning strategies | Rebecca Oxford (1990): direct (memory, cognitive, compensation) and indirect (metacognitive, affective, social) |
| Bilingualism | Additive (L2 added without loss of L1) vs subtractive (L2 replaces L1), Lambert’s terms |
| BICS and CALP | Jim Cummins: Basic Interpersonal Communicative Skills (everyday fluency, quicker) vs Cognitive Academic Language Proficiency (academic language, slower) |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Error (Corder): systematic, competence | vs | Mistake: random, performance, self-correctable |
| Interlingual error: from L1 | vs | Intralingual error: from L2 rules |
| LAD (Chomsky): innate device | vs | LASS (Bruner): social support system |
| ZPD (Vygotsky) | vs | Scaffolding (Wood, Bruner and Ross, 1976) |
| Comprehensible input (Krashen, 1982) | vs | Comprehensible output (Swain, 1985) |
| Interaction Hypothesis (Long) | vs | Noticing Hypothesis (Schmidt, 1990) |
| Interlanguage (Selinker, 1972) | vs | Interference (contrastive analysis) |
| Overgeneralisation (goed) | vs | Overextension (doggie for all animals) |
| Integrative motivation | vs | Instrumental motivation |
| Robert Gardner (motivation) | vs | Howard Gardner (multiple intelligences) |
| Lenneberg (critical period, 1967) | vs | Lado (contrastive analysis, 1957) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Who proposed the Critical Period Hypothesis, and in which book?
- What does “i” stand for in Krashen’s “i + 1”?
- Which term did Selinker use for interlanguage features that stop developing?
Answers
- Eric Lenneberg, Biological Foundations of Language (1967).
- The learner’s current level of competence; “+1” is the next step just beyond it.
- Fossilisation.
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) A child who says “I goed” and “two foots” is showing:
- (a) overextension
- (b) overgeneralisation
- (c) fossilisation
- (d) negative transfer
Answer and explanation
(b) Overgeneralisation: applying regular past-tense and plural rules to irregular words. Overextension concerns word meaning; fossilisation and transfer are second-language terms.
Q2. (Practice) The distinction between “errors” and “mistakes” in learner language was drawn by:
- (a) Robert Lado
- (b) Larry Selinker
- (c) S. Pit Corder
- (d) Merrill Swain
Answer and explanation
(c) S. Pit Corder, “The Significance of Learners’ Errors” (1967).
Q3. (Practice) Consider the following statements about Krashen’s Monitor Model:
- It distinguishes conscious learning from subconscious acquisition.
- It holds that a high affective filter helps learners concentrate on input.
- It holds that speaking emerges once enough comprehensible input has been acquired.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 1 and 3 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 1 and 3 only. A high affective filter (anxiety, low motivation) blocks input; Krashen wants it low.
Q4. (Practice) Bruner’s “LASS” was proposed as a counterpart to:
- (a) Vygotsky’s ZPD
- (b) Chomsky’s LAD
- (c) Krashen’s monitor
- (d) Piaget’s schema
Answer and explanation
(b) Chomsky’s LAD. The Language Acquisition Support System stresses the caregiver’s role alongside any innate device.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Chomsky rejected the behaviourist account of language acquisition. Reason (R): Children routinely produce sentences and forms they have never heard and so could not have imitated.
Answer and explanation
(a). The creativity of language, including overgeneralised forms, cannot come from imitation and reinforcement alone; this is central to Chomsky’s 1959 critique.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): Contrastive analysis can predict all the errors a second-language learner will make. Reason (R): Contrastive analysis assumes that difficulty arises where the first and second languages differ.
Answer and explanation
(d). A is false: many errors (intralingual, developmental) are not predicted by contrastive analysis, and many predicted errors do not occur. R correctly states its assumption.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (scholar) with List II (concept).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. B.F. Skinner | I. Interlanguage |
| B. Eric Lenneberg | II. Operant conditioning |
| C. Larry Selinker | III. Comprehensible output |
| D. Merrill Swain | IV. Critical period |
- (1) A-II, B-IV, C-I, D-III
- (2) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
- (3) A-IV, B-II, C-I, D-III
- (4) A-II, B-IV, C-III, D-I
Answer and explanation
(1) A-II, B-IV, C-I, D-III.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following in chronological order of publication:
A. Selinker, “Interlanguage”
B. Chomsky’s review of Skinner’s Verbal Behavior
C. Krashen, Principles and Practice in Second Language Acquisition
D. Corder, “The Significance of Learners’ Errors”
(1) B, D, A, C
(2) D, B, A, C
(3) B, A, D, C
(4) B, D, C, A
Answer and explanation
(1) B, D, A, C. 1959 → 1967 → 1972 → 1982.
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| L1 stages | Cooing → babbling (~6 months) → one-word/holophrastic (~12 months) → two-word (~18–24 months) → telegraphic → multiword |
| Evidence | Overgeneralisation, U-shaped learning; Berko’s wug test (1958); Brown’s 14 morphemes (1973) |
| Behaviourism | Skinner, Verbal Behavior (1957): imitation, reinforcement, habit |
| Nativism | Chomsky’s review (1959); LAD, UG, poverty of the stimulus |
| Critical period | Lenneberg (1967); lateralisation; puberty; Genie |
| Cognitivism | Piaget: language follows thought; four stages |
| Interactionism | Vygotsky (1934; Eng. 1962): ZPD, MKO, private speech; scaffolding (Wood, Bruner, Ross, 1976); Bruner’s LASS (1983) |
| Contrastive analysis | Fries (1945), Lado (1957); transfer, interference |
| Error analysis | Corder (1967); error vs mistake; interlingual vs intralingual |
| Interlanguage | Selinker (1972); five processes; fossilisation |
| Krashen | Principles and Practice (1982): acquisition–learning, natural order, monitor, input (i + 1), affective filter; Natural Approach with Terrell (1983) |
| After Krashen | Long (interaction), Swain (output, 1985), Schmidt (noticing, 1990), Schumann (acculturation, 1978) |
| Individual differences | MLAT (1959); integrative/instrumental (Gardner and Lambert); Oxford’s strategies (1990); BICS/CALP (Cummins) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- ELT Methods, Syllabus, Skills and Testing — how each theory produced a teaching method
- Factors Affecting Teaching and Methods of Teaching in Higher Education — the Paper 1 view of teacher-centred and learner-centred methods
- Language and Pedagogy: chapter overview