Skip to content

ELT Methods, Syllabus Design, Skills and Language Testing

UGC NET English pedagogy: Grammar-Translation to CLT, TBLT and postmethod, the designer methods, syllabus types, LSRW skills, CEFR and language testing.

  • 19 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 19 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: Three Classrooms
  3. 1. Approach, Method, Technique
  4. 2. A Timeline of Methods
  5. 3. The Traditional and Structural Methods
  6. 4. The “Designer Methods” of the 1960s and 1970s
  7. 5. Communicative Language Teaching (CLT)
  8. 6. Task-Based, Lexical and Content-Based Teaching
  9. 7. The Postmethod Condition
  10. 8. Syllabus Design
  11. 9. Teaching the Four Skills
  12. 10. Language Testing and Evaluation
  13. Memory Tricks
  14. Don’t Confuse
  15. Common Mistakes
  16. Practice
  17. Quick Revision Table
  18. Key Takeaways
  19. What’s Next

Prerequisites

The Hook: Three Classrooms


1. Approach, Method, Technique

FrameworkLevelsMeaning
Edward Anthony (1963)Approach → Method → TechniqueApproach = assumptions about language and learning (axiomatic); method = an overall plan for presenting language (procedural); technique = a specific classroom activity (implementational)
Jack Richards and Theodore Rodgers, Approaches and Methods in Language Teaching (first edition 1986)Approach → Design → ProcedureDesign covers objectives, syllabus, types of activity, roles of learners, teachers and materials; procedure covers classroom techniques

2. A Timeline of Methods

timeline
    title Language teaching methods (approximate periods)
    19th century : Grammar-Translation Method
    Late 19th to early 20th century : Reform Movement : Direct Method (Berlitz schools from 1878)
    1920s to 1960s : Oral Approach and Situational Language Teaching (Palmer, Hornby, West)
    1940s to 1960s : Audio-Lingual Method (Fries, structuralism plus behaviourism)
    1960s to 1970s : Designer methods : Silent Way, Community Language Learning, Suggestopedia, TPR
    1970s onward : Communicative Language Teaching : Natural Approach (1983)
    1980s to 1990s : Task-Based Language Teaching (Prabhu 1987) : Lexical Approach (Lewis 1993)
    1990s onward : Postmethod (Kumaravadivelu 1994, 2003)

3. The Traditional and Structural Methods

Grammar-Translation Method (GTM)

Also called the Classical Method, it grew from the teaching of Latin and Greek and dominated European language teaching in the nineteenth century.

FeatureDetail
GoalRead the literature of the target language; mental discipline
SkillsReading and writing; little or no speaking and listening
GrammarTaught deductively: rule first, then examples and exercises
MediumThe mother tongue is the medium of instruction
ActivitiesTranslation both ways, bilingual vocabulary lists, memorisation of rules and paradigms
FocusAccuracy
Teacher’s roleAuthority

The Reform Movement and the Direct Method

In the 1880s phoneticians such as Henry Sweet in England, Wilhelm Viëtor in Germany (his pamphlet Language Teaching Must Start Afresh!, 1882) and Paul Passy in France called for the primacy of speech, the use of phonetics and connected texts. The International Phonetic Association (1886) grew from this movement.

The Direct Method (also “natural method”), spread by Maximilian Berlitz’s language schools (the first opened in 1878 in Providence, Rhode Island), applied these ideas:

FeatureDetail
MediumTarget language only; no translation
MeaningThrough demonstration, pictures, objects, mime
GrammarTaught inductively
SkillsSpeaking and listening first; correct pronunciation stressed
ClassroomQuestion-and-answer exchanges between teacher and students
ProblemNeeded native-like fluent teachers; hard to use in large public-school classes

François Gouin’s Series Method (sequences of actions described in sentences: “I walk to the door. I open the door …”) was an earlier naturalistic experiment of the same kind.

Oral Approach and Situational Language Teaching (SLT)

A British development from the 1920s to the 1960s, led by Harold Palmer and A.S. Hornby.

  • Language is taught orally first, with structures selected, graded and presented in situations (in the classroom, at the shop).
  • Its lesson pattern became PPP: Presentation, Practice, Production.
  • Michael West (who taught in Bengal) produced the New Method Readers and the General Service List of English Words (1953), a list of about 2,000 high-frequency words for teaching.
  • Hornby co-compiled the dictionary that became the Oxford Advanced Learner’s Dictionary and founded the journal English Language Teaching (later ELT Journal) in 1946.

Audio-Lingual Method (ALM)

FeatureDetail
OriginUnited States; grew from the wartime Army Specialized Training Program (“Army Method”, 1940s) and the structural approach of Charles Fries and others at the University of Michigan; established as a method in the 1950s
Theory of languageStructural linguistics (Bloomfield, Fries): language is a system of patterns, speech is primary
Theory of learningBehaviourism (Skinner): language is habit, formed by stimulus, response, reinforcement
TechniquesDialogue memorisation; pattern drills: repetition, substitution, transformation, chain drills; minimal-pair drills; language laboratory
ErrorsTo be prevented: they form bad habits
GrammarInductive, through drills; no explicit rules
SequenceListening → speaking → reading → writing
DeclineChomsky’s attack on behaviourism (1959) and learners’ failure to transfer drilled patterns to real communication

4. The “Designer Methods” of the 1960s and 1970s

MethodFounderKey features
Silent WayCaleb GattegnoTeacher stays silent as much as possible; learners discover and create; Cuisenaire rods, colour-coded sound-colour charts and Fidel charts; “teaching subordinated to learning”
Community Language Learning (CLL)Charles A. CurranBased on counselling psychology: teacher as counsellor (knower), learner as client; learners sit in a circle, say what they want in L1, the teacher translates, the utterance is recorded and analysed
SuggestopediaGeorgi Lozanov (Bulgaria)Removing psychological barriers (desuggestion) and creating positive suggestion; relaxed setting, comfortable chairs, baroque music during “concerts” in which long dialogues are read; learners take new identities
Total Physical Response (TPR)James AsherLearners respond to commands with physical actions (“Stand up. Walk to the window.”); comprehension before production; low stress; draws on how children learn L1
Natural ApproachStephen Krashen and Tracy Terrell (1983)Applies Krashen’s hypotheses: comprehensible input, a silent period, low affective filter, communication over grammar

5. Communicative Language Teaching (CLT)

From the late 1960s British applied linguists, influenced by Hymes’s communicative competence and Halliday’s functional linguistics, argued that knowing a language means being able to use it to do things.

LandmarkYearContribution
J.A. van Ek, The Threshold Level (Council of Europe)1975Specification of what a learner needs to function independently
D.A. Wilkins, Notional Syllabuses1976Syllabus organised by notions (time, quantity, location) and functions (requesting, apologising, inviting)
John Munby, Communicative Syllabus Design1978Detailed needs analysis model
H.G. Widdowson, Teaching Language as Communication1978Usage (knowledge of rules) vs use (ability to communicate)
Brumfit and Johnson (eds), The Communicative Approach to Language Teaching1979Key collection of papers
William Littlewood, Communicative Language Teaching1981Pre-communicative and communicative activities
A.P.R. Howatt, A History of English Language Teaching1984Weak version (learning to use English) vs strong version (using English to learn it)

Features of CLT:

  • Goal is communicative competence; fluency is valued alongside accuracy.
  • Meaning is primary; language is learned through using it.
  • Activities: information gap, opinion gap, role-play, simulations, problem-solving, pair and group work.
  • Authentic materials (timetables, menus, newspapers).
  • Errors are a natural part of learning; correction is selective.
  • Teacher as facilitator, needs analyst, co-communicator; learner as negotiator.
  • L1 is used judiciously, not banned.

6. Task-Based, Lexical and Content-Based Teaching

Task-Based Language Teaching (TBLT)

N.S. Prabhu’s Bangalore Project (the Communicational Teaching Project, run in schools in south India from 1979 to 1984) taught English through tasks with no explicit grammar teaching, on the view that grammar is acquired when the mind is focused on meaning. It was reported in Prabhu’s Second Language Pedagogy (1987).

Prabhu’s three task types:

Task typeLearners must …Example
Information-gaptransfer information from one person or form to anotherComplete a timetable from a partner’s half
Reasoning-gapderive new information by inferenceWork out the best route from a set of train times
Opinion-gapexpress a personal preference or attitudeDecide what to do about a social problem

Jane Willis, A Framework for Task-Based Learning (1996), gave the standard lesson framework:

  1. Pre-task: introduction to topic and task.
  2. Task cycle: task (in pairs or groups) → planning (preparing to report) → report (to the class).
  3. Language focus: analysis and practice of language that arose.

Other key names: David Nunan (Designing Tasks for the Communicative Classroom, 1989) and Rod Ellis (Task-based Language Learning and Teaching, 2003).

Lexical Approach and content-based teaching

  • Michael Lewis, The Lexical Approach (1993): language consists of grammaticalised lexis, not lexicalised grammar; teach chunks, collocations and fixed expressions.
  • Content-Based Instruction (CBI) and CLIL (Content and Language Integrated Learning): a subject (science, history) is taught through the target language, so language is learned as the medium of content.

Lesson frameworks compared

FrameworkStagesAssociated with
PPPPresentation → Practice → ProductionSituational Language Teaching
ESAEngage → Study → Activate (in flexible orders: straight arrows, boomerang, patchwork)Jeremy Harmer
TTTTest → Teach → TestDiagnostic, task-first teaching
Willis TBLPre-task → task cycle → language focusJane Willis (1996)

7. The Postmethod Condition

N.S. Prabhu, “There Is No Best Method—Why?” (TESOL Quarterly, 1990): the search for the best method is mistaken; what matters is the teacher’s “sense of plausibility”, a personal, evolving understanding of how learning happens.

B. Kumaravadivelu, “The Postmethod Condition” (TESOL Quarterly, 1994) and Beyond Methods: Macrostrategies for Language Teaching (2003), proposed a postmethod pedagogy built on three parameters:

ParameterMeaning
ParticularityTeaching must be sensitive to a particular group of teachers and learners in a particular context
PracticalityTeachers should theorise from their practice and practise what they theorise
PossibilityPedagogy should tap learners’ socio-political consciousness and identity (drawing on Freire)

He also proposed ten macrostrategies: maximise learning opportunities; minimise perceptual mismatches; facilitate negotiated interaction; promote learner autonomy; foster language awareness; activate intuitive heuristics; contextualise linguistic input; integrate language skills; ensure social relevance; raise cultural consciousness.


8. Syllabus Design

DistinctionMeaning
Curriculum vs syllabusCurriculum is the whole educational programme (aims, content, methods, evaluation); syllabus is the selection and sequencing of content
Synthetic vs analytic (Wilkins, 1976)Synthetic: language broken into pieces taught one by one for the learner to put together (structural); analytic: language presented in whole chunks organised by purpose (notional-functional, task-based)
Product vs processFocus on what is learned vs on how learning happens
Syllabus typeOrganised aroundExample unit
Structural (grammatical)Grammar items, simple to complex“The present perfect”
SituationalSettings where language is used“At the bank”
Notional-functionalNotions and communicative functions“Making requests”; “Expressing time”
Skill-basedSub-skills of LSRW“Skimming for gist”
Task-basedTasks to be completed“Plan a trip from a timetable”
Content-basedSubject matter“Climate change”
ProceduralProblem-solving tasks, no language content specified (Prabhu)Bangalore Project tasks
ProcessNegotiated between teacher and learners (Breen and Candlin)Decided in class
LexicalWords, collocations and chunks“Phrases with make and do”

9. Teaching the Four Skills

SkillReceptive or productiveMedium
ListeningReceptiveOral
SpeakingProductiveOral
ReadingReceptiveWritten
WritingProductiveWritten

Listening and reading

  • Bottom-up processing: building meaning from the smallest units (sounds, letters, words) upwards.
  • Top-down processing: using background knowledge and expectations to interpret the text.
  • Schema theory: comprehension depends on activating the reader’s existing knowledge structures (schemata); hence pre-reading and pre-listening activities.
  • Reading sub-skills: skimming (for gist), scanning (for specific information), intensive reading (close, detailed, often in class), extensive reading (large quantities for pleasure and fluency, often graded readers).
  • SQ3R (Survey, Question, Read, Recite, Review), a study-reading method associated with Francis P. Robinson (1946).
  • Lesson pattern: pre-, while- and post- reading or listening.

The Comprehension unit of Paper 1 applies the same strategies to the exam’s own passages.

Speaking and writing

  • Accuracy vs fluency activities (Christopher Brumfit’s distinction).
  • Writing approaches: product (imitate a model text), process (planning, drafting, revising, editing, with feedback between drafts), genre (analyse how texts of a genre are structured for their purpose).

Grammar and vocabulary

  • Deductive (rule → examples) vs inductive (examples → learners discover the rule).
  • Focus on form (attention to form arising during meaning-focused activity; Michael Long’s term) vs focus on forms (the traditional grammar lesson).
  • Consciousness-raising: helping learners notice features of the language without requiring immediate production.

ESP and the CEFR

  • English for Specific Purposes (ESP): courses designed from learners’ needs. Divided into EAP (academic) and EOP (occupational). Key text: Tom Hutchinson and Alan Waters, English for Specific Purposes: A Learning-Centred Approach (1987).
  • Common European Framework of Reference for Languages (CEFR), Council of Europe, 2001: six levels in three bands.
BandLevels
Basic userA1 (Breakthrough), A2 (Waystage)
Independent userB1 (Threshold), B2 (Vantage)
Proficient userC1 (Effective Operational Proficiency), C2 (Mastery)

10. Language Testing and Evaluation

Types of test by purpose

TestPurpose
ProficiencyGeneral ability, regardless of any course (IELTS, TOEFL)
AchievementWhat has been learned in a particular course
DiagnosticIdentify strengths and weaknesses for remedial teaching
PlacementPlace learners at the right level
AptitudePredict ability to learn a language (MLAT)

Other distinctions

PairContrast
Formative vs summativeDuring the course, to improve learning vs at the end, to judge it
Norm-referenced vs criterion-referencedCompares a candidate with other candidates vs with a fixed standard
Discrete-point vs integrativeTests one element at a time (Lado’s tradition) vs several skills together (cloze, dictation: John Oller’s work)
Direct vs indirectPerforms the skill (writing an essay) vs tests sub-skills that underlie it (choosing correct sentences)
Objective vs subjectiveScoring needs no judgement (MCQs) vs scoring needs judgement (essays)

A cloze test deletes words at regular intervals (every nth word) from a passage; the method was introduced by Wilson Taylor in 1953.

Qualities of a good test

QualityMeaning
ValidityThe test measures what it claims to measure. Content validity (representative sample of the syllabus); construct validity (measures the underlying ability as theorised); criterion-related validity, either concurrent (agrees with another trusted measure now) or predictive (predicts future performance); face validity (looks right to candidates and users)
ReliabilityConsistent results: test-retest, parallel forms, split-half, inter-rater (between scorers) and intra-rater (one scorer over time)
PracticalityFeasible in time, cost and administration
Washback (backwash)The effect of a test on teaching and learning: positive (teaching the test means teaching the skill) or negative (narrow cramming)
AuthenticityTest tasks resemble real-world language use

Item analysis: two numbers

Facility value (difficulty index) is the proportion of candidates who answer an item correctly:

$$\text{FV} = \frac{\text{number of correct responses}}{\text{total number of candidates}}$$

Discrimination index compares the top and bottom scoring groups (of equal size n):

$$D = \frac{U - L}{n}$$

where U and L are the numbers of correct answers in the upper and lower groups.

Worked example. 60 candidates take a test. 45 answer item 7 correctly, so \( \text{FV} = 45 / 60 = 0.75 \): a fairly easy item. In the top 20 scorers, 18 got it right; in the bottom 20, 8 got it right. Then \( D = (18 - 8) / 20 = 0.5 \): the item separates strong from weak candidates well. An item that more weak candidates get right than strong ones has a negative \( D \) and should be revised or dropped.


Memory Tricks

Don’t Confuse

ThisvsThat
Approach–method–technique (Anthony, 1963)vsApproach–design–procedure (Richards and Rodgers, 1986)
GTM: deductive, L1 medium, reading/writingvsDirect Method: inductive, target language only, speaking first
Audio-Lingual: US, behaviourist drillsvsSituational Language Teaching: British, structures in situations, PPP
Silent Way (Gattegno)vsSuggestopedia (Lozanov) vs CLL (Curran) vs TPR (Asher)
Wilkins: Notional Syllabuses (1976)vsWiddowson: Teaching Language as Communication (1978), usage vs use
Weak CLT: learn to use EnglishvsStrong CLT: use English to learn it (Howatt)
Prabhu: Bangalore Project, Second Language Pedagogy (1987), sense of plausibilityvsKumaravadivelu: postmethod, 3 parameters, 10 macrostrategies
Skimming: gistvsScanning: specific information
Formative: duringvsSummative: at the end
Norm-referenced: against othersvsCriterion-referenced: against a standard
Validity: measures the right thingvsReliability: measures consistently
Achievement: what the course taughtvsProficiency: general ability, any course

Common Mistakes


Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. Who directed the Bangalore Project, and in which book was it reported?
  2. Which method uses Cuisenaire rods and colour charts?
  3. What does “washback” mean in language testing?
Answers
  1. N.S. Prabhu; Second Language Pedagogy (1987).
  2. The Silent Way (Caleb Gattegno).
  3. The effect of a test on teaching and learning, positive or negative.

Level 2: Exam-style MCQs

Q1. (Practice) Which of the following is not a feature of the Grammar-Translation Method?

  • (a) Deductive teaching of grammar
  • (b) Use of the mother tongue as the medium of instruction
  • (c) Emphasis on oral fluency from the first lesson
  • (d) Translation of literary passages
Answer and explanation

(c). GTM neglects speaking and listening; oral fluency from the start is a Direct Method principle.

Q2. (Practice) In an item analysis, 72 candidates attempted an item and 54 answered it correctly. What is the facility value of the item?

  • (a) 0.25
  • (b) 0.54
  • (c) 0.75
  • (d) 1.33
Answer and explanation

(c) 0.75. \( \text{FV} = 54 / 72 = 0.75 \). (d) inverts the fraction; a facility value can never exceed 1.

Q3. (Practice) Consider the following statements about Communicative Language Teaching:

  1. It draws on Hymes’s notion of communicative competence.
  2. It treats learner errors as bad habits to be prevented by drilling.
  3. It uses information-gap activities and authentic materials.

Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  • (a) 1 and 2 only
  • (b) 1 and 3 only
  • (c) 2 and 3 only
  • (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation

(b) 1 and 3 only. Statement 2 describes the Audio-Lingual Method.

Q4. (Practice) “Particularity, practicality and possibility” are the parameters of:

  • (a) Krashen’s Natural Approach
  • (b) Kumaravadivelu’s postmethod pedagogy
  • (c) Willis’s task-based framework
  • (d) Harmer’s ESA model
Answer and explanation

(b) Kumaravadivelu’s postmethod pedagogy (1994, 2003).

Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence

For assertion–reason questions, use these options:

  • (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
  • (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
  • (c) A is true, but R is false
  • (d) A is false, but R is true

Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): The Audio-Lingual Method relies heavily on repetition and pattern drills. Reason (R): It assumes, following behaviourist psychology, that language learning is the formation of habits.

Answer and explanation

(a). Drills exist to form correct habits through repeated stimulus, response and reinforcement.

Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): A test with high reliability must also have high validity. Reason (R): Reliability refers to the consistency of test scores.

Answer and explanation

(d). A is false: a test can measure the wrong thing consistently. R is a correct definition.

Q3. (Practice) Match List I (method) with List II (founder or developer).

List IList II
A. Silent WayI. James Asher
B. SuggestopediaII. Charles A. Curran
C. Total Physical ResponseIII. Caleb Gattegno
D. Community Language LearningIV. Georgi Lozanov
  • (1) A-III, B-IV, C-I, D-II
  • (2) A-IV, B-III, C-I, D-II
  • (3) A-III, B-IV, C-II, D-I
  • (4) A-III, B-I, C-IV, D-II
Answer and explanation

(1) A-III, B-IV, C-I, D-II.

Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following in chronological order:

  • A. Wilkins, Notional Syllabuses

  • B. Prabhu, Second Language Pedagogy

  • C. Lewis, The Lexical Approach

  • D. Kumaravadivelu, Beyond Methods

  • (1) A, B, C, D

  • (2) B, A, C, D

  • (3) A, C, B, D

  • (4) A, B, D, C

Answer and explanation

(1) A, B, C, D. 1976 → 1987 → 1993 → 2003.


Quick Revision Table

ItemDetail
FrameworksAnthony (1963): approach–method–technique; Richards and Rodgers (1986): approach–design–procedure
GTMDeductive grammar, translation, L1 medium, reading and writing, accuracy
Reform MovementSweet, Viëtor (1882), Passy; IPA (1886)
Direct MethodBerlitz (from 1878); target language only; inductive; speech first
SLT / Oral ApproachPalmer, Hornby, West (General Service List, 1953); PPP
ALMFries; Army Method; structuralism + behaviourism; drills, dialogues, language lab
Designer methodsSilent Way (Gattegno), CLL (Curran), Suggestopedia (Lozanov), TPR (Asher), Natural Approach (Krashen and Terrell, 1983)
CLTvan Ek (1975), Wilkins (1976), Munby (1978), Widdowson (1978), Littlewood (1981), Howatt weak/strong (1984)
TBLTPrabhu: Bangalore Project (1979–84), Second Language Pedagogy (1987), three gaps; Willis (1996); Nunan; Ellis
Lexical ApproachLewis (1993): chunks, collocations
PostmethodPrabhu (1990) sense of plausibility; Kumaravadivelu (1994, 2003): 3 parameters, 10 macrostrategies
Syllabus typesStructural, situational, notional-functional, skill, task, content, procedural, process, lexical; synthetic vs analytic
SkillsBottom-up/top-down; schema; skimming/scanning; intensive/extensive; product/process/genre writing
ESP and CEFRHutchinson and Waters (1987); CEFR (2001) A1–C2
TestingProficiency, achievement, diagnostic, placement, aptitude; validity, reliability, practicality, washback; cloze (Taylor, 1953); FV and D

Key Takeaways

What’s Next