Skip to content

The Birmingham School: Hoggart, Williams, Thompson and Hall

UGC NET English: British cultural studies: Hoggart, Williams, E.P. Thompson, the CCCS, Hall's encoding/decoding, subcultures and cultural materialism.

  • 19 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 13 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: A Scholarship Boy Reads His Own Street
  3. 1. The Founding Texts
  4. 2. The Centre for Contemporary Cultural Studies (CCCS)
  5. 3. Subcultures, Youth and Resistance
  6. 4. Cultural Materialism and New Historicism
  7. Memory Tricks
  8. Don’t Confuse
  9. Common Mistakes
  10. Practice
  11. Quick Revision Table
  12. Key Takeaways
  13. What’s Next

Prerequisites

The Hook: A Scholarship Boy Reads His Own Street


1. The Founding Texts

British cultural studies is usually traced to three books and one historian, all by writers connected with adult education and the early New Left:

AuthorWorkYearContribution
Richard HoggartThe Uses of Literacy: Aspects of Working-Class Life1957Close, sympathetic reading of northern working-class life and its threat from new commercial mass entertainment
Raymond WilliamsCulture and Society 1780–19501958History of the idea of culture as a response to industrialism; culture as a whole way of life
Raymond WilliamsThe Long Revolution1961Three categories of culture; structure of feeling; the “long revolution” of democracy, industry and culture
E.P. ThompsonThe Making of the English Working Class1963History from below; class as a relationship made by people in experience

Richard Hoggart, The Uses of Literacy (1957)

The book has two parts:

PartTitleContent
One“An ‘Older’ Order”Affectionate description of interwar working-class life in the northern cities: home, mother, neighbourhood, the sense of “Us” and “Them”, tolerance, the “full rich life” of the pub, the club and the seaside outing
Two“Yielding Place to New”Critique of the new mass publications and entertainments of the 1950s: sex-and-violence novels, popular newspapers, the “juke-box boys” of the milk bars, a “candy-floss world” of shallow pleasure

Hoggart also wrote a famous chapter on the scholarship boy, uprooted by education from his class and not at home in the middle class: a figure drawn from his own life.

Raymond Williams: culture is ordinary

Raymond Williams (1921–1988), born in Pandy on the Welsh border, taught in adult education, then at Cambridge. He is the most cited figure in the unit.

WorkYearRemember
“Culture is Ordinary” (essay)1958Culture means both a whole way of life and the arts and learning; both are ordinary, made in every society and every mind
Culture and Society 1780–19501958Five keywords that changed meaning in the Industrial Revolution: industry, democracy, class, art, culture; “There are in fact no masses; there are only ways of seeing people as masses”
Border Country (novel)1960Fiction of the Welsh border and the scholarship boy’s return
The Long Revolution1961Ideal, documentary and social definitions; structure of feeling; the “selective tradition”
Communications1962Communication systems and their control
The Country and the City1973The pastoral myth of a lost rural “organic” past keeps receding into earlier periods; country-house poems read against the labour they hide
“Base and Superstructure in Marxist Cultural Theory” (essay)1973Rethinks the Marxist model; introduces dominant, residual and emergent
Television: Technology and Cultural Form1974Television as “flow” rather than a series of discrete programmes; technology does not determine culture by itself
Keywords: A Vocabulary of Culture and Society1976Historical semantics of key words
Marxism and Literature1977Full statement of cultural materialism; dominant, residual, emergent; structure of feeling
Problems in Materialism and Culture1980Collected essays

Williams’s key concepts

ConceptMeaning
Culture is ordinaryCulture is not the possession of a minority: every society makes meanings in the whole of its life
Structure of feelingThe lived, felt sense of a particular period or generation: the “culture of a period”, present in its art and conventions but not yet fixed as formal ideology. Williams used the phrase from the 1950s and developed it in The Long Revolution and Marxism and Literature
Selective traditionThe way each period selects from the past what will count as “tradition”, and neglects the rest; the canon is made, not given
Dominant, residual, emergentAny culture contains the dominant (the central, effective system of meanings), the residual (formed in the past but still active in the present, such as rural or religious values) and the emergent (new meanings, values and practices being created)
Cultural materialismWilliams’s name for his own position: culture (including literature) is a material practice of production, not a mere reflection of an economic “base”
FlowThe planned sequence of television, in which programmes, trailers and advertisements run together as a single experience

E.P. Thompson: history from below

E.P. Thompson’s The Making of the English Working Class (1963) covers roughly 1780 to 1832. Its preface makes three famous claims:

  • “Making”: the working class “was present at its own making”; it did not simply appear as an effect of the factory system.
  • Class is a relationship, a historical happening in human experience, not a thing or a fixed structure.
  • The historian should rescue the stockinger, the Luddite cropper and the hand-loom weaver “from the enormous condescension of posterity”.

Thompson’s emphasis on experience and agency is the historian’s version of Williams’s “culture is ordinary”. He later attacked Althusser’s structuralist Marxism in The Poverty of Theory (1978).


2. The Centre for Contemporary Cultural Studies (CCCS)

timeline
    title The Birmingham Centre in outline
    1957 to 1963 : Hoggart, Williams and Thompson publish the founding texts
    1964 : Hoggart founds the CCCS at the University of Birmingham
    1968 to 1979 : Stuart Hall leads the Centre : turn to structuralism, Gramsci, media, subcultures, feminism, race
    1973 : Hall, Encoding and Decoding in the Television Discourse
    1975 to 1979 : Resistance through Rituals, Policing the Crisis, Learning to Labour, Subculture
    1979 : Hall moves to the Open University
    2002 : The University of Birmingham closes its cultural studies department
FactDetail
Founded1964, University of Birmingham, by Richard Hoggart, its first director
Stuart HallJoined in 1964; led the Centre from 1968 (acting director from 1968, director from 1972; Hoggart left for UNESCO in 1970) until 1979, when he moved to the Open University
MethodCollective, interdisciplinary work in sub-groups (media, subcultures, women’s studies, race, history); publications in Working Papers in Cultural Studies and as stencilled papers
ClosureThe department was closed by the university in 2002

Stuart Hall (1932–2014)

Born in Kingston, Jamaica, Hall came to Oxford as a Rhodes Scholar, was the first editor of the New Left Review (1960), and became the defining figure of British cultural studies.

WorkYearKey idea
The Popular Arts (with Paddy Whannel)1964Discrimination within popular culture (good and bad films, jazz) rather than against it
“Encoding and Decoding in the Television Discourse”1973 (CCCS paper); revised as “Encoding/Decoding”, 1980Meaning is encoded by producers and decoded by audiences, who may not read it as intended
Resistance through Rituals (ed. with Tony Jefferson)1975 (as a journal issue); 1976 (book)Youth subcultures as symbolic resistance
Policing the Crisis: Mugging, the State and Law and Order (with Critcher, Jefferson, Clarke and Roberts)1978The 1970s moral panic about “mugging” as a sign of a crisis of hegemony; police and courts as primary definers of news
“The Great Moving Right Show”1979Analysis of Thatcherism as “authoritarian populism”
“Cultural Studies: Two Paradigms”1980Field split between culturalism and structuralism
“Notes on Deconstructing ’the Popular’”1981Popular culture as a site of struggle
“Cultural Identity and Diaspora”1990Identity is a matter of “becoming” as well as “being”; a production, never complete
Representation: Cultural Representations and Signifying Practices (ed.)1997Three approaches to representation: reflective, intentional, constructionist

Encoding/decoding

Hall broke with the linear sender → message → receiver model of mass communication. The television message is encoded at production (within professional routines and dominant ideologies) and decoded by viewers in their own social situation. The two moments are not necessarily symmetrical: what is meant is not always what is understood.

Decoding positionWhat the viewer doesExample
Dominant-hegemonicReads the message in the preferred code in which it was encoded, accepting it fullyA viewer accepts a news bulletin’s framing of a strike as “disruption to the public”
NegotiatedAccepts the dominant definitions in general but adapts or resists them where they touch local or personal interests“Strikes do harm the economy, but our union’s pay claim is fair”
OppositionalUnderstands the preferred reading but decodes the message in a contrary frameworkA worker reads every mention of “the national interest” as “the employers’ interest”

Hall also mentions a professional code (the broadcaster’s own technical and professional conventions), which operates within the dominant-hegemonic code. David Morley’s The ‘Nationwide’ Audience (1980) tested the model with groups of viewers of a BBC current-affairs programme; it followed Charlotte Brunsdon and Morley’s Everyday Television: ‘Nationwide’ (1978).

Two paradigms

CulturalismStructuralism
Williams, Hoggart, ThompsonLévi-Strauss, Althusser, Barthes
Stresses experience, agency, human makingStresses structures (language, ideology) that make subjects
Culture as a whole way of life, livedCulture as signifying systems, codes
Danger: humanist, untheorisedDanger: no room for agency or change

Hall argued that neither was adequate on its own, and that the work of Gramsci (hegemony) offered a way between them: subjects are shaped by structures but meanings are always being contested. This is called the “turn to Gramsci” in British cultural studies (see Frankfurt School, Gramsci, Althusser, Barthes and Bourdieu).

Representation and the circuit of culture

In Representation (1997) Hall distinguished three approaches:

ApproachMeaning lies…
Reflective (mimetic)In the object, person or event in the real world; language mirrors it
IntentionalIn what the speaker or author intends
Constructionist (semiotic, after Saussure; discursive, after Foucault)In the systems of representation through which meaning is constructed

Hall’s own position is constructionist. The Open University textbook series of the same year used a “circuit of culture” (in du Gay, Hall and others, Doing Cultural Studies: The Story of the Sony Walkman, 1997), whose five moments are representation, identity, production, consumption and regulation.


3. Subcultures, Youth and Resistance

AuthorWorkYearKey idea
Phil Cohen“Subcultural Conflict and Working-Class Community”1972Subcultures as “magical” (symbolic, imaginary) resolutions of contradictions in the parent working-class culture
Stanley CohenFolk Devils and Moral Panics1972Moral panic about the mods and rockers of the mid-1960s; media amplification creates “folk devils”
Hall and Jefferson (eds)Resistance through Rituals1975–76Youth subcultures (teds, mods, skinheads) as symbolic resistance within a framework of hegemony
Angela McRobbie and Jenny Garber“Girls and Subcultures”1975Girls are absent from subcultural studies; their culture lies in the bedroom and the magazine
Paul WillisLearning to Labour: How Working Class Kids Get Working Class Jobs1977Ethnography of “the lads” in a Midlands school; their counter-school culture prepares them for manual labour
Paul WillisProfane Culture1978Bikeboys and hippies; homology between a group’s values and its objects and music
Dick HebdigeSubculture: The Meaning of Style1979Punk style as bricolage and “noise”; subcultures incorporated through commodity and ideological forms

Hebdige, Subculture: The Meaning of Style (1979)

TermMeaning in Hebdige
StyleA signifying practice: clothes, music, hair and dance as a coded refusal
Bricolage(from Lévi-Strauss) Taking objects from their usual context and re-assembling them to make new meanings: the safety pin as punk jewellery, the Union Jack on the back of a mod’s parka
Homology(from Willis) The fit between a group’s values and its style; punk’s chaos was itself ordered
NoiseSubculture as an interference in the orderly sequence of media representation
IncorporationSubcultures are recuperated in two ways: the commodity form (styles turned into mass-produced goods) and the ideological form (deviants labelled, trivialised, “domesticated” by the media)

Hebdige also traced the dialogue between black British (West Indian) culture (reggae, Rastafarianism) and white working-class youth styles.

Gender and race enter the Centre

DevelopmentWorkYear
Feminist critique of the Centre’s male biasCCCS Women’s Studies Group, Women Take Issue1978
Girls’ magazinesMcRobbie’s study of the teenage magazine JackieLate 1970s
Race and racismCCCS, The Empire Strikes Back: Race and Racism in 70s Britain1982
Race, nation and classPaul Gilroy, There Ain’t No Black in the Union Jack1987
DiasporaPaul Gilroy, The Black Atlantic: Modernity and Double Consciousness1993

Gilroy took “double consciousness” from W.E.B. Du Bois (The Souls of Black Folk, 1903) and imagined the Black Atlantic as a transnational culture of the African diaspora, connecting Africa, the Caribbean, America and Britain, against the “ethnic absolutism” of national cultures. Hall later recalled that feminism had broken into the Centre unexpectedly, interrupting its work and forcing it to rethink.


4. Cultural Materialism and New Historicism

Williams’s term cultural materialism gave its name to a British school of Renaissance criticism in the 1980s. It is usually paired with the American new historicism. Both read literature alongside non-literary texts of its period; they differ in politics. (Both are also treated as literary theory in Unit 9; here the focus is their link to cultural studies.)

Cultural materialism (British)New historicism (American)
Key textJonathan Dollimore and Alan Sinfield (eds), Political Shakespeare: New Essays in Cultural Materialism (1985)Stephen Greenblatt, Renaissance Self-Fashioning: From More to Shakespeare (1980)
SourcesWilliams, Gramsci, MarxismFoucault, Geertz’s thick description
ProgrammeDollimore and Sinfield’s foreword names four features: historical context, theoretical method, political commitment, textual analysisGreenblatt called it a “poetics of culture”; Louis Montrose’s formula: “the historicity of texts and the textuality of history”
PowerStresses dissidence and the possibility of subversion; asks how Shakespeare is used today (in schools, theatre, national heritage)Often finds that subversion is produced in order to be contained (Greenblatt’s essay “Invisible Bullets”)
PoliticsOpenly committed (socialist, feminist, gay)Less overtly political

Memory Tricks

Don’t Confuse

ThisvsThat
Stanley Cohen, Folk Devils and Moral Panics (1972)vsPhil Cohen, “Subcultural Conflict and Working-Class Community” (1972)
Paul Willis, Learning to Labour (1977): ethnography of schoolboysvsDick Hebdige, Subculture: The Meaning of Style (1979): punk style
Bricolage (Hebdige, from Lévi-Strauss)vsHomology (Willis, used by Hebdige)
Residual culture (old, still active)vsArchaic element (old, recognised only as past)
Williams’s structure of feeling (lived experience of a period)vsAlthusser’s ideology (imaginary relation to real conditions)
The Long Revolution (Williams, 1961)vsThe Making of the English Working Class (Thompson, 1963)
Cultural materialism (Dollimore and Sinfield, British, 1985)vsNew historicism (Greenblatt, American, 1980)
Culturalism (Williams, Thompson)vsStructuralism (Althusser, Barthes)
Gilroy’s There Ain’t No Black in the Union Jack (1987)vsGilroy’s The Black Atlantic (1993)

Common Mistakes


Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. Who founded the Centre for Contemporary Cultural Studies, and in which year?
  2. What are Hall’s three decoding positions?
  3. Which book did Hoggart divide into “An ‘Older’ Order” and “Yielding Place to New”?
Answers
  1. Richard Hoggart, 1964, University of Birmingham.
  2. Dominant-hegemonic, negotiated, oppositional.
  3. The Uses of Literacy (1957).

Level 2: Exam-style MCQs

Q1. (Practice) “There are in fact no masses; there are only ways of seeing people as masses.” This statement occurs in:

  • (a) The Uses of Literacy
  • (b) Culture and Society 1780–1950
  • (c) Mass Civilisation and Minority Culture
  • (d) Subculture: The Meaning of Style
Answer and explanation

(b) Raymond Williams, in the conclusion of Culture and Society (1958). The sentence is his direct reply to the Leavisite language of “masses” (option c).

Q2. (Practice) In Raymond Williams’s account, values and practices formed in the past but still active in the present are called:

  • (a) dominant
  • (b) emergent
  • (c) residual
  • (d) hegemonic
Answer and explanation

(c) residual. Williams gives organised religion and the idea of rural community as examples. Emergent elements are new meanings still being formed.

Q3. (Practice) Consider the following statements about Dick Hebdige’s Subculture: The Meaning of Style (1979):

  1. It borrows the concept of bricolage from Lévi-Strauss.
  2. It argues that subcultures are incorporated through commodity and ideological forms.
  3. It is an ethnography of a Midlands secondary school.

Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  • (a) 1 only
  • (b) 1 and 2 only
  • (c) 2 and 3 only
  • (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation

(b) 1 and 2 only. Statement 3 describes Paul Willis’s Learning to Labour (1977).

Q4. (Practice) Stuart Hall’s analysis of Thatcherism described it as:

  • (a) repressive desublimation
  • (b) authoritarian populism
  • (c) the culture industry
  • (d) passive revolution of the Right only
Answer and explanation

(b) In “The Great Moving Right Show” (1979). Repressive desublimation is Marcuse’s term; the culture industry is Adorno and Horkheimer’s.

Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence

For assertion–reason questions, use these options:

  • (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
  • (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
  • (c) A is true, but R is false
  • (d) A is false, but R is true

Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Hall argued that a television message may be decoded in a way its producers did not intend. Reason (R): For Hall, encoding and decoding are distinct moments that are not necessarily symmetrical, since viewers decode from their own social positions.

Answer and explanation

(a). The lack of symmetry between the two moments is exactly why negotiated and oppositional readings are possible.

Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): E.P. Thompson insisted that the working class “was present at its own making”. Reason (R): Thompson treated class as a fixed economic structure that determines consciousness.

Answer and explanation

(c). A is true. R is false: Thompson treated class as a relationship and a historical happening in experience, which is why he stressed the class’s own agency.

Q3. (Practice) Match List I (author) with List II (work).

List IList II
A. Paul WillisI. Folk Devils and Moral Panics
B. Stanley CohenII. The Black Atlantic
C. Paul GilroyIII. Learning to Labour
D. David MorleyIV. The ‘Nationwide’ Audience
  • (1) A-III, B-I, C-II, D-IV
  • (2) A-I, B-III, C-II, D-IV
  • (3) A-III, B-II, C-I, D-IV
  • (4) A-III, B-I, C-IV, D-II
Answer and explanation

(1) A-III, B-I, C-II, D-IV.

Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following in chronological order of first publication:

  • A. Policing the Crisis

  • B. The Uses of Literacy

  • C. The Making of the English Working Class

  • D. Keywords

  • (1) B, C, D, A

  • (2) B, C, A, D

  • (3) C, B, D, A

  • (4) B, D, C, A

Answer and explanation

(1) B, C, D, A. 1957 → 1963 → 1976 → 1978.


Quick Revision Table

FactDetail
Hoggart, The Uses of Literacy (1957)“An ‘Older’ Order” / “Yielding Place to New”; Us and Them; juke-box boys; scholarship boy
Williams, Culture and Society (1958)Five keywords; “no masses, only ways of seeing people as masses”
Williams, “Culture is Ordinary” (1958)Culture = whole way of life + arts and learning, both ordinary
Williams, The Long Revolution (1961)Ideal/documentary/social; structure of feeling; selective tradition
Williams, laterCountry and the City (1973); Television (1974): flow; Keywords (1976); Marxism and Literature (1977): dominant, residual, emergent; cultural materialism
Thompson (1963)Making of the English Working Class; “enormous condescension of posterity”; Poverty of Theory (1978)
CCCSFounded 1964 by Hoggart; Hall 1968–79; closed 2002
HallEncoding/decoding (1973; 1980); Policing the Crisis (1978); “Two Paradigms” (1980); “Cultural Identity and Diaspora” (1990); Representation (1997)
SubculturesS. Cohen 1972 (moral panic); Resistance through Rituals 1975–76; Willis 1977; Hebdige 1979 (bricolage, incorporation)
Gender and raceWomen Take Issue (1978); The Empire Strikes Back (1982); Gilroy 1987, 1993
Cultural materialism vs new historicismDollimore and Sinfield 1985 vs Greenblatt 1980

Key Takeaways

What’s Next