International Taxation: Double Taxation Relief and Transfer Pricing
UGC NET Commerce: double taxation, DTAA under sections 90 and 91, relief methods, OECD and UN models, BEPS, transfer pricing, arm's length methods and APAs.
- 14 min
On this page · 12 sections
Prerequisites
- Basic Concepts, Residential Status, Exempt and Agricultural Income — residence and “deemed to accrue in India” are the two claims that collide.
- International Business and Trade — multinational enterprises and why they trade within the group.
- International Financial Management — withholding taxes and remittance rules in multinational capital budgeting.
This page covers the official line “International taxation: double taxation and its avoidance mechanism; transfer pricing”. Section numbers are those of the Income-tax Act, 1961; the Income-tax Act, 2025 (in force from 1 April 2026) keeps treaty relief and transfer pricing under new section numbers.
The Hook: Two Countries, One Rupee
1. Double Taxation: Meaning and Types
Double taxation arises when the same income is taxed in two countries, usually because one country taxes on residence (global income of its residents) and the other on source (income arising within its borders).
| Type | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Juridical double taxation | The same person taxed on the same income in two countries | An Indian resident taxed in India and in the UK on UK rent |
| Economic double taxation | The same income taxed in the hands of two different persons | Company profits taxed at the corporate level and again as dividends |
Causes: residence–source conflict; dual residence (both countries treat the person as resident); and source–source conflict (both claim the income arises within them).
2. The Avoidance Mechanism
Relief under Indian law
| Section | Kind of relief | When |
|---|---|---|
| 90 | Bilateral relief: the Central Government enters into an agreement (DTAA) with another country | India has a treaty with that country |
| 90A | Bilateral relief through an agreement between a specified association in India and one in a specified territory | Arrangement not between two governments |
| 91 | Unilateral relief: India gives credit on its own | No agreement with that country |
Section 90(2): where a DTAA exists, the assessee is governed by the provisions of the Act or the treaty, whichever is more beneficial. To claim treaty benefit a non-resident must produce a Tax Residency Certificate (TRC) from his home country (section 90(4)), with prescribed particulars. Foreign tax credit is claimed under Rule 128, which requires Form 67.
Conditions and computation of section 91 relief
Relief under section 91 is available to a person who is resident in India in the PY, whose income accrued outside India (and is not deemed to accrue in India), has been taxed in a country with which India has no agreement, and on which he has paid tax in that country.
Relief = doubly taxed income × the lower of (Indian average rate, foreign average rate).
Indian average rate = Indian income-tax on total income ÷ total income. Questions normally give the rate or the tax; the example below ignores surcharge and cess for simplicity.
Methods of eliminating double taxation
| Method | How it works | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| Exemption (full) | Residence country exempts the foreign income entirely | Only the source country taxes |
| Exemption with progression | Foreign income exempt but counted to decide the rate on other income | Like partial integration |
| Credit (full) | Residence country allows credit for the whole foreign tax | Rare: could refund tax paid abroad |
| Credit (ordinary) | Credit for foreign tax limited to the home tax on that income | The common method; India’s DTAAs mostly use it |
| Tax sparing | Credit for foreign tax spared (forgiven by incentives) as if paid | Preserves developing countries’ incentives |
| Deduction | Foreign tax treated as an expense | Least generous |
Model conventions
| OECD Model Tax Convention | UN Model Double Taxation Convention | |
|---|---|---|
| Prepared for | Developed (capital-exporting) countries | Developing (capital-importing) countries |
| Bias | Residence-based taxation | Source-based taxation |
| Permanent establishment | Narrower | Wider (e.g., includes some service PEs) |
India’s treaties draw on both models. Most follow the same article pattern: persons and taxes covered, definitions, residence (with tie-breaker rules for dual residents: permanent home, centre of vital interests, habitual abode, nationality, then mutual agreement), permanent establishment (PE), business profits (taxable in the source country only if attributable to a PE), dividends, interest, royalties and fees for technical services (shared, with source-country withholding caps), capital gains, elimination of double taxation, non-discrimination, mutual agreement procedure (MAP) and exchange of information.
Treaty abuse and BEPS
- Treaty shopping: a resident of a third country routes investment through a treaty country to get treaty benefits. The Supreme Court in Union of India v. Azadi Bachao Andolan (2003) upheld treaty benefits based on a Mauritius TRC. The India–Mauritius treaty was amended by a 2016 protocol to give India the right to tax capital gains on shares acquired from 1 April 2017.
- BEPS (Base Erosion and Profit Shifting): the OECD/G20 project whose final reports (October 2015) set out 15 actions, including on digital economy, treaty abuse, transfer pricing documentation and dispute resolution.
- The Multilateral Instrument (MLI) modifies many bilateral treaties at once to apply BEPS treaty measures; India signed it in 2017.
- Pillar Two of the OECD/G20 Inclusive Framework sets a global minimum tax of 15% for large multinational groups.
- Domestic anti-avoidance: GAAR (Chapter X-A) can deny treaty benefits to impermissible avoidance arrangements (see the next page).
3. Transfer Pricing (Sections 92–92F)
Meaning
Transfer price is the price at which goods, services, intangibles, loans or other benefits pass between associated enterprises (AEs) of the same group. Because the parties are under common control, the price can be set to shift profit to low-tax countries. Transfer pricing regulations require such transactions to be priced at the arm’s length price (ALP): the price that would be charged between unrelated parties in uncontrolled conditions.
India introduced its transfer pricing code through the Finance Act, 2001 (sections 92 to 92F).
Key provisions
| Section | Content |
|---|---|
| 92 | Income from an international transaction (or specified domestic transaction) to be computed at ALP. The ALP is applied only if it increases income or reduces loss (92(3)) |
| 92A | Associated enterprise: participation in management, control or capital, e.g., holding 26% or more of voting power, or appointing more than half the board |
| 92B | International transaction: between two or more AEs, at least one a non-resident (purchase, sale, services, lending, intangibles, cost-sharing) |
| 92BA | Specified domestic transactions between related domestic parties above a threshold |
| 92C | Methods of computing ALP; the most appropriate method |
| 92CA | Reference to the Transfer Pricing Officer (TPO) |
| 92CB | Safe harbour rules: margins the department will accept |
| 92CC / 92CD | Advance Pricing Agreement (APA) and its effect |
| 92CE | Secondary adjustment: excess money with the AE to be repatriated or treated as an advance |
| 92D / 92E | Documentation to be kept; accountant’s report in Form 3CEB |
| 286 | Country-by-country reporting for large groups (with master file) |
Methods of determining ALP (section 92C, Rule 10B)
| Method | How the ALP is found | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Comparable Uncontrolled Price (CUP) | Price charged in a comparable uncontrolled transaction | Commodities, interest, royalties where close comparables exist |
| Resale Price Method (RPM) | Resale price to an unrelated buyer less a normal gross margin | Distributors who resell without much value addition |
| Cost Plus Method (CPM) | Direct and indirect costs of production plus a normal gross mark-up | Manufacturers, contract manufacturers, service providers |
| Profit Split Method (PSM) | Combined profit of AEs split by relative contribution | Highly integrated transactions, unique intangibles |
| Transactional Net Margin Method (TNMM) | Net profit margin relative to a base (costs, sales, assets) compared with uncontrolled ones | The most widely used method in practice; services and routine functions |
| Other method (Rule 10AB) | Any method that takes into account the price that has been or would be charged | Where none of the five fits |
When a method gives several prices, the arm’s length range (or the arithmetic mean, where the range does not apply) is used.
Advance Pricing Agreement and dispute avoidance
An APA (section 92CC, introduced by the Finance Act, 2012) is an agreement between the CBDT and a taxpayer fixing the ALP or the method for future international transactions, for up to five years, with a rollback to earlier years. APAs are unilateral (taxpayer and India), bilateral or multilateral (involving the treaty partner’s tax authority too). Other dispute routes: safe harbour rules, MAP under the treaty, and the Dispute Resolution Panel.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| Pair | First | Second |
|---|---|---|
| Section 90 vs 91 | Treaty (bilateral) relief | Unilateral relief, no treaty |
| Juridical vs economic double taxation | Same person, two countries | Same income, two persons |
| Exemption vs credit method | Residence country gives up the right to tax | Residence country taxes but credits foreign tax |
| Tax sparing vs ordinary credit | Credit for tax forgiven abroad | Credit only for tax actually paid |
| RPM vs CPM | Start from resale price, subtract margin | Start from cost, add mark-up |
| CUP vs TNMM | Compares prices | Compares net margins |
| Unilateral vs bilateral APA | Taxpayer and Indian authority only | Treaty partner’s authority also joins |
| TRC vs Form 3CEB | Residence proof to claim treaty benefit | Accountant’s report on international transactions |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions in the UGC NET format. None is a previous-year question.
Level 1: Foundation
- Which section of the Income-tax Act, 1961 provides unilateral relief from double taxation?
- Which transfer pricing method subtracts a normal gross margin from the resale price?
- What percentage of voting power is a standard test for associated enterprises under section 92A?
Answers
- Section 91.
- Resale Price Method.
- 26% or more.
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) A resident has doubly taxed income of ₹4,00,000 from a non-treaty country where he paid tax at 20%. His Indian average rate of tax is 12%. Relief under section 91 is:
- (a) ₹80,000
- (b) ₹48,000
- (c) ₹32,000
- (d) Nil
Answer and explanation
(b) ₹48,000. Relief at the lower rate: 4,00,000 × 12%.
Q2. (Practice) Which transfer pricing method is generally the most suitable for a distributor that buys finished goods from its foreign parent and resells them without significant value addition?
- (a) Cost Plus Method
- (b) Profit Split Method
- (c) Resale Price Method
- (d) Comparable Uncontrolled Price Method
Answer and explanation
(c). RPM starts from the resale price and fits distributors whose function is resale.
Q3. (Practice) Consider the following statements:
- Under section 90(2), the assessee may apply the provisions of the Act or of the DTAA, whichever is more beneficial.
- A Tax Residency Certificate is required for a non-resident to claim treaty benefit.
- The UN Model Convention favours residence-based taxation.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 only
- (b) 1 and 2 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b). The UN Model favours source-country taxation.
Q4. (Practice) An Indian company’s foreign AE sells it goods at ₹1,500 per unit. The same goods sell to unrelated parties at ₹1,350. For 4,000 units the transfer pricing adjustment is:
- (a) ₹6,00,000 added to income
- (b) ₹6,00,000 deducted from income
- (c) ₹54,00,000 added to income
- (d) No adjustment
Answer and explanation
(a). The Indian company overpaid ₹150 a unit; 150 × 4,000 = ₹6,00,000 of the purchase cost is disallowed, increasing income.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Transfer pricing regulations require international transactions between associated enterprises to be valued at arm’s length price. Reason (R): Associated enterprises can set prices between themselves to shift profits to jurisdictions with lower tax rates.
Answer and explanation
(a). The risk of profit shifting is the reason for the arm’s length rule.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): Tax sparing credit is valued by developing countries that offer tax holidays to foreign investors. Reason (R): Under the ordinary credit method, the investor’s residence country gives credit only for tax actually paid abroad, which would cancel the benefit of the holiday.
Answer and explanation
(a). Without tax sparing, tax forgiven by the host country is collected by the residence country instead.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I with List II.
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Section 90 | I. Transfer Pricing Officer |
| B. Section 91 | II. Advance Pricing Agreement |
| C. Section 92CA | III. Relief where no agreement exists |
| D. Section 92CC | IV. Agreement with a foreign country for relief |
- (1) A-IV, B-III, C-I, D-II
- (2) A-III, B-IV, C-I, D-II
- (3) A-IV, B-III, C-II, D-I
- (4) A-I, B-II, C-III, D-IV
Answer and explanation
(1) A-IV, B-III, C-I, D-II.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the tie-breaker tests for an individual resident in both treaty countries, in the order the model conventions apply them:
A. Nationality
B. Permanent home
C. Habitual abode
D. Centre of vital interests
E. Mutual agreement of the competent authorities
(1) B, D, C, A, E
(2) D, B, C, A, E
(3) B, C, D, A, E
(4) A, B, D, C, E
Answer and explanation
(1) B, D, C, A, E. Permanent home, then centre of vital interests, then habitual abode, then nationality, and finally mutual agreement.
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Key fact |
|---|---|
| Double taxation | Residence vs source; juridical vs economic |
| Section 90 / 90A / 91 | Treaty / specified association / unilateral |
| 90(2) | Act or treaty, whichever more beneficial |
| TRC | Needed for treaty benefit (90(4)); Form 67 for credit (Rule 128) |
| Section 91 relief | Doubly taxed income × lower of Indian and foreign average rate |
| Relief methods | Exemption (full, progression), credit (full, ordinary), tax sparing, deduction |
| OECD / UN | Residence / source |
| Tie-breaker | Home → vital interests → habitual abode → nationality → MAP |
| BEPS | OECD/G20, 15 actions, 2015; MLI; Pillar Two 15% minimum |
| TP code | Sections 92–92F; Finance Act 2001 |
| AE | 92A; e.g., 26% voting power |
| International transaction | 92B; at least one AE non-resident |
| ALP methods | CUP, RPM, CPM, PSM, TNMM, other |
| Form 3CEB | Accountant’s report (92E) |
| APA | 92CC; up to 5 years + rollback; unilateral/bilateral/multilateral |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Corporate Tax Planning and Tax Decisions in Business Situations — avoidance, evasion and GAAR
- FDI, FPI and Balance of Payments — the investment flows treaties are meant to encourage
- Regional Integration and International Institutions — OECD, G20 and the institutions behind BEPS
- Income-tax and Corporate Tax Planning chapter