Skip to content

Corporate Tax Planning and Tax Decisions in Business Situations

UGC NET Commerce: tax planning vs avoidance vs evasion, GAAR, corporate rates and MAT, and tax effects on make-or-buy, lease, replace and shut-down decisions.

  • 16 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 13 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: Three Ways to Pay Less Tax
  3. 1. Corporate Tax Planning: Concepts and Significance
  4. 2. Corporate Tax Rates (PY 2025-26)
  5. 3. Techniques of Corporate Tax Planning
  6. 4. Tax Considerations in Specific Business Situations
  7. Memory Tricks
  8. Don’t Confuse
  9. Common Mistakes
  10. Practice
  11. Quick Revision Table
  12. Key Takeaways
  13. What’s Next

Prerequisites

This page covers two official lines: “Corporate tax planning: concepts and significance; tax avoidance versus tax evasion; techniques of corporate tax planning” and “Tax considerations in specific business situations: make or buy decisions; own or lease an asset; retain, renewal or replacement of asset; shut down or continue operations”. Section numbers are those of the Income-tax Act, 1961; rates are for previous year 2025-26.

The Hook: Three Ways to Pay Less Tax


1. Corporate Tax Planning: Concepts and Significance

Tax planning is the arrangement of a person’s financial affairs so that full benefit is taken of the deductions, exemptions, allowances, rebates and lower rates permitted by law, in a manner consistent with the intent of the legislature. Corporate tax planning applies this to companies, where tax is a major cost and decisions are large.

TermMeaning
Tax planningReducing tax by using provisions as Parliament intended (e.g., choosing a regime, claiming depreciation, investing in eligible assets)
Tax managementCompliance: filing returns on time, deducting and depositing TDS, keeping records, avoiding interest and penalty
Tax avoidanceReducing tax through arrangements that comply with the letter of the law but defeat its intent, often artificial or without commercial substance
Tax evasionIllegal non-payment through concealment of income, false accounts, inflated expenses, suppression of sales

Types of tax planning:

  • Short-range (year-end steps, e.g., an investment to claim a deduction) and long-range (structure, location, capital structure).
  • Permissive (using provisions the law expressly allows) and purposive (choosing arrangements to fit a provision’s purpose, such as selecting an eligible location or business).

Significance: tax is one of the largest outflows of a company; saving it improves cash flow, cost of capital and competitiveness; planning reduces litigation and penalties; and it steers investment where the government wants it (manufacturing, R&D, employment, backward areas).

Tax avoidance versus tax evasion

BasisTax planningTax avoidanceTax evasion
LegalityLegal and moralLegal in form; against the spiritIllegal
Intent of lawFollowedDefeatedViolated
MethodUses incentives and optionsLoopholes, artificial or circular arrangementsConcealment, fraud, false records
TimingBefore liability arisesBefore liability arisesUsually after liability arises
ConsequenceAcceptedCounter-measures (GAAR, SAARs), tax recoveredPenalty and prosecution

Penalties for evasion include section 270A (penalty of 50% of tax on under-reported income, 200% where under-reporting results from misreporting) and prosecution under section 276C for wilful attempts to evade tax.

The case law

CaseCourt and yearHolding (in summary)
IRC v. Duke of WestminsterHouse of Lords, 1936A taxpayer may arrange his affairs to reduce tax; courts look at the legal form (the Westminster principle)
W.T. Ramsay Ltd v. IRCHouse of Lords, 1981Pre-planned circular transactions with no commercial purpose can be disregarded
McDowell & Co. Ltd v. CTOSupreme Court of India, 1985 (Constitution Bench)Tax planning is legitimate within the law, but colourable devices cannot be part of it; dubious methods to avoid tax are not acceptable
Union of India v. Azadi Bachao AndolanSupreme Court, 2003Treaty shopping through Mauritius not illegal per se; TRC accepted
Vodafone International Holdings v. Union of IndiaSupreme Court, 2012Offshore transfer of shares of a foreign company not taxable in India; the transaction is to be looked at as a whole, not dissected. Parliament then amended section 9 retrospectively (2012); the retrospective demands were withdrawn by the Taxation Laws (Amendment) Act, 2021

GAAR (Chapter X-A, sections 95–102)

The General Anti-Avoidance Rule applies from AY 2018-19 (1 April 2017). An arrangement is an impermissible avoidance arrangement if its main purpose is to obtain a tax benefit and it has any one of four tainted elements:

  1. It creates rights or obligations not ordinarily created at arm’s length;
  2. It results in misuse or abuse of the provisions of the Act;
  3. It lacks commercial substance (or is deemed to);
  4. It is carried out by means or in a manner not ordinarily employed for bona fide purposes.

Consequences include disregarding or recharacterising the arrangement, ignoring an entity, reallocating income, and denying treaty benefits. GAAR applies only where the tax benefit of the arrangement exceeds ₹3 crore in a year (Rule 10U). Specific rules such as clubbing, transfer pricing and section 94 (dividend and bonus stripping) are SAARs (specific anti-avoidance rules).


2. Corporate Tax Rates (PY 2025-26)

CompanyRateWith surcharge and 4% cess (effective)
Domestic company, turnover in the specified earlier year up to ₹400 crore25%Surcharge 7% above ₹1 crore, 12% above ₹10 crore
Other domestic companies30%Same surcharge
Section 115BAA (domestic company, opts out of most incentives)22%25.168% (flat 10% surcharge)
Section 115BAB (new manufacturing company; manufacturing begun by 31 March 2024)15%17.16%
Foreign company35%Surcharge 2% / 5%

Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT, section 115JB): a company (other than one under 115BAA/115BAB) pays at least 15% of book profit. MAT credit (tax paid in excess of normal tax) can be carried forward for 15 years (115JAA). Non-corporate assessees claiming certain deductions pay Alternate Minimum Tax at 18.5% (115JC).

What 115BAA costs: no additional depreciation, no deductions under sections 10AA, 32AD, 33AB, 33ABA, 35AD and most of 35, and no Chapter VI-A deductions other than 80JJAA and 80M; brought-forward losses attributable to these cannot be set off; and no MAT, so no MAT credit. Once exercised, the option cannot be withdrawn.


3. Techniques of Corporate Tax Planning

AreaTechnique
Form of organisationCompare company (22–30% + dividend tax in shareholders’ hands) with firm or LLP (30%, partner’s share exempt, remuneration and interest deductible within limits)
Choice of regime115BAA versus normal rates with incentives and MAT; compare the present value of tax over several years
LocationUnits in an IFSC, earlier SEZ units (10AA, for units that began before its sunset), notified backward areas (higher additional depreciation)
Nature of businessSpecified businesses under 35AD (deduction of capital expenditure), start-ups (80-IAC), employment generation (80JJAA)
Capital structureInterest is deductible, dividends are not: debt creates a tax shield (subject to the 30%-of-EBITDA cap on interest to non-resident AEs under section 94B)
Dividend and buybackDividends taxed in shareholders’ hands; from 1 October 2024 buyback proceeds are also taxed as dividend
Depreciation and timingPut assets to use for 180 days or more to earn the full rate; time asset sales so a block does not cease (section 50)
Amalgamation and demergerTax-neutral transfers (section 47); carry forward of accumulated losses and unabsorbed depreciation (section 72A) if conditions are met
LossesFile returns by the due date; watch section 79 (closely held companies lose losses if 51% beneficial shareholding changes, with exceptions)
Employee remunerationTax-efficient pay structure: employer NPS (80CCD(2)), perquisites valued under Rule 3
Compliance timingPay 43B items before the return due date; deduct and deposit TDS to avoid 40(a)(ia)
graph TD
    A["Corporate tax planning"] --> B["Structure decisions
form, location, regime"] A --> C["Financing decisions
debt vs equity, dividend, buyback"] A --> D["Investment decisions
make/buy, lease/own, replace"] A --> E["Operating decisions
shut down, timing, remuneration"] A --> F["Restructuring
amalgamation, demerger, losses"]

4. Tax Considerations in Specific Business Situations

The rule from Capital Budgeting holds: compare after-tax incremental cash flows in present value. Tax enters in three ways: every deductible cost saves tax at rate \( t \); depreciation saves tax although it is not a cash cost (the tax shield = depreciation × \( t \)); and asset sales may create capital gains or reduce a block.

(a) Make or buy

Make: variable cost and avoidable fixed costs are deductible; any new plant earns depreciation (and, for a manufacturer outside 115BAA, additional depreciation). Buy: the purchase price is fully deductible. Compare PV of after-tax costs; also weigh quality, supply security and idle capacity.

(b) Own (borrow and buy) or lease

Lease: lease rentals are fully deductible (the lessor, as owner, claims depreciation). Own: the owner claims depreciation and interest on the loan. Discount at the after-tax cost of debt, \( k_d(1-t) \), because leasing is a substitute for borrowing; discounting at that rate also accounts for the interest tax shield.

Under actual tax law, depreciation is on the WDV of the block; a question that says “straight-line” is simplifying.

(c) Retain, renew or replace an asset

  • Repairs and renewals that keep an asset running are revenue expenditure (deductible at once, sections 30/31); those that create a new asset or extend capacity are capital (depreciation only).
  • Replacement: the sale price of the old asset is deducted from the block. The block continues as long as it has assets and a positive balance, so depreciation goes on and no capital gain arises.
  • If the block becomes empty, or sale proceeds exceed the block’s opening WDV plus additions, the excess is a short-term capital gain under section 50, whatever the holding period. If the block is empty but a balance remains, it is a short-term capital loss.
  • Planning: buy the replacement in the same year (and use it 180 days or more for full depreciation) so the block survives.

(d) Shut down or continue

In the short run, continue while contribution exceeds avoidable fixed costs. Tax adds two points: (i) a loss from a unit is set off against profits of other units in the same year (sections 70–71), reducing the group’s tax; (ii) business losses can be carried forward for 8 years even if the business that incurred them is discontinued, and unabsorbed depreciation indefinitely. Compensation received on closure, retrenchment compensation paid, and the sale of assets (section 50) also need costing.


Memory Tricks

Don’t Confuse

PairFirstSecond
Tax planning vs tax managementMinimising tax lawfullyComplying with procedures
Avoidance vs evasionLegal form, against intent; GAARIllegal; penalty and prosecution
Westminster vs McDowellForm governs; arrange affairs freelyColourable devices not allowed
GAAR vs SAARGeneral, judgement-basedSpecific provisions (clubbing, TP, section 94)
MAT vs AMTCompanies, 15% of book profitNon-corporates, 18.5% of adjusted total income
115BAA vs 115BAB22%, any domestic company15%, new manufacturing companies (sunset passed)
Lease rent vs depreciation + interestLessee’s deductionOwner-borrower’s deductions
Repairs vs renewal creating new assetRevenue, deductibleCapital, depreciation

Common Mistakes


Practice

All questions below are original practice questions in the UGC NET format. None is a previous-year question.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. Which Supreme Court case of 1985 said colourable devices cannot be part of tax planning?
  2. What is the base rate of tax for a domestic company opting for section 115BAA?
  3. Under which section is gain on sale of a depreciable asset taxed as short-term capital gain?
Answers
  1. McDowell & Co. Ltd v. CTO.
  2. 22% (25.168% with surcharge and cess).
  3. Section 50.

Level 2: Exam-style MCQs

Q1. (Practice) Which of the following is an example of tax evasion?

  • (a) Opting for the concessional rate under section 115BAA
  • (b) Claiming depreciation on an asset used for more than 180 days
  • (c) Recording fictitious purchases to reduce profit
  • (d) Investing in specified bonds to claim exemption under section 54EC
Answer and explanation

(c). Fictitious purchases are falsification of accounts. The others are lawful tax planning.

Q2. (Practice) A company can buy a component at ₹40 or make it at a variable cost of ₹30. Tax rate 30%. The after-tax saving per unit from making is:

  • (a) ₹10
  • (b) ₹7
  • (c) ₹3
  • (d) ₹13
Answer and explanation

(b) ₹7. Pre-tax saving ₹10 × (1 − 0.30) = ₹7 (no new asset is needed).

Q3. (Practice) Consider the following statements about GAAR:

  1. It applies to an arrangement whose main purpose is to obtain a tax benefit and which has at least one tainted element.
  2. It can be used to deny the benefit of a tax treaty.
  3. It applies whatever the amount of tax benefit involved.

Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  • (a) 1 only
  • (b) 1 and 2 only
  • (c) 2 and 3 only
  • (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation

(b). GAAR applies only where the tax benefit exceeds ₹3 crore in the relevant year.

Q4. (Practice) A block of plant (single asset, WDV ₹4,00,000) is sold for ₹4,60,000 and no asset is added in the year. The tax consequence is:

  • (a) LTCG ₹60,000
  • (b) STCG ₹60,000
  • (c) Depreciation on ₹4,00,000
  • (d) No consequence
Answer and explanation

(b). The block ceases to exist; the excess of sale price over WDV is short-term capital gain under section 50, regardless of how long the asset was held.

Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence

For assertion–reason questions, use these options:

  • (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
  • (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
  • (c) A is true, but R is false
  • (d) A is false, but R is true

Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): In a lease-versus-buy decision, cash flows are discounted at the after-tax cost of debt. Reason (R): Leasing is a substitute for borrowing, and interest on borrowing is tax-deductible.

Answer and explanation

(a). Because the lease displaces debt, its cash flows carry debt-like risk and the after-tax borrowing rate is the right discount rate.

Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): Tax avoidance is illegal and attracts prosecution. Reason (R): General Anti-Avoidance Rules empower the tax authorities to disregard arrangements lacking commercial substance.

Answer and explanation

(d). A is false: avoidance is lawful in form; evasion attracts prosecution. R is true.

Q3. (Practice) Match List I with List II.

List I (Case)List II (Principle)
A. Duke of Westminster (1936)I. Colourable devices are not part of tax planning
B. McDowell (1985)II. Taxpayer may arrange affairs to reduce tax
C. Azadi Bachao Andolan (2003)III. Offshore share transfer looked at as a whole
D. Vodafone (2012)IV. Treaty benefits through a Mauritius TRC upheld
  • (1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
  • (2) A-I, B-II, C-IV, D-III
  • (3) A-II, B-I, C-III, D-IV
  • (4) A-II, B-IV, C-I, D-III
Answer and explanation

(1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III.

Q4. (Practice) Arrange these cases in chronological order:

  • A. Vodafone International Holdings v. Union of India

  • B. McDowell & Co. v. CTO

  • C. IRC v. Duke of Westminster

  • D. Union of India v. Azadi Bachao Andolan

  • (1) C, B, D, A

  • (2) B, C, D, A

  • (3) C, D, B, A

  • (4) C, B, A, D

Answer and explanation

(1) C, B, D, A. 1936, 1985, 2003, 2012.


Quick Revision Table

ItemKey fact
Tax planningLawful, within intent
Tax managementCompliance
Avoidance / evasionLoophole, GAAR / illegal, 270A and 276C
270A penalty50% under-reporting; 200% misreporting
Westminster / McDowell1936 form / 1985 no colourable devices
Azadi Bachao / Vodafone2003 TRC / 2012 look at, retrospective law withdrawn 2021
GAARCh X-A, ss 95–102; AY 2018-19; main purpose + 1 taint; ₹3 crore
Corporate rates25% (≤ ₹400 crore turnover), 30%, 22% (115BAA), 15% (115BAB), 35% foreign
115BAA effective25.168%; no MAT; no most incentives
MAT / credit15% of book profit / 15 years
Make or buyCompare PV of after-tax costs incl. depreciation shield
Own or leaseDiscount at \( k_d(1-t) \)
ReplacementBuy in the same year to keep the block alive; else section 50 STCG
Shut downContinue if contribution > avoidable fixed costs; losses set off/carried forward

Key Takeaways

What’s Next