Motivation and Leadership: Concepts and Theories
UGC NET Commerce: Maslow, Herzberg, McGregor, McClelland, Vroom, Adams and Locke on motivation; trait, behavioural, contingency and transformational leadership.
- 16 min
On this page · 11 sections
Prerequisites
- Management Principles, Functions and Organisation Structure: motivation and leadership are the core of the directing function described there.
- Public Administration: Leadership and Motivation covers the same theories for Political Science candidates. The dates and works on both pages agree, so either can be used for revision.
This page covers the official line “Motivation and leadership: concept and theories”.
The Hook: Same Salary, Different Effort
Part A: Motivation
1. Concept
Motivation is the process that arouses, directs and sustains behaviour towards a goal. Its root is the Latin movere, “to move”. Three elements recur in definitions: intensity (how hard), direction (towards what) and persistence (for how long).
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Motive | An inner state (need, drive) that moves a person |
| Motivation | The process of stimulating action |
| Motivator / incentive | The external means used to motivate (pay, praise, promotion) |
| Intrinsic motivation | Comes from the work itself: achievement, interest, growth |
| Extrinsic motivation | Comes from outside: pay, benefits, security |
| Positive / negative motivation | Rewards vs fear of punishment |
The motivation process runs: unsatisfied need → tension → drive → search behaviour → need satisfied → reduction of tension.
2. Content and process theories
| Content theories (what motivates) | Process theories (how motivation works) |
|---|---|
| Maslow: hierarchy of needs | Vroom: expectancy theory |
| Herzberg: two-factor theory | Porter and Lawler: performance–satisfaction model |
| McGregor: Theory X and Y | Adams: equity theory |
| Alderfer: ERG | Locke: goal-setting theory |
| McClelland: acquired needs | Skinner: reinforcement (often listed separately) |
| Argyris: immaturity–maturity |
3. Maslow’s hierarchy of needs
Abraham Maslow, “A Theory of Human Motivation”, Psychological Review, 1943; expanded in Motivation and Personality, 1954.
graph BT
A["1. Physiological
food, water, shelter, basic pay"] --> B["2. Safety / security
job security, pension, safe workplace"]
B --> C["3. Social / belongingness
friendship, acceptance, team"]
C --> D["4. Esteem
recognition, status, self-respect"]
D --> E["5. Self-actualisation
realising one's full potential"]- Needs are met in order, from the bottom up; the first four are deficiency needs and self-actualisation is a growth need.
- A satisfied need no longer motivates; the next higher need takes over.
- Criticism: the order is not universal, people pursue several needs at once, and the evidence for a strict hierarchy is weak.
4. Herzberg’s two-factor (motivation–hygiene) theory
Frederick Herzberg, with Mausner and Snyderman, The Motivation to Work (1959). It was based on interviews with about 200 engineers and accountants in Pittsburgh, using the critical incident method.
| Hygiene (maintenance) factors | Motivators (satisfiers) |
|---|---|
| Company policy and administration | Achievement |
| Supervision | Recognition |
| Relationship with supervisor and peers | Work itself |
| Working conditions | Responsibility |
| Salary | Advancement |
| Status, job security, personal life | Growth |
| Context of the job (extrinsic) | Content of the job (intrinsic) |
- Absence of hygiene factors causes dissatisfaction; their presence only removes dissatisfaction and does not motivate.
- Motivators cause satisfaction; their absence leads to “no satisfaction”, not dissatisfaction.
- So satisfaction and dissatisfaction are two separate continua, not opposite ends of one.
- Practical result: job enrichment (vertical loading of the job with responsibility and control).
5. McGregor’s Theory X and Theory Y
Douglas McGregor, The Human Side of Enterprise (1960).
| Theory X (traditional) | Theory Y (modern) |
|---|---|
| People dislike work and avoid it | Work is as natural as play or rest |
| Must be coerced, controlled, threatened | Exercise self-direction towards objectives they are committed to |
| Avoid responsibility, prefer to be directed | Accept and seek responsibility |
| Little ambition, want security above all | Creativity is widely spread in the population |
| Leads to autocratic management | Leads to participative management, delegation, job enlargement |
William Ouchi’s Theory Z (1981) described Japanese-style management: long-term employment, collective decision-making, slow evaluation and promotion, and a holistic concern for employees.
6. Other content theories
| Theory | Author, year | Key idea |
|---|---|---|
| ERG theory | Clayton Alderfer, 1969 | Existence, Relatedness, Growth; several needs at once; frustration–regression (if a higher need is blocked, a person falls back on a lower one) |
| Acquired (learned) needs | David McClelland, The Achieving Society, 1961 | Need for achievement (nAch), affiliation (nAff), power (nPow); high achievers prefer moderate risk and quick feedback |
| Immaturity–maturity | Chris Argyris, Personality and Organization, 1957 | People mature from passivity to activity, dependence to independence; rigid formal organisations keep them immature |
| Four systems | Rensis Likert, New Patterns of Management, 1961 | System 1 exploitive-authoritative, 2 benevolent-authoritative, 3 consultative, 4 participative group; System 4 is most effective |
Maslow vs Alderfer vs Herzberg:
| Maslow | Alderfer | Herzberg |
|---|---|---|
| Physiological, safety | Existence | Hygiene |
| Social, external esteem | Relatedness | Hygiene (mostly) |
| Internal esteem, self-actualisation | Growth | Motivators |
7. Vroom’s expectancy theory
Victor Vroom, Work and Motivation (1964). People are motivated when they believe effort will lead to performance, performance will lead to a reward, and the reward is valued.
$$ \text{Motivation (force)} = \text{Expectancy} \times \text{Instrumentality} \times \text{Valence} $$| Term | Link | Range |
|---|---|---|
| Expectancy (E) | Effort → performance | Probability, 0 to 1 |
| Instrumentality (I) | Performance → reward | Probability, 0 to 1 |
| Valence (V) | Value placed on the reward | −1 to +1 |
Because the terms multiply, if any one is zero, motivation is zero.
8. Other process theories
Porter and Lawler model (Managerial Attitudes and Performance, 1968): effort depends on the value of the reward and the perceived effort–reward probability; performance also depends on abilities and traits and role perceptions; performance brings intrinsic and extrinsic rewards, which produce satisfaction if they are seen as equitable. Its key reversal: performance leads to satisfaction, not the other way round.
J. Stacy Adams: equity theory (1963). A person compares the ratio of his outcomes to inputs with that of a referent (a colleague, a friend elsewhere, or himself earlier):
$$ \frac{\text{Outcomes}_{\text{self}}}{\text{Inputs}_{\text{self}}} \quad \text{vs} \quad \frac{\text{Outcomes}_{\text{referent}}}{\text{Inputs}_{\text{referent}}} $$If his ratio is lower, he feels under-rewarded and may cut effort, ask for more pay, change the referent, distort perceptions or leave. If it is higher, he feels over-rewarded (guilt), which people tolerate more easily.
Edwin Locke: goal-setting theory (1968): specific and difficult goals, when accepted and supported by feedback, produce higher performance than vague “do your best” goals. It is the psychological basis of MBO.
B. F. Skinner: reinforcement theory (operant conditioning): behaviour followed by pleasant consequences tends to be repeated. Four methods:
| Method | What happens | Effect on behaviour |
|---|---|---|
| Positive reinforcement | A pleasant consequence is given | Increases |
| Negative reinforcement | An unpleasant consequence is removed | Increases |
| Punishment | An unpleasant consequence is given | Decreases |
| Extinction | Reinforcement is withdrawn | Decreases |
Reinforcement can be continuous or partial (fixed-interval, variable-interval, fixed-ratio, variable-ratio). Variable-ratio schedules produce the most persistent behaviour.
Part B: Leadership
9. Concept
Leadership is the ability to influence people to work willingly towards group goals. Leadership vs management: management relies on formal authority to plan, organise and control; leadership relies on influence and vision. A manager may not be a leader, and an informal leader may hold no managerial post.
Leadership styles by use of authority:
| Style | Feature |
|---|---|
| Autocratic | Leader decides alone; little delegation |
| Democratic / participative | Leader consults; group shares decisions |
| Laissez-faire / free-rein | Leader leaves decisions to the group |
| Paternalistic | Leader acts as a protective parent |
The Iowa studies of Kurt Lewin, Ronald Lippitt and Ralph White (1939) compared autocratic, democratic and laissez-faire leadership of boys’ clubs.
10. The development of leadership theory
graph LR
A["Trait theories
Who is a leader?"] --> B["Behavioural theories
What do leaders do?"]
B --> C["Contingency theories
Which style, when?"]
C --> D["Transactional and
transformational"]Trait theories (including the older “great man” view) searched for inborn qualities: intelligence, self-confidence, drive, integrity. Ralph Stogdill’s review (1948) found no consistent set of traits that separated leaders from non-leaders across situations.
11. Behavioural theories
| Study | Dimensions |
|---|---|
| Ohio State studies (late 1940s) | Initiating structure (task) and consideration (people): two independent dimensions |
| University of Michigan studies | Employee-oriented and production-oriented leaders; employee-oriented associated with higher productivity |
| Likert’s four systems (1961) | System 1 to System 4; System 4 (participative group) most effective; “linking pin” |
Blake and Mouton’s Managerial Grid (1964) plots concern for production (horizontal axis, 1–9) against concern for people (vertical axis, 1–9):
| Position | Name | Description |
|---|---|---|
| 1,1 | Impoverished | Minimum effort on both |
| 9,1 | Authority–compliance (task) | Production first, people last |
| 1,9 | Country club | Comfortable, friendly, low output |
| 5,5 | Middle-of-the-road | Balance and compromise |
| 9,9 | Team management | High on both; considered ideal |
Tannenbaum and Schmidt’s continuum (“How to Choose a Leadership Pattern”, Harvard Business Review, 1958) ranges from boss-centred (the manager makes and announces the decision) to subordinate-centred (the manager lets the group decide within limits). The right point depends on forces in the manager, the subordinates and the situation.
12. Contingency (situational) theories
Fred Fiedler’s contingency model (A Theory of Leadership Effectiveness, 1967):
- Leadership style is measured by the Least Preferred Co-worker (LPC) scale. A high LPC score indicates a relationship-oriented leader; a low LPC score a task-oriented leader.
- Situational favourableness depends on three variables: leader–member relations, task structure and position power.
- Task-oriented leaders do best in highly favourable or highly unfavourable situations; relationship-oriented leaders do best in moderately favourable ones.
- Style is treated as fixed: change the situation, or the leader, rather than the style.
Hersey and Blanchard’s situational leadership (“life cycle theory of leadership”, 1969): the right style depends on follower readiness (maturity), combining ability and willingness.
| Readiness | Followers are | Style |
|---|---|---|
| R1 | Unable and unwilling | Telling (S1): high task, low relationship |
| R2 | Unable but willing | Selling (S2): high task, high relationship |
| R3 | Able but unwilling | Participating (S3): low task, high relationship |
| R4 | Able and willing | Delegating (S4): low task, low relationship |
Robert House’s path–goal theory (1971): the leader clarifies the path to the follower’s goals and removes obstacles. Four behaviours (House and Mitchell, 1974): directive, supportive, participative, achievement-oriented. It draws on Vroom’s expectancy theory.
Vroom–Yetton model (1973): a decision tree for choosing how far to involve subordinates in a decision, from autocratic through consultative to group, depending on the need for decision quality and acceptance.
Leader–member exchange (LMX): leaders form an in-group of trusted subordinates and an out-group, with different quality of exchange. It is associated with George Graen and colleagues in the 1970s.
13. Transactional, transformational and later views
James MacGregor Burns, Leadership (1978), distinguished:
| Transactional leadership | Transformational leadership |
|---|---|
| Exchange: rewards for performance | Raises followers’ values and aspirations |
| Contingent reward, management by exception | Inspires followers to transcend self-interest |
| Works within the existing culture | Changes the culture |
Bernard Bass (Leadership and Performance Beyond Expectations, 1985) gave the four Is of transformational leadership: idealised influence, inspirational motivation, intellectual stimulation, individualised consideration.
Other views that appear in options:
- Charismatic leadership: followers attribute extraordinary qualities to the leader; the idea of charismatic authority goes back to Max Weber.
- Servant leadership: Robert Greenleaf’s essay “The Servant as Leader” (1970): the leader serves first.
- Substitutes for leadership (Kerr and Jermier): some features of followers, tasks and organisations make leadership unnecessary.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| Pair | First | Second |
|---|---|---|
| Content vs process theories | What motivates (needs) | How motivation works (expectancy, equity, goals) |
| Hygiene factor vs motivator | Context, prevents dissatisfaction (salary, supervision) | Content, creates satisfaction (achievement, recognition) |
| Maslow vs Alderfer | Strict hierarchy; satisfaction–progression | Three needs; several at once; frustration–regression |
| Theory Y vs Theory Z | McGregor 1960, assumption about people | Ouchi 1981, Japanese management |
| Expectancy vs instrumentality | Effort → performance | Performance → reward |
| Negative reinforcement vs punishment | Removes something unpleasant; behaviour increases | Adds something unpleasant; behaviour decreases |
| Fiedler vs Hersey–Blanchard | Style fixed; fit the situation to the leader | Style flexible; leader adapts to follower readiness |
| High LPC vs low LPC | Relationship-oriented | Task-oriented |
| Burns vs Bass | 1978: transforming vs transactional | 1985: four Is |
| Ohio vs Michigan studies | Initiating structure, consideration | Production-oriented, employee-oriented |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Who proposed the ERG theory?
- In Blake and Mouton’s grid, what is the 9,9 style called?
- What does valence mean in Vroom’s theory?
Answers
- Clayton Alderfer (1969).
- Team management.
- The value or attractiveness a person attaches to a reward.
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) Which of the following is a motivator in Herzberg’s theory?
- (a) Working conditions
- (b) Salary
- (c) Recognition
- (d) Company policy
Answer and explanation
(c) Recognition. The other three are hygiene factors.
Q2. (Practice) An employee rates expectancy at 0.6, instrumentality at 0.5 and valence at 0.8. Her motivational force under Vroom’s model is:
- (a) 1.90
- (b) 0.24
- (c) 0.30
- (d) 0.48
Answer and explanation
(b) 0.24. \( 0.6 \times 0.5 \times 0.8 = 0.24 \). Adding the three (1.9) is the trap.
Q3. (Practice) According to Fiedler, a task-oriented leader is most effective when the situation is:
- (a) Moderately favourable only
- (b) Highly favourable or highly unfavourable
- (c) Highly unfavourable only
- (d) Unaffected by leader–member relations
Answer and explanation
(b). Low-LPC (task-oriented) leaders do best at the two extremes; high-LPC leaders in the middle.
Q4. (Practice) Consider the following statements:
- Alderfer’s ERG theory allows more than one need to operate at the same time.
- The Porter–Lawler model holds that satisfaction leads to performance.
- Locke’s goal-setting theory favours specific and difficult goals.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 2 and 3 only
- (c) 1 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(c) 1 and 3 only. Porter and Lawler reversed the human-relations view: performance leads to satisfaction.
Q5. (Practice) Followers who are able but unwilling call for which style in the Hersey–Blanchard model?
- (a) Telling
- (b) Selling
- (c) Participating
- (d) Delegating
Answer and explanation
(c) Participating (R3): low task and high relationship behaviour, to build willingness.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): According to Herzberg, a pay rise may remove dissatisfaction without motivating the employee. Reason (R): Salary is a hygiene factor that relates to the context of the job.
Answer and explanation
(a). Hygiene factors only prevent dissatisfaction; salary is one of them, which explains A.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): Under expectancy theory, an employee who greatly values a reward may still not be motivated. Reason (R): Motivation is the sum of expectancy, instrumentality and valence.
Answer and explanation
(c). A is true: if expectancy or instrumentality is zero, motivation is zero. R is false: the terms are multiplied, not added. (The multiplication is precisely why A holds.)
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (Thinker) with List II (Theory or concept).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. David McClelland | I. Equity theory |
| B. J. Stacy Adams | II. Need for achievement, affiliation and power |
| C. Rensis Likert | III. Path–goal theory |
| D. Robert House | IV. System 4 management |
- (1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
- (2) A-I, B-II, C-IV, D-III
- (3) A-II, B-I, C-III, D-IV
- (4) A-IV, B-I, C-II, D-III
Answer and explanation
(1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following in chronological order:
A. Vroom’s Work and Motivation
B. Maslow’s “A Theory of Human Motivation”
C. Herzberg’s The Motivation to Work
D. Burns’s Leadership
(1) B, C, A, D
(2) C, B, A, D
(3) B, A, C, D
(4) B, C, D, A
Answer and explanation
(1) B, C, A, D. 1943 → 1959 → 1964 → 1978.
Q5. (Practice) Arrange Maslow’s needs from the lowest to the highest:
A. Esteem
B. Safety
C. Self-actualisation
D. Physiological
E. Social
(1) D, B, E, A, C
(2) D, E, B, A, C
(3) B, D, E, A, C
(4) D, B, A, E, C
Answer and explanation
(1) D, B, E, A, C. Physiological, safety, social, esteem, self-actualisation.
Quick Revision Table
| Thinker | Work / theory | Year | Remember |
|---|---|---|---|
| Maslow | Hierarchy of needs | 1943 (1954 book) | Five levels; satisfied need does not motivate |
| Herzberg | The Motivation to Work | 1959 | Hygiene vs motivators; job enrichment |
| McGregor | The Human Side of Enterprise | 1960 | Theory X / Theory Y |
| McClelland | The Achieving Society | 1961 | nAch, nAff, nPow |
| Likert | New Patterns of Management | 1961 | Systems 1–4 |
| Adams | Equity theory | 1963 | Outcome/input ratio vs referent |
| Vroom | Work and Motivation | 1964 | M = E × I × V |
| Blake and Mouton | Managerial Grid | 1964 | 1,1; 9,1; 1,9; 5,5; 9,9 |
| Fiedler | Contingency model | 1967 | LPC; three situational variables |
| Locke | Goal-setting | 1968 | Specific, difficult goals plus feedback |
| Porter and Lawler | Performance–satisfaction model | 1968 | Performance → satisfaction |
| Alderfer | ERG | 1969 | Frustration–regression |
| Hersey and Blanchard | Situational / life cycle | 1969 | Telling, selling, participating, delegating |
| House | Path–goal | 1971 | Directive, supportive, participative, achievement-oriented |
| Burns / Bass | Transformational leadership | 1978 / 1985 | Transactional vs transformational; four Is |
| Ouchi | Theory Z | 1981 | Japanese management |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Corporate Governance and Business Ethics: the next official line
- Compensation, Appraisal and Industrial Relations: incentives put motivation theory into pay
- Organisational Behaviour, Culture and Change: perception, attitudes and groups behind motivation
- Paper 1: Teaching Aptitude, Learner Characteristics: motivation in the classroom