Skip to content

Corporate Governance and Business Ethics

UGC NET Commerce: governance theories, Cadbury to Kotak committees, Companies Act 2013 and SEBI LODR, CSR, and ethical theories for business.

  • 14 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 13 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: A Letter in January 2009
  3. 1. Corporate Governance: Meaning
  4. 2. Milestones: Committees and Codes
  5. 3. Governance Provisions in Indian Law
  6. 4. Business Ethics: Concept
  7. Memory Tricks
  8. Don’t Confuse
  9. Common Mistakes
  10. Practice
  11. Quick Revision Table
  12. Key Takeaways
  13. What’s Next

Prerequisites

This page covers the official line “Corporate governance and business ethics”.

The Hook: A Letter in January 2009


1. Corporate Governance: Meaning

The definition most often quoted comes from the Cadbury Committee (UK, 1992): corporate governance is “the system by which companies are directed and controlled”.

The problem it addresses was described by Adolf Berle and Gardiner Means in The Modern Corporation and Private Property (1932): in a large company, ownership (dispersed shareholders) is separated from control (professional managers), and managers may not act in the owners’ interest.

Pillars of good governance

PillarMeaning
AccountabilityThe board answers to shareholders; management answers to the board
TransparencyTimely, accurate disclosure of material information
FairnessEquitable treatment of all shareholders, including minorities
ResponsibilityCompliance with law and regard for stakeholders
IndependenceIndependent directors and auditors free of conflicts

Theories of corporate governance

TheoryKey author(s), yearView of managersGovernance answer
Agency theoryMichael Jensen and William Meckling, 1976Agents who may pursue self-interest at the principal’s costMonitoring, independent boards, incentive pay aligned with shareholder value; the costs are agency costs
Stewardship theoryLex Donaldson and James Davis, 1991Stewards who want to do a good jobEmpower managers; combined CEO–chair role can work
Stakeholder theoryR. Edward Freeman, Strategic Management: A Stakeholder Approach, 1984Serve all groups affected by the firmBalance interests of employees, customers, suppliers, community, shareholders
Resource dependence theoryJeffrey Pfeffer and Gerald Salancik, 1978Firm depends on external resourcesBoard links the firm to resources (finance, contacts, legitimacy)

Agency costs include monitoring costs (borne by the principal), bonding costs (borne by the agent to show good faith) and the residual loss.

Models of corporate governance

ModelWhereFeatures
Anglo-American (outsider / market-based)USA, UKDispersed ownership, active stock markets, unitary board, shareholder primacy
German (insider / two-tier)GermanySupervisory board (including employee representatives under co-determination) over a management board; banks as large holders
Japanese (keiretsu)JapanCross-shareholdings in business groups, main-bank system, relationship-based
Indian (family / business group)IndiaPromoter-controlled groups alongside state-owned and widely held companies; the main agency problem is often majority vs minority shareholders

2. Milestones: Committees and Codes

International

YearMilestoneRemember
1992Cadbury Committee, UK“Directed and controlled”; separate chair and CEO; audit committee; non-executive directors; comply or explain
1995Greenbury Committee, UKDirectors’ remuneration
1998Hampel Committee, UKReview leading to the Combined Code
1999OECD Principles of Corporate GovernanceRevised 2004; G20/OECD Principles 2015 and 2023
2002Sarbanes-Oxley Act, USAAfter Enron and WorldCom; CEO/CFO certification; internal control reporting (Sec 404); PCAOB to oversee auditors

India

YearMilestoneRemember
1998CII: Desirable Corporate Governance: A CodeFirst voluntary code, from industry
1999Kumar Mangalam Birla Committee (SEBI)Led to Clause 49 of the Listing Agreement (2000)
2002Naresh Chandra Committee (Department of Company Affairs)Auditor–company relationship; auditor rotation; independence
2003N. R. Narayana Murthy Committee (SEBI)Strengthened Clause 49: audit committee, risk management, whistle-blower policy
2005J. J. Irani CommitteeReview of company law; fed into the Companies Act, 2013
2013Companies Act, 2013Independent directors, women directors, committees, CSR (Sec 135)
2015SEBI (Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2015Replaced the Listing Agreement and Clause 49; in force from 1 December 2015
2017Uday Kotak Committee (SEBI)Board independence, separation of chair and MD/CEO for large listed firms, board diversity

3. Governance Provisions in Indian Law

Companies Act, 2013

SectionProvision
149(1)Maximum 15 directors (more by special resolution); at least one woman director in prescribed classes of company
149(4)Every listed public company: at least one-third of directors to be independent
149(6)Criteria of independence
149(10), (11)Independent director: term of up to five consecutive years; re-appointment by special resolution; no more than two consecutive terms, then a three-year cooling-off
Schedule IVCode for independent directors
166Duties of directors: act in good faith, in the interests of the company, employees, shareholders, community and environment; exercise due care
177Audit committee: at least three directors, with independent directors forming a majority; vigil mechanism (whistle-blowing) under Sec 177(9)
178Nomination and remuneration committee; stakeholders relationship committee
184, 188Disclosure of directors’ interest; related party transactions
135Corporate social responsibility

SEBI LODR Regulations, 2015 (listed entities)

RegulationProvision
17Board composition: at least half independent if the chairperson is executive (or a promoter-related non-executive); at least one-third if the chairperson is non-executive; at least one woman director, and an independent woman director in the larger listed entities
18Audit committee: at least three members, two-thirds independent, chaired by an independent director
19 / 20 / 21Nomination and remuneration / stakeholders relationship / risk management committees
34Annual report contents, including the Business Responsibility and Sustainability Report (BRSR) for the top listed entities by market capitalisation

Corporate social responsibility (Section 135)

  • Applies to a company with, in the preceding financial year, net worth of ₹500 crore or more, or turnover of ₹1,000 crore or more, or net profit of ₹5 crore or more.
  • Must spend at least 2% of the average net profits of the three immediately preceding financial years on activities in Schedule VII (hunger and poverty, education, health, gender equality, environment, heritage, armed forces veterans, sports, PM’s relief fund and others, rural development, slum development, disaster management).
  • Must constitute a CSR committee of the board (with relaxations for smaller obligations) and disclose a CSR policy.

4. Business Ethics: Concept

Ethics is the study of what is morally right and wrong. Business ethics applies it to business decisions: honesty in dealings, fairness to stakeholders, and responsibility to society.

BasisLawEthics
SourceThe stateConscience, culture, religion, professional codes
EnforcementCourts, penaltiesSocial and personal sanction
ScopeMinimum standardHigher, broader standard
RelationSomething legal may be unethical; something ethical may not be legally required

Sources of business ethics: religion, culture, law, professional codes, and the leadership of the organisation. Gandhiji’s trusteeship principle held that the wealthy should hold surplus wealth in trust for society; it is the classic Indian argument for business responsibility.

Normative ethical theories

TheoryKey thinker(s)Test of a right action
Utilitarianism (teleological, consequentialist)Jeremy Bentham, J. S. MillGreatest good of the greatest number
Deontology (duty-based)Immanuel KantAct on a rule you could will as universal law (categorical imperative); treat people as ends, never merely as means
Rights theoryNatural-rights traditionRespect for fundamental rights (life, privacy, free speech)
Justice theoryJohn Rawls, A Theory of Justice, 1971Fair distribution, chosen behind a “veil of ignorance”; inequalities justified only if they benefit the least advantaged
Virtue ethicsAristotleWhat would a person of good character do?
Ethical relativismMorality depends on culture; no universal standard

Kohlberg’s stages of moral development

Lawrence Kohlberg described three levels of moral reasoning, each with two stages:

LevelBasis of right and wrong
Pre-conventionalAvoiding punishment; self-interest and exchange
ConventionalApproval of others; law and order
Post-conventional (principled)Social contract; universal ethical principles

Corporate social responsibility models

Archie Carroll’s pyramid of CSR (1991), from the base up:

graph BT
    A["Economic responsibility
Be profitable (required)"] --> B["Legal responsibility
Obey the law (required)"] B --> C["Ethical responsibility
Do what is right and fair (expected)"] C --> D["Philanthropic responsibility
Be a good corporate citizen (desired)"]
  • Milton Friedman (New York Times Magazine, 1970): “The social responsibility of business is to increase its profits”, within the rules of the game. This is the shareholder (classical) view.
  • John Elkington coined the triple bottom line (1994): people, planet, profit.
  • ESG (environmental, social, governance) reporting is the investor-facing form of the same idea; in India, SEBI’s BRSR is the reporting format for top listed entities.

Ethical issues in business

AreaTypical issues
FinanceInsider trading (SEBI (Prohibition of Insider Trading) Regulations, 2015), window dressing, creative accounting
MarketingMisleading advertising, unfair pricing, unsafe products
HRMDiscrimination, harassment, unfair dismissal, privacy
EnvironmentPollution, resource depletion, greenwashing
GovernanceConflicts of interest, related-party transactions, bribery

Whistle-blowing is the disclosure of wrongdoing by an insider. Companies provide a vigil mechanism (Sec 177(9) and the LODR); for public servants, India enacted the Whistle Blowers Protection Act, 2014.

Tools for ethical management: a code of ethics and conduct, ethics committees and officers, ethics training, ethics audits, and above all ethical leadership from the top (“tone at the top”).


Memory Tricks

Don’t Confuse

PairFirstSecond
Agency vs stewardship theoryManagers are self-interested agents; monitor themManagers are trustworthy stewards; empower them
Shareholder vs stakeholder viewFriedman: maximise profit within the lawFreeman: balance all affected groups
Kumar Mangalam Birla vs Narayana Murthy1999, led to Clause 492003, strengthened Clause 49
Naresh Chandra vs J. J. Irani2002, auditor independence2005, company law review
Clause 49 vs LODROld Listing Agreement clause (from 2000)Regulations of 2015, in force from 1 Dec 2015
Utilitarianism vs deontologyJudge by consequencesJudge by duty and rules
Ethics vs lawVoluntary, widerEnforceable, minimum
Cadbury vs Greenbury1992, financial aspects of governance1995, directors’ pay

Common Mistakes


Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. Which committee defined corporate governance as “the system by which companies are directed and controlled”?
  2. Under Section 149(4), what minimum proportion of a listed company’s directors must be independent?
  3. Who wrote A Theory of Justice (1971)?
Answers
  1. The Cadbury Committee (UK, 1992).
  2. One-third.
  3. John Rawls.

Level 2: Exam-style MCQs

Q1. (Practice) Clause 49 of the Listing Agreement was introduced on the recommendations of the:

  • (a) Naresh Chandra Committee
  • (b) Kumar Mangalam Birla Committee
  • (c) J. J. Irani Committee
  • (d) Uday Kotak Committee
Answer and explanation

(b) Kumar Mangalam Birla Committee (1999), set up by SEBI.

Q2. (Practice) A company’s net profits for the three preceding financial years were ₹12 crore, ₹18 crore and ₹24 crore. Its minimum CSR spending for the current year is:

  • (a) ₹0.48 crore
  • (b) ₹0.36 crore
  • (c) ₹1.08 crore
  • (d) ₹0.24 crore
Answer and explanation

(b) ₹0.36 crore. Average \( = (12 + 18 + 24) \div 3 = 18 \) crore; \( 2\% \times 18 = 0.36 \) crore. Option (a) wrongly uses only the last year (\( 2\% \times 24 \)); option (c) is 2% of the total.

Q3. (Practice) Which theory holds that managers, left on their own, will act as responsible guardians of the company’s assets?

  • (a) Agency theory
  • (b) Stewardship theory
  • (c) Resource dependence theory
  • (d) Transaction cost theory
Answer and explanation

(b) Stewardship theory (Donaldson and Davis, 1991).

Q4. (Practice) Consider the following statements:

  1. Under Section 177, independent directors must form a majority of the audit committee.
  2. An independent director may hold office for at most two consecutive terms of five years each.
  3. The SEBI LODR Regulations came into force before the Companies Act, 2013.

Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  • (a) 1 and 2 only
  • (b) 2 and 3 only
  • (c) 1 and 3 only
  • (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation

(a) 1 and 2 only. The LODR Regulations are of 2015 (in force 1 December 2015), after the 2013 Act.

Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence

For assertion–reason questions, use these options:

  • (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
  • (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
  • (c) A is true, but R is false
  • (d) A is false, but R is true

Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Agency theory recommends independent directors and performance-linked pay for managers. Reason (R): Agency theory assumes that managers may pursue their own interests rather than those of shareholders.

Answer and explanation

(a). Monitoring and incentive alignment follow directly from the assumption of self-interested agents.

Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): In Carroll’s pyramid, philanthropic responsibility forms the base. Reason (R): Carroll describes philanthropic responsibility as desired rather than required by society.

Answer and explanation

(d). A is false: economic responsibility is the base. R is true.

Q3. (Practice) Match List I (Thinker) with List II (Idea).

List IList II
A. Milton FriedmanI. Categorical imperative
B. Immanuel KantII. Triple bottom line
C. John ElkingtonIII. Stakeholder approach to strategic management
D. R. Edward FreemanIV. Social responsibility of business is to increase its profits
  • (1) A-IV, B-I, C-II, D-III
  • (2) A-IV, B-II, C-I, D-III
  • (3) A-III, B-I, C-II, D-IV
  • (4) A-I, B-IV, C-II, D-III
Answer and explanation

(1) A-IV, B-I, C-II, D-III.

Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following in chronological order:

  • A. Narayana Murthy Committee report

  • B. Cadbury Committee report

  • C. SEBI LODR Regulations

  • D. Kumar Mangalam Birla Committee report

  • E. Uday Kotak Committee report

  • (1) B, D, A, C, E

  • (2) D, B, A, C, E

  • (3) B, A, D, C, E

  • (4) B, D, A, E, C

Answer and explanation

(1) B, D, A, C, E. 1992 → 1999 → 2003 → 2015 → 2017.


Quick Revision Table

ItemKey fact
Cadbury (UK)1992; “directed and controlled”; comply or explain
Berle and Means1932; separation of ownership and control
Agency theoryJensen and Meckling, 1976; agency costs
Stewardship / stakeholder / resource dependenceDonaldson and Davis 1991 / Freeman 1984 / Pfeffer and Salancik 1978
Sarbanes-OxleyUSA, 2002; Sec 404 internal control
OECD Principles1999; revised 2004, 2015, 2023
Indian committeesCII 1998, Birla 1999 (Clause 49), Naresh Chandra 2002, Narayana Murthy 2003, Irani 2005, Kotak 2017
SEBI LODR2015, in force 1 Dec 2015
Sec 149≤ 15 directors; one-third independent (listed); woman director; 2 × 5-year terms
Sec 177 / 178Audit committee, vigil mechanism / NRC, SRC
Sec 135 CSR₹500 cr net worth / ₹1,000 cr turnover / ₹5 cr profit; 2% of 3-year average; Schedule VII
Carroll (1991)Economic, legal, ethical, philanthropic
Friedman (1970)Business’s responsibility is to increase profits
Elkington (1994)Triple bottom line
Rawls (1971)Justice as fairness, veil of ignorance

Key Takeaways

What’s Next