Compensation, Performance Appraisal, Collective Bargaining and Workers' Participation
UGC NET Commerce: job evaluation, Halsey and Rowan incentives, fringe benefits, 360 degree appraisal, collective bargaining and workers' participation.
- 20 min
On this page · 16 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: Two Questions Every Employee Asks
- 1. Compensation Management
- 2. Job Evaluation
- 3. Incentives
- 4. Fringe Benefits
- 5. Performance Appraisal
- 6. Collective Bargaining
- 7. Workers’ Participation in Management (WPM)
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Human Resource Management: Planning, Recruitment, Training and Succession: job analysis, which feeds job evaluation and appraisal.
- Motivation and Leadership: incentives apply expectancy and equity theory; Herzberg explains why pay alone does not motivate.
- Accounting and Auditing: Cost and Management Accounting: Halsey and Rowan also appear under labour cost.
This page covers three official lines: “Compensation management: job evaluation; incentives and fringe benefits”, “Performance appraisal including 360 degree performance appraisal” and “Collective bargaining and workers’ participation in management”.
The Hook: Two Questions Every Employee Asks
1. Compensation Management
Compensation is everything an employee receives in return for work.
| Component | Examples |
|---|---|
| Direct (financial) | Basic pay, dearness allowance, other allowances, overtime, incentives, bonus, commission |
| Indirect (fringe benefits) | Provident fund, gratuity, insurance, medical care, leave, housing, canteen, education |
| Non-financial | Recognition, challenging work, career growth, work–life balance |
Wage concepts
The Committee on Fair Wages (1948) defined three levels:
| Level | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Minimum wage | Enough for bare subsistence plus some provision for efficiency (education, medical care, amenities) |
| Fair wage | Between the minimum and the living wage, depending on productivity, prevailing rates and the capacity of the industry to pay |
| Living wage | Enough for a reasonable standard of comfort: food, clothing, housing, education, insurance, and some comforts |
Wage theories in options: subsistence theory (wages tend to the subsistence level; associated with Ricardo), wage-fund theory (a fixed fund for wages; associated with J. S. Mill), residual claimant theory (Walker), marginal productivity theory (J. B. Clark), and bargaining theory (wages settled by relative bargaining power).
Pay structure tools: pay grades and ranges, broadbanding (fewer, wider grades), wage and salary surveys, and the compa-ratio:
$$ \text{Compa-ratio} = \frac{\text{Actual pay}}{\text{Mid-point of the pay range}} $$A ratio of 0.9 (actual pay ₹54,000 against a mid-point of ₹60,000) means the employee is paid 10% below the mid-point.
2. Job Evaluation
Job evaluation is the systematic process of determining the relative worth of jobs in an organisation, so that a fair and consistent pay structure can be built. It rates the job, not the jobholder. It is based on job analysis (job description and specification).
Process: gain acceptance → form an evaluation committee → identify and analyse jobs → choose the method → evaluate jobs → build the pay structure → review.
Methods
| Method | Type | How it works | Strength / weakness |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ranking | Non-quantitative, whole job | Jobs ranked from highest to lowest as wholes | Simple, cheap / subjective; shows order, not distance between jobs |
| Job classification (grading) | Non-quantitative, whole job | Pre-set grades with descriptions; each job slotted into a grade (common in government service) | Easy to understand / rigid, broad grades |
| Factor comparison | Quantitative, factor-based | Key (benchmark) jobs ranked on factors such as mental requirements, skill, physical requirements, responsibility and working conditions; their pay is split across the factors; other jobs compared factor by factor in money terms | Detailed / complex, hard to explain |
| Point rating (point factor) | Quantitative, factor-based | Compensable factors divided into degrees, each with points; a job’s total points decide its grade | Most widely used, objective / costly to design |
The Hay Guide Chart-Profile method, a widely used point-type method, scores jobs on know-how, problem solving and accountability (with working conditions where relevant).
3. Incentives
An incentive is a payment over and above the basic wage for performance above a standard. Notation: \( S \) = standard (allowed) time, \( T \) = time taken, \( R \) = rate per hour.
Individual incentive plans
| Plan | Earnings | Key feature |
|---|---|---|
| Time rate | \( T \times R \) | No incentive |
| Straight piece rate | Units × rate per unit | Pure output-based |
| Halsey premium plan | \( T R + 50\% \times (S - T) R \) | Bonus = half of the time saved (the share can vary; the Halsey–Weir variant uses one-third) |
| Rowan plan | \( T R + \dfrac{S - T}{S} \times T R \) | Bonus = proportion of time saved × time wages |
| Taylor’s differential piece rate | Low rate below standard, high rate at or above standard | Sharp penalty for low output |
| Merrick’s multiple piece rate | Three graded piece rates | Milder than Taylor’s |
| Gantt task and bonus | Time wage guaranteed below standard; bonus at standard | Guaranteed minimum |
| Emerson’s efficiency plan | Time wage guaranteed; bonus starts at an efficiency of \( 66\tfrac{2}{3}\% \) and rises with efficiency | Gradual bonus |
| Bedaux point plan | Work measured in “B” points (one minute of work) | Bonus on points saved |
The rule: when the time saved is less than half of the standard time, Rowan pays more; at exactly half both pay the same; when it is more than half, Halsey pays more. Under Rowan the bonus can never exceed the time wages for the hours worked, which protects the employer when standards are loose.
Group and organisation-wide plans
| Plan | Feature |
|---|---|
| Scanlon plan | Gain-sharing based on the ratio of labour cost to sales value of production; suggestion committees |
| Rucker plan | Gain-sharing based on value added |
| Improshare (Improved Productivity through Sharing) | Gain-sharing based on hours saved against a standard |
| Profit sharing | A share of company profits paid to employees |
| Co-partnership / ESOP | Employees acquire shares and thus a stake in ownership |
Requirements of a good incentive plan: simple and understandable, fair standards set by work study, linked directly to effort, paid promptly, with a guaranteed minimum and union acceptance.
4. Fringe Benefits
Fringe benefits are supplementary benefits given in addition to wages, usually not linked to performance.
| Statutory (required by law) | Voluntary (employer’s choice) |
|---|---|
| Provident fund (Employees’ Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952) | Housing, transport, canteen |
| Employees’ State Insurance (ESI Act, 1948) | Medical facilities beyond ESI, group insurance |
| Gratuity (Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972) | Education for children, scholarships |
| Maternity benefit (Maternity Benefit Act, 1961; 26 weeks after the 2017 amendment) | Leave travel concession, holiday homes |
| Bonus (Payment of Bonus Act, 1965: minimum 8.33%, maximum 20%) | Recreation, clubs, counselling, employee assistance |
Gratuity under the 1972 Act is paid on leaving after at least five years of continuous service (the condition is waived on death or disablement), at 15 days’ wages for each completed year, with the month taken as 26 working days:
$$ \text{Gratuity} = \text{Last drawn monthly wages} \times \frac{15}{26} \times \text{Completed years of service} $$Cafeteria (flexible) benefits let each employee choose from a menu of benefits up to a fixed value, which suits a diverse workforce.
5. Performance Appraisal
Performance appraisal is the systematic evaluation of an employee’s performance on the job and of his potential for development. Potential appraisal looks forward: can he handle higher responsibilities?
Uses: pay increments and incentives, promotion and transfer, training needs, feedback and counselling, validation of selection tests, and HR planning.
Process: set performance standards → communicate them → measure actual performance → compare with standards → discuss the appraisal with the employee (appraisal interview) → take corrective action or decisions.
Methods
| Traditional (past-oriented) | Modern (future-oriented) |
|---|---|
| Straight ranking | Management by Objectives (MBO) (Drucker, 1954) |
| Paired comparison | Behaviourally Anchored Rating Scales (BARS) (Smith and Kendall, 1963) |
| Forced distribution | Assessment centre |
| Graphic rating scale | 360-degree appraisal |
| Checklist (simple, weighted) | Human resource accounting |
| Forced choice | Psychological appraisal |
| Critical incident (Flanagan, 1954) | |
| Essay (free form), field review, confidential report |
- Paired comparison: each employee is compared with every other, one pair at a time. Number of comparisons \( = \dfrac{N(N-1)}{2} \). For 8 employees, \( 8 \times 7 \div 2 = 28 \) comparisons.
- Forced distribution: raters must place fixed percentages of employees in each category (for example 10% top, 20% above average, 40% average, 20% below average, 10% bottom), based on the normal curve. It controls leniency and central tendency.
- Graphic rating scale: traits (quality, quantity, dependability) rated on a scale; the most common traditional method.
- Critical incident: the supervisor records examples of especially good or bad behaviour during the period.
- BARS: combines critical incidents with a rating scale; each point on the scale is anchored by a description of actual behaviour.
- Assessment centre: candidates go through simulations (in-basket, group discussion, role play) observed by several trained assessors; mainly for potential appraisal of managers.
Rating errors
| Error | What happens |
|---|---|
| Halo effect | One favourable trait colours the whole rating |
| Horn effect | One unfavourable trait colours the whole rating |
| Leniency | Rating everyone high |
| Strictness (severity) | Rating everyone low |
| Central tendency | Rating everyone average |
| Recency | Judging by recent events only |
| Similar-to-me | Favouring those like the rater |
| Contrast | Rating relative to the previous employee rated, not against standards |
| Personal bias | Prejudice on caste, gender, religion and the like |
360-degree appraisal
360-degree appraisal (multi-source or multi-rater feedback) collects ratings of an employee from everyone around him:
graph TD
E(("Employee")) --- S["Superior"]
E --- P["Peers"]
E --- U["Subordinates"]
E --- C["Internal and external customers"]
E --- SF["Self-appraisal"]| Advantages | Limitations |
|---|---|
| Wider, more balanced picture | Time-consuming and costly |
| Reduces a single superior’s bias | Peers may collude or settle scores |
| Captures behaviour that the boss does not see | Subordinates may fear reprisal unless anonymous |
| Useful for leadership development | Raters need training; feedback can hurt if handled badly |
Good practice keeps raters anonymous, uses the results mainly for development rather than pay, and has a trained facilitator give the feedback. A 720-degree appraisal, in common usage, repeats the 360-degree exercise after a period (or adds external stakeholders) to check whether the person has acted on the feedback.
6. Collective Bargaining
Collective bargaining is the process by which employers and organised employees (through their unions) negotiate terms and conditions of employment, and administer the resulting agreement. The ILO describes it as negotiation between an employer (or employers’ organisation) and workers’ organisations about working conditions and terms of employment. The term is generally credited to Sidney and Beatrice Webb.
Features: collective (group action); bipartite (employer and union; government only as facilitator); continuous; flexible give-and-take; a form of industrial democracy.
Theories (Neil Chamberlain)
| Theory | Collective bargaining is… |
|---|---|
| Marketing theory | A contract for the sale of labour |
| Governmental theory | A constitutional system of rules governing the workplace |
| Managerial (industrial relations) theory | Joint decision-making in which unions share in management |
Types (Walton and McKersie, 1965)
Richard Walton and Robert McKersie (A Behavioral Theory of Labor Negotiations, 1965) identified four sub-processes:
| Type | Nature |
|---|---|
| Distributive bargaining | Win–lose; dividing a fixed amount (wages) |
| Integrative bargaining | Win–win; solving shared problems (productivity, safety) |
| Attitudinal structuring | Shaping trust and attitudes between the parties |
| Intra-organisational bargaining | Building consensus within each side |
Other forms: productivity bargaining (pay increases traded for productivity gains), concessionary bargaining (unions give up gains in hard times), and composite bargaining (bargaining on wider issues such as staffing and policy).
Levels: plant (unit) level, industry level, and national level.
Process
graph LR
A["Preparation
(data, charter of demands)"] --> B["Negotiation"]
B --> C["Agreement
(settlement)"]
C --> D["Implementation
and administration"]If talks fail, the parties may use conciliation, mediation, voluntary arbitration or adjudication, and pressure tactics such as strikes and lockouts.
Prerequisites: a strong, representative union and its recognition; willingness to give and take; a fact-based approach; and a supportive legal framework.
Indian and international framework
- Trade Unions Act, 1926: registration of unions.
- Industrial Disputes Act, 1947: a settlement reached in conciliation or by agreement binds the parties (Section 18).
- Code of Discipline (Indian Labour Conference, 1958): voluntary, includes guidelines on union recognition.
- ILO Conventions No. 87 (Freedom of Association, 1948) and No. 98 (Right to Organise and Collective Bargaining, 1949). India has not ratified either.
- Industrial Relations Code, 2020: replaces the 1926, 1946 and 1947 Acts and provides for a negotiating union or negotiating council in an establishment.
7. Workers’ Participation in Management (WPM)
WPM gives workers a say in managerial decisions that affect them. It is an expression of industrial democracy.
Constitutional basis: Article 43A (inserted by the 42nd Amendment, 1976), a Directive Principle: the State shall take steps to secure the participation of workers in the management of undertakings.
Forms and levels
| Level of participation | Nature |
|---|---|
| Information sharing | Management informs workers |
| Consultative | Workers are consulted; management decides |
| Associative | Management accepts the joint body’s recommendations |
| Administrative | Workers share in implementing decisions |
| Decisive (co-decision) | Joint decisions on major issues |
| Form | Example |
|---|---|
| Joint consultation | Works committees, joint management councils |
| Board representation | Worker directors |
| Ownership participation | Co-partnership, ESOPs |
| Suggestion and problem-solving | Suggestion schemes, quality circles (associated with Kaoru Ishikawa in Japan, from 1962) |
| Self-management | Workers’ councils (the former Yugoslav model) |
| Co-determination | German Mitbestimmung: employee seats on supervisory boards |
Indian schemes in sequence
| Year | Scheme | Key point |
|---|---|---|
| 1947 | Works committees (Section 3, Industrial Disputes Act) | Establishments with 100 or more workmen; equal representatives of employer and workers |
| 1958 | Joint Management Councils (JMCs) | Followed the Industrial Policy Resolution, 1956; consultative, voluntary |
| 1975 | Shop councils and joint councils | Manufacturing and mining units with 500 or more workers; shop level and plant level |
| 1977 | Scheme for commercial and service organisations in the public sector | Extended participation to services such as hospitals and banks |
| 1983 | Comprehensive scheme | Participation at shop floor, plant and board levels in central public sector undertakings |
| 1990 | Participation of Workers in Management Bill | Introduced in Parliament; never enacted |
Why WPM has had limited success in India: multiplicity of unions and inter-union rivalry, management’s reluctance to share power, workers’ lack of education and information, overlap with collective bargaining, and the voluntary nature of most schemes.
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| Pair | First | Second |
|---|---|---|
| Job evaluation vs performance appraisal | Worth of the job | Performance of the person |
| Factor comparison vs point rating | Money values against key jobs | Points per factor degree |
| Ranking vs paired comparison | Single overall ranking | Each pair compared; \( N(N-1)/2 \) comparisons |
| Halsey vs Rowan | Fixed share (50%) of time saved | Proportion of time saved × time wages; bonus never exceeds time wages |
| Halo vs horn effect | One good trait inflates | One bad trait deflates |
| Leniency vs central tendency | Everyone rated high | Everyone rated average |
| Distributive vs integrative bargaining | Win–lose | Win–win |
| Collective bargaining vs WPM | Bipartite negotiation of terms | Workers share in decisions |
| Works committee vs JMC | 1947, statutory (ID Act) | 1958, voluntary |
| ILO C87 vs C98 | Freedom of association (1948) | Right to organise and collective bargaining (1949) |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Which two job evaluation methods are quantitative?
- How many comparisons are needed to rate 12 employees by the paired comparison method?
- Which Article of the Constitution provides for workers’ participation in management?
Answers
- Factor comparison and point rating.
- \( 12 \times 11 \div 2 = \) 66.
- Article 43A (42nd Amendment, 1976).
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) Standard time for a job is 40 hours, time taken is 30 hours, and the wage rate is ₹60 per hour. The worker’s earnings under the Rowan plan are:
- (a) ₹2,100
- (b) ₹2,250
- (c) ₹2,400
- (d) ₹1,800
Answer and explanation
(b) ₹2,250. Time wages \( = 30 \times 60 = 1{,}800 \). Bonus \( = \tfrac{40 - 30}{40} \times 1{,}800 = 0.25 \times 1{,}800 = 450 \). Total ₹2,250. Option (a) is the Halsey figure: \( 1{,}800 + 0.5 \times 10 \times 60 = 2{,}100 \). Since only a quarter of standard time was saved (less than half), Rowan pays more, as expected.
Q2. (Practice) Which appraisal method anchors points on a rating scale with descriptions of actual job behaviour?
- (a) Graphic rating scale
- (b) Forced distribution
- (c) BARS
- (d) Field review
Answer and explanation
(c) Behaviourally Anchored Rating Scales, which combine critical incidents with a rating scale.
Q3. (Practice) In Walton and McKersie’s framework, bargaining in which both sides look for solutions that benefit both is:
- (a) Distributive bargaining
- (b) Integrative bargaining
- (c) Attitudinal structuring
- (d) Intra-organisational bargaining
Answer and explanation
(b) Integrative bargaining (win–win).
Q4. (Practice) Consider the following statements about 360-degree appraisal:
- It includes feedback from subordinates and peers.
- It is usually recommended mainly for developmental purposes.
- It removes the need for training raters.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 only
- (b) 1 and 2 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 1 and 2 only. Multi-source feedback needs more rater training, not less.
Q5. (Practice) An employee’s last drawn monthly wages are ₹26,000 and he has 10 completed years of service. His gratuity under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 is:
- (a) ₹1,30,000
- (b) ₹1,50,000
- (c) ₹2,60,000
- (d) ₹1,56,000
Answer and explanation
(b) ₹1,50,000. \( 26{,}000 \times 15 \div 26 \times 10 = 15{,}000 \times 10 \). Option (a) wrongly divides by 30 (\( 26{,}000 \times 15 \div 30 \times 10 \)).
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): Forced distribution reduces the central tendency and leniency errors. Reason (R): Under forced distribution, the rater must place fixed percentages of employees in each performance category.
Answer and explanation
(a). Because the rater cannot put everyone in the middle or at the top, those errors are controlled.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): Job evaluation determines the relative worth of the jobholder. Reason (R): Job evaluation is based on job descriptions and job specifications.
Answer and explanation
(d). A is false: job evaluation determines the worth of the job, not the jobholder. R is true.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I (Incentive plan) with List II (Feature).
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Halsey plan | I. Gain-sharing based on labour cost to sales value ratio |
| B. Rowan plan | II. Bonus is a fixed share of time saved |
| C. Scanlon plan | III. Bonus starts at two-thirds efficiency |
| D. Emerson plan | IV. Bonus can never exceed time wages |
- (1) A-II, B-IV, C-I, D-III
- (2) A-IV, B-II, C-I, D-III
- (3) A-II, B-IV, C-III, D-I
- (4) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
Answer and explanation
(1) A-II, B-IV, C-I, D-III.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following Indian schemes of workers’ participation in chronological order:
A. Joint Management Councils
B. Comprehensive scheme for central public sector undertakings
C. Works committees under the Industrial Disputes Act
D. Shop councils and joint councils
(1) C, A, D, B
(2) A, C, D, B
(3) C, D, A, B
(4) C, A, B, D
Answer and explanation
(1) C, A, D, B. 1947 → 1958 → 1975 → 1983.
Q5. (Practice) Arrange the steps of collective bargaining in order:
A. Implementation of the agreement
B. Preparation of the charter of demands
C. Negotiation
D. Signing of the agreement
(1) B, C, D, A
(2) C, B, D, A
(3) B, D, C, A
(4) B, C, A, D
Answer and explanation
(1) B, C, D, A.
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Key fact |
|---|---|
| Committee on Fair Wages | 1948; minimum, fair, living wage |
| Compa-ratio | Actual pay ÷ range mid-point |
| Job evaluation | Worth of jobs; ranking, classification (non-quantitative); factor comparison, point rating (quantitative) |
| Hay method | Know-how, problem solving, accountability |
| Halsey | \( TR + 50\%(S-T)R \) |
| Rowan | \( TR + \frac{S-T}{S} TR \); bonus ≤ time wages |
| Halsey vs Rowan | Saving < 50%: Rowan higher; = 50%: equal; > 50%: Halsey higher |
| Emerson | Bonus from \( 66\tfrac{2}{3}\% \) efficiency |
| Group plans | Scanlon, Rucker, Improshare, profit sharing, ESOP |
| Gratuity | Wages × 15/26 × years; 5-year minimum; ceiling ₹20 lakh |
| Bonus Act 1965 | 8.33% minimum, 20% maximum |
| Paired comparison | \( N(N-1)/2 \) |
| BARS / critical incident | Smith and Kendall 1963 / Flanagan 1954 |
| 360-degree | Superior, peers, subordinates, customers, self |
| Walton and McKersie (1965) | Distributive, integrative, attitudinal structuring, intra-organisational |
| Chamberlain | Marketing, governmental, managerial theories |
| ILO C87 / C98 | 1948 / 1949; not ratified by India |
| Article 43A | 42nd Amendment, 1976; Directive Principle |
| WPM schemes | 1947 works committees, 1958 JMCs, 1975 shop and joint councils, 1977 services, 1983 comprehensive |
| Quality circles | Ishikawa, Japan, 1962 |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Organisational Behaviour, Culture and Change: perception errors in appraisal, conflict and negotiation behind bargaining
- Corporate Governance and Business Ethics: executive pay and the nomination and remuneration committee
- Accounting and Auditing: Cost and Management Accounting: labour cost and incentive plans from the costing side
- Chapter overview