Cost of Capital, Leverage and Capital Structure Theories
UGC NET Commerce: cost of debt, preference and equity, CAPM, WACC, operating and financial leverage, EBIT-EPS analysis, NI, NOI, traditional and MM theories.
- 18 min
On this page · 15 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: The Cheapest Money Is Not Free
- 1. Cost of Capital: Meaning and Uses
- 2. Specific Costs
- 3. Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC)
- 4. Leverage
- 5. Capital Structure: Meaning and Determinants
- 6. Capital Structure Theories
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Scope of Finance, Time Value of Money, Sources of Finance and Lease Financing — the sources whose cost is measured here, and the present-value formulas behind every cost.
- Cost and Management Accounting — contribution and fixed cost, which reappear as operating leverage.
- Financial Statement Analysis — debt–equity and interest coverage ratios.
This page covers the cost of capital half of the official line “Cost of capital and time value of money” and the whole line “Capital structure”. Leverage is included because it is the bridge between the two: it measures how the choice of debt changes risk and return.
The Hook: The Cheapest Money Is Not Free
1. Cost of Capital: Meaning and Uses
The cost of capital is the minimum rate of return a firm must earn on its investments to keep the market value of its shares unchanged. It is the required rate of return of the suppliers of capital, and therefore the hurdle (cut-off) rate for capital budgeting.
| Concept | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Explicit cost | Discount rate that equates the funds received with the PV of the outflows (interest, dividends, redemption): the IRR of the financing cash flows |
| Implicit cost | Opportunity cost: the return forgone (retained earnings) |
| Specific cost | Cost of one source (\( K_d, K_p, K_e, K_r \)) |
| Composite / overall / weighted average cost | \( K_o \) or WACC, the combined cost of all sources |
| Marginal cost | Cost of the next rupee of new capital raised |
| Historical vs future cost | Book cost of past funds vs expected cost of new funds; future cost is relevant for decisions |
Uses: cut-off rate for projects; designing the capital structure; evaluating the finance department; dividend and working capital decisions.
2. Specific Costs
Cost of debt (\( K_d \))
Let \( I \) = annual interest, \( t \) = tax rate, \( NP \) = net proceeds (issue price less flotation costs), \( RV \) = redemption value, \( n \) = years to maturity.
| Case | Formula |
|---|---|
| Irredeemable debt (after tax) | \( K_d = \dfrac{I(1-t)}{NP} \) |
| Redeemable debt (approximation) | \( K_d = \dfrac{I(1-t) + \frac{RV - NP}{n}}{\frac{RV + NP}{2}} \) |
| Exact method | The rate that equates NP with the PV of after-tax interest and redemption value (the bond’s after-tax YTM) |
Debt is the cheapest source for two reasons: lenders bear less risk than shareholders, and interest is tax-deductible (the tax shield).
Cost of preference shares (\( K_p \))
| Case | Formula |
|---|---|
| Irredeemable | \( K_p = \dfrac{D_p}{NP} \) |
| Redeemable | \( K_p = \dfrac{D_p + \frac{RV - NP}{n}}{\frac{RV + NP}{2}} \) |
No tax adjustment: preference dividend is paid out of post-tax profits.
Cost of equity (\( K_e \))
| Approach | Formula | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Dividend price approach | \( K_e = \dfrac{D_1}{P_0} \) | No growth |
| Dividend growth (Gordon) model | \( K_e = \dfrac{D_1}{P_0} + g \) | \( D_1 = D_0(1+g) \); for a new issue use \( NP \) in place of \( P_0 \) |
| Earnings price approach | \( K_e = \dfrac{E_1}{P_0} \) | Assumes 100% payout or retained earnings earning \( K_e \) |
| Realised yield approach | Average of past returns actually earned | Backward-looking |
| CAPM | \( K_e = R_f + \beta(R_m - R_f) \) | Systematic risk only; see Risk and Return |
| Bond yield plus risk premium | \( K_d \) (pre-tax) + a premium of a few per cent | Rough cross-check |
Cost of retained earnings (\( K_r \))
Retained earnings belong to shareholders, so their cost is the return shareholders could earn elsewhere: \( K_r = K_e \) (no flotation cost). If shareholders would pay personal tax and brokerage on reinvesting the dividend, \( K_r = K_e(1 - t_p)(1 - f) \), which makes retained earnings slightly cheaper than new equity.
3. Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC)
$$K_o = W_e K_e + W_r K_r + W_p K_p + W_d K_d$$Weights can be book value (from the balance sheet; easy, stable) or market value (current prices; theoretically preferred because the firm raises capital at market prices). Target weights reflect the planned capital structure.
4. Leverage
Leverage is the use of fixed-cost assets or fixed-cost funds to magnify returns. Fixed costs are a lever: a small change in sales produces a larger change in profit.
graph LR
A["Sales"] -->|"less variable cost"| B["Contribution"]
B -->|"less fixed operating cost
OPERATING LEVERAGE"| C["EBIT"]
C -->|"less interest
FINANCIAL LEVERAGE"| D["EBT"]
D -->|"less tax, preference dividend"| E["Earnings for equity / EPS"]| Leverage | Formula | Measures | Risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Operating (DOL) | \( \dfrac{\text{Contribution}}{\text{EBIT}} = \dfrac{\%\Delta \text{EBIT}}{\%\Delta \text{Sales}} \) | Effect of fixed operating costs | Business risk |
| Financial (DFL) | \( \dfrac{\text{EBIT}}{\text{EBT}} = \dfrac{\%\Delta \text{EPS}}{\%\Delta \text{EBIT}} \) | Effect of fixed financial charges | Financial risk |
| DFL with preference shares | \( \dfrac{\text{EBIT}}{\text{EBIT} - I - \frac{D_p}{1-t}} \) | ||
| Combined (DCL) | \( \text{DOL} \times \text{DFL} = \dfrac{\text{Contribution}}{\text{EBT}} = \dfrac{\%\Delta \text{EPS}}{\%\Delta \text{Sales}} \) | Total effect of sales on EPS | Total risk |
DOL is undefined at the operating break-even point (EBIT = 0) and falls as sales move above it. A firm with high DOL usually prefers low DFL to keep total risk manageable.
Trading on equity: using fixed-cost debt to raise the return to equity. It is favourable when the return on capital employed exceeds the cost of debt, and unfavourable otherwise.
EBIT–EPS analysis and the indifference point
The indifference point is the EBIT at which two financing plans give the same EPS. Above it, the plan with more debt gives a higher EPS; below it, the plan with less debt is better.
$$\frac{(X - I_1)(1-t) - D_{p1}}{N_1} = \frac{(X - I_2)(1-t) - D_{p2}}{N_2}$$The financial break-even point is the EBIT at which EPS is zero: \( \text{EBIT} = I + \dfrac{D_p}{1-t} \).
5. Capital Structure: Meaning and Determinants
Capital structure is the mix of long-term sources (equity, preference, debt) in a firm’s total capitalisation. Financial structure is wider: it includes current liabilities too. An optimal capital structure is the mix that minimises the overall cost of capital and so maximises the value of the firm.
Determinants: stability of cash flows and earnings; business risk and DOL; cost of each source; tax rate; control considerations; flexibility and debt capacity; market conditions; size and age of the firm; legal and regulatory limits; lenders’ covenants.
Features of a sound capital structure (often listed): profitability (minimum cost), solvency (debt within capacity), flexibility, conservatism, and control.
6. Capital Structure Theories
Common assumptions for the classroom versions: only debt and equity; no taxes (unless stated); 100% payout; constant EBIT; no growth; perpetual life; total assets fixed (only the mix changes).
Notation: \( V = S + D \), \( K_o = \dfrac{\text{EBIT}}{V} \), \( K_e = \dfrac{\text{EBIT} - I}{S} \).
Net Income (NI) approach
Proposed by David Durand (1952). \( K_d \) and \( K_e \) stay constant as debt rises; \( K_d < K_e \), so replacing equity with debt lowers \( K_o \) and raises value. Optimal structure: as much debt as possible. Capital structure is relevant.
Net Operating Income (NOI) approach
Also Durand (1952). The market capitalises the firm as a whole at a constant \( K_o \); the split between debt and equity does not matter. As debt rises, \( K_e \) rises just enough to keep \( K_o \) constant. Capital structure is irrelevant; no optimum.
Traditional (intermediate) approach
A middle path: moderate debt lowers \( K_o \) at first (cheap debt outweighs the rise in \( K_e \)); beyond a point, \( K_e \) and later \( K_d \) rise sharply and \( K_o \) rises. \( K_o \) is U-shaped (or saucer-shaped), so there is an optimal capital structure.
Modigliani–Miller (MM)
Franco Modigliani and Merton Miller (1958), “The Cost of Capital, Corporation Finance and the Theory of Investment”, American Economic Review.
| Proposition | Without taxes (1958) | With corporate taxes (1963 correction) |
|---|---|---|
| I: value | \( V_L = V_U \); value independent of capital structure | \( V_L = V_U + tD \); value rises with debt (tax shield) |
| II: cost of equity | \( K_e = K_o + (K_o - K_d)\dfrac{D}{S} \) | \( K_e = K_u + (K_u - K_d)(1-t)\dfrac{D}{S} \), where \( K_u \) is the cost of equity of the unlevered firm (with tax, \( K_o \) of the levered firm falls below \( K_u \)) |
| Implication | Like NOI, but proved through arbitrage | Nearly all-debt is optimal (in theory) |
Assumptions (1958): perfect capital markets; no taxes; no transaction costs; investors are rational and can borrow and lend at the same rate as firms (homemade leverage); firms in the same risk class; 100% payout.
Arbitrage process: if a levered firm sells for more than an identical unlevered firm, investors sell the levered firm’s shares, borrow personally in the same proportion, and buy the unlevered firm’s shares. They earn the same income with less investment, and this selling and buying pushes the two values together.
Criticisms: personal and corporate leverage are not perfect substitutes; transaction costs; personal borrowing costs more; institutional limits on borrowing; bankruptcy costs and agency costs of debt are ignored.
Later theories
| Theory | Core idea | Associated with |
|---|---|---|
| Trade-off theory | Optimal debt balances the tax shield against expected bankruptcy (financial distress) costs | Developed after MM (1963) to explain why firms do not use 100% debt |
| Pecking order theory | Because managers know more than investors (information asymmetry), firms prefer internal funds → debt → equity (equity last) | Myers and Majluf (1984); earlier observation by Gordon Donaldson |
| Agency cost theory | Debt disciplines managers (less free cash flow to waste) but creates conflicts between shareholders and lenders | Jensen and Meckling (1976) |
| Signalling theory | Capital structure choices convey managers’ private information; issuing debt signals confidence | Stephen Ross |
graph TD
R["Is capital structure relevant to value?"] --> Y["Relevant"]
R --> N["Irrelevant"]
Y --> Y1["NI approach: more debt, always better"]
Y --> Y2["Traditional: U-shaped Ko, optimum exists"]
Y --> Y3["MM 1963 with tax: VL = VU + tD"]
Y --> Y4["Trade-off: tax shield vs distress cost"]
N --> N1["NOI approach: constant Ko"]
N --> N2["MM 1958 without tax: arbitrage proof"]Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| Pair | First | Second |
|---|---|---|
| Operating vs financial leverage | Fixed operating costs; business risk; Contribution ÷ EBIT | Fixed financial charges; financial risk; EBIT ÷ EBT |
| NI vs NOI | \( K_e \), \( K_d \) constant; relevant | \( K_o \) constant; irrelevant |
| MM 1958 vs MM 1963 | No tax; \( V_L = V_U \) | Corporate tax; \( V_L = V_U + tD \) |
| Explicit vs implicit cost | Actual outflows (interest, dividend) | Opportunity cost (retained earnings) |
| Indifference point vs financial BEP | EPS equal under two plans | EPS zero under one plan |
| Capital vs financial structure | Long-term sources only | Long-term + current liabilities |
| Book vs market value weights | Balance sheet amounts | Current market prices (preferred) |
| Trade-off vs pecking order | Target debt ratio exists | No target; hierarchy of sources |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- A company’s contribution is ₹6,00,000 and EBIT is ₹2,00,000. What is its DOL?
- Under which approach does the overall cost of capital remain constant whatever the debt–equity mix?
- Which source of capital has a cost that is adjusted for corporate tax?
Answers
- 6,00,000 ÷ 2,00,000 = 3.
- The Net Operating Income (NOI) approach (and MM without taxes).
- Debt: \( K_d = I(1-t)/NP \).
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) A share sells for ₹80. The company has just paid a dividend of ₹5 and dividends are expected to grow at 4% a year. The cost of equity is closest to:
- (a) 6.25%
- (b) 10.25%
- (c) 10.50%
- (d) 11.00%
Answer and explanation
(c) 10.50%. \( D_1 = 5 \times 1.04 = 5.20 \); \( K_e = 5.20/80 + 0.04 = 0.065 + 0.04 = 10.5\% \). Option (b) uses \( D_0 \): 5/80 + 4% = 10.25%.
Q2. (Practice) A firm has DOL 2.5 and DFL 2. If sales rise by 8%, EPS will rise by:
- (a) 16%
- (b) 20%
- (c) 36%
- (d) 40%
Answer and explanation
(d) 40%. DCL = 2.5 × 2 = 5; 5 × 8% = 40%.
Q3. (Practice) According to MM with corporate taxes, an unlevered firm worth ₹50 crore that issues ₹20 crore of perpetual debt (tax rate 25%) and uses it to buy back shares will be worth:
- (a) ₹50 crore
- (b) ₹55 crore
- (c) ₹65 crore
- (d) ₹70 crore
Answer and explanation
(b) ₹55 crore. \( V_L = V_U + tD = 50 + 0.25 \times 20 = 55 \).
Q4. (Practice) Consider the following statements:
- Market value weights are theoretically preferred to book value weights in computing WACC.
- The cost of retained earnings is zero because no dividend is paid on them.
- Flotation costs raise the cost of a new equity issue above that of retained earnings.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 1 and 3 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 1 and 3 only. Statement 2 is the classic error: retained earnings carry an opportunity cost equal to (or slightly below) \( K_e \).
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): For a profitable company, the after-tax cost of debt is lower than the coupon rate on that debt. Reason (R): Interest on debt is a tax-deductible expense.
Answer and explanation
(a). Because interest reduces taxable profit, each rupee of interest costs the company only \( (1 - t) \) rupees: 10% debt at a 30% tax rate costs 7%. The qualifier “profitable” matters: a loss-making company gets no immediate tax saving.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): Under the MM hypothesis without taxes, the cost of equity rises as the debt–equity ratio rises. Reason (R): Shareholders demand a higher return to compensate for the increased financial risk.
Answer and explanation
(a). MM Proposition II: \( K_e = K_o + (K_o - K_d)D/S \). The rise in \( K_e \) reflects the extra financial risk borne by shareholders and exactly offsets the cheaper debt, keeping \( K_o \) constant.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I with List II.
| List I (Theory) | List II (Feature) |
|---|---|
| A. Net Income approach | I. Overall cost of capital is U-shaped |
| B. Traditional approach | II. Value rises with debt because \( K_e \) and \( K_d \) are constant |
| C. Pecking order theory | III. Arbitrage keeps levered and unlevered values equal |
| D. MM (1958) | IV. Internal funds, then debt, then equity |
- (1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
- (2) A-I, B-II, C-IV, D-III
- (3) A-II, B-I, C-III, D-IV
- (4) A-III, B-I, C-IV, D-II
Answer and explanation
(1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the following in the order in which they appear when moving down an income statement from sales to EPS:
A. EBT
B. Contribution
C. EBIT
D. Earnings available to equity shareholders
(1) B, C, A, D
(2) C, B, A, D
(3) B, A, C, D
(4) B, C, D, A
Answer and explanation
(1) B, C, A, D. Sales − variable cost = contribution; − fixed operating cost = EBIT; − interest = EBT; − tax and preference dividend = earnings for equity. DOL acts between B and C, DFL between C and A.
Q5. (Practice) Arrange the capital structure theories in chronological order of their publication:
A. Pecking order theory (Myers and Majluf)
B. MM irrelevance proposition
C. NI and NOI approaches (Durand)
D. Agency cost theory (Jensen and Meckling)
(1) C, B, D, A
(2) B, C, D, A
(3) C, B, A, D
(4) C, D, B, A
Answer and explanation
(1) C, B, D, A. Durand 1952 → MM 1958 → Jensen and Meckling 1976 → Myers and Majluf 1984.
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Formula / fact |
|---|---|
| \( K_d \) irredeemable | \( I(1-t)/NP \) |
| \( K_d \) redeemable | \( [I(1-t) + (RV-NP)/n] \div [(RV+NP)/2] \) |
| \( K_p \) | \( D_p/NP \) (no tax adjustment) |
| \( K_e \) Gordon | \( D_1/P_0 + g \) |
| \( K_e \) CAPM | \( R_f + \beta(R_m - R_f) \) |
| \( K_r \) | \( = K_e \) (or \( K_e(1-t_p)(1-f) \)) |
| WACC | \( \sum W_i K_i \); market weights preferred |
| DOL / DFL / DCL | C/EBIT; EBIT/EBT; C/EBT |
| Financial BEP | EBIT = \( I + D_p/(1-t) \) |
| NI (Durand 1952) | Relevant; more debt → higher value |
| NOI (Durand 1952) | Irrelevant; \( K_o \) constant |
| Traditional | U-shaped \( K_o \); optimum exists |
| MM 1958 / 1963 | \( V_L = V_U \) / \( V_L = V_U + tD \) |
| Pecking order (1984) | Internal → debt → equity |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Capital Budgeting — the WACC computed here becomes the discount rate for NPV
- Risk and Return Analysis — where beta and CAPM come from
- Working Capital and Dividend Decisions — MM’s irrelevance argument returns for dividends
- Business Finance Quick Revision