Capital Budgeting: Conventional and Scientific Techniques
UGC NET Commerce: payback, ARR, NPV, IRR, PI, MIRR, NPV-IRR conflict, capital rationing, and risk analysis by RADR, certainty equivalent and decision tree.
- 16 min
On this page · 15 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: The Project That Pays Back Fast
- 1. Capital Budgeting: Meaning, Features and Process
- 2. Conventional (Traditional, Non-discounting) Techniques
- 3. Scientific (Modern, Discounted Cash Flow) Techniques
- 4. NPV vs IRR: When They Conflict
- 5. Capital Rationing
- 6. Risk Analysis in Capital Budgeting
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Scope of Finance and Time Value of Money — PVIF and PVIFA are used on every line here.
- Cost of Capital and Capital Structure — the WACC is the discount rate (hurdle rate) for NPV.
- Cost and Management Accounting — relevant costs, sunk costs and opportunity costs decide which cash flows enter the analysis.
This page covers the official line “Capital budgeting decisions: conventional and scientific techniques of capital budgeting analysis”. The line is read in two ways in textbooks, and UGC NET questions draw on both, so both are covered:
- Evaluation techniques: the conventional (traditional, non-discounting) methods, payback and ARR, versus the scientific (modern, discounted cash flow) methods, NPV, IRR, PI, discounted payback and MIRR.
- Risk analysis techniques: conventional risk adjustments (payback, risk-adjusted discount rate, certainty equivalent) versus statistical/scientific ones (probability distribution, standard deviation and coefficient of variation, sensitivity analysis, decision tree, simulation).
The Hook: The Project That Pays Back Fast
1. Capital Budgeting: Meaning, Features and Process
Capital budgeting is the process of evaluating and selecting long-term investments whose benefits extend over more than one year: new plant, expansion, replacement, R&D, new products, acquisitions.
Why it matters: large outlays; long-term effect on profitability and risk; decisions are often irreversible or reversible only at a heavy loss; they shape the firm’s future growth.
Types of decisions: expansion, replacement and modernisation, diversification; and by relationship, independent (accept all that pass), mutually exclusive (choose one), and contingent (one requires another).
graph LR
A["1. Identify
investment ideas"] --> B["2. Estimate
cash flows"]
B --> C["3. Evaluate
(payback, NPV, IRR)"]
C --> D["4. Select and
authorise"]
D --> E["5. Implement"]
E --> F["6. Review
(post-audit)"]Estimating relevant cash flows
| Include | Exclude |
|---|---|
| Incremental after-tax cash flows | Sunk costs (already spent, e.g. a feasibility study) |
| Opportunity costs of resources used (land the firm already owns) | Allocated overheads that do not change |
| Changes in working capital (outflow at start, recovered at end) | Interest and dividends (financing costs are in the discount rate) |
| Salvage value (after tax) at the end | Non-cash charges themselves (depreciation enters only via its tax shield) |
| Side effects on other products (cannibalisation) |
Cash flow after tax (CFAT) = EBIT(1 − t) + depreciation, or equivalently PAT + depreciation when there is no debt in the project’s cash flow.
2. Conventional (Traditional, Non-discounting) Techniques
Payback period
The time needed to recover the initial investment from the project’s cash inflows.
- Even inflows: \( \text{Payback} = \dfrac{\text{Initial investment}}{\text{Annual cash inflow}} \)
- Uneven inflows: add cumulative inflows until the investment is recovered; interpolate in the final year.
Decision: accept if payback ≤ target period; rank by shorter payback.
Merits: simple; emphasises liquidity; a rough guard against risk and obsolescence (early cash is safer). Demerits: ignores time value; ignores cash flows after payback; no link to the cost of capital or to shareholder wealth.
Payback reciprocal (\( 1/\text{payback} \)) approximates the IRR only when the life is long (at least twice the payback) and inflows are even.
Accounting (average) rate of return (ARR)
$$\text{ARR} = \frac{\text{Average annual profit after tax (after depreciation)}}{\text{Average investment}} \times 100$$Average investment \( = \dfrac{\text{Initial cost} - \text{Salvage}}{2} + \text{Salvage} + \text{Working capital} \). Some texts use the initial investment as the denominator; state which one you use.
Merits: simple; uses accounting data; considers profits over the whole life. Demerits: uses accounting profit, not cash flow; ignores time value; several possible definitions.
3. Scientific (Modern, Discounted Cash Flow) Techniques
Net present value (NPV)
$$\text{NPV} = \sum_{t=1}^{n} \frac{C_t}{(1+k)^t} - C_0$$\( k \) = cost of capital. Decision: accept if NPV > 0; among mutually exclusive projects choose the highest NPV.
Merits: time value; all cash flows; consistent with wealth maximisation; NPVs are additive (value additivity); assumes reinvestment at the cost of capital (the more realistic assumption). Demerits: needs the cost of capital; gives an absolute figure that does not show efficiency per rupee invested; can favour large projects.
Internal rate of return (IRR)
The discount rate at which NPV = 0, i.e. PV of inflows = initial outlay. Found by trial and error and linear interpolation:
$$\text{IRR} = L + \frac{\text{NPV}_L}{\text{NPV}_L - \text{NPV}_H} \times (H - L)$$Decision: accept if IRR > cost of capital.
Merits: time value; a percentage that managers understand; does not need \( k \) to compute (only to decide). Demerits: assumes reinvestment at the IRR itself (often unrealistic); multiple IRRs or no IRR when cash flows change sign more than once (non-conventional cash flows); can rank mutually exclusive projects wrongly; tedious by hand.
Profitability index (PI) or benefit–cost ratio
$$\text{PI} = \frac{\text{PV of cash inflows}}{\text{PV of cash outflows}}$$Decision: accept if PI > 1 (equivalent to NPV > 0). PI is the best ranking tool under capital rationing with divisible projects. Net PI = PI − 1.
Discounted payback period
Payback computed on discounted cash flows. It fixes the time-value flaw of simple payback but still ignores flows after the cut-off. Discounted payback is always longer than simple payback (for positive \( k \)).
Modified IRR (MIRR)
Compound all inflows to the end of the life at the cost of capital (terminal value, TV), then find the rate that equates the PV of outflows with the TV:
$$\text{MIRR} = \left(\frac{\text{TV}}{\text{PV of outflows}}\right)^{1/n} - 1$$MIRR removes the IRR’s reinvestment-rate problem and the multiple-IRR problem.
4. NPV vs IRR: When They Conflict
For a single independent project with conventional cash flows, NPV and IRR always give the same accept/reject decision. For mutually exclusive projects they can rank differently because of:
- Size (scale) disparity: different initial outlays.
- Timing disparity: one project’s inflows come early, the other’s late.
- Life disparity: unequal lives (use the equivalent annual annuity or replacement-chain method).
The root cause is the reinvestment assumption: NPV assumes intermediate cash flows are reinvested at \( k \); IRR assumes at the IRR. When they conflict, follow NPV, because it measures the addition to shareholder wealth.
The discount rate at which the NPV profiles of two projects cross is Fisher’s rate of intersection (the crossover rate), named after Irving Fisher. Below it, NPV and IRR rankings conflict; above it, they agree.
5. Capital Rationing
Capital rationing is a situation where the firm cannot accept all positive-NPV projects because funds are limited. External (hard) rationing arises from market constraints; internal (soft) rationing from management’s own limits on spending.
Rule: maximise the total NPV within the budget.
- Divisible projects: rank by PI and fill the budget, taking a fraction of the last project.
- Indivisible projects: test the feasible combinations; ranking by PI is a guide, not a guarantee.
6. Risk Analysis in Capital Budgeting
Cash flow estimates are uncertain. Risk means the possible variability of returns around the expected value.
Conventional techniques
| Technique | How it works | Limitation |
|---|---|---|
| Payback | Shorter payback for riskier projects | Ignores time value and later flows |
| Risk-adjusted discount rate (RADR) | Add a risk premium to the discount rate: \( k_{adj} = R_f + \text{premium} \) | Assumes risk grows with time at a compound rate; the premium is subjective |
| Certainty equivalent (CE) | Convert each risky cash flow into its certain equivalent: \( \alpha_t \times C_t \), with \( 0 \le \alpha_t \le 1 \); discount at the risk-free rate | \( \alpha \) values are subjective; but it separates risk from time |
Statistical (scientific) techniques
| Technique | How it works |
|---|---|
| Probability and expected value | Assign probabilities to outcomes; expected NPV \( = \sum p_i \cdot \text{NPV}_i \) |
| Standard deviation | Absolute dispersion of NPVs around the expected NPV |
| Coefficient of variation | \( \sigma \div \text{expected NPV} \); relative risk; compare projects of different size |
| Sensitivity analysis | Change one variable at a time (sales, price, cost) and see how NPV changes; finds the critical variables (“what if”) |
| Scenario analysis | Change several variables together (best, base, worst case) |
| Decision tree | Maps sequential decisions and chance events as branches; roll back from the end using expected values |
| Simulation (Monte Carlo) | Draw random values for each variable from its probability distribution many times; build a distribution of NPV (associated with David Hertz, Harvard Business Review, 1964) |
| Hillier model | Expected NPV and its standard deviation from the probability distributions of yearly cash flows (independent or perfectly correlated) |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| Pair | First | Second |
|---|---|---|
| Payback vs discounted payback | Undiscounted flows; shorter | Discounted flows; longer |
| ARR vs IRR | Accounting profit, no discounting | Cash flows, discount rate where NPV = 0 |
| NPV vs PI | Absolute rupee gain | Relative gain per rupee; best for rationing |
| IRR vs MIRR | Reinvestment at IRR; multiple IRRs possible | Reinvestment at \( k \); unique |
| Independent vs mutually exclusive | Accept all with NPV > 0 | Choose highest NPV |
| Sensitivity vs scenario analysis | One variable at a time | Several variables together |
| Hard vs soft capital rationing | Imposed by the market | Imposed by management |
| Certainty equivalent vs RADR | Adjust cash flows; discount at \( R_f \) | Adjust the discount rate |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- A project costs ₹60,000 and generates ₹15,000 a year. What is its payback period?
- At what discount rate is a project’s NPV equal to zero?
- What PI value corresponds to an NPV of zero?
Answers
- 60,000 ÷ 15,000 = 4 years.
- At its IRR.
- PI = 1.
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) A project costing ₹2,00,000 has a PV of cash inflows of ₹2,30,000 at the firm’s cost of capital. Its NPV and PI are:
- (a) ₹30,000 and 1.15
- (b) ₹30,000 and 0.87
- (c) ₹2,30,000 and 1.15
- (d) ₹30,000 and 1.30
Answer and explanation
(a). NPV = 2,30,000 − 2,00,000 = ₹30,000; PI = 2,30,000 ÷ 2,00,000 = 1.15.
Q2. (Practice) Which of the following capital budgeting techniques does not consider the time value of money?
- (a) Profitability index
- (b) Discounted payback period
- (c) Accounting rate of return
- (d) Modified internal rate of return
Answer and explanation
(c) ARR. It averages accounting profits without discounting. The others are DCF methods.
Q3. (Practice) NPV at 12% is ₹4,000 and at 14% is −₹1,000. The IRR by interpolation is:
- (a) 12.8%
- (b) 13.2%
- (c) 13.6%
- (d) 14.4%
Answer and explanation
(c) 13.6%. IRR = 12 + 4,000 ÷ (4,000 + 1,000) × 2 = 12 + 1.6 = 13.6%.
Q4. (Practice) Consider the following statements:
- The IRR method implicitly assumes that intermediate cash flows are reinvested at the IRR.
- A project with non-conventional cash flows may have more than one IRR.
- NPV and IRR can give different accept/reject decisions for a single independent project with conventional cash flows.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 only
- (b) 1 and 2 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 1 and 2 only. For an independent project with conventional cash flows, NPV > 0 exactly when IRR > k, so statement 3 is false.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): When NPV and IRR rank two mutually exclusive projects differently, the NPV ranking should be preferred. Reason (R): NPV assumes reinvestment of intermediate cash flows at the cost of capital and measures the absolute addition to shareholder wealth.
Answer and explanation
(a). R gives both standard reasons for preferring NPV.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): The payback period method is a useful rough measure of a project’s liquidity and risk. Reason (R): The payback period method takes into account all cash flows over the life of the project.
Answer and explanation
(c). A is true. R is false: payback ignores cash flows after the payback period, which is its chief defect.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I with List II.
| List I (Technique) | List II (Feature) |
|---|---|
| A. Certainty equivalent | I. Random sampling of variables from probability distributions |
| B. Sensitivity analysis | II. Risky cash flows converted into riskless ones |
| C. Decision tree | III. Effect on NPV of changing one variable at a time |
| D. Monte Carlo simulation | IV. Sequential decisions and chance events, rolled back by expected values |
- (1) A-II, B-III, C-IV, D-I
- (2) A-III, B-II, C-IV, D-I
- (3) A-II, B-IV, C-III, D-I
- (4) A-I, B-III, C-IV, D-II
Answer and explanation
(1) A-II, B-III, C-IV, D-I.
Q4. (Practice) Arrange the stages of the capital budgeting process in order:
A. Evaluation of proposals
B. Post-completion audit
C. Identification of investment opportunities
D. Estimation of cash flows
E. Selection and authorisation
(1) C, D, A, E, B
(2) C, A, D, E, B
(3) D, C, A, E, B
(4) C, D, E, A, B
Answer and explanation
(1) C, D, A, E, B. Implementation falls between E and B.
Q5. (Practice) For Worked example 1 above (cost of capital 10%), arrange the measures in increasing order of their value: (A) ARR on average investment, (B) IRR, (C) MIRR, (D) cost of capital.
- (1) D, C, B, A
- (2) D, A, C, B
- (3) C, D, B, A
- (4) D, C, A, B
Answer and explanation
(1) D, C, B, A. 10% < 13.05% < 15.32% < 20%. ARR is highest here because it ignores timing and is measured on average (half) investment, which is one reason it is not comparable with the DCF measures.
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Formula / fact |
|---|---|
| Payback (even) | Investment ÷ annual inflow |
| ARR | Average PAT ÷ average investment |
| Average investment | (Cost − salvage)/2 + salvage + WC |
| NPV | PV inflows − PV outflows; accept if > 0 |
| IRR | Rate where NPV = 0; \( L + \frac{NPV_L}{NPV_L - NPV_H}(H-L) \) |
| PI | PV inflows ÷ PV outflows; accept if > 1 |
| MIRR | \( (TV/PV_{out})^{1/n} - 1 \); reinvest at \( k \) |
| NPV vs IRR conflict | Mutually exclusive projects; size, timing, life; follow NPV |
| Crossover rate | Fisher’s rate of intersection |
| Capital rationing | Divisible: rank by PI; indivisible: best combination |
| CE method | \( \alpha_t C_t \) discounted at \( R_f \) |
| RADR | \( R_f \) + risk premium |
| CV | σ ÷ expected NPV (relative risk) |
| Simulation | Monte Carlo; David Hertz (1964) |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Working Capital and Dividend Decisions — the short-term counterpart of the investment decision
- International Financial Management — multinational capital budgeting adds exchange rates and remittance rules to the same NPV logic
- Risk and Return Analysis — standard deviation and CAPM, used above for project risk
- Paper 1: Data Interpretation — the same comfort with tables and percentages
- Business Finance Quick Revision