Production and Cost: Variable Proportions, Returns to Scale and Cost Curves
UGC NET Commerce: law of variable proportions, returns to scale, isoquants, Cobb-Douglas, cost concepts, and short-run and long-run cost curves.
- 21 min
On this page · 16 sections
- Prerequisites
- The Hook: The Crowded Kitchen
- 1. The Production Function
- 2. The Law of Variable Proportions
- 3. Isoquants and the Least-cost Combination
- 4. Returns to Scale
- 5. Cost Concepts
- 6. Short-run Cost Curves
- 7. Long-run Cost Curves
- Memory Tricks
- Don’t Confuse
- Common Mistakes
- Practice
- Quick Revision Table
- Key Takeaways
- What’s Next
Prerequisites
- Consumer Behaviour: isoquants and isocost lines below mirror indifference curves and budget lines.
- Meaning, Scope and Objectives of Business Firms: the marginal and opportunity-cost principles.
- Fixed and variable costs as used in Cost and Management Accounting. The economist’s cost curves are the theory behind break-even analysis.
This page covers two official lines: “Law of variable proportions; law of returns to scale” and “Theory of cost: short-run and long-run cost curves”. Production comes first because every cost curve is the mirror image of a production relationship.
The Hook: The Crowded Kitchen
1. The Production Function
A production function is the technical relationship between physical inputs and the maximum physical output obtainable from them, with given technology:
$$Q = f(L, K, \ldots)$$| Period | Meaning | Applicable law |
|---|---|---|
| Short run | At least one factor (plant, machinery: K) is fixed; others (labour: L) vary | Law of variable proportions (returns to a factor) |
| Long run | All factors are variable; the firm can change its scale | Returns to scale |
Total, average and marginal product
| Measure | Formula |
|---|---|
| Total product (TP) | Total output from a given quantity of the variable factor |
| Average product (AP) | \( AP_L = TP / L \) |
| Marginal product (MP) | \( MP_L = \Delta TP / \Delta L \) |
Relationships (the same as between average and marginal anything):
- When MP > AP, AP rises; when MP < AP, AP falls; MP = AP where AP is at its maximum. MP cuts AP from above at AP’s peak.
- When MP is positive, TP rises; when MP = 0, TP is maximum; when MP is negative, TP falls.
- MP reaches its maximum before AP does (at TP’s point of inflexion).
2. The Law of Variable Proportions
When more and more units of a variable factor are combined with a fixed quantity of other factors, the marginal product of the variable factor may rise at first, but eventually diminishes, and finally becomes negative. The law is also called the law of diminishing returns (to a factor) or the law of non-proportional returns.
Assumptions: technology is given; only one factor varies; units of the variable factor are homogeneous; it is possible to vary factor proportions; short run.
The three stages
| Stage | From → to | TP | AP | MP | Name |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| I | Origin → AP maximum (MP = AP) | Rises at an increasing, then a diminishing rate | Rises | Rises, then falls, stays above AP | Increasing returns to the variable factor |
| II | AP maximum → MP = 0 (TP maximum) | Rises at a diminishing rate, to maximum | Falls | Falls, positive | Diminishing returns |
| III | Beyond MP = 0 | Falls | Falls | Negative | Negative returns |
Why increasing returns at first? Better use of the indivisible fixed factor, and specialisation and division of labour. Why diminishing returns later? The fixed factor becomes scarce relative to the variable factor; factors are imperfect substitutes for each other (Joan Robinson’s explanation); overcrowding. Why negative returns? Too many units of the variable factor obstruct one another and damage the fixed factor.
3. Isoquants and the Least-cost Combination
An isoquant (iso-product curve, equal-product curve) shows all combinations of two inputs (L and K) that produce the same output. It is the producer’s equivalent of an indifference curve, but each isoquant has a definite output number attached (cardinal), whereas an IC only ranks.
- Marginal rate of technical substitution: \( MRTS_{LK} = -\Delta K / \Delta L = MP_L / MP_K \). It diminishes, so isoquants are convex to the origin.
- Isoquants slope downward, do not intersect, and higher isoquants mean more output.
- Ridge lines join the points on each isoquant where MP of one factor is zero; the efficient (economic) region of production lies between them (Stage II for both factors).
- The isocost line shows input combinations with the same total cost: \( wL + rK = C \); slope \( = -w/r \).
Least-cost combination (producer’s equilibrium): the isocost line is tangent to the isoquant:
$$MRTS_{LK} = \frac{MP_L}{MP_K} = \frac{w}{r} \quad \Longleftrightarrow \quad \frac{MP_L}{w} = \frac{MP_K}{r}$$with the isoquant convex at that point. The locus of these tangency points as output expands is the expansion path.
4. Returns to Scale
Returns to scale describe how output responds when all inputs are increased in the same proportion (the scale of the firm changes). This is a long-run concept.
| Type | If all inputs rise by \( k \) times, output rises by… | Also called |
|---|---|---|
| Increasing returns to scale (IRS) | More than \( k \) times | Economies of scale dominate |
| Constant returns to scale (CRS) | Exactly \( k \) times | Linearly homogeneous production function |
| Decreasing returns to scale (DRS) | Less than \( k \) times | Diseconomies of scale dominate |
On an isoquant map: with IRS, successive isoquants for equal output increments get closer together along a ray; with CRS, they are equidistant; with DRS, they get farther apart.
The usual sequence and its causes
As a firm grows, it typically passes through IRS → CRS → DRS.
- Causes of IRS: indivisibility of factors (a large machine or a manager cannot be halved), specialisation and division of labour, technical economies of large machines, dimensional relations (doubling the surface area of a tank’s walls more than doubles its volume).
- Causes of DRS: management becomes harder to coordinate and control; communication and supervision problems; scarcity of the entrepreneurial factor (which cannot be increased in proportion).
Economies and diseconomies of scale
Classified by Marshall into internal and external:
| Type | Arises from | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Internal economies | Growth of the firm itself; enjoyed by that firm alone | Technical (bigger machines, linked processes), managerial (specialist managers), marketing (bulk buying, advertising spread over more units), financial (cheaper borrowing), risk-bearing (diversification) |
| External economies | Growth of the industry or its location; shared by all firms | Skilled labour pool, ancillary suppliers, better infrastructure, trade journals and research bodies |
| Internal diseconomies | Firm becomes too big | Coordination and control problems, red tape, labour relations |
| External diseconomies | Industry becomes too concentrated | Rising input prices, congestion, pollution |
Economies of scope (a related idea): cost savings from producing several products together rather than separately (shared distribution, brand, plant).
The Cobb–Douglas production function
Proposed by Charles Cobb and Paul Douglas (1928):
$$Q = A L^{\alpha} K^{\beta}$$- \( \alpha \) and \( \beta \) are the output elasticities of labour and capital.
- Returns to scale depend on \( \alpha + \beta \): greater than 1 → IRS; equal to 1 → CRS; less than 1 → DRS.
- In the CRS case (\( \alpha + \beta = 1 \)) the function is linearly homogeneous, \( \alpha \) and \( \beta \) are the shares of labour and capital in output, and Euler’s theorem holds: \( L \cdot MP_L + K \cdot MP_K = Q \) (paying each factor its marginal product exactly exhausts output).
- The elasticity of substitution between L and K is 1.
Variable proportions vs returns to scale
| Point | Law of variable proportions | Returns to scale |
|---|---|---|
| Period | Short run | Long run |
| Inputs varied | One, others fixed | All, in the same proportion |
| Factor proportion | Changes | Unchanged |
| Scale of plant | Fixed | Changes |
| Shown on isoquant map by | A horizontal line at fixed K | A ray from the origin |
| Phases | Increasing, diminishing, negative returns (to a factor) | Increasing, constant, decreasing returns (to scale) |
5. Cost Concepts
| Concept | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Accounting (explicit) cost | Actual payments to outsiders: wages, rent, materials, interest |
| Implicit (imputed) cost | Value of the owner’s own resources used: own capital, own building, own labour |
| Economic cost | Explicit + implicit cost (includes normal profit) |
| Opportunity cost | Value of the best alternative forgone |
| Fixed cost | Does not vary with output in the short run (rent, salaries of permanent staff, depreciation by time) |
| Variable cost | Varies with output (raw material, power, direct labour) |
| Sunk cost | Already incurred and unrecoverable; irrelevant for decisions |
| Incremental cost | Change in total cost from a decision (lumpy) |
| Marginal cost | Change in total cost from one more unit |
| Private vs social cost | Cost to the firm vs cost to society (private cost + externalities such as pollution) |
Normal profit is the minimum return needed to keep the entrepreneur in the industry; economists treat it as a cost, so economic profit = TR − (explicit + implicit costs). Zero economic profit means the firm is earning normal profit.
6. Short-run Cost Curves
Definitions
$$TC = TFC + TVC, \qquad AFC = \frac{TFC}{Q}, \qquad AVC = \frac{TVC}{Q}$$$$ATC = AFC + AVC = \frac{TC}{Q}, \qquad MC = \frac{\Delta TC}{\Delta Q} = \frac{\Delta TVC}{\Delta Q}$$MC depends only on variable cost, since fixed cost does not change with output.
Shapes and relationships
| Curve | Shape | Why |
|---|---|---|
| TFC | Horizontal line | Fixed cost does not change with output |
| TVC | Starts at the origin; rises, first at a diminishing then at an increasing rate (inverse S) | Increasing then diminishing returns to the variable factor |
| TC | Same shape as TVC, shifted up by TFC | TC = TFC + TVC |
| AFC | Falls continuously; rectangular hyperbola; approaches but never touches the X-axis | Fixed cost spread over more units; \( AFC \times Q = \) constant |
| AVC | U-shaped | Mirror image of AP: \( AVC = w / AP_L \) |
| ATC | U-shaped; its minimum lies to the right of min AVC | AFC keeps pulling ATC down after AVC has started rising |
| MC | U-shaped; reaches its minimum first | Mirror image of MP: \( MC = w / MP_L \) |
Why the short-run curves are U-shaped: the law of variable proportions. Increasing returns to the variable factor lower AVC and MC; diminishing returns raise them.
7. Long-run Cost Curves
In the long run all factors vary, so there is no fixed cost: LTC = LVC. The firm can choose any plant size.
LAC as the envelope curve
Each plant size has its own short-run average cost curve (SAC). For each output, the firm chooses the plant with the lowest SAC. The long-run average cost (LAC) curve is the locus of these lowest points: it envelops the SACs from below. Hence it is called the envelope curve, and also the planning curve, because the firm uses it to plan which plant to build. The construction is associated with Jacob Viner (1931).
graph LR
A["Many plant sizes
SAC1, SAC2, SAC3 ..."] --> B["For each output, pick the
plant with the lowest SAC"]
B --> C["LAC = envelope of the SACs
(planning curve)"]
C --> D["Falling part: economies of scale
Minimum: optimum plant
Rising part: diseconomies"]Tangency points (a favourite statement question):
- Where LAC is falling, it is tangent to each SAC on the falling part of that SAC, to the left of the SAC’s minimum. (A larger plant under-used beats a smaller plant used at its optimum.)
- Where LAC is rising, it touches each SAC to the right of the SAC’s minimum.
- Only at the minimum of LAC is it tangent to an SAC at that SAC’s minimum. That plant is the optimum plant and that output the optimum scale: \( SAC = SMC = LAC = LMC \).
Shape of LAC and LMC
- Traditional theory: LAC is U-shaped, but flatter than SACs. It falls because of economies of scale (IRS) and rises because of diseconomies of scale (DRS). The U-shape of the SAC comes from variable proportions; the U-shape of the LAC comes from returns to scale.
- LMC is derived from the SMCs at the tangency points (not an envelope of them). It cuts LAC at LAC’s minimum, from below; it is steeper than LAC on both sides of that point.
- Modern theory and empirical studies: LAC is often L-shaped (or saucer-shaped): costs fall steeply at first, then stay roughly flat over a wide range, because technical economies continue and managerial diseconomies are offset by better management techniques. The output at which LAC stops falling is the minimum efficient scale (MES).
| Curve pair | Cause of the U-shape |
|---|---|
| SAC, AVC, SMC | Law of variable proportions (short run) |
| LAC, LMC | Returns to scale / economies and diseconomies of scale (long run) |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| Pair | First | Second |
|---|---|---|
| Diminishing returns vs decreasing returns to scale | Short run; one factor varied; MP falls | Long run; all factors varied proportionally; output rises less than proportionately |
| Isoquant vs indifference curve | Output; numbered (cardinal) | Satisfaction; only ranked (ordinal) |
| MRTS vs MRS | \( MP_L/MP_K \); producer | \( MU_x/MU_y \); consumer |
| Internal vs external economies | Growth of the firm; that firm only | Growth of the industry; all firms |
| AFC vs AVC | Always falls; rectangular hyperbola | U-shaped |
| SAC U-shape vs LAC U-shape | Variable proportions | Returns to scale |
| Envelope tangency left of min vs at min | Falling LAC: tangent to falling part of SAC | Only at min LAC: tangent at min SAC (optimum plant) |
| Explicit vs implicit cost | Cash paid to outsiders | Opportunity cost of own resources |
Common Mistakes
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- At what point does Stage II of the law of variable proportions end?
- Which short-run cost curve is a rectangular hyperbola?
- In \( Q = AL^{0.7}K^{0.3} \), what kind of returns to scale operate?
Answers
- Where MP of the variable factor is zero (TP is maximum).
- AFC.
- Constant returns to scale (0.7 + 0.3 = 1).
Level 2: Exam-style MCQs
Q1. (Practice) Total fixed cost is ₹600. At an output of 50 units, total cost is ₹1,350. AVC at this output is:
- (a) ₹12
- (b) ₹15
- (c) ₹27
- (d) ₹750
Answer and explanation
(b) ₹15. TVC = ₹1,350 − ₹600 = ₹750; AVC = 750 ÷ 50 = ₹15. (ATC = ₹27; AFC = ₹12.)
Q2. (Practice) Total cost rises from ₹2,000 to ₹2,090 when output rises from 40 to 41 units. The marginal cost of the 41st unit is:
- (a) ₹50
- (b) ₹50.98
- (c) ₹90
- (d) ₹2,090
Answer and explanation
(c) ₹90. MC = change in TC for one more unit = 2,090 − 2,000. (₹50.98 is ATC at 41 units.)
Q3. (Practice) The long-run average cost curve is U-shaped in traditional theory mainly because of:
- (a) The law of diminishing marginal utility
- (b) The law of variable proportions
- (c) Economies and diseconomies of scale
- (d) Falling average fixed cost
Answer and explanation
(c). In the long run all factors vary; the shape of LAC reflects returns to scale. (b) explains the short-run curves; there is no fixed cost in the long run, ruling out (d).
Q4. (Practice) Consider the following statements:
- MC cuts AVC and ATC at their respective minimum points.
- Minimum AVC occurs at a larger output than minimum ATC.
- The vertical distance between ATC and AVC falls as output rises.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 1 and 3 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 1 and 3 only. Minimum AVC comes at a smaller output than minimum ATC, because falling AFC keeps pulling ATC down after AVC has started to rise. The gap ATC − AVC = AFC, which falls continuously.
Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence
For assertion–reason questions, use these options:
- (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- (c) A is true, but R is false
- (d) A is false, but R is true
Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): A rational producer never operates in Stage III of the law of variable proportions. Reason (R): In Stage III, the marginal product of the variable factor is negative.
Answer and explanation
(a). With negative MP, using fewer units of the variable factor would raise output while lowering cost, so no rational producer stays there.
Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): The long-run average cost curve is tangent to every short-run average cost curve at the minimum point of the latter. Reason (R): The long-run average cost curve is an envelope of short-run average cost curves.
Answer and explanation
(d). A is false: on the falling part of LAC, tangency is to the left of each SAC’s minimum; on the rising part, to the right. Only the optimum plant is touched at its minimum. R is true.
Q3. (Practice) Match List I with List II.
| List I (Curve or concept) | List II (Feature) |
|---|---|
| A. AFC | I. Planning curve |
| B. LAC | II. Rectangular hyperbola |
| C. Isoquant | III. Output elasticities sum to one |
| D. Linearly homogeneous Cobb–Douglas | IV. Equal output from different input combinations |
- (1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III
- (2) A-I, B-II, C-IV, D-III
- (3) A-II, B-IV, C-I, D-III
- (4) A-II, B-I, C-III, D-IV
Answer and explanation
(1) A-II, B-I, C-IV, D-III.
Q4. (Practice) As output rises from zero in the short run with U-shaped cost curves, arrange the following in the order in which they occur:
A. ATC reaches its minimum
B. MC reaches its minimum
C. AVC reaches its minimum
(1) B, C, A
(2) C, B, A
(3) B, A, C
(4) A, C, B
Answer and explanation
(1) B, C, A. MC bottoms out first, then rises to cut AVC at its minimum and later ATC at its minimum (see worked examples 4 and 5).
Q5. (Practice) Under the law of variable proportions, arrange the following events in the order in which they occur as more of the variable factor is used:
A. MP of the variable factor becomes zero
B. AP of the variable factor reaches its maximum
C. MP of the variable factor reaches its maximum
(1) C, B, A
(2) B, C, A
(3) C, A, B
(4) A, B, C
Answer and explanation
(1) C, B, A. MP peaks first (inflexion of TP), then AP peaks where MP = AP (end of Stage I), then MP falls to zero (end of Stage II).
Quick Revision Table
| Item | Key fact |
|---|---|
| Short run / long run | At least one factor fixed / all factors variable |
| AP–MP | MP = AP at max AP; TP max at MP = 0 |
| Law of variable proportions | Stage I to max AP; Stage II to MP = 0 (rational); Stage III MP < 0 |
| MRTS | \( MP_L/MP_K \); diminishing → convex isoquant |
| Least-cost combination | \( MP_L/w = MP_K/r \); isocost tangent to isoquant |
| Returns to scale | All inputs × k: output > k (IRS), = k (CRS), < k (DRS) |
| Cobb–Douglas (1928) | \( Q = AL^\alpha K^\beta \); \( \alpha + \beta \) vs 1; CRS → Euler’s theorem |
| Internal vs external economies | Firm’s own growth vs industry’s growth (Marshall) |
| Economic cost | Explicit + implicit (incl. normal profit) |
| AFC | Rectangular hyperbola; always falling |
| AVC, ATC, MC | U-shaped; MC min first, then AVC min, then ATC min |
| MC rule | Cuts AVC and ATC at their minima, from below |
| LAC | Envelope / planning curve (Viner, 1931); U-shaped due to returns to scale |
| Tangency | Falling LAC: left of SAC min; rising LAC: right; optimum plant at LAC min |
| Modern LAC | L-shaped; minimum efficient scale |
Key Takeaways
What’s Next
- Market Structures and Pricing: put these cost curves against AR and MR to find price and output in each market form
- Cost and Management Accounting: the accountant’s version, with break-even analysis and relevant costs
- Demand Analysis and Elasticity: revise the revenue side before the equilibrium page
- Paper 1: Data Interpretation Calculations: practice for reading cost tables quickly
- Quick Revision: Business Economics