Skip to content

Auditing: Independent Audit, Vouching, Verification, Audit Report and Recent Trends

UGC NET Commerce: statutory audit under the Companies Act 2013, Standards on Auditing, vouching, verification, audit opinions, cost audit and new audits.

  • 16 min read
  • Updated
On this page · 16 sections
  1. Prerequisites
  2. The Hook: Watchdog, Not Bloodhound
  3. 1. Meaning, Objectives and Types of Audit
  4. 2. Independent Financial Audit: the Companies Act, 2013
  5. 3. Vouching
  6. 4. Verification and Valuation of Assets and Liabilities
  7. 5. Audit of Financial Statements and the Audit Report
  8. 6. Cost Audit
  9. 7. Recent Trends in Auditing
  10. Memory Tricks
  11. Don’t Confuse
  12. Common Mistakes
  13. Practice
  14. Quick Revision Table
  15. Key Takeaways
  16. What’s Next

Prerequisites

This page covers two official lines: “Auditing: independent financial audit; vouching; verification and valuation of assets and liabilities; audit of financial statements and audit report; cost audit” and “Recent trends in auditing: management audit; energy audit; environment audit; systems audit; safety audit”.

The Hook: Watchdog, Not Bloodhound


1. Meaning, Objectives and Types of Audit

Auditing is an independent examination of the financial statements of an entity, with a view to expressing an opinion on whether they give a true and fair view in accordance with the applicable financial reporting framework.

SA 200 (Overall Objectives of the Independent Auditor and the Conduct of an Audit in Accordance with Standards on Auditing) sets the objective: to obtain reasonable assurance that the financial statements as a whole are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error, and to report accordingly. Reasonable assurance is high, but not absolute, because of the inherent limitations of an audit (use of judgment, test checking, persuasive rather than conclusive evidence, possibility of collusion).

BasisTypes
By lawStatutory audit (Companies Act, 2013; banks; co-operatives; trusts), tax audit (income-tax law), cost audit (Sec 148)
By organisationInternal audit (by employees or an outside firm for management), government audit (C&AG)
By timingContinuous, periodical (final/annual), interim
By scopeBalance sheet audit, complete audit, partial audit

Primary and secondary objectives

  • Primary: an opinion on the truth and fairness of the financial statements.
  • Secondary (incidental): detection and prevention of errors (omission, commission, principle, compensating) and frauds (misappropriation of cash or goods; manipulation of accounts). Under SA 240, the primary responsibility for preventing and detecting fraud rests with management and those charged with governance.

2. Independent Financial Audit: the Companies Act, 2013

SectionProvision
Sec 139(1)Auditor appointed at the first AGM to hold office till the conclusion of the sixth AGM (a five-year term)
Sec 139(2)Rotation for listed and prescribed companies: an individual for not more than one term of five years; an audit firm for not more than two terms of five years; cooling-off of five years
Sec 139(5), (7)Government companies: auditor appointed by the Comptroller and Auditor-General of India (C&AG)
Sec 139(6)First auditor of a non-government company appointed by the Board within 30 days of registration
Sec 140Removal (special resolution and Central Government approval) and resignation
Sec 141Eligibility: only a chartered accountant or a firm (majority of partners CAs); disqualifications; ceiling of 20 companies
Sec 142Remuneration fixed in general meeting
Sec 143Powers and duties; 143(3) matters to report; 143(11) CARO; 143(12) reporting fraud to the Central Government
Sec 144Prohibited services for the auditor (below)
Sec 145 / 146Auditor to sign the report / auditor to attend the general meeting unless exempted
Sec 147Penalties
Sec 148Cost audit
Sec 138Internal audit for prescribed classes

Section 144 prohibited services: accounting and book-keeping; internal audit; design and implementation of any financial information system; actuarial services; investment advisory; investment banking; rendering outsourced financial services; management services; and any other kind prescribed.

Key Standards on Auditing (SAs)

SASubject
200Overall objectives of the independent auditor
210Agreeing the terms of audit engagements (engagement letter)
230Audit documentation
240Auditor’s responsibilities relating to fraud
300Planning an audit
315Identifying and assessing risks of material misstatement
320Materiality in planning and performing an audit
500Audit evidence
505External confirmations
520Analytical procedures
530Audit sampling
570Going concern
580Written representations
610Using the work of internal auditors
700Forming an opinion and reporting on financial statements
701Communicating key audit matters (KAM)
705Modifications to the opinion
706Emphasis of matter and other matter paragraphs

Audit risk = inherent risk × control risk × detection risk. The auditor controls only detection risk: the higher the assessed risk of material misstatement, the lower the acceptable detection risk, and the more substantive testing needed.


3. Vouching

Vouching is the examination of documentary evidence (vouchers) in support of entries in the books, to establish their authority, accuracy and genuineness. Because it tests transactions at their source, textbooks call it the essence (backbone) of auditing.

Item vouchedEvidence to check
Cash salesCash memos, counterfoils, daily sales summaries, till rolls
Credit purchasesPurchase order, goods received note, supplier’s invoice, approval
WagesAttendance records, wage sheets, authorisation, statutory deductions
Capital expenditureBoard resolution, invoices, title deeds, installation certificates
Receipts from debtorsCounterfoils of receipts, bank paying-in slips, debtor confirmations

Teeming and lading (lapping) is a fraud in which cash received from one debtor is misappropriated and the shortage covered by crediting later receipts from another; vouching receipts against dates in the bank statement detects it.

Routine checking and test checking

  • Routine checking: checking casts, carry-forwards, postings and balances.
  • Test checking (audit sampling, SA 530): checking a representative sample instead of every transaction, on the basis that the sample allows a reasonable conclusion about the population. Methods: random, systematic, block, monetary unit sampling.

4. Verification and Valuation of Assets and Liabilities

TermQuestion it answers
VouchingIs the transaction genuine and properly recorded?
VerificationDoes the asset or liability exist at the balance sheet date, is it owned by (or an obligation of) the entity, is it free from undisclosed charges, and is it properly presented?
ValuationIs it shown at the right amount under the applicable standard?

Verification checks existence, ownership (rights and obligations), possession, freedom from charge, and presentation. Valuation is primarily the management’s responsibility; the auditor examines whether it follows the framework, relying on experts where needed.

ItemVerificationValuation basis (AS / Ind AS)
Land and buildingsTitle deeds, registration, encumbrance certificatesCost less depreciation (land not depreciated); revaluation if policy
Plant and machineryPhysical inspection, fixed asset registerCost less depreciation (AS 10 / Ind AS 16); impairment (AS 28 / Ind AS 36)
InvestmentsInspection of certificates or demat statements, broker notesAS 13: current at lower of cost and fair value; long-term at cost less permanent decline
InventoriesAttendance at physical stock-taking, cut-off testsLower of cost and NRV (AS 2 / Ind AS 2)
DebtorsExternal confirmations (SA 505), ageingLess provision for doubtful debts
Cash and bankCash count; bank confirmation and reconciliationFace value
LiabilitiesConfirmation, review of subsequent payments, search for unrecorded liabilitiesContingent liabilities disclosed (AS 29 / Ind AS 37)

5. Audit of Financial Statements and the Audit Report

Forming an opinion (SA 700, SA 705)

OpinionWhen
Unmodified (clean)Financial statements are prepared, in all material respects, in accordance with the framework
Qualified (“except for”)Misstatements are material but not pervasive; or the auditor cannot obtain sufficient appropriate evidence, and possible effects are material but not pervasive
AdverseMisstatements are material and pervasive: the statements do not give a true and fair view
Disclaimer of opinionThe auditor cannot obtain sufficient appropriate evidence, and possible effects could be material and pervasive

Elements of the auditor’s report (SA 700, revised)

Title; addressee; Opinion section (placed first); Basis for Opinion; Material Uncertainty Related to Going Concern (SA 570, if applicable); Key Audit Matters (SA 701, mandatory for listed entities); Other Information (SA 720); Responsibilities of Management for the financial statements; Auditor’s Responsibilities; Report on Other Legal and Regulatory Requirements (Sec 143(3) matters and CARO); signature with membership number and UDIN; place; date.

Emphasis of Matter (SA 706) draws attention to a matter already properly presented in the statements (for example, a major litigation) and does not modify the opinion. Other Matter paragraphs refer to matters outside the statements relevant to users’ understanding of the audit.

CARO 2020: the Companies (Auditor’s Report) Order, 2020, issued under Section 143(11), requires auditors of specified companies to report on matters such as fixed assets, inventory, loans given, deposits, statutory dues, defaults in repayment, use of funds raised, fraud and whistle-blower complaints.

Audit report vs audit certificate

A report expresses an opinion (true and fair view); a certificate confirms the exactness of specific facts (for example, a certificate of export turnover).


6. Cost Audit

Cost audit is the verification of cost accounts and a check on adherence to the cost accounting plan. In India:

  • Section 148, Companies Act, 2013: the Central Government may direct specified classes of companies (by industry and turnover) to maintain cost records and to have them audited.
  • Companies (Cost Records and Audit) Rules, 2014 specify the industries and thresholds.
  • Cost auditor: a cost accountant in practice (member of the Institute of Cost Accountants of India, ICMAI), appointed by the Board on the recommendation of the audit committee, with remuneration ratified by shareholders. The statutory auditor of the company cannot be its cost auditor.
  • The cost auditor submits the report to the Board in Form CRA-3; the company files it with the Central Government in Form CRA-4.
  • Cost Accounting Standards (CAS) are issued by the ICMAI’s Cost Accounting Standards Board.
PointFinancial auditCost audit
FocusTrue and fair view of financial statementsCorrectness of cost records, efficiency of resource use
AuditorChartered accountant (Sec 141)Cost accountant (Sec 148)
Section139–147148
Report toMembers (shareholders)Board, then Central Government

AuditWhat it examinesNotes
Management auditEffectiveness of management itself: objectives, plans, organisation, policies, decisions, controlsForward-looking, non-statutory; also called operational or performance audit in a broad sense
Energy auditEnergy use and the scope for saving energyUnder the Energy Conservation Act, 2001, the Bureau of Energy Efficiency (BEE) frames norms; designated consumers (energy-intensive industries) must get an energy audit done by an accredited energy auditor
Environment auditCompliance with environmental laws, use of resources, waste, emissions and environmental management systemsUnder the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 framework, specified units file an annual environmental statement; ISO 14001 guides environmental management systems
Systems audit (IS / IT audit)Reliability, security and integrity of computerised information systemsApproaches: auditing around, through and with the computer; Computer Assisted Audit Techniques (CAATs); test data, embedded audit modules
Safety auditWorkplace safety: hazards, procedures, equipment, training, compliance with safety lawsRequired for hazardous industries; a systematic check of occupational health and safety management

Related terms that appear in options:

  • Propriety audit: whether expenditure is wise, prudent and in the public interest (government audit, C&AG).
  • Efficiency (performance) audit: whether resources are used economically and efficiently.
  • Social audit: assessment of an organisation’s social performance; in India also a statutory feature of programmes such as MGNREGA.
  • Forensic audit: investigation of fraud for use in legal proceedings.
  • Peer review: review of an audit firm’s quality by other practitioners (ICAI Peer Review Board).

Memory Tricks

Don’t Confuse

PairFirstSecond
Vouching vs verificationTransactions, during the yearAssets and liabilities, at balance sheet date
Verification vs valuationExistence, ownershipAmount
Qualified vs adverseMaterial, not pervasiveMaterial and pervasive misstatement
Adverse vs disclaimerAuditor knows statements are wrongAuditor cannot form an opinion
Emphasis of matter vs qualificationOpinion unmodifiedOpinion modified
Report vs certificateOpinionConfirmation of facts
Statutory vs internal auditIndependent; to members; Sec 139–143For management; Sec 138; statutory auditor barred from it (Sec 144)
Cost audit vs financial auditCost accountant, Sec 148Chartered accountant, Sec 139

Common Mistakes


Practice

All questions below are original practice questions written in the UGC NET format. They are not previous-year questions.

Level 1: Foundation

  1. Which Standard on Auditing deals with going concern?
  2. Under Section 139(2), for how many terms can an audit firm be appointed in a listed company?
  3. Who may be appointed cost auditor under Section 148?
Answers
  1. SA 570.
  2. Two terms of five consecutive years.
  3. A cost accountant in practice.

Level 2: Exam-style MCQs

Q1. (Practice) The auditor concludes that misstatements in the financial statements are material and pervasive. The opinion will be:

  • (a) Qualified
  • (b) Adverse
  • (c) Disclaimer
  • (d) Unmodified with emphasis of matter
Answer and explanation

(b) Adverse. Material and pervasive misstatement → adverse; material and pervasive inability to obtain evidence → disclaimer.

Q2. (Practice) Which of the following is not a prohibited service for a company’s statutory auditor under Section 144?

  • (a) Internal audit
  • (b) Actuarial services
  • (c) Investment banking
  • (d) Taxation services
Answer and explanation

(d) Taxation services are not in the Section 144 list (they may require approval of the Board or audit committee). The other three are prohibited.

Q3. (Practice) “A watchdog, but not a bloodhound” was said in:

  • (a) London and General Bank case
  • (b) Kingston Cotton Mill case
  • (c) Garner v Murray
  • (d) Salomon v Salomon
Answer and explanation

(b) Kingston Cotton Mill (1896), by Lopes L.J.

Q4. (Practice) Consider the following statements:

  1. Verification includes establishing the existence and ownership of an asset.
  2. Valuation of assets is primarily the responsibility of the auditor.
  3. Vouching is concerned mainly with transactions recorded in the books.

Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  • (a) 1 and 2 only
  • (b) 1 and 3 only
  • (c) 2 and 3 only
  • (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation

(b) 1 and 3 only. Valuation is management’s responsibility; the auditor examines whether it is appropriate.

Level 3: Assertion–reason, match and sequence

For assertion–reason questions, use these options:

  • (a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
  • (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
  • (c) A is true, but R is false
  • (d) A is false, but R is true

Q1. (Practice) Assertion (A): An audit provides reasonable, not absolute, assurance. Reason (R): An audit has inherent limitations such as test checking and the persuasive rather than conclusive nature of evidence.

Answer and explanation

(a). The inherent limitations are exactly why assurance cannot be absolute (SA 200).

Q2. (Practice) Assertion (A): An emphasis of matter paragraph modifies the auditor’s opinion. Reason (R): An emphasis of matter paragraph draws users’ attention to a matter appropriately presented or disclosed in the financial statements.

Answer and explanation

(d). A is false: the opinion stays unmodified. R is true (SA 706).

Q3. (Practice) Match List I (Standard) with List II (Subject).

List IList II
A. SA 240I. Audit sampling
B. SA 530II. Key audit matters
C. SA 701III. Fraud
D. SA 505IV. External confirmations
  • (1) A-III, B-I, C-II, D-IV
  • (2) A-I, B-III, C-II, D-IV
  • (3) A-III, B-IV, C-II, D-I
  • (4) A-II, B-I, C-III, D-IV
Answer and explanation

(1) A-III, B-I, C-II, D-IV.

Q4. (Practice) Arrange the stages of a statutory audit in the usual sequence:

  • A. Issuing the audit report

  • B. Agreeing the terms of engagement

  • C. Gathering audit evidence (tests of controls and substantive procedures)

  • D. Planning and risk assessment

  • E. Evaluating evidence and forming an opinion

  • (1) B, D, C, E, A

  • (2) D, B, C, E, A

  • (3) B, C, D, E, A

  • (4) B, D, E, C, A

Answer and explanation

(1) B, D, C, E, A. The SA numbering follows the same arc: 210 → 300/315 → 500 → 700.


Quick Revision Table

FactDetail
SA 200Reasonable assurance; free from material misstatement due to fraud or error
Audit riskInherent × control × detection; auditor controls detection risk
Kingston Cotton Mill (1896)“Watchdog, but not a bloodhound” (Lopes L.J.)
London and General Bank (1895)Auditor must ascertain the true financial position
Sec 139(2)Individual 1 × 5 yrs; firm 2 × 5 yrs; 5-yr cooling-off
Sec 141Only CAs; ceiling 20 companies
Sec 143(12)Auditor reports fraud to Central Government
Sec 144Prohibited services incl. internal audit, book-keeping, actuarial, investment banking
Sec 148Cost audit; cost accountant; CRA-3, CRA-4
OpinionsUnmodified, qualified, adverse, disclaimer (SA 700, 705)
SA 701 / 706Key audit matters / emphasis of matter
CARO 2020Under Sec 143(11)
Energy auditEnergy Conservation Act, 2001; BEE; designated consumers
Systems auditAround, through, with the computer; CAATs

Key Takeaways

What’s Next

Advertisement
Advertisement